How Do Fewer Operating Hours or Higher Installation Costs Affect the Business Case for Waste Heat Recovery?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
Fewer operating hours and higher installation costs can significantly weaken the business case for waste heat recovery, because a larger investment must then be recouped from smaller annual energy savings. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) uses heat from sources such as exhaust gases and engine cooling water for electricity generation or direct heat use. In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), part of this heat is converted into electricity that can reduce the load on existing generating sets.
When the ship operates for fewer hours under suitable conditions, annual net electricity generation and the associated fuel savings may decrease. At the same time, higher installation costs increase the required investment without the installation automatically recovering more energy as a result. Both changes can extend the payback period, reduce the net present value and lower the expected return. The size of the effect depends on which operating hours are lost, how much financial value the WHRS would deliver during those hours and which additional work is actually needed.
The remaining economic life and the timing of the investment are also determining factors. A sensitivity analysis shows how far energy output can fall or costs rise before the project falls short of its financial criteria, when a different technical design becomes more attractive and when the original investment decision must be reassessed.
Why Do Operating Hours and Installation Costs Affect the Business Case in Different Ways?
The economic feasibility of a WHRS is determined by the total investment and the financial benefits realized over its service life. With electricity generation, these benefits arise primarily because recovered energy displaces existing electricity generation. When existing generating sets consequently use less fuel, fuel costs and possibly certain emissions costs may decrease. Those savings must cover the cost of the complete installation. This includes the main equipment, ship-specific connections, engineering, installation and commissioning. During operation, additional maintenance and other operating costs may also arise.
Fewer suitable operating hours primarily affect future returns. When the WHRS receives sufficient waste heat and can supply useful electricity for less time, annual net energy production may decrease. As a result, fuel cost savings may also fall, while the original investment remains unchanged. Higher installation costs, by contrast, affect what it costs to install and commission the system. When additional foundations, cooling provisions or electrical modifications prove necessary, for example, the investment increases. Annual electricity generation need not increase as a result.
This distinction is important because the two changes require different assessments. With fewer operating hours, it must be investigated how much energy generation is lost and how much fuel is consequently no longer saved. With higher installation costs, it must be established which additional work is needed, why it was not included in the original budget and whether it affects performance or the timing of entry into service.
Operating costs may also respond differently. Certain maintenance activities are related to the number of running hours, while periodic inspections, fixed facilities and certain service obligations may persist even with less use. Higher installation costs do not automatically change operating costs. Additional pumps, heat exchangers or other parts of the installation may, however, entail new maintenance costs. These effects must be assessed separately to capture the full financial effect of the higher investment.
When fewer operating hours and higher installation costs occur simultaneously, the project is affected through both higher costs and lower savings. A larger investment must then be justified by smaller future net savings. The WHRS need not perform less well technically in this situation. An installation can work fully in accordance with the original specifications and still become a less attractive investment if the ship is used differently or the installation proves more expensive. Technical performance and the financial outcome must therefore be assessed separately.
Which Operating Hours Actually Determine WHRS Output?
For the economic assessment, a distinction must be made between the ship's operating hours, the running hours of the engines concerned and the hours during which the WHRS can actually supply useful energy. These periods need not coincide completely. An engine may, for example, run for long periods without providing enough usable heat at every load for electricity generation with an ORC. Exhaust gas temperature and mass flow rate change with engine load. The available cooling water heat may also be distributed differently when the engine operates at a lower or higher power.
An hour of engine operation is therefore not automatically equivalent to an hour during which the ORC can deliver its rated electrical power. At a lower engine load, less heat may be available, so the ORC produces less electricity or reaches an operating point at which its own auxiliary consumption represents a large proportion of gross generator output. Under certain conditions, the ORC may deliver too little net electricity to justify running it. The useful operating hours must therefore correspond to the actual heat supply and the permitted operating range of the ORC.
The available cooling also affects production. When cooling water temperature rises, condensing pressure may increase and the usable expansion range may narrow. The same engine load therefore need not yield the same net ORC production on every voyage. There must also be sufficient electrical demand. A WHRS may technically produce electricity while the ship needs little electrical power during a particular operating mode. When the load on the other generating sets cannot be reduced further, ORC production may be limited.
