Which Costs Besides the WHRS Installation Should You Include When Retrofitting an Existing Ship?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
When retrofitting a waste heat recovery system to an existing ship, you must allow for the costs of engineering, system connections, ship modifications, installation, shipyard work and commissioning in addition to the equipment offered. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) must be integrated with the existing engine, cooling and electrical systems. For an installation based on the Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), additional heat exchangers, piping, pumps, foundations and controls may be needed.
Moving equipment into the engine room, structural modifications, ship-specific approvals and any additional downtime may also affect the total retrofit investment. Which costs actually arise depends heavily on the existing ship configuration and the agreed scope of supply. A heat exchanger or pump may, for example, already be part of the WHRS quotation, while the connection to the existing shipboard installation must be carried out separately. A supplier may also offer a complete ORC module without covering all the shipyard work needed to install and commission it.
A reliable retrofit budget therefore begins with establishing the components and work included, the necessary additional provisions and the costs that can only be determined with sufficient accuracy after ship-specific engineering. The aim is a budget for the complete installation as it can actually be built, without missing connections, double-counted costs or insufficiently substantiated assumptions about the required time at the shipyard.
Why Is the Price of the WHRS Installation Not Automatically the Total Retrofit Investment?
The price of a waste heat recovery system may relate to different scopes of supply. A quotation may cover only the main module, but may also cover a broader package including heat exchangers, pumps, electrical equipment and control arrangements. Without a clear description of the supply, it is therefore not known which components and work are still needed to make the installation ready for operation.
In an ORC, the expander, generator, working-fluid pump and other components of the thermodynamic cycle may be housed within a single module. However, the connections to the original heat sources, the ship's cooling system and the shipboard electrical system may fall outside the same scope of supply. The heat exchangers through which waste heat is absorbed may also be separate components. When the ORC is supplied through a water or thermal oil circuit, additional pipework, circulation pumps and controls may be needed. The price of the main equipment therefore gives only limited insight into the work needed to prepare the ship for installation.
A ship with suitable connection options may require relatively limited modifications. With a different engine-room layout, however, extensive modifications to exhaust gas piping, cooling water circuits or electrical distribution equipment may be necessary. The existing ship configuration thus directly affects the costs incurred in addition to the WHRS supply.
An important starting point is the distinction between supplying equipment and carrying out the connections. When an exhaust gas heat exchanger is included in the WHRS quotation, for example, this does not automatically mean that removal of existing pipe sections, fitting of new supports and installation on board are also included. The same applies to a pump included in the supply package that the shipyard must connect to the ship's pipework. Purchase and installation are then separate activities, even when they concern the same component.
Conversely, a component must not be included again as a separate equipment purchase when it is already part of the agreed supply. For every cost item, it must therefore be clear whether it concerns equipment, installation, connection or a combination of these. The terms of supply may also affect the allocation of costs. Transport to the shipyard, unloading, temporary storage and actually bringing the equipment on board need not, for example, be carried out by the same party.
In addition to the scope of supply, it must therefore be known where responsibility for transport, installation, connection and testing begins and ends. A quotation for an installation ready for operation may consequently differ substantially from a quotation for an ORC module alone. These amounts must not be compared as equivalent project prices without further assessment. First, it must be clear what additional work each offer would require to deliver an installation ready for service.
The complete retrofit budget is therefore built up from the configuration that must actually function on board. It identifies which equipment is already included in the offer, which connections and work are still needed and which party is responsible for them. Only when these boundaries are sufficiently clear can it be reliably determined which costs actually arise in addition to the WHRS supply. This avoids mistaking a lower module price for a lower overall retrofit cost.
Which Engineering and Technical Investigations Are Needed Before Installation?
A WHRS retrofit begins with an assessment of the existing shipboard installation. The selected equipment must fit within the available space and allow safe connection to the heat sources and to the ship's cooling and electrical distribution systems. Sufficiently reliable technical data are needed for this purpose. Existing drawings are often the starting point, but they may not fully reflect the ship as it is now. During previous maintenance periods, pipes may have been rerouted, pumps replaced or additional installations fitted. When these modifications have not been adequately documented, inspections and dimensional checks on board may be necessary.
