When Is Investment in Waste Heat Recovery on a Ship Economically Attractive?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
Investment in waste heat recovery is economically attractive when the value of the energy actually saved over the ship's economic life outweighs the total investment, additional operating costs and associated risks. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) uses heat from sources such as exhaust gases and engine cooling water to supply electricity or useful heat. Electricity generated by an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) can reduce the load on existing generating sets, saving fuel costs and potentially emissions costs.
However, financial attractiveness does not depend solely on the installation's rated power. The amount of waste heat at the usual engine loads, annual operating hours, the system's own energy consumption and how much of the generated electricity the ship can use also matter. The costs of heat exchangers, cooling, electrical connections, installation, maintenance and any downtime must also be included. A larger installation therefore does not automatically represent a better investment. It must first be established how much net energy becomes available under actual operating conditions and which fuel costs and other costs the ship can avoid.
These benefits are then compared with the total investment and operating costs, taking account of the remaining economic life and uncertainties in future operation. The investment becomes particularly attractive when the savings retain sufficient financial value even under realistic, less favourable conditions. It is also important that this value actually accrues to the party bearing the investment cost.
When Does Available Waste Heat Provide Sufficient Economic Value?
The economic assessment starts with the heat actually available during normal ship operation. An internal combustion engine rejects some of the energy supplied by the fuel through its exhaust and cooling circuits, among other routes. Under suitable conditions, this heat can be used again, but not every heat flow offers the same opportunities for useful energy production. For an ORC installation, the amount of heat, temperature level and availability during operating hours are particularly important. For exhaust gas heat, gas temperature, mass flow rate and the limit on how far the exhaust gas may be cooled determine how much thermal power can be extracted within acceptable technical limits.
For engine cooling water, the available temperature, flow rate and existing engine cooling requirements play a similar role. The temperature difference between the hot side and the available cooling medium also affects how much electricity can be produced from the heat absorbed. A high exhaust gas temperature therefore does not automatically mean that high annual electricity production is possible. If the engine concerned operates at high load only for short periods, the number of hours with sufficient usable heat may remain limited.
Conversely, a heat source with lower peak power may be economically attractive if it supplies enough usable heat for many operating hours. The energy that can actually be recovered over a full year may then be more important than the highest thermal power available only occasionally.
The time at which heat is released also determines how much economic value can be realized. For electricity production, not only must the ORC receive sufficient heat, but suitable cooling and electrical demand must also be available at the same time. If the ship needs very little electricity in a particular operating mode, some of the potential electrical output may go unused. The available thermal power then does not automatically represent a corresponding amount of avoided fuel costs.
Direct heat use concerns a different energy requirement. Waste heat can, for example, reduce the load on an existing heating installation, provided that the temperature level is suitable and heat demand occurs when the heat becomes available. It must be investigated which sources of heat are already used on board. If an existing exhaust gas boiler supplies heat for fuel treatment or heating, for example, that same heat is not automatically available in full for an additional ORC.
A new installation that takes heat away from an existing useful application may mean that energy has to be produced elsewhere again. The financial assessment must therefore be based on the additional energy savings for the whole ship, not solely on the output of the new installation. Sufficient available waste heat is thus only the first condition. There must also be an application through which recovered heat or electricity can actually displace energy the ship would otherwise pay to produce or purchase.
Economic value therefore does not arise from available thermal power alone. The determining factors are how much energy can usefully be recovered under actual operating conditions and which costs of the original energy supply this avoids.
Why Is Annual Net Energy Output More Important Than Maximum Power?
The maximum electrical power of an ORC module describes what the installation can produce under certain reference conditions. For an investment decision, however, what matters is how much net electricity the system supplies in service and how much of it the ship can use. During ship operation, engine load changes. Exhaust gas flow rate, exhaust gas temperature and the available cooling-water heat may consequently also change. The ORC must adjust its thermodynamic operating point to these conditions within the permitted limits.
At lower engine load, less electricity may be produced. A condition may also arise in which insufficient heat remains available to provide a positive net electrical contribution. At higher engine load, electricity production may increase, but the capacity of the heat exchangers, expander or generator may limit further increases in power. More available heat therefore does not automatically mean that the ORC can supply more electricity.