For the financial return, the electricity source actually displaced is also decisive. A kilowatt-hour of ORC electricity that reduces output from fuel-fired generating sets may have a different financial value from electricity that primarily limits shore power consumption or battery discharge. The economically relevant hours are therefore the periods during which sufficient suitable waste heat and cooling are available, the ORC can supply net electricity and using that electricity actually avoids other energy costs. The total number of engine hours provides insufficient information for this purpose.
This difference becomes important when the ship's sailing or working profile changes. A general reduction in annual sailing hours need not lead to a proportional reduction in WHRS output. When prolonged sailing periods with favourable engine loading are lost in particular, a substantial part of the expected electricity generation may be lost. When periods in which the ORC delivered hardly any useful net electricity disappear instead, the effect on annual output may remain relatively limited.
The remaining operating hours may also take place under different conditions. A ship may, for example, sail for fewer hours but operate at a higher average engine load during the remaining sailing periods. The net energy generated by the ORC per hour may change as a result. Conversely, the total number of engine hours may remain almost unchanged while a larger proportion takes place at low load. Available heat and financial value per hour may then decrease without the number of running hours changing substantially.
A reliable sensitivity analysis must therefore account for the distribution of operating hours across the relevant engine loads and electrical operating modes. Reducing all the original engine hours by a uniform percentage provides insufficient certainty about the actual consequences for energy output.
How Do Fewer Operating Hours Affect Annual Net Financial Savings?
When fewer suitable WHRS operating hours are available, annual net electricity generation may decrease. The financial consequences then depend on which existing generation the ORC actually displaces. When an ORC supplies electricity to the shipboard electrical system, existing generating sets may need to produce less electrical power. The fuel savings are determined by the change in their actual fuel consumption.
The fuel consumption curves of the engines concerned are important here. A generating set does not use the same amount of fuel per kilowatt-hour produced at every load. The financial value of a kilowatt-hour of ORC electricity may therefore differ at different generator loads. The generator operating strategy also affects the outcome. During certain operating modes, the WHRS only reduces the load on one or more running generating sets. Under other conditions, production may be sufficient to take an entire generating set out of service.
If the periods in which a generating set could be shut down are lost, the fuel savings may decrease more sharply than a simple calculation based on the lost ORC kilowatt-hours suggests. After all, the total savings depend on the difference in fuel consumption of the complete generator configuration. The heat source must also be taken into account. When the ORC receives heat from the same generating sets whose loads are reduced by its output, engine load and thus the available heat supply may change. Any change in generator dispatch must therefore be assessed using the resulting engine loads.
The fuel actually saved is then valued at the relevant fuel price. When less fuel is saved because of fewer suitable operating hours, the financial value of those savings also decreases with otherwise unchanged prices. Any benefits from avoided emissions costs may also become smaller. This applies insofar as the emissions concerned fall within the applicable regulations and the financial benefits actually accrue to the party bearing the investment.
The WHRS operating costs still have to be covered from the reduced savings. Some costs may change partly with the number of running hours. With less use, certain wear-related work may, for example, become necessary later, depending on the technical design and the manufacturer's requirements. Other costs, however, persist. Periodic inspections, certain safety checks, service obligations and maintenance of equipment that must remain available even during downtime need not decrease in proportion to the number of production hours.
An installation that is regularly started and stopped may also have different maintenance requirements from an ORC that operates steadily for long periods. Fewer operating hours therefore do not automatically mean that operating costs also fall in the same proportion. When avoided fuel costs decrease sharply while a substantial proportion of fixed costs persists, annual net financial savings may decline relatively quickly.
Under unfavourable conditions, the net savings may become very small. The additional operating costs over the period examined may also exceed the financial value of the recovered energy. The installation is therefore not automatically technically unsuitable, but the remaining financial return may be insufficient to justify the investment. After all, the original investment costs do not change because of the lower number of operating hours, while the annual net cash flows available to recover those costs are lower.