With limited engine room space, a targeted dimensional survey can help to establish the actual dimensions, pipe routes and access openings. The work and costs required depend on the accuracy needed for a reliable installation design. The existing heat sources must also be investigated. For exhaust gas heat, relevant factors include gas temperature, mass flow rate and permitted exhaust back pressure. For engine cooling water, the available temperatures, flow rates and conditions for the original engine cooling must be known.
These data must correspond to the engine loads at which the WHRS will actually operate. A heat calculation based solely on rated engine power provides insufficient certainty about performance during normal operation. The ship-specific design then sets out how the heat sources will be connected to the selected system. In doing so, the heat exchangers, any intermediate circuits, connection points and necessary control arrangements are matched to the existing engine installation.
The consequences for ship cooling must also be investigated. When the ORC condenser is connected to an existing central cooling water circuit, it must be established whether heat rejection capacity, pump performance and the distribution of coolant through the pipework are adequate. With insufficient capacity, additional coolers, pumps or other modifications may become necessary. These provisions can only be budgeted reliably when the thermal and hydraulic consequences of the connection have been worked out in sufficient detail.
The electrical connection also requires engineering. The generator, protection systems and any power electronics must suit the existing shipboard electrical system. It must also be investigated whether the power management system (PMS) can handle the additional electricity generation.
The structural assessment forms another part of the preparation. Foundations, pipe supports and any modifications to the ship's structure must be suitable for the equipment weight, vibration and other relevant loads. The consequences for the total ship weight and the position of the centre of gravity may also require attention. When these modifications affect the existing stability data, additional assessment or documentation may be necessary.
The engineering required may therefore encompass several technical disciplines. The costs are determined not solely by the number of drawings or calculations, but primarily by the extent and interdependence of the ship modifications. An initial feasibility assessment may be sufficient to select a promising configuration. For the detailed design and installation, additional calculations, detailed drawings and technical assessments may then be needed.
The budget must therefore distinguish between engineering already included in the WHRS supply and ship-specific work carried out by the shipyard, owner or other parties involved. It must also remain clear which technical investigations are still needed before the associated installation costs can be finalized.
Which Additional Costs Does Connection to the Exhaust Gas Path Cause?
For waste heat recovery from exhaust gases, a heat exchanger must be incorporated at a suitable point in the existing exhaust system. The additional costs are determined not solely by the heat exchanger, but primarily by the work needed to connect it safely. Depending on the available space, existing pipe sections may need to be modified or replaced. New bends, connections, supports and thermal insulation may also be needed to incorporate the heat exchanger into the original path.
The selected position must suit the existing exhaust gas components. When silencers, existing exhaust gas boilers or aftertreatment equipment take up much of the space along the exhaust run, a different pipe route may become necessary. This can entail additional pipework, installation work and modifications to supports or existing equipment.
The permitted exhaust back pressure remains an important technical limit in this respect. A heat exchanger causes flow resistance and thus contributes to the total pressure drop of the exhaust gas installation. When the existing installation has insufficient margin below the back-pressure limit, a modified piping configuration may be needed. The necessary work may therefore extend beyond installing the new heat exchanger. Other parts of the exhaust gas path may also need to be modified to keep the total flow resistance within the permitted engine limits.
The condition of the system in service must also be taken into account. Fouling can increase the pressure loss across the heat exchanger. The installation must stay within the permitted back pressure in service, including when its heat transfer surfaces are no longer completely clean. Controls or a bypass may also be needed to regulate heat extraction or maintain the original exhaust gas discharge when the WHRS is out of service.
The equipment actually required depends on the engine, the heat exchanger and the existing exhaust gas installation. A bypass therefore does not automatically constitute a separate cost item in every WHRS retrofit.
The temperature of the exhaust gases also affects the design. Hot pipes expand during operation, so connections, supports and any expansion joints must be designed so that they do not transmit excessive forces to the heat exchanger, turbocharger or other equipment. The necessary thermal insulation and protection against hot surfaces must also suit the new configuration. When existing insulation must be removed and reinstated, this work may also form part of the retrofit.
Access for inspection and cleaning may also entail additional work. An exhaust gas heat exchanger must remain sufficiently accessible during operation. When existing equipment must be moved or additional access is needed for this purpose, this affects the total costs. Depending on the installation location, temporary access and lifting arrangements may also be needed, such as scaffolding, lifting equipment or access to pipe sections that are difficult to reach. The provisions required must correspond to the actual access available for installation and maintenance.