Annual production must therefore not be calculated by multiplying maximum generator power by the total number of engine hours without further assessment. Such a calculation takes insufficient account of the operating conditions under which the installation actually functions. A realistic estimate considers each relevant operating mode separately. It is established how much heat is available in each operating mode, what electrical power the selected ORC can produce under the corresponding cooling conditions and for how many hours these conditions are expected to occur.
Condenser operation also affects output. With warmer cooling water, the condensing temperature may rise, so the available expansion range narrows and electricity production decreases. An output calculation based solely on favourable cooling conditions may therefore be too optimistic.
The installation's own electricity consumption is then accounted for. The working-fluid pump, any intermediate circuit pumps, additional cooling equipment and other necessary components may use some of the gross generator power. Net production must be determined within a clear system boundary. It must be known which auxiliary loads are already accounted for in a stated net module output and what additional electrical load arises from the complete installation.
Particularly at lower load, the difference between gross and net power may become important. Certain pumps and other equipment continue to draw power while generator power decreases. Net output may therefore fall proportionally more than gross output.
WHRS availability also affects annual energy output. During start-up, maintenance, faults or periods with insufficient heat supply, less or no electricity is produced. Some auxiliary equipment may still consume energy during these periods. Electrical demand on board may also limit production. If the shipboard electrical system cannot use all the available output, the ORC may need to reduce output, even when sufficient waste heat remains available on the hot side.
Annual net energy output therefore follows from the combination of heat supply, cooling conditions, electricity production that can actually be used, auxiliary consumption and effective operating hours. Together, these factors determine how much energy actually becomes available over the year to replace existing production.
This explains why a smaller ORC module may be more economical than a larger unit under certain conditions. A smaller module may better match the usual engine load and provide a useful net contribution over more operating hours. This does not mean that a smaller module is automatically preferable. If sufficient heat and electrical demand are available for long periods, a larger installation may instead deliver greater annual energy savings.
The economic comparison must therefore be based on the expected net annual output of each design. Rated generator power is a technical characteristic for this purpose, but not an independent measure of financial attractiveness.
How Do You Translate WHRS Electricity into Avoided Fuel Costs?
The financial value of recovered electricity is determined by the existing generation it displaces. When an ORC supplies electricity to the shipboard electrical system, one or more existing generating sets may need to produce less power. Fuel savings follow from the difference in fuel consumption with and without the WHRS. For this purpose, it must be known how the load on the generating sets concerned changes and how much fuel these engines use under the relevant conditions.
The engines' fuel consumption curves are important here. A generating set does not use the same amount of fuel per kilowatt-hour produced at every load. It is therefore not always sufficient to multiply net ORC electricity by a single fixed fuel consumption factor. The calculation must match the load that the existing engines actually carry with and without the WHRS contribution. The way in which electrical power is distributed among the available generating sets must also be taken into account.
When several generating sets continue to operate in parallel, ORC production may reduce their individual loads. With a different operating strategy, it may be possible to shut down one generating set altogether, after which the remaining engines take over the electrical load. These situations may have different effects on total fuel consumption. The necessary power reserve and safe operation of the shipboard electrical system remain determining factors.
A generating set therefore cannot be shut down solely for financial reasons if electrical operation becomes insufficiently reliable as a result. The calculated fuel savings must be consistent with technically sound generator dispatch. A particular interaction arises when the ORC uses heat from the same generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity generated. The lower generator load may reduce the available exhaust gas and cooling-water heat.
ORC production may consequently also change. The expected fuel savings must therefore be determined for the resulting distribution of engine loads, using consistent waste heat and electrical output figures.
Additional losses must also be included. If an exhaust gas heat exchanger causes additional back pressure, this may affect the engine's fuel consumption under certain conditions. The electricity consumption of pumps and other necessary equipment must also be correctly accounted for in the energy balance. Auxiliary consumption already deducted from gross ORC production must not be counted again as the same loss item.
