Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

Which Form of Waste Heat Recovery Is Suitable for Your Ship: Direct Heat Use, a Steam Cycle or ORC?

Which form of waste heat recovery best suits a ship depends on the available heat sources, the demand for heat and electricity on board and the conditions in which the system must operate. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can use waste heat directly for heating or to generate electricity. Direct heat use is a natural choice when waste heat can meet an existing heating demand. A steam cycle may be worth considering when sufficient heat is available at a suitable temperature to produce electricity through a steam turbine. An Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) can generate electricity from heat sources for which a conventional steam cycle may be less practical.

No single solution can be assumed to be the most efficient or economically attractive from the outset. A system that recovers a large amount of heat does not necessarily deliver the greatest fuel savings. The saving depends on which existing energy generation is actually displaced, whether for heat or electricity. The temperatures and flow rates of the heat sources, existing heat consumers, electrical load, cooling conditions and operating hours must therefore be assessed together. It also makes a difference whether the waste heat is currently rejected without being used or already put to good use. Ultimately, the most suitable recovery route is the solution that can make the greatest useful contribution to the ship's energy supply under actual operating conditions, while remaining technically feasible and economically justified.

Why Does the Choice of Waste Heat Recovery Start with Heat and Electricity Demand on Board?

During operation, a marine engine rejects heat through several routes, including exhaust gases, engine cooling water and charge-air cooling. Some of this heat can be recovered, but that does not in itself mean that an additional system also saves energy. For that to happen, the recovered heat must displace existing energy generation or reduce the energy input needed to supply the same heat or electricity. When hot water, thermal oil or process heat is needed on board, a heat exchanger can transfer the available waste heat directly to a suitable consumer. Conversion to electricity is then unnecessary. If the demand is mainly for electricity, it is worth assessing whether a thermodynamic cycle can convert that heat into electrical power using an expander and generator.

This distinction matters when choosing the system. Electricity can supply a range of equipment and, if required, be converted back into heat. Heat at a given temperature, however, cannot serve every electrical or thermal application without further conversion. When waste heat can directly meet a suitable heating demand, there is no need to convert it into electricity only to use that electricity for heating.

The recovery options available depend in part on the temperature of the heat source. Exhaust gases generally contain heat at a higher temperature than engine cooling water. Both can carry away considerable amounts of energy, but they offer different possibilities for electricity production. Converting heat into mechanical power requires a usable temperature difference between the heat source and the point at which the remaining heat is rejected. At a lower source temperature, this difference is generally smaller. As a result, the maximum possible proportion of the heat input that can be converted into mechanical work is also lower. A large amount of low-temperature heat therefore does not automatically produce more electricity than a smaller amount of heat at a higher temperature.

The considerations are different for direct heat use. Heat from a relatively low-temperature cooling circuit may be sufficient for a consumer that only needs moderately warm water. The same heat may be considerably less attractive for electricity production, particularly when the available coolant is too warm.

The timing of heat availability also plays an important role. A ship may produce a large amount of exhaust gas heat while under way, whereas demand for certain forms of heating is high during other operating periods. The electrical load can also differ between passage, manoeuvring, time in port and work on site. The choice therefore starts with identifying which existing energy generation the available waste heat can displace. Only once the quantities of heat and electricity needed during the same operating periods are clear can the suitability of each recovery route be assessed.

When Is Direct Heat Use Preferable?

Direct heat use is particularly attractive when an existing thermal consumer can be supplied with heat that would otherwise be rejected unused. A heat exchanger transfers this heat to, for example, a water or thermal oil circuit. No separate thermodynamic process for electricity production is needed. On board, heat can be used for accommodation heating, hot water supply, fuel treatment and certain cargo or process systems. Which applications are relevant depends on the ship type, the fuel used and the existing shipboard systems. For a ship with a substantial, recurring heat demand, a direct connection between the heat source and consumer may offer advantages. If exhaust gas heat partly replaces an existing fuel-fired heating system, for example, the need for additional fuel decreases. The actual benefit depends on how much heat the consumer can absorb and the additional energy consumption required to transfer that heat.

For heat to be transferred, the heat source must be at a sufficiently higher temperature than the receiving circuit requires. Without a temperature difference, a heat exchanger cannot transfer heat. If the available temperature is close to the required operating temperature, the heat exchanger area needed, the flow rates and the operating limits become more important. The heating system's controls must also be able to handle a varying heat supply. An engine does not supply the same amount of heat at every load. If the available waste heat decreases, the thermal consumer must still be able to operate at the required temperature. This may require keeping an existing boiler, electric heater or other heat source available to supplement the recovered heat.