When exhaust gas aftertreatment equipment is present, it must be established whether the new heat exchanger maintains the prescribed temperature and flow conditions. An apparently simple connection may therefore require additional engineering and installation work. The cost of integrating the heat exchanger into the exhaust system are ultimately determined by the existing piping configuration, the selected heat exchanger position and the modifications needed to keep the engine and exhaust gas functions within their permitted limits.
Which Costs Arise for Engine Cooling Water and Additional Intermediate Circuits?
In addition to exhaust gas heat, an ORC can use heat from engine cooling water or other suitable hot circuits. When the existing ship has not been prepared for this heat extraction, additional connections and modifications to the cooling water installation may be needed. First, it must be established from which circuit heat can be extracted and which temperatures and flow rates are available there. The connection must preserve the engine's existing temperature control and cooling functions.
When a heat exchanger is incorporated into an existing cooling water circuit, new piping, isolation valves and supports may be needed. The hydraulic behaviour may also change because the new component causes additional flow resistance. Depending on the existing pump and piping configuration, modifications may be necessary to maintain sufficient circulation through all equipment served by the circuit. The costs therefore depend not only on the new heat exchanger, but also on the consequences for the original circuit.
Engine cooling must also continue to function when the ORC temporarily absorbs no heat. Additional isolation, control or bypass arrangements may be needed for this purpose, depending on the original cooling water configuration and the selected connection.
When the heat source is not connected directly to the ORC module, a separate intermediate circuit may be used. A water or thermal oil circuit then transfers the recovered heat to the ORC. Such an intermediate circuit requires piping, equipment to circulate the fluid and possibly additional heat exchangers. Depending on the design, provision for thermal expansion, filters, isolation valves, instrumentation and thermal insulation may also be necessary.
The amount of piping also depends on the distance between the heat source and the ORC module. A long route or one that is difficult to access may require more piping material, supports and penetrations. Additional installation work may also be needed when pipes must be routed past existing machinery or through confined spaces. The selected module position therefore affects not only the available space, but also the cost of transferring heat to the module.
If thermal oil is used, the installation and safety provisions must be suitable for the selected fluid and the operating temperatures. This may entail different technical requirements and costs from an intermediate circuit using water. The initial charge of fluid and any prescribed treatment of the fluid may also be relevant at handover. These costs must be distinguished from subsequent replacement or maintenance during operation.
However, a separate intermediate circuit must not automatically be budgeted as an extra cost on every ORC quotation. Some installations are supplied with certain heat exchangers, pumps or connection arrangements, whereas in other designs these components form part of the ship-specific integration. The budget must therefore make clear which components fall within the agreed WHRS supply and which new provisions are needed to connect the selected heat source safely to the module.
When Does the ORC Condenser Require Modifications to Ship Cooling?
In an ORC, only part of the heat supplied is converted into mechanical work and then into electrical energy. Most of the remaining heat must be rejected through the condenser. The existing ship cooling system must therefore provide sufficient capacity and suitable connection options. When sufficient cooling capacity and suitable connection points are already available, the additional work may be limited to pipe connections, isolation valves and the necessary controls.
When the existing ship cooling system cannot adequately accommodate the connection, more extensive modifications may be needed. These may involve additional pumps, different pipe diameters, modifications to central coolers or a different distribution of cooling water flows. After all, the original ship cooling system also serves engines and other technical equipment. Connection of the ORC condenser must not unacceptably affect the necessary cooling functions of these systems.
In determining the required capacity, a distinction must be made between different heat sources. When the ORC uses exhaust gas heat, heat that previously left the ship mainly in the exhaust may subsequently be transferred through the condenser to the ship cooling system. When the ORC uses heat from engine cooling water, part of the original heat rejection may instead shift to a different location within the cooling system. The amount of additional heat that the overall cooling system must reject therefore depends on the selected configuration.
The full condenser duty must therefore not be added to all the original cooling loads without further assessment. Any increase in cooling capacity must be sized for the heat loads after installation. The hydraulic connection may also entail costs. A central cooler may, for example, have sufficient total heat transfer capacity, while the selected branch of the cooling circuit or circulation pump cannot supply the required cooling water flow rate to the condenser.
In that case, modifications to pumps, piping or controls may be necessary without the total cooling capacity having to be expanded in the same proportion. The assessment must therefore distinguish thermal capacity from hydraulic performance.