Once the fuel savings have been established, they can be valued at the relevant fuel price. When different fuels are used, it must be clear which fuel is actually consumed in smaller quantities. The financial value of the same amount of avoided energy may, after all, differ by fuel and engine configuration. The selected pricing basis is also important. The calculation must match the fuel costs actually borne by the party concerned. A general market price need not equal the cost of the fuel actually purchased.
For direct heat use, the amount of original heat production that is no longer needed is established in a similar way. When recovered heat reduces the load on an existing boiler, the savings depend on how much less fuel this boiler actually uses as a result.
Possible maintenance savings on existing generating sets may also have financial value. If the ORC makes it possible to shut down a generating set for longer periods, this may reduce running hours and certain maintenance costs. However, a partially unloaded generating set does not automatically provide the same maintenance savings as an engine that is fully shut down. The effect on maintenance must therefore be assessed on the basis of the actual change in engine use.
The value of recovered electricity therefore does not simply equal a general electricity price per kilowatt-hour. What matters is which existing generation, fuel purchases and, where relevant, maintenance the WHRS avoids.
Which Total Investment Costs Belong to a WHRS Project?
The purchase price of an ORC module represents only part of the investment needed to implement waste heat recovery on board. The complete installation must be connected to the available heat sources and to the ship's cooling and electrical systems. Depending on the configuration, additional heat exchangers, intermediate circuits, pumps and pipe connections may be needed for this purpose. This equipment partly determines how much heat the ORC actually receives and how much net electricity becomes available to the ship.
For recovery from exhaust gases, a heat exchanger must be incorporated at a suitable location in the existing exhaust gas path. The heat exchanger must operate within the engine's permitted back-pressure and temperature limits. Modifications to existing pipes, supports, expansion joints or other exhaust gas equipment may be needed for this purpose. The operation of any exhaust gas aftertreatment equipment already fitted must also be maintained.
On the cold side, sufficient condenser capacity must be available. If the existing ship cooling system has insufficient capacity, additional coolers, pumps or modifications to the cooling-water circuits may become necessary. The electrical connection also entails costs. The ORC generator must be safely connected to the shipboard electrical system, including the necessary switchgear, protection, control and any power electronics.
The main module and additional components must also be capable of being physically installed. Foundations, structural reinforcement, maintenance space and the work needed to bring heavy equipment on board may add to the cost. The added mass and location of the installation may also have consequences for the ship. If the additional weight or changed weight distribution affects operational capabilities, this must be included in the technical and economic assessment.
The investment budget must therefore cover the complete, functioning WHRS installation. The purchase price of the ORC module alone provides insufficient information on total project costs. Engineering, required technical assessments, installation, testing and commissioning also form part of the relevant investment. If additional ship-specific approvals are needed, the associated work must also be included.
For a retrofit, the existing engine-room layout in particular may strongly affect the total investment. A technically suitable ORC module may, for example, only fit after pipe runs have been rerouted or existing equipment temporarily removed. A different configuration with comparable net energy output may therefore be financially preferable if less extensive ship modifications are needed. Installation costs may thus partly determine which technical design is preferable.
The installation schedule must also be assessed. If the work can take place during an already scheduled yard period, the extra downtime may be shorter than if a separate yard visit is required for the WHRS. A distinction must be made between costs that would arise even without the project and costs actually caused by waste heat recovery. A maintenance visit that was already scheduled does not automatically constitute a WHRS project cost in full.
By contrast, additional engineering, installation work and any extension of the yard stay must be attributed to the project if they arise solely from the new installation. Operational consequences may also be financially relevant. If the ship remains out of service for longer or is temporarily less available for service because of the installation, this may lead to additional costs or lost revenue, depending on the contractual situation.
For newbuilds, foundations, pipe routes and technical connections can already be included during ship design. Certain later modifications can thus be avoided, but a WHRS integrated at an early stage does not automatically become an attractive investment as a result. For newbuilds too, all necessary equipment and its costs must be included.
For each WHRS design examined, project costs must also be established on the same basis. Only then can it be assessed whether the additional net energy output of a larger or more complex installation has sufficient financial value to justify the additional investment.