On some ships, exhaust gas heat is used to produce steam for heating or other thermal applications. This is also direct waste heat use. An exhaust gas boiler that supplies steam to a heating system, however, does not automatically constitute a steam cycle for electricity production. For that, the steam must drive an expander that delivers mechanical power. This distinction is particularly relevant when a ship already has a steam system. The existing exhaust gas boiler can save fuel because less steam has to be produced by an oil-fired boiler. That does not mean, however, that the steam produced is also suitable for generating electricity without further modifications.

Direct heat use is not preferable in all circumstances. If a ship only needs heat for short periods, there may be no demand for recovered heat during most of the engine's operating hours. The existing heat demand may also already be largely met by other waste heat sources, limiting the additional saving. The assessment chiefly concerns how much less fuel or electricity the existing heating system needs to use, taking any additional auxiliary consumption into account. If the saving remains limited but enough usable waste heat is still available, electricity production may be a more attractive option.

When Is a Steam Cycle Suitable for Electricity Production from Waste Heat?

A steam cycle is an option when sufficient heat is available at a suitable temperature to produce steam that can then generate mechanical power. In a conventional water-steam cycle, also known as a Steam Rankine Cycle, water is heated and evaporated under pressure. The steam produced then expands in a turbine that can drive a generator. In a condensing arrangement, the steam is condensed back into water after expansion. A feedwater pump raises the condensate to the required pressure before it is heated again. A suitable heat source must therefore be accompanied by sufficient capacity to reject the remaining heat. In other arrangements, steam may be extracted from the turbine for process heat, or the turbine exhaust steam may still be useful for heating.

On ships, an exhaust gas boiler can supply the heat required. The exhaust gases transfer heat to the water-steam system, after which the steam produced becomes available for electricity generation. The power the turbine can deliver depends in part on the pressure, temperature, mass flow rate and state of the steam. A higher usable temperature generally provides greater potential for converting heat into mechanical work. Sufficient heat must, however, remain available to maintain the required steam flow and steam conditions during operation. A high exhaust gas temperature alone therefore does not make a steam cycle attractive. The amount of heat available, the time spent at that load and the temperature difference between the heat source and the cold side are also decisive.

The installation requires space and a range of supporting equipment. A steam turbine, generator, feedwater system, piping and associated control and protection systems must fit into the ship's existing installation. A condensing cycle also needs a condenser with sufficient cooling capacity. Depending on the design, equipment may also be needed for water treatment, condensate management and maintaining suitable steam conditions.

If the ship already has an extensive steam system, some existing equipment may be usable. This can influence the choice of a steam cycle, but does not automatically make adding a turbine straightforward. A system originally designed solely to supply heating steam does not necessarily have the steam pressure, temperature and flow rate required for worthwhile electricity production. The distribution of the steam produced needs particular attention when it is already used for heating. Steam that goes directly to a thermal consumer is not simultaneously available for full expansion in a turbine producing electricity. A design with steam extraction or use of turbine exhaust steam may be technically viable. The electrical and thermal outputs must then be calculated from the actual steam flows, pressure levels and demand for heat.

The system must also continue to function properly under varying engine loads. If the available exhaust gas heat decreases, the steam flow rate and turbine load may fall. The system must therefore suit the operating modes in which the ship is actually used. If additional fuel is needed to maintain steam production, this consumption must be included in the net energy saving. A steam cycle for waste heat recovery is particularly worth investigating when a sufficiently large and usable heat flow is available for long periods, electricity production meets a clear demand and the necessary equipment can be suitably integrated. With smaller quantities of heat, highly variable operating conditions or major retrofit constraints, another recovery route may be more suitable.

When Can ORC Waste Heat Recovery Be More Suitable than a Steam Cycle?

An Organic Rankine Cycle uses an organic working fluid instead of water in its thermodynamic cycle. In a common arrangement, the working fluid is heated and evaporated under pressure. The vapour then flows through an expander that drives a generator. After expansion, the fluid condenses back into a liquid in the condenser. A pump then returns it to the hot side of the system. The thermodynamic properties of the chosen working fluid allow the cycle to be tailored to temperature and pressure ranges that differ from those of a conventional water-steam cycle. ORC may therefore be worth considering when the available waste heat is not well suited to a practical steam system. A lower boiling point does not mean, however, that an organic cycle automatically generates more electricity. The output also depends on the other properties of the working fluid, the temperature differences and the performance of the individual components.