Why Can Higher Installation Costs Make the Investment Less Attractive?
For an existing ship, the full extent of a WHRS retrofit is not always known during the initial technical assessment. An ORC module may, for example, appear to fit within the available engine-room space, while further engineering reveals that new foundations, different pipe routes or additional structural work are necessary. Connection to the exhaust gas path may also require more work than initially expected. An exhaust gas heat exchanger must function within the permitted engine and exhaust gas conditions. When the existing piping configuration offers insufficient space or there is little margin below the back-pressure limit, more extensive modifications may be needed.
On the cold side, it may become apparent that the existing ship cooling system lacks sufficient capacity or suitable connection points. Additional pumps, heat exchangers, piping or other provisions may consequently become necessary. The electrical connection may also increase the investment. The switchboard, protection systems and power management system must be compatible with the new generator output. When this work was not sufficiently included in the original budget, the total investment may be higher than initially anticipated.
The main economic consequence is that a larger investment does not automatically yield higher energy output. When additional foundations or piping modifications are needed solely to install the originally selected ORC safely and make it ready for service, the expected net electricity generation may remain unchanged. The same annual savings must then justify a larger investment. As a result, the payback period and other financial assessment measures may become less favourable without the installation's technical performance changing.
A distinction must be made here between an actual cost increase and an incomplete original budget. When certain work was necessary from the outset but was not yet in the initial estimate, the original estimate was incomplete. These costs then become apparent during further technical development, without the project necessarily having become more complex than the actual situation on the ship required from the outset. Costs already included in the agreed WHRS supply must also not be treated again as additional expenditure.
A different situation arises when the additional work also affects future technical performance. Additional cooling capacity may, for example, be needed not only to connect the condenser safely, but also to produce more net electricity at certain cooling water temperatures. In that case, the higher investment may deliver additional energy output. However, that additional output must be substantiated on the basis of the actual heat and cooling conditions.
Installing a larger cooler or an additional pump does not in itself prove that the ORC will deliver more electricity. Additional provisions may also consume electricity themselves or require maintenance. The financial assessment must therefore distinguish between higher costs for the same net performance and higher costs accompanied by a demonstrable change in future cash flows.
For the investment decision, the complete, technically practicable configuration is ultimately decisive. The original module price or initial rough retrofit estimate does not provide a sufficient basis for this when the necessary connections and ship modifications are now better known.
How Do Fewer Operating Hours and Higher Installation Costs Reinforce Each Other?
Fewer suitable operating hours and higher installation costs can jointly result in a substantially less favourable business case than when only one of these assumptions changes. With fewer operating hours, annual net energy production may decrease. As a result, fuel and other energy cost savings may fall. At the same time, with higher installation costs, the amount that must be invested increases.
A larger outlay must therefore be recovered from smaller future net savings. Particularly when the original business case only just met the owner's financial criteria, this combination may be important. A relatively small reduction in annual net savings can already extend the expected payback period noticeably. When additional installation costs arise at the same time, the required payback period increases further.
However, the combined effect need not exceed the sum of the separate effects on net present value. With otherwise unchanged assumptions, a higher initial investment and a lower present value of future savings can be accounted for separately. The simple payback period, by contrast, may respond more strongly because the initial investment rises as annual net savings fall. Particularly when those savings are already relatively limited, the calculated payback period may increase sharply.
The timing of the work may also affect the result. When additional structural modifications or cooling water work delay entry into service, the WHRS cannot yet recover energy during part of the originally planned operating period. The investment may consequently increase while the first financial savings become available later. The change in the timing of these cash flows may also affect net present value.
Any extension of the shipyard period may also lead to lost operating revenue or other attributable costs. Double counting of the same downtime period as a financial loss must be avoided here. A period during which the ship would not sail because of an extended shipyard stay must not, for example, be counted both as the full loss of revenue from operating the ship and as a separate loss of WHRS returns without further assessment when both effects relate to the same reference case.
The technical assumptions must also remain mutually consistent. When higher installation costs are associated with a different engine configuration, this may also affect the available heat supply. The original estimate of net electricity generation must then be checked against the revised configuration. The revised costs and returns must relate to the same final ship configuration and operation.