How Do Maintenance, Availability and Remaining Economic Life Affect the Outcome?
A waste heat recovery system incurs additional operating costs. These must be compared with the energy and emissions savings expected over the same period. In an ORC, heat exchangers, pumps, the expander, generator and control equipment may require maintenance. Depending on the design, the condition of the organic working fluid may also warrant inspection, analysis or treatment.
Maintenance requirements differ between installations. A turbine and a screw expander, for example, need not require maintenance on the same components or have the same overhaul requirements. Heat exchanger fouling may also depend on the fuel used, water quality and engine load. Deposits may reduce heat transfer and increase flow resistance, so maintenance becomes necessary to keep performance within the intended limits.
This work causes direct maintenance costs and may simultaneously reduce the available production hours. When the WHRS is out of service during maintenance, the ship cannot recover energy from the waste heat concerned during that period. The required electricity or heat may then have to be supplied by other equipment. The financial impact can include both maintenance expenditure and the temporary loss of energy savings.
Annual output must therefore be based on realistic availability. A calculation that assumes continuous operation at rated power, with no allowance for maintenance or faults, may overestimate its financial value. Major overhauls and component replacements during its service life may also be relevant. If, for example, an expander, pump or other major component needs a major service during the financial appraisal period, the costs and any downtime must be included in the cash flow calculation.
Double counting must be prevented. If net annual output has already been reduced for expected maintenance downtime, the same energy loss must not be deducted again as a separate adjustment. The same applies to electrical auxiliary consumption. Energy already included in calculated net electricity generation must not be entered again as the same operating cost item.
Alongside maintenance and availability, the ship's remaining economic life is important. The service life of an ORC may differ from the period for which the current owner still wishes or is able to operate the ship. An installation may remain technically usable for a long time, while the ship is sold, replaced or substantially modified earlier. In that case, it must be established over which period the investor can actually realize the expected financial benefits.
Any residual value may be relevant, but must not be assumed without substantiation. The value of a WHRS on sale depends, among other things, on its technical condition, suitability for future use and a prospective buyer's interest. Planned engine or fuel changes may also affect usability. An existing ORC may continue to function after such a change, but may need different heat exchangers or changes to the controls.
If such work is sufficiently plausible during the assessment period, its consequences for investment costs and energy output must be included. An investment with attractive annual savings may therefore be less favourable if the remaining operating period is short. Conversely, an installation with relatively modest annual output may be financially attractive if it stays in service for many years and maintenance and investment costs are sufficiently limited.
The economic life must therefore match the actual expectations for the ship and the period over which the investing party can realize the benefits. Not only the ORC's technical service life, but above all the period over which the investor can capture the savings determines how much value the investment can deliver.
What Financial Value Do EU ETS, FuelEU Maritime and Tax Schemes Have?
Alongside avoided fuel costs, the effects of emissions regulations and any tax incentives may also be relevant to a WHRS investment. These benefits must be assessed separately because they have different legal bases and conditions of application.
Under the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), the responsible shipping companies must surrender allowances for the relevant greenhouse gas emissions within its scope. If waste heat recovery reduces fuel consumption, emissions covered by EU ETS may also decrease. From the 2026 emissions year, the system for the cargo and passenger ships concerned covers, in addition to CO2, CH4 and N2O. The full phase-in of the emission allowance obligation also applies to the relevant emissions for 2026.
The economic value of these savings depends on the emissions actually avoided, the geographical coverage of the voyages and port activities concerned, and the value of emission allowances. Not every tonne of CO2 avoided during worldwide operation automatically leads to a corresponding reduction in the ETS obligation. The financial contribution must be determined for the emissions actually covered by the applicable system.
The contractual allocation of emissions costs also merits attention. The party financing the WHRS investment need not automatically be the one receiving the financial benefit of a lower allowance requirement.