An ORC-based waste heat recovery system can, for example, be considered where engine cooling water is available, heat flows are relatively small or source temperatures vary during operation. Exhaust gas heat can also be used with this technology. ORC is therefore not intended solely for low-temperature heat. Some ORC configurations use several heat sources. Heat from an engine cooling circuit can, for example, be used to preheat the working fluid, while exhaust gas heat then provides further heating and evaporation. Whether this combination is worthwhile depends on the chosen cycle and the available temperatures and flow rates.

Heat from different sources cannot simply be added together as though it were all available at the same temperature. Within the cycle, a heat source at a higher temperature may fulfil a different function from a source at a lower temperature. The point at which each source is connected to the ORC circuit partly determines how much heat can actually be transferred to the working fluid.

Cooling capacity is also particularly important. The condenser must reject the heat remaining after conversion into mechanical power. Particularly at a relatively low source temperature, electricity production may depend heavily on the cooling water temperature. If the cooling water becomes warmer, the condensing temperature may rise. This can reduce the available expansion range and reduce electrical output. A ship that rejects a large amount of heat through its engine cooling water therefore does not necessarily have a suitable heat source for ORC. It must first be established how much net electrical power the chosen combination of heat source, working fluid, expander and cooling can deliver. With a small temperature difference, electrical output may remain limited even when the available thermal power is considerable.

The complete installation comprises more than just the ORC module. A heat exchanger can, for example, transfer heat from the exhaust gases to a separate water or thermal oil circuit that then supplies the ORC. Pumps, cooling, electrical equipment and protection systems are also needed. These components may themselves consume energy, and they place demands on the available space and the ship's existing installation. The chosen working fluid also affects the safety provisions required. Depending on its properties, relevant considerations may include flammability, operating pressure, temperature, toxicity and environmental properties. Using ORC does not remove these design and safety issues.

Part-load performance and control capabilities also matter in a comparison with a steam cycle. An ORC system can be designed for a varying heat supply, but not every module maintains the same performance as temperatures and flow rates change. The rated generator power can also limit how much of a temporarily increased heat supply is actually converted into electricity. A comparative modelling study by Andreasen, Meroni and Haglind, published in 2017, investigated a steam cycle and various ORC configurations for a container ship. With equal assumed turbine efficiencies, the steam cycle studied delivered more net power at higher engine loads, whereas ORC performed better at lower loads. When different turbine efficiencies were assumed, the relative performance changed. These results depend on the configurations and assumptions studied and do not establish a general ranking for other ships.

The main reason to investigate ORC is therefore not that an organic working fluid would be inherently more efficient. ORC may be attractive when the available temperatures, quantity of heat, system size and operating conditions are better suited to an organic cycle than to a conventional steam cycle. The comparison must establish which system delivers more net electricity under the relevant heat-source and cooling conditions.

How Does Existing Waste Heat Use Affect the Choice?

On many ships, some of the available engine heat is already used. An exhaust gas boiler may, for example, supply steam for heating, while heat from the engine cooling water is used to supply hot water or operate a freshwater generator. These existing applications partly determine how much additional saving a new waste heat recovery system can deliver. If exhaust gas heat already supplies a thermal consumer, a new steam turbine or ORC system may draw heat away from that existing application. The original heat production may consequently decrease, and the ship may have to meet the same heat demand in another way. If a fuel-fired boiler has to operate more often to meet that demand, the additional fuel consumption must be weighed against the electricity generated.

Similar considerations apply to engine cooling water. If heat from a high-temperature cooling circuit is already used for heating or freshwater production, not all of the circuit's thermal power is necessarily available for additional recovery by an ORC. The existing heat demand and required engine temperatures determine how much heat can safely be extracted. Under suitable conditions, different applications can nevertheless be combined. Heat at a higher temperature can first be used for a consumer that needs that temperature. If sufficient usable heat then remains, a subsequent application at a lower temperature can be investigated.

Such sequential heat use requires compatible temperatures, flow rates and controls. After the first heat transfer, a sufficient temperature difference must remain for the next application. The required return temperatures and the limits of the original engine installation must also be maintained. For an existing steam system, the assessment can consider whether the steam produced can supply both a turbine and the heat users. The possible electricity production then depends, among other factors, on the steam pressure, the required process pressure and the chosen distribution of the steam. Direct heat use and ORC can also operate alongside each other under suitable conditions, provided the heat balance allows it.

The choice between the three technologies therefore depends heavily on what would happen to the heat without the new system. Heat that would otherwise be rejected unused offers a different potential for savings than heat already reducing the load on a fuel-fired heating system. The same quantity of heat must not be counted as a full additional saving for two applications.