Cooling water temperatures during the actual operational profile are also important. A condenser that can reject sufficient heat with cold seawater need not support the same ORC electrical output under warmer conditions. When additional cooling capacity is needed, it must be established how this can be achieved technically. In certain configurations, this may also have consequences for the existing seawater cooling system.
An additional seawater pump or greater heat rejection may, for example, necessitate modifications to the available water intake, sea chest or overboard discharge. Such modifications may require extensive work on the ship and, depending on the design, dry-docking. However, this is not a standard requirement for every ORC retrofit. The need follows from the existing cooling water installation, the actual condenser heat load and the selected connection method.
The financial consequences thus depend on more than the rated condenser duty. In particular, the existing cooling capacity, the hydraulic arrangement and the work needed to make the new connection safely determine which additional costs arise.
Which Electrical Connections and Control Arrangements Are Added?
The existing shipboard electrical system must be able to accept the ORC generator's output safely. Additional electrical equipment that does not automatically form part of the WHRS supply may be needed for this purpose. Which provisions are needed depends on the generator design and the characteristics of the existing electrical installation. Depending on the configuration, the generator may be connected directly or through power electronics.
Switches, protection systems, transformers or other electrical provisions may also be needed to deliver the generator's output to the shipboard electrical system under the required conditions. The existing distribution equipment must provide sufficient space and electrical capacity for this purpose. When the available connection options are insufficient, modifications to the switchboard or other parts of the electrical distribution may become necessary. This can make electrical integration considerably more extensive than fitting an additional generator connection.
The protection systems must also suit the modified configuration. The addition of a generator may affect fault currents, power flows and the interaction between existing and new protection systems. A review of protection coordination and any adjustments required may therefore form part of the electrical engineering. The electrical installation must, after connection of the WHRS, continue to function safely under the relevant normal and abnormal operating conditions.
The required cabling forms a separate element. The distance between the ORC module, any converters and the connection point in the switchboard affects the cable length and the cable routes. When existing cable routes offer insufficient space, additional cable trays, supports or penetrations may be needed. The accessibility of these routes during installation may also affect the work required.
The electrical supply to the WHRS auxiliaries must also be taken into account. Pumps, controls, instrumentation and additional cooling may require separate supplies or connections.
Integration with the power management system (PMS) forms another important part of the integration. When the ORC supplies electricity, existing generating sets may need to produce less power. The PMS must be able to handle this change while maintaining the required power reserve. The energy supply must also respond appropriately if WHRS output drops unexpectedly or is lost altogether.
Depending on the existing generator control system, modifications to software, communication links, protection systems or the control of electrical load sharing may be needed for this purpose. The consequences of such modifications must be taken into account in the electrical engineering and functional testing. After all, an electrically connected generator is not automatically fully integrated into the ship's energy supply.
Metering equipment may also entail relevant costs. When net WHRS output must be recorded separately or compliance with a performance guarantee must be demonstrated, additional energy meters and measurement points may be needed. These provisions must correspond to the system boundary agreed for the technical assessment or acceptance. After all, gross generator output and the net contribution to the shipboard electrical system need not represent the same quantity.
The budget for electrical integration must therefore cover more than physically connecting the generator. Auxiliary supplies, protection systems, PMS integration, metering equipment and necessary functional tests must also be adequately covered, insofar as they are not already included in the WHRS supply.
Which Structural, Transport and Installation Costs Are Necessary?
The physical integration of a WHRS may entail additional work, particularly when the available engine room space is limited. The mounting location must be able to bear the equipment's weight and operating loads. Depending on the existing ship structure, new foundations, supports or local reinforcements may be necessary. Not only the main module's own weight, but also ship motions, vibration and forces from connected piping play a role here.
The structural assessment must therefore correspond to the actual equipment and the location where it is installed. Heat exchangers, pumps and other components may also need separate supports. For pipes subject to large temperature changes, thermal expansion must also be taken into account. Insufficient allowance for movement or insufficient support can cause unwanted forces on the equipment and existing ship structure.
The addition of equipment may also affect the total ship weight and the position of the centre of gravity. When these modifications can affect the existing stability data, additional calculations and revised documentation may be needed. Previous modifications to the ship may also be relevant here. After all, the combined change in weight and centre of gravity may be greater than that of the WHRS alone.