FuelEU Maritime works differently. Regulation (EU) 2023/1805 assesses the average greenhouse gas intensity of the energy used. With the same energy mix and applicable emission factors, lower energy use through waste heat recovery does not automatically reduce that intensity. Lower energy use can, however, change the magnitude of the FuelEU compliance balance. For a ship with a negative compliance balance, lower energy use may reduce the deficit under otherwise unchanged conditions.
With a positive compliance balance, the same energy savings may instead reduce the magnitude of the available surplus. The effects thus depend on the ship's original compliance position. The financial value is also influenced by the relevant energy quantities and any use of banking, borrowing or pooling. A WHRS therefore cannot automatically be credited with a fixed FuelEU bonus per kilowatt-hour produced.
If recovered electricity mainly displaces a particular fuel, the relative shares of the energy sources used may also change. In that case, the weighted average greenhouse gas intensity may also change. The direction and magnitude of this effect must be established in accordance with the FuelEU methodology.
Avoided fuel costs and possible benefits from EU ETS or FuelEU Maritime may be distinct financial effects of the same technical energy savings. However, they must be calculated separately to prevent the same savings from being valued several times. If a particular emissions cost is already fully included in the energy price used, for example, it must not be entered again as a separate financial benefit without an adjustment.
Tax incentives may also be relevant. For Dutch businesses, the Energy Investment Allowance (EIA) may be available if both the business and the asset meet the applicable conditions. The 2026 Energy List includes an Organic Rankine Cycle or Kalina cycle under asset code 221102 for converting waste heat into mechanical or electrical energy.
The EIA offers, in 2026 and subject to conditions, an additional tax deduction of 40% of qualifying investment costs. This is not a direct discount of 40% on the purchase price. The actual tax benefit depends, among other things, on the business's tax position and the investment costs that actually qualify for the deduction.
The listing of the ORC on the Energy List also does not mean that every installation on board a ship automatically meets all conditions. The investor's tax position, use of the asset and any specific exclusions must be assessed, among other factors. The date on which the business makes the binding investment commitment also matters. For purchase costs, the general rule is that the investment must be notified to the Netherlands Enterprise Agency (RVO) within three months of entering into this commitment.
For a proposed investment, it is therefore important to check eligibility before placing a binding order. Otherwise, the expected relief may no longer be available under the applicable conditions. In the financial calculation, avoided fuel costs, possible emissions costs and any tax benefits are therefore shown separately. It must be clear which savings arise directly from operation, which depend on future regulations and market prices, and which apply only if the tax conditions have been met.
How Sensitive Is the Investment to Fuel Prices and Future Ship Modifications?
The economic outcome of a WHRS investment may change substantially if operation during its economic life differs from the original expectations. Fuel prices and the actual operational and load profile in particular may affect financial returns. If an installation saves a comparable amount of fuel each year, the financial value of those savings increases at higher fuel prices. At lower prices, the same technical savings become less valuable.
The ship's deployment also determines how much energy can be recovered. An ORC selected for sustained engine loading may produce less electricity if the ship later sails for fewer hours or operates more frequently at part load. Electrical demand may also change. If generator dispatch or the distribution of electricity consumption changes, a larger or smaller share of ORC production can be used on board.
A future fuel or engine change may also have consequences. If the ship starts using a different fuel or the engine installation is modified, exhaust gas temperatures, flow rates and the distribution of heat across the cooling circuits may change. The existing ORC may consequently operate at a different operating point. Additional modifications to heat exchangers, intermediate circuits or control may also become necessary.
If such changes are sufficiently plausible within the economic assessment period, their consequences for investment costs and future energy output must be investigated. The original heat conditions must then not be retained for the full service life without further assessment.
The interaction with other energy-saving measures also merits attention. If ship resistance or the required propulsion power is reduced, for example, the main engine may consume less fuel. Less heat may consequently also become available through the exhaust gases and engine cooling. The ship may then become more energy-efficient overall, while ORC electricity production decreases.
This does not automatically mean that the combination is financially unfavourable. However, it must be established what additional savings the WHRS still delivers within the ship configuration that arises after the other measures have been implemented. Individual saving percentages must therefore not simply be added together if the measures affect each other's engine load or heat supply. The combined energy and cost savings must relate to a single, internally consistent operating configuration.