The combined assessment therefore shows whether the higher costs and lower savings still leave sufficient financial headroom. It also becomes clear whether the original investment still meets the selected financial criteria under the changed conditions.
How Do Payback Period, Net Present Value and Return Change?
The simple payback period gives an initial indication of the time needed to recoup the investment from the expected net financial savings. When annual net savings are sufficiently stable and positive, this period can be estimated by dividing the investment by the annual net savings.
With fewer suitable operating hours, annual savings may decrease, making the simple payback period longer. With higher installation costs, the investment increases. When annual net savings remain unchanged, this also leads to a longer payback period. When both changes occur simultaneously, both effects lengthen the payback period. However, this simple relationship does not provide a complete picture of the financial outcome under all conditions.
Annual savings can, after all, change because of engine load, fuel prices, availability and maintenance costs. The installation may also be put into operation later, or major overhauls may be needed during its service life. In addition, the simple payback period does not account for the time value of money. It therefore does not automatically show how much economic value the project creates over its full service life.
For this purpose, net present value can be used. With this method, the expected future cash flows are discounted to present value at an appropriate rate. The present value of the relevant investment expenditure is deducted from that amount. When the investment increases and future cash flows otherwise remain unchanged, net present value decreases. When fewer suitable operating hours lead to lower net savings, the present value of future returns also falls.
The combination may therefore reduce an initially positive net present value or make it negative. A project that offered sufficient economic value under the original assumptions may become less attractive under the changed conditions. A delay in entry into service may also change the outcome. The savings are then received later and may be realized over a shorter period. It must be clear here whether the ship's total economic life remains unchanged or whether the period during which the WHRS can still deliver financial value also changes.
The internal rate of return can also be used to assess attractiveness. With a suitable cash flow pattern, this measure provides insight into the return arising from the investment. A higher initial investment or lower future net savings may reduce this return. The outcome is then compared with the owner or investor's required rate of return.
The appraisal must use a consistent cash flow basis. When the assessment is based on project cash flows, the discount rate must correspond to that basis. Financing costs, taxes and any tax benefits must not be arbitrarily mixed into a calculation built on a different financial basis.
The simple payback period, net present value and the internal rate of return thus answer different questions. The payback period primarily shows how quickly the original investment is recouped from the savings. Net present value assesses the value of future cash flows using the required rate of return. The internal rate of return provides an additional measure of investment return under suitable conditions.
For a sound decision, it must therefore be established which financial criteria are decisive for the investor concerned. It can then be assessed how the changed operating hours and installation costs affect each of these measures.
When Does the Remaining Economic Life Become a Limitation?
A WHRS may be technically suitable for prolonged use, while the period during which the owner can benefit economically from the investment is considerably shorter. For an existing ship, therefore, it is not only the technical service life of the ORC that is important, but above all the remaining economic life and expected use during that period.
When fewer suitable operating hours are available, annual net savings may fall. The investment is then recouped over a longer period, provided that the remaining positive net cash flows are sufficient. When installation costs also rise, a larger amount must be recouped from these lower annual savings. This becomes particularly important when the payback period approaches the remaining period during which the ship is expected to be operated.
A WHRS can still save fuel during these remaining years and yet deliver insufficient financial value to justify the full investment. The amount of usable energy and the economic result must therefore be assessed separately.
The actual plans for the ship must be taken into account here. A planned sale, replacement of the engine installation or extensive modernization may affect the period during which the original WHRS configuration is used. A future change in fuel, engine load or operating strategy may also affect the heat supply. The technical service life of the ORC therefore does not mean that the original net energy output remains available throughout that entire period.
Any residual value may form part of the financial assessment, but must not be assumed without substantiation. The value of a WHRS upon sale depends, for example, on its technical condition, suitability for the next owner's operations and the terms under which the ship is transferred. When the current owner no longer operates the installation, the remaining technical service life may consequently take on a different financial significance. Any residual value reflected in the sale must be distinguished from the savings that the current owner receives during operation.