However, a new inclining test or other specific stability test is not automatically mandatory for every ORC retrofit. Which assessment is necessary depends on the extent of the modifications and the applicable regulations.
Transport of the equipment to the installation location also constitutes a separate cost factor. An ORC module may, for example, fit within the available space at its final location in the engine room, while the existing access openings are too small to bring the module inside as a single unit. Engine room hatches, deck openings, passageways and the available lifting space may therefore determine the installation method. If the access route is unsuitable, temporary dismantling work, additional lifting arrangements or structural modifications may be needed.
A modular design may offer an alternative under certain circumstances. In an ORC suitable for this approach, components can be brought on board separately and then assembled in their final position. This can avoid certain extensive modifications to the ship's structure. This approach may require more connection, assembly and testing work.
However, not every factory-assembled ORC module can be dismantled without implications for the installation. The selected arrangement must comply with the design, safety conditions and supplier's requirements.
The logistical costs must also be sufficiently clearly defined. Transport to the shipyard, unloading, temporary storage, protective packaging, cranes and actually bringing the equipment on board may fall under different supply and work packages. When heavy components must be placed in their final location, additional lifting equipment or temporary supports may be necessary. This work must be matched to the available space and load-bearing capacity of the structures involved.
Sufficient working space must also be available during installation. With limited space, existing equipment may need to be temporarily removed or relocated. Work on the ship's structure and piping may also necessitate a particular installation sequence. The final arrangement may be technically suitable, while the necessary installation operations prove difficult to carry out without advance planning.
Future maintenance access must also be maintained. A solution that requires less work during installation may become less attractive during operation if important components are no longer accessible. The structural and installation costs are therefore determined by the entire route to the installation site and the final layout. The dimensions and mass of the ORC module alone provide insufficient information about the costs of actually installing it on board.
How Do Shipyard Planning and Additional Downtime Affect Retrofit Costs?
A WHRS retrofit may require work for which existing engine, cooling water and electrical installations must be temporarily taken out of service. The work must therefore be coordinated with the available yard stay and the work already planned for the ship. During modification of the exhaust gas path, for example, the engine concerned may be temporarily unavailable. Modifications to cooling water circuits or electrical distribution equipment may also affect other necessary ship systems.
The installation sequence is therefore also determined by the periods during which these installations are safely available for work. Not all modifications can be carried out independently of one another. When the retrofit can be combined with an already planned shipyard visit, this may offer opportunities to combine some tasks and use the same periods of downtime. However, this does not mean that all the costs of the existing shipyard visit must be attributed to the WHRS.
For the retrofit budget, the additional work and costs that would not have arisen without the WHRS project are particularly relevant. When an engine is already being taken out of service for planned maintenance, for example, it must be established which additional work is made necessary by connection of the heat exchanger. It must also be investigated whether the WHRS installation extends the planned yard stay. An installation that can be carried out within the maintenance period already available may have different financial consequences from a project for which the ship must remain out of service for additional days.
Additional downtime can carry a substantial cost. When the ship is consequently unavailable for scheduled service, revenue may be lost or additional contractual obligations may arise. Which costs are actually relevant depends on how the ship is used, the operating agreement and the consequences of the delay. A general fixed value per day of downtime is therefore not suitable for every retrofit budget without further substantiation.
Double counting of costs must also be avoided here. When the net loss of operating revenue has already been included, the same loss must not be entered again as a separate cost item without an additional basis. The same applies to a shipyard period that was also necessary for other work. The WHRS budget must then primarily cover the additional costs and any extension to the yard stay.
Detailed engineering can help coordinate the installation work. When foundations, pipe routes and electrical connections have been worked out in sufficient detail before the ship becomes available for installation, work can be better coordinated. Certain provisions may possibly be prepared during an earlier maintenance period. In this way, part of the installation can be separated from the work for which the main ship systems must be out of service.
However, phased implementation does not automatically mean that every WHRS retrofit can take place without additional downtime. The necessary isolation of systems and any structural work remain determining factors. Moreover, when existing systems are opened up, discrepancies may become apparent that are not fully shown in the available drawings. The schedule must therefore allow for the technical uncertainties that remain after preparation.