WHRS availability also remains uncertain. Fouling, maintenance, component faults and changes in cooling may affect net annual energy output. The savings achieved may consequently be lower than originally expected.
For the financial assessment, a sensitivity analysis is therefore needed. It shows how the outcome changes with different assumptions about operating hours, heat supply, fuel prices, electrical auxiliary consumption, availability and maintenance costs. If avoided emissions costs form a significant part of the expected return, the relevant emission allowance prices and legal assumptions must also be included in the assessment.
The assumptions used must remain technically compatible with each other. It is not correct, for example, to combine a substantially reduced engine load with the original maximum thermal power available from the exhaust gas if those conditions cannot occur simultaneously. A less favourable scenario shows how much financial value remains if the ship is operated at a suitable load for fewer hours or fuel prices fall. A more favourable scenario shows what additional value is possible if the installation is used for longer or avoids higher costs of existing energy production.
This is not solely about calculating the widest possible range. What matters is which assumptions actually determine the financial outcome and how plausible the different operating conditions are. The sensitivity analysis must primarily make clear whether the investment is attractive only under favourable assumptions or also retains sufficient value when realistic setbacks occur.
How Do You Assess Payback Period, Net Present Value and Return?
The financial assessment of a WHRS investment starts with the expected cash flows over its economic life. The appraisal relates investment expenditure to the annual savings and other cash flows the investor actually receives or incurs. Net operating cash flow arises from the avoided costs, less the additional operating costs caused by the WHRS.
Avoided fuel costs may account for most of the savings. Any benefits from EU ETS, FuelEU Maritime or other schemes are included only if they are sufficiently substantiated and actually accrue to the investing party. Future maintenance costs and any capital expenditure on replacements must also be included. Cash flows therefore need not be the same every year.
The simple payback period gives an initial indication of the period needed to recover the original investment from net financial savings. This method may be useful for an initial assessment, particularly if annual savings are relatively stable. However, a simple payback period does not automatically account for the time value of money. Significant costs may also be missed in the payback calculation if they arise only later, such as a major overhaul or component replacement.
An assessment based on net present value may therefore give a more complete picture. In this method, future cash flows are discounted to present value at an appropriate rate. The present value of the relevant investment expenditure is then deducted. Net present value thus shows whether the expected returns within the selected assessment period represent sufficient value relative to the investment and the required rate of return used.
The internal rate of return can also be used to assess attractiveness. For suitable cash flow patterns, this measure provides insight into the return arising from the investment. The outcome is then compared with the financial criteria of the owner or investor concerned. Which assessment is decisive depends in part on the required rate of return and the alternative uses of the available investment capital.
In the financial calculation, a consistent cash flow basis must be used. If the assessment concerns the project as a whole, project cash flows and the corresponding required rate of return are used. If the return on equity is being examined instead, financing cash flows may also be relevant. These two approaches must not be mixed without further adjustment.
It must also be clear how taxes, tax benefits, depreciation and any residual value are accounted for. Depreciation is a non-cash charge that may affect the investor's tax position. Similarly, a possible EIA deduction does not yield the same amount as a direct subsidy without further calculation. The tax value must therefore be established within the financial and tax position of the investor concerned.
The discount rate must also match the cash flows used. If future price increases are included in the cash flows, the treatment of inflation must be consistent with the selected discount rate. For net present value, the ship's remaining economic life is also relevant. Financial returns arising only after the expected sale or withdrawal from service must not be included as a benefit for the current owner without an appropriate residual value assessment.
There is therefore no universally applicable payback period that can be considered attractive for every waste heat recovery system. An owner with a short remaining operating period may use different financial criteria from an owner who intends to continue using a ship for a long time. The uncertainty of future cash flows, availability of investment capital and presence of alternative projects may also influence the decision.
A reliable assessment therefore shows more than a payback period or return. It must also be clear whether the investment meets the selected financial criteria, how much headroom there is for adverse changes and whether the outcome remains sufficiently favourable under plausible operating conditions.