The timing of installation is also important. When additional installation work delays handover, the remaining period until a planned sale or decommissioning may become shorter. The WHRS must then realize sufficient future net savings within the operating period that actually remains. A payback period longer than this period is an important warning sign.
However, the final decision must be based on the complete cash flows, including any sufficiently substantiated residual value and the required rate of return. A project with a relatively long simple payback period need not automatically be unsuitable when the total net present value is still sufficiently positive. Conversely, an investment with an apparently acceptable payback period may be insufficiently attractive financially when important future costs or risks have not been included in that initial calculation.
The remaining economic life thus determines how much time is available to actually recover higher installation costs from annual savings that may be lower than forecast. This period must correspond to the ship's expected operation and the financial position of the investing party.
How Do You Determine the Economic Threshold of the WHRS Investment?
The economic threshold is the point at which the WHRS investment only just meets the financial criterion that the owner or investor uses for the project. Which threshold is relevant depends on the selected assessment method. When a maximum payback period is used, the appraisal can establish the minimum annual net savings needed to recoup the full investment within this period. The basis is the expected financial returns after accounting for the relevant operating costs.
It is then determined how many suitable WHRS operating hours are needed to realize these savings. That number depends on the net electricity generation and financial value available during the different operating modes. When the ORC produces substantially less electricity at part load, more operating hours may be needed than in a calculation based on rated generator power. The distribution of operating hours across the engine load range therefore remains decisive.
The generator operating strategy also affects the economic threshold. When the WHRS enables an entire generating set to be shut down during certain operating modes, the fuel saved per hour may differ from the saving when the same electrical production only reduces the load on running engines. The threshold therefore cannot always be determined using a single fixed financial return per ORC operating hour. The calculation must account for the engine loads and the existing energy production that is actually replaced.
In an assessment based on net present value, a different threshold is used. The appraisal can establish the maximum investment the present value of the expected future net cash flows can support. It can also be determined which minimum return over the remaining service life is needed to achieve a net present value of zero or another agreed acceptance threshold.
In this way, it becomes apparent how much scope the original business case has for additional installation costs. The same can be investigated for a lower number of suitable operating hours. When the current calculation has only a limited positive net present value, a relatively small reduction in annual savings may be sufficient to reach the acceptance threshold. If net present value is well above the threshold, the investment can accommodate more setbacks under otherwise unchanged conditions.
The combination of both changes must also be assessed. With a higher investment, the minimum necessary future net savings become greater. When fewer suitable operating hours are available, those higher savings must be achieved over fewer hours of useful generation. It may become apparent here that the technically possible electricity generation delivers insufficient financial value to recoup the additional installation costs. The installation may then remain technically practicable while the financial threshold is exceeded.
There is no universal minimum for ORC operating hours or maximum percentage for additional installation costs that determines whether a WHRS is economically viable. The relevant threshold depends on the actual installation costs, net energy output, avoided fuel and emissions costs, operating costs and remaining economic life.
The economic threshold is therefore project-specific. It must be established for the technical configuration, operating conditions and financial criteria to which the investment decision actually relates.
Which Scenarios Are Needed for a Reliable Sensitivity Analysis?
A sensitivity analysis reveals how the original WHRS business case changes when actual conditions differ from key assumptions. For this purpose, a baseline scenario is first established that corresponds to the technically substantiated installation configuration and how the ship is expected to operate. Net energy output is determined in this scenario for the relevant engine loads, heat source conditions, cooling and electrical demand. This energy output is then linked to the fuel-fired or other energy production that is actually replaced.
The financial value of those savings, together with the operating costs, forms the basis for future net cash flows. The investment estimate includes the full cost of the selected installation, including the necessary ship-specific connections and modifications.
It is then investigated what happens when fewer suitable operating hours are available. In doing so, the total number of hours must not merely be reduced. It must also be established which operating periods are lost and how much net electricity and fuel savings the original estimate attributed to those periods. After all, a changed distribution between high and low engine load may affect average ORC production. The generator operating strategy may also change when less electricity remains available or electrical demand occurs during other periods.