Coordination between the supplier, shipyard and shipowner also affects implementation costs. When equipment is not available at the agreed time or a necessary connection point proves not to be ready, the installation sequence may need to be adjusted. The budget must therefore correspond to a workable schedule in which the main activities, responsibilities and interdependencies are sufficiently known. The yard schedule can then account for work beyond fitting the main module.
Which Costs Relate to Safety, Approval and Commissioning?
Once installed, a WHRS must operate safely alongside the existing ship systems. Additional safety provisions, technical assessments and tests may be necessary for this purpose. In an ORC, the properties of the organic working fluid and the operating conditions of the cycle play a particular role. Depending on the fluid used and the installation design, provisions may be needed for ventilation, overpressure protection, leak detection or safe containment and handling of the working fluid.
When such provisions are not present within the WHRS supply or the existing shipboard installation, they may entail additional costs. Which measures are needed must be determined from the selected installation and the applicable safety conditions. The initial charge of ORC working fluid also warrants attention. Under some supply arrangements, the fluid may already be part of the installation offered. In other cases, supply, filling or treatment during commissioning must be organized separately.
These costs form part of the necessary handover when they are required to make the installation ready for operation. They must be distinguished from subsequent replacement or maintenance of the working fluid during operation.
The behaviour of the installation in the event of faults must also be adequately assessed. When cooling fails or the generator can no longer deliver electrical power, the ORC must be able to reduce output or shut down as required. The original engine, exhaust gas and cooling water functions must be maintained in doing so. Depending on the design, additional control, isolation and protection arrangements may be necessary for this purpose.
It must also be established which ship-specific assessments and approvals apply. The requirements of the classification society, flag state and other competent authorities depend on the ship concerned and the selected WHRS configuration. Product or design approval for a separate ORC module does not automatically mean that all connections and modifications on board can be implemented without further assessment. Integration into the existing ship systems must be adequately substantiated separately.
The necessary technical documentation, any changes to existing certification data and the associated inspections must therefore be established in advance. In this way, it can be determined which tasks and costs to allow for in obtaining ship-specific approval.
Commissioning follows installation. During this process, the heat and cooling connections, electrical connection and relevant control and protection functions are checked. Depending on the design, pressure and leak tests, electrical checks and functional tests, among other things, may be needed before normal operation is permitted.
It must also be established whether the ORC functions within its permitted operating range under suitable operating conditions. The tests required depend on the installation, the applicable regulations and the agreed handover conditions.
When a performance guarantee forms part of the contract, separate performance verification may also be necessary. In this process, the guaranteed power, the system boundary and the relevant heat and cooling conditions are assessed according to a method agreed in advance. Such an acceptance test does not automatically serve the same purpose as a technical check through which it is established that the installation has been safely installed and may be put into operation. Both assessment objectives must therefore remain sufficiently distinct.
The availability of suitable test conditions may also affect implementation. A particular engine load, cooling water temperature or electrical load need not be present during every short shipyard test. It must therefore be clear in advance when performance verification will take place, which conditions apply for a valid test and which party will make the required test facilities available.
The transfer of technical documentation, operating instructions and any crew training may also form part of handover. Responsibility and costs for this must correspond to the agreed scope of supply. The budget must therefore provide for more than a physically installed system. All the necessary work to hand over the WHRS ready for operation in accordance with the agreed technical, safety and acceptance conditions must also be adequately covered.
Which Costs After Handover Do You Keep Separate From the Retrofit Investment?
In addition to the costs of installing the WHRS ready for operation, the system may incur maintenance and other operating costs in service. These are relevant to the economic assessment, but do not automatically form part of the original retrofit expenditure. In an ORC, heat exchangers, pumps, the expander, generator and control equipment may require periodic maintenance. The condition of the organic working fluid may also, depending on the design, warrant inspection, analysis or treatment.
Maintenance requirements depend on the selected equipment and operating conditions. An exhaust gas heat exchanger may, for example, need cleaning because of fouling, while mechanical components may require major inspections or overhauls during their service life. This work must be budgeted separately when it is relevant to future operating costs. After all, the initial project budget and the costs over the economic life serve different purposes.
Spare parts and maintenance provisions also warrant attention. A distinction must be made here between parts supplied at initial handover and parts purchased only later during operation. An initial stock of necessary spare parts may form part of the original project costs when it must be available at handover under the supply agreements. Subsequent replacements and periodic servicing, by contrast, fall under the costs of using the installation.