Who Receives the Financial Benefit of the Energy Saved?
In ship operation, a distinction must be made between the party financing a WHRS investment and the party benefiting directly from lower energy consumption. These parties need not be the same. A shipowner may, for example, purchase and maintain the installation, while the ship is operated under an agreement in which another party pays certain fuel costs.
In that case, the owner making the investment may not receive the fuel cost savings. The WHRS may then create value for the ship as a whole, while the investor receives only part of this value. Contract duration may also be relevant. If the ship is deployed under different operating terms for part of its remaining economic life, the party receiving the WHRS benefits may change.
For emissions costs, a similar allocation applies. Under EU ETS, legal responsibility for surrendering emission allowances may lie with the designated shipping company, while the shipping company may be entitled to recover the costs from another party under certain conditions. The European ETS Directive contains specific provisions for this when another party contractually bears ultimate responsibility for fuel purchases or operational decisions about matters such as route, speed and cargo.
Under FuelEU Maritime, the company designated under the Regulation remains responsible for compliance obligations and any FuelEU penalties. However, certain costs may be allocated to commercial operators by contract. The precise financial consequences must therefore be established on the basis of the relevant legislation and the operating agreement actually in force. A technical emissions reduction is not automatically an equally large cash flow saving for every party involved.
Any maintenance savings or benefits from a change in generator dispatch also do not necessarily accrue to the party that made the ORC investment. For the economic assessment, it must therefore be clear who pays for the investment and maintenance, who bears the fuel costs, and who can benefit from lower energy and emissions costs.
A WHRS may be economically attractive for the ship as a whole, while the project remains less favourable for the individual investor if the financial benefits largely accrue to another party. Agreements on sharing savings, adjusting the payment for the use of the ship or allocating investment costs can change this relationship.
However, the financial assessment must be based on cash flows that have actually been agreed and are sufficiently substantiated. A possible future payment must not automatically be included as a certain return if the parties have yet to make a binding agreement. A sound investment decision therefore considers more than the total economic value of the WHRS for the ship. The financial value that the investing party can actually receive during the relevant period of use is also a determining factor.
When Is a Smaller ORC or Direct Heat Use Economically More Attractive?
The installation with the highest rated power need not deliver the greatest economic value. A larger ORC can produce more electricity when enough heat is available, but the required thermal input is not available in every operating mode. If the ship operates at part load for long periods, some of the rated capacity may be used only for limited periods. At the same time, a larger installation may require more space, heat exchanger capacity, condenser capacity and supporting equipment.
A smaller ORC may, under certain conditions, better match the usual engine load. The installation may consequently operate within a suitable operating range for a larger share of the relevant operating hours. The investment may also be lower if less complex heat and cooling equipment is needed. However, the lower purchase and installation costs must be compared with the additional electricity that a larger unit could generate at higher engine loads.
The economic preference therefore does not follow solely from the relationship between average engine load and rated ORC power. A larger installation may still be more attractive if sufficient heat and electrical demand are available for long periods. In that case, the additional net electricity generation may represent sufficient value to justify the higher investment and operating costs. The comparison must therefore be based on the differences between the annual net cash flows of the possible designs.
The choice between electricity production and direct heat use may also be important. If the ship has suitable heat demand, waste heat can be used directly through a heat exchanger. A complete ORC with an expander and generator may not be needed for this purpose. The equipment required, investment costs and maintenance requirements may therefore differ.
However, the economic value of direct heat use depends on the useful heat the system can actually supply and the existing heat production it displaces. A heat source may be technically suitable for heating, while insufficient heat demand exists during much of the operating period. Annual financial savings may then remain limited, even when a large amount of waste heat is available.
An ORC may instead be attractive if enough usable waste heat is available for many operating hours and the ship simultaneously has a relevant demand for electrical energy. A combination of direct heat use and electricity production may also be technically possible. The distribution of the available heat must then be assessed jointly.
When equipment that uses heat receives some of the heat, that same energy is not automatically available again in full for the ORC. Financial returns must therefore not be calculated as though both applications independently have the entire original heat flow available to them. The combined installation costs must also be included. A combination may deliver additional value, but may require more heat exchangers, pipework, control and maintenance.