A separate scenario investigates higher installation costs. In this scenario, possible additional work is linked to the existing project budget. It is important that the additional costs have a clear technical basis, for example through a more complex exhaust pipe run, additional cooling provisions, structural modifications or a longer shipyard period. It must also be established whether this work only increases the investment or also affects net energy production and future operating costs.
Fewer suitable operating hours and higher installation costs are then combined in a single scenario. In this way, it becomes apparent what happens when a larger investment must be recouped from smaller annual net savings. The consequences of later entry into service may also be included when the additional installation work leads to a longer installation period. The delay and its associated financial consequences must be accounted for only once in doing so.
In addition to these two main variables, other uncertainties can be investigated when they contribute materially to the outcome. Changes in fuel prices, for example, affect the financial value of the same amount of avoided fuel. Different emissions costs or future ship modifications may also affect cash flows, insofar as these effects are sufficiently substantiated. The aim is to understand the main uncertainties, not to calculate every conceivable change without a technical basis.
The scenarios must therefore remain technically and financially coherent. When it is assumed that the ship operates more often at low engine load, the calculation must not use the original maximum thermal power available from the exhaust gas without further substantiation. A larger cooler included as an additional investment item must also not automatically lead to higher electrical ORC power. Such a performance improvement must be demonstrated separately for the actual heat and cooling conditions.
The results of all scenarios are then assessed against the same financial criteria. In this way, it becomes apparent how much lower savings or higher costs each financial criterion can accommodate. The analysis must primarily make clear which assumptions carry the most weight and which uncertainties must be investigated further for the investment decision.
When the investment remains attractive only with favourable operating hours and the originally low installation costs, the business case is sensitive to setbacks. When the combined less favourable scenario also still delivers sufficient financial value, a more strongly substantiated basis for further decision-making emerges.
Can a Smaller ORC or a Different Technical Design Improve the Business Case?
When the original business case deteriorates, a different technical design may better suit the changed conditions. A larger ORC can produce more electricity with a sufficient heat supply, but may also require a higher investment and more extensive heat and cooling provisions. When the ship operates for fewer hours at favourable engine loads, part of the rated capacity may be used only to a limited extent. A smaller ORC may then better suit the available heat and operate within an appropriate range for a larger proportion of the relevant operating hours.
The necessary connections and cooling provisions may also be less extensive. Investment costs may consequently be lower, depending on the technical design and the existing ship configuration. A smaller module may, however, produce less electricity at higher engine loads. The lower investment must therefore be compared with any reduction in annual net energy output.
A smaller ORC is therefore not automatically more favourable economically. When sufficient waste heat and electrical demand are available for long periods during the remaining operating hours, a larger installation may still save more net energy. The choice must therefore be based on the difference between the future net cash flows of the individual designs. Rated generator power or purchase price alone provides insufficient information for this purpose.
A different installation position or pipe route may also offer opportunities to reduce installation costs. When the ORC is placed closer to a suitable heat source or cooling connection, shorter pipes and simpler supports may be needed under certain conditions. Structural suitability, safe operation and maintenance access remain decisive here. A shorter pipe route is not automatically cheaper when extensive modifications to the engine room or a more difficult route for bringing the equipment on board would be required.
Shipyard planning may also affect costs. When certain work can be combined with an already planned maintenance period, additional downtime may be reduced. However, the downtime costs actually avoided must be determined from the existing operating schedule and the work arising from the WHRS retrofit. A planned shipyard period does not automatically mean that the entire installation can take place without additional costs or downtime.
Another possibility is direct heat use. When the ship has suitable heat demand for sufficient hours, waste heat may be used directly to reduce existing heat production. A complete ORC installation with an expander and generator is not always needed for this purpose. The necessary equipment and associated costs may therefore differ.
Whether direct heat use is financially more attractive depends on the available temperature level, simultaneous heat demand and the costs of the energy production that is actually replaced. A combination of direct heat use and electricity generation may also be technically possible. In that case, the available heat must be carefully distributed between the different applications.
The same heat cannot be attributed in full to both applications simultaneously without further substantiation. The additional heat exchangers, piping and control arrangements must also be included in the total investment and operating costs.