WHRS availability may also have financial consequences. When the ORC is out of service because of maintenance or a fault, less electricity may be produced from waste heat during that period. The ship may then need to meet that demand using existing generating sets or other energy sources. As a result, the actual net energy savings may be lower than with an installation that remains available during the same period.
However, lost energy savings and the cost of carrying out maintenance are distinct financial effects. The maintenance costs and the financial consequence of temporarily lost energy savings must therefore be assessed separately.
The installation's own energy consumption must also be accounted for consistently. Electricity for pumps, cooling and other auxiliary components may already be included in the calculated net ORC output. When these energy flows have been accounted for in that output, they must not be deducted from the savings again as the same operating cost item. Conversely, additional consumption that still falls outside the system boundary used must be included.
The distinction between initial project costs and future operating costs helps to carry out the financial assessment on a consistent basis. For the retrofit budget, the concern is the necessary expenditure up to and including the agreed handover. This may include, for example, the initial charge of working fluid, the agreed documentation and the spare parts supplied.
For the full economic assessment, the relevant costs over the remaining service life are also included. In this way, it remains clear what amount is needed to install the system on board and which additional financial burdens arise after the WHRS has been put into operation.
How Do You Avoid Missing Cost Items and Double-Budgeted Work?
A reliable retrofit budget requires a clear allocation of components and work between the parties involved. The WHRS supplier may, for example, be responsible for the ORC module and certain heat exchangers, while the shipyard provides the foundations, pipe connections and electrical connections. The shipowner may also be responsible for making the existing installations, technical documentation and certain facilities needed to carry out the work available. When these boundaries are insufficiently clear, necessary work may fall outside all the individual quotations.
An exhaust gas heat exchanger may, for example, be fully included in the quotation, while it has not yet been established who will modify the existing exhaust gas piping or fit the necessary supports. The same can occur with the condenser. A cooling water connection may have been provided for in the design, while it is still insufficiently clear whether the existing circulation pump is suitable or a larger central cooler will become necessary.
The budget must therefore correspond to the complete technical configuration and to a clear allocation of equipment supply and work. For every important connection, it is established which equipment is needed, who supplies it and who carries out the work to make the connection to the existing ship.
Budgeting the same components more than once must also be avoided here. When an intermediate circuit pump is already included in the WHRS supply, it must not appear again as a separate purchase item in the shipyard budget. However, the installation or electrical connection of that same pump may still fall outside the supply. A distinction must therefore be made between the costs of the equipment and the work needed to connect it and make it ready for service.
Such differences may also arise in engineering and commissioning. A quotation may, for example, cover technical drawings of the ORC module, but not the complete ship-specific engineering. Similarly, the supplier may carry out certain functional tests while the shipyard or owner remains responsible for checking other parts of the installation. These responsibilities must therefore be defined clearly.
The allocation of transport and installation costs also warrants attention. A supplier may deliver equipment to the shipyard, while unloading, lifting and installation must be organized separately. When this work is already included in another quotation, it must not be added again as a full separate cost item. The individual offers must therefore be assessed against the same actual division of supply and installation work.
A distinction must also be made between additional work for the WHRS and already planned ship maintenance. When an existing pipe would already have been replaced during the same shipyard period, it must be established which part of the work the WHRS adds. Possible delays must also be assessed on this basis. An extension of the shipyard period because of the WHRS may have financial consequences, but the originally planned downtime must not be attributed entirely to the new project without further substantiation.
Another important factor is uncertainty about the ship's existing systems and layout. When pipe routes, structural connection points or the available cooling capacity have not yet been sufficiently investigated, certain costs may remain provisional. This uncertainty must not be treated as though the work will entail no additional costs. Within the budget, it must remain identifiable which amounts are based on sufficiently detailed quotations and which are still estimates.
It must also be clear which costs remain dependent on a technical decision, for example concerning the selected pipe route, cooling water connection or ORC module location. An appropriate contingency allowance may be included for work whose extent has not yet been fully established. The allowance must reflect the ship's specific technical uncertainties.
There is no general contingency percentage that is suitable for every WHRS retrofit without substantiation. The necessary allowance for unforeseen costs depends on the available data, the complexity of the work and the uncertainties that remain after technical preparation. It must also be clear how changes during implementation are handled. When unexpected work proves necessary after opening an existing pipe or removing equipment, it must be established which technical modification is necessary and what consequences this has for costs and planning.