How Do the Operational Profile and the Ship's Installation Affect the Choice of a WHRS?

The same form of waste heat recovery may deliver a different output on different ships. This is not only due to differences in engine power or heat source temperature. The way engines are used and the energy demand during operation also determine how much of the recovered energy can actually be used. A ship that sails for long periods at a relatively constant engine load may produce a reasonably predictable amount of heat during those periods. This may offer favourable conditions for a system that needs to function at a suitable operating point for extended periods. Which recovery route is preferable then depends on the available temperature, heat quantity and energy demand.

With frequent load changes, the heat supply changes continually. During manoeuvring, port operations or work that involves bringing engines online or taking them offline, the temperature and flow rate of the heat sources may vary. A steam cycle or ORC must be able to respond to these changes without disrupting the original engine functions. For direct heat use, the main concern is whether the consumer continues to receive sufficient heat despite these variations.

For electricity production, the relationship between engine load and electrical demand also matters. Electricity from a steam turbine or ORC can reduce the load on existing generating sets. If the recovered heat comes from the same engines, the available heat supply may change as well. The new operating mode must therefore be assessed as a whole. Not every kilowatt-hour generated delivers the same fuel savings. Reducing the load on a running generating set has a different effect from shutting a set down completely. The actual fuel savings depend on the specific fuel consumption at the new engine load and the required power reserve. At low electrical demand, it may also be necessary to limit the output of the waste heat recovery system.

For direct heat use, it is particularly important that heat production and demand coincide. Sufficient waste heat may be available while sailing, whereas additional heating is needed while the ship is stationary and the main heat source is out of service. An existing boiler or other heat supply may then remain necessary, even when a large amount of heat is recovered while sailing.

Alongside the operational profile, the existing engine and ship systems impose technical limits. A heat exchanger in the exhaust gas path causes a pressure drop, while the total exhaust gas back pressure must remain within the engine's permitted limits. The design must also account for how far the exhaust gases may be cooled and for any existing aftertreatment equipment. Fouling and corrosion also require attention in exhaust gas heat recovery. How far the exhaust gases may be cooled depends in part on the fuel used, the gas composition and the heat exchanger design. Under conditions where condensation is a concern, cooling surfaces below the relevant condensation thresholds can lead to corrosive deposits. The system must therefore suit the actual exhaust gas conditions and remain sufficiently accessible for inspection and cleaning.

When recovering heat from engine cooling water, the required engine temperature must be maintained. Heat recovery must not interfere with the original cooling function, which must remain reliable when the engine produces less heat or the recovery system is out of service. A steam cycle or ORC that produces electricity also places demands on cooling. In a condensing arrangement, most of the heat that is not converted into electricity must be rejected through the condenser. The existing central coolers, pumps and pipework must be suitable for this, while sufficient capacity must also remain available for equipment already served by the cooling-water system.

The additional cooling load depends in part on the origin of the recovered heat. When exhaust gas heat is used, heat that previously left the ship through the funnel may instead be transferred to the ship's cooling system. When heat is recovered from engine cooling water, part of the existing cooling load may instead be rejected through the condenser. Both the total heat load and its distribution across the individual cooling circuits must therefore be assessed for the new operating mode.

Available installation space can also influence which technology is preferable. A conventional steam cycle needs different equipment and piping arrangements from direct heat use or ORC. In a retrofit, the existing engine room layout, foundations, pipe routes and maintenance access may limit the options. In a newbuild, the heat supply, electrical installation and allocation of space can be matched to the chosen recovery route at an earlier stage. Ultimately, the complete installation must be technically feasible. A thermodynamically favourable solution need not be the best choice if it requires unduly extensive modifications to exhaust gas, cooling water, steam or electrical systems.

How Do You Compare the Net Contribution of Direct Heat Use, Steam and ORC?

The three forms of waste heat recovery cannot be assessed reliably by comparing their thermal or electrical power ratings alone. A heat exchanger supplying useful heat serves a different function from a turbine or ORC generator producing electricity. The comparison must therefore be based on the existing energy generation that each solution can actually displace on board. For direct heat use, it is first established how much heat can be supplied to an existing consumer during the relevant operating periods. The consumer must actually need that heat at that time. It can then be calculated how much less heat the existing heating system needs to produce and what fuel or electricity saving this delivers. The efficiency of the original heat supply and any additional auxiliary consumption are taken into account.