When the ship's future deployment remains uncertain, postponing the investment may also be an option. This may be relevant, for example, when it is still insufficiently known how many suitable operating hours the ship will have in the coming years or which installation costs will actually become necessary. However, postponement also has consequences. The expected energy savings are realized later and the available economic life may become shorter.
The preference for a smaller ORC, a different arrangement, direct heat use or postponement therefore follows from the future net financial value of the different possibilities. Each option must be assessed on the basis of a technically practicable configuration and sufficiently realistic operating conditions.
When Must the Original Investment Decision Be Revised?
A WHRS business case must be reassessed when the expected operating hours, energy output, installation costs or economic life change materially. This can happen during the initial engineering work. When an additional ship inspection demonstrates, for example, that more extensive structural modifications or more cooling capacity are needed, the original investment estimate may prove insufficient. The ship's expected use may also change before the ORC is ordered or installed.
When fewer suitable WHRS operating hours are expected, annual net energy production must be recalculated. Avoided fuel costs and other relevant financial benefits are then adjusted to the changed operating conditions. The revised cost and savings forecasts are then assessed over the remaining economic life. In this way, it can be established whether the project still meets the financial criteria on which the original decision was based.
The assessment changes when the project has already been partly implemented. At the original investment decision, all expected project costs and future benefits are assessed. When certain expenditure has since been incurred irreversibly, these costs can no longer be avoided by stopping the work. For a decision on continuation or termination, the future costs and benefits that differ between the two options must therefore be compared in particular.
Existing contractual obligations, any cancellation costs and the value of equipment already supplied must also be taken into account here when they are financially relevant. The fact that much money has already been spent does not in itself provide sufficient reason to carry out all the remaining work as well. The earlier expenditure does not automatically make a future investment more attractive.
Conversely, a less favourable forecast for the original project does not automatically mean that stopping is the best decision. When the remaining investment is limited and the WHRS can subsequently still deliver sufficient net financial value, continuation may still be justified under current conditions. The assessment must therefore correspond to the time at which the decision is made and to the costs and returns that can still actually be influenced from that point onwards.
Even after entry into service, fewer operating hours may warrant revising the output forecast. The ORC may function well technically while the ship produces less usable electricity because of a changed operational profile. It must then be established whether the lower output is likely to persist or primarily related to temporary changes in operation. This distinction may be decisive in determining whether a technical modification is economically worthwhile.
When such a modification is considered, the additional investment is compared with the additional net savings that can still be realized as a result during the remaining service life. The original investment does not automatically form the appropriate basis for the new decision. Earlier expenditure may remain relevant to assessment of the original project result, but does not necessarily determine whether a subsequent modification is financially prudent.
The reassessment may show that the WHRS still offers sufficient economic potential despite fewer operating hours or higher installation costs. It may also become apparent that a smaller module, modified connection or different form of heat use better suits the new conditions. When important technical data remain uncertain, additional engineering or more reliable substantiation of the future operational profile may be needed. In other situations, postponement or discontinuing the configuration under consideration may be more prudent financially.
The effect of fewer operating hours and higher installation costs on the business case is ultimately determined by their combined effect on future net cash flows. Fewer suitable operating hours may reduce the fuel and other energy costs avoided annually, while higher installation costs increase the investment. When handover is also delayed, the period during which financial savings are realized may become shorter. The payback period may consequently become longer, while net present value and the expected return may decrease.
The decisive question is whether the WHRS still delivers sufficient financial value under the changed conditions within the remaining economic life and the selected investment criteria. Reassessing usable operating hours, net energy output, additional installation costs and relevant uncertainties together shows when the business case remains attractive and when the technical or financial assumptions must be revised.
This Article Within the Series
A WHRS can perform well technically and still disappoint financially when fewer suitable operating hours remain or installation proves more expensive. Which expenses increase the investment is shown by the additional costs of a WHRS retrofit. In addition to the effects on payback period and return, the financial effects of EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime may also affect future cash flows. These uncertainties call for a combined sensitivity analysis within the business case and investment decision for WHRS installations.