The handling of additional work must correspond to the agreed responsibilities. A clear record of changes shows how the final project costs compare with the original budget.
A complete budget therefore does not arise solely from adding together the available quotations. It must also demonstrate that all necessary equipment, connections, work and handover conditions are adequately covered, without gaps in responsibility or double-counted costs.
When Is the Complete WHRS Retrofit Budget Sufficiently Substantiated?
A WHRS retrofit budget forms a reliable basis for an investment decision when the technically necessary modifications are sufficiently known and the estimated costs reflect the actual scope of supply. For this purpose, it must first be clear which WHRS configuration is being investigated. The selected heat sources determine which heat exchangers and connections are needed, while the position of the ORC module affects the pipe routes, foundations, installation and future maintenance access.
The existing cooling capacity and electrical distribution must also have been sufficiently assessed to establish which additional provisions will become necessary. The budget must also correspond to the actual condition of the ship. When the engine room layout, existing piping or structural support are still insufficiently known, additional inspections may be needed before the work can be priced reliably.
The installation plan must also be sufficiently detailed. This includes access for equipment, the available lifting equipment and space, the installation sequence and the periods during which engine, cooling water or electrical installations must be temporarily taken out of service. Any additional downtime is assessed on the basis of the consequences actually caused by the WHRS retrofit. A distinction must be maintained here between the original shipyard schedule and the additional work that the project makes necessary.
Engineering, ship-specific assessments, transport, installation, commissioning and any performance verification are then included, insofar as they are not already covered by the agreed supply. It must remain clear which costs are sufficiently established and which are still uncertain. After all, a technical uncertainty may affect both the selected installation and the work required on the ship.
An initial budget may be suitable for determining whether further engineering and additional quotations are worthwhile. However, it does not automatically provide sufficient evidence to make a binding investment commitment. When important cost items still depend on the pipe route, cooling capacity or structural integration, it may be necessary to investigate these elements further before the total investment can be established with sufficient reliability.
Alternative arrangements may also lead to different costs. A different position for the ORC module may, for example, allow a shorter pipe run for transferring heat, but at the same time create a more difficult transport route. A different heat exchanger configuration may limit modifications to the exhaust gas path, while additional pumps or an intermediate circuit become necessary instead. The various costs therefore cannot be assessed independently of the technical configuration.
The budget must therefore relate to a coherent, technically practicable installation. A general module layout with connections still to be defined does not provide a reliable basis for the total retrofit investment. The terms of the quotations concerned must also align with one another. After all, a fixed price for a component provides no certainty about additional work that has not yet been worked out in detail.
Conversely, a provisional cost estimate can be refined later when the required technical data are available. The status of every important cost item must therefore remain sufficiently identifiable. For the investment decision, it is particularly important that the scale of the costs that remain uncertain and the possible consequences of changes are sufficiently clear. In this way, it can be assessed how much certainty the overall budget actually provides.
The complete retrofit investment is then linked to the expected energy output and the ship's economic life. A distinction must be maintained here between the expenditure to install the WHRS ready for operation and future operating costs.
The costs in addition to the WHRS installation are thus determined by all the additional work needed to integrate the selected recovery system safely and reliably into the existing ship. An identical ORC module may therefore result in different total retrofit costs on two ships. The available engine room space, exhaust gas route, cooling capacity, electrical installation, structural constraints and the yard schedule determine which additional work is actually necessary.
A reliable budget makes these costs visible, distinguishes them from items already included in the supply and work already planned for the ship, and keeps technical uncertainties identifiable until the necessary data are available. Only when the selected installation, connections, implementation responsibilities and agreed handover have been sufficiently defined can it be established what amount is actually needed to install and commission the WHRS on board.
In this way, the price of the main equipment is not confused with the total retrofit investment, and the financial appraisal can proceed on a sound cost basis.
This Article Within the Series
The price of a WHRS module gives a useful picture of the investment only when the required ship modifications, installation and any additional downtime have also been included. Whether this expenditure pays for itself also depends on the fuel savings from WHRS electricity generation. How fewer operating hours or higher installation costs change the financial result calls for a sensitivity analysis within the business case and investment decision for WHRS installations.