The preference for a larger or smaller ORC, direct heat use or a combination ultimately follows from the additional savings that each configuration can actually deliver and the costs needed to achieve them. If the available heat is insufficiently suited to an electricity-generating installation, direct heat use may be more attractive. Conversely, if there is very little useful heat demand but sufficient electrical demand, an ORC may offer greater economic value.
The right choice is therefore based on the ship's actual heat and energy balance. The highest available thermal or electrical power is not an independent selection criterion.
What Data Are Needed for a Sound Investment Decision?
A reliable economic assessment starts with a sufficiently complete picture of the ship's expected use. For this purpose, data are needed on the engines installed, their loads and operating hours under the relevant sailing and operating conditions. The temperatures and flow rates of the available heat sources must also be known, as must the heat already used on board. On this basis, it can be established how much additional waste heat remains available for the recovery installation being examined.
The possible net energy production is then determined. For an ORC, performance at different engine loads is linked for this purpose to the available cooling conditions, relevant auxiliary consumption and electrical demand on board. The calculation must also take account of periods in which the installation receives insufficient heat, must reduce output or is out of service. Gross output at a favourable design point alone provides insufficient information about annual financial returns.
It is then established which existing generation the recovered electricity or heat actually displaces. For electricity production, the main consideration is the change in fuel consumption of the generating sets concerned. For direct heat use, it is determined which original fuel-fired heat production is no longer needed.
The fuel saved is then valued at the relevant cost of the fuel it replaces. A distinction must be made between direct fuel savings and any additional financial consequences for maintenance and emissions costs. These benefits must also be correctly attributed to the party bearing the investment cost. Savings that accrue entirely to another party to the operating agreement are not automatically an available cash flow for the investor.
The total project costs must also be known with sufficient accuracy. The budget includes the WHRS module and all necessary heat exchangers, pumps, pipes, cooling equipment, electrical connections, structural modifications, engineering and installation costs. For a retrofit, work required solely because of the WHRS is distinguished from maintenance or other modifications that would also be carried out without the project. The additional investment costs are thus established consistently.
Operating costs are then linked to the expected service life. Maintenance, any major overhauls, available production hours and possible downtime must be included. The ship's remaining economic life and expected operating agreements are also relevant. The financial value of the energy savings must actually be available to the investing party during the assessment period.
If certain assumptions are uncertain, they must remain identifiable in the calculation. An initial technical and financial estimate may be suitable for establishing whether further engineering is worthwhile, but does not automatically provide sufficient evidence for a final investment decision. The expected cash flows are therefore assessed under different realistic conditions. This shows how changes in operating hours, heat supply, energy prices, availability and maintenance costs affect the financial outcome.
If the investment is attractive only with continuously high engine load, exceptionally favourable energy prices or insufficiently substantiated maximum availability, the financial result may be vulnerable. If the project also delivers sufficient positive financial value under less favourable but plausible operating conditions, a stronger basis for further decision-making emerges.
The assessment may also show that a smaller installation better matches the operational profile, that direct heat use offers more value or that the ship's remaining economic life is insufficient to recover the investment. Investment in waste heat recovery is thus particularly attractive when the recovered energy actually replaces other energy production over sufficient operating hours. The financial benefits must then outweigh all necessary investment and operating costs over the relevant economic life.
The decisive factor is not the highest stated generator power or the greatest amount of available engine heat, but the additional net financial value that the WHRS can realize under the expected operating conditions. Considering this value alongside total costs, the remaining economic life, who receives the savings and the main uncertainties helps establish whether a waste heat recovery system represents a sound investment or whether another technical solution better suits the ship.
This Article in the Series
The economic value of a WHRS starts with the energy actually saved, not with maximum generator power. Here, the different effects on EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime show that avoided emissions do not automatically have the same financial effect. How much fuel is actually saved depends on the factors determining savings from WHRS electricity. These returns must be weighed against the total costs and risks within the business case and investment decision for WHRS installations.