For a steam cycle, the relevant quantity is the electricity that the turbine-generator can deliver under the available steam conditions. The relevant auxiliary energy consumption is deducted, including that of the required pumps, condensing equipment and other auxiliaries, to the extent that this consumption arises or changes because of the new installation. The same principle applies to ORC. The stated generator power of a module does not automatically equal the net electrical power that the complete waste heat recovery system makes available on board. The consumption of working fluid pumps, any intermediate circuit pumps, additional cooling and other equipment must also be accounted for consistently.

It must then be established how much of the net electricity generated can actually be used on board. A kilowatt-hour from a waste heat recovery system only saves fuel to the extent that it reduces other energy production that consumes fuel. The amount of fuel saved depends in part on the specific fuel consumption of the engines and generating sets concerned at their new loads. The effect on other shipboard systems must also be included in the calculation. Additional exhaust back pressure can affect engine performance, while a change in cooling water circulation may require additional pumping power. In a steam system, extra boiler heat may be needed to maintain the desired steam conditions. If a cycle producing electricity draws heat away from existing thermal consumers, any additional fuel required for those consumers must also be included.

The annual operating hours then determine how much each operating mode contributes to the total output. A system that delivers high electrical power when the heat supply peaks may deliver less energy over a whole year than a smaller system that better suits the most common operating modes. With ORC, the rated generator power may also limit output when more heat temporarily becomes available. For a reliable annual calculation, the relevant operating periods must be examined separately. Heat availability, cooling conditions and electricity demand must reflect conditions that actually occur simultaneously. Otherwise, combining the highest exhaust gas temperature, the lowest cooling water temperature and the greatest electrical demand from different operating periods may give an unrealistically favourable impression of the output.

A useful comparison therefore starts with the ship's existing energy balance. The engine load profile, heat sources, existing heat demand, electrical load and cooling conditions are assessed together. For each recovery route, it is then established how much useful heat or net electricity can be delivered during the different operating periods and how much this actually changes the existing fuel consumption.

The investment must also be assessed alongside the energy saving. The solution with the greatest net saving is not necessarily the most attractive project if the costs of equipment, pipework modifications, shipyard time or future maintenance differ considerably. The remaining service life, maintenance requirements and the value of the energy actually displaced also help determine whether a larger investment is justified. An initial system selection does not require all heat exchangers, pumps and pipes to have been definitively sized. It must, however, be sufficiently clear which existing energy generation each route can displace, which technical provisions are needed for this and which constraints can materially change the expected output. These findings can then guide further investigation of the most promising options.

Which Form of Waste Heat Recovery Ultimately Best Suits Your Ship?

Direct heat use is particularly suitable for a ship with a sufficiently large heat demand that occurs when waste heat is available at the required temperature. If this reduces existing fuel-fired or electrically powered heating, this route may be attractive without a separate installation for electricity production.

A waste heat recovery system with a steam cycle is particularly worth considering when sufficient heat at a suitable temperature is available for long periods. Steam production, the turbine and the supporting equipment must be capable of delivering worthwhile net electricity output. An existing steam system may offer advantages, provided the available steam and the original heat consumers are properly matched.

ORC may be more suitable when the ship needs electricity and the temperature, heat quantity or operating conditions are better suited to an organic cycle. The system's own auxiliary consumption, the available cooling, the rated system power and actual electrical demand must be taken into account. A lower source temperature does not in itself prove that ORC will produce sufficient electricity or perform better than a steam cycle.

Sometimes a combination of applications offers the greatest potential. Heat may, for example, first supply an existing thermal consumer, with any remaining usable heat then considered for electricity production under suitable conditions. It may also become clear that additional waste heat recovery offers little benefit because most of the available heat is already put to good use or the modifications needed to integrate the system are too extensive.

The form that ultimately best suits your ship is therefore not determined by a single temperature threshold, the rated engine power or the highest stated recovery efficiency. Direct heat use is preferable when it can effectively replace existing heat production. A steam cycle or ORC becomes attractive when conversion to electricity delivers a greater net benefit under the actual heat and cooling conditions. Comparing the options for the same ship and the same operating periods makes clear which recovery route is technically suitable and which solution actually offers the greatest usable benefit.

This Article within the Series

Choosing between direct heat use, a steam cycle and ORC requires an understanding not only of the energy demand but also of which heat can safely be extracted. In the assessment of heat sources on board, temperature, mass flow rate and the technical limits of heat extraction are key considerations. How these conditions relate to the engine installation, cooling and shipboard electrical system is central to the system selection and integration of a WHRS.