Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

When Is a Heat Source on Board Suitable for Waste Heat Recovery?

A heat source on board is suitable for waste heat recovery when sufficient heat is available at a usable temperature under the ship's actual operating conditions and can be extracted without exceeding the applicable technical limits. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) must be able to absorb the heat without the engine or other shipboard systems involved exceeding their permitted operating limits. Exhaust gases, engine cooling water and other heat-carrying circuits may be suitable, but not all the heat released by an engine can be recovered without restrictions.

The amount of heat that can actually be used depends on the temperature, mass flow rate, allowable temperature drop and thermal properties of the fluid. Existing heat users, pressure losses, the engine's normal operation, the cooling system's function and the available operating hours must also be taken into account. For electricity production, the temperature difference between the heat source and the available coolant is also important. A high exhaust gas temperature or a high cooling-water flow rate is therefore insufficient on its own to establish whether a heat source is suitable. This requires a clear understanding of how much waste heat can be extracted without exceeding the applicable technical limits under the relevant operating conditions, what proportion can be transferred to a new system and whether the recovered energy can actually be used.

Why Is Not All Heat Rejected by the Engine Suitable for Waste Heat Recovery?

A marine engine converts only part of the fuel energy supplied into mechanical power. Another part is rejected as heat through the exhaust gases, engine cooling water, charge-air cooling and lubricating-oil cooling, among other routes. These heat flows differ considerably in temperature, quantity and technical accessibility. As a result, they do not all offer the same opportunities for waste heat recovery. The assessment must distinguish between the total amount of heat rejected and the proportion that can actually be used. An engine may, for example, lose substantial amounts of heat through the exhaust gases, while some of that heat cannot be extracted without technical consequences. This is because the exhaust gases cannot be cooled without limit, and the additional flow resistance must also remain within the permitted limits.

Different restrictions apply to engine cooling water. The cooling system removes heat to keep the engine within the required temperature range. An additional heat exchanger must not disrupt temperature control or the necessary cooling-water circulation. Even when the cooling water carries heat at a high rate, the existing cooling configuration determines how much heat can be transferred within the required operating limits.

The location at which heat is extracted also makes a difference. Exhaust gases immediately downstream of the turbocharger differ from those leaving an existing exhaust gas boiler, which has already extracted heat. The temperature and the thermal power still available downstream will therefore differ. The heat available upstream is therefore no longer available in full further downstream.

Hot-water, steam and thermal-oil circuits may also offer suitable connection points, but they are not necessarily independent primary heat sources. A thermal oil circuit may, for example, carry heat previously absorbed from exhaust gases. That same energy must not be counted as additionally available both at the exhaust gas source and in the thermal oil circuit. To determine the thermal power actually available, it must first be clear where the heat is released, which circuits carry it away and which existing applications already absorb heat. It can then be established where a WHRS could still extract heat, without including the same heat flow more than once in the energy balance.

How Do Temperature, Mass Flow Rate and Cooling Determine the Usable Waste Heat?

For a fluid stream undergoing no phase change, thermal power depends on its mass flow rate, specific heat capacity and the difference between its inlet and outlet temperatures. For an initial calculation, the mass flow rate in kg/s is multiplied by the average specific heat capacity in kJ/(kg·K) and the temperature drop in K. The result is the thermal power in kW. This calculation must be based on the temperature range over which heat may actually be extracted. The thermal properties of the medium must also be correctly taken into account. If the specific heat capacity changes considerably over that range or a phase change occurs, the thermal power can be determined more accurately using the mass flow rate and the corresponding difference in specific enthalpy.

An exhaust gas stream may, for example, have a relatively high temperature but a low mass flow rate at a particular engine load. The available thermal power may therefore be lower than the temperature suggests. Conversely, a cooling-water circuit with a much higher flow rate may carry substantial amounts of heat despite its lower temperature. In a circulating cooling-water circuit, however, it must be clear which temperature drop actually corresponds to heat rejected by the engine and what proportion of that heat is available for additional recovery.

A reliable calculation also requires clarity about which flow rate is specified. A volumetric flow rate is not the same as a mass flow rate. This distinction is particularly important for exhaust gases, because the volume occupied by the gas depends in part on temperature, pressure and composition. Without the corresponding reference conditions, a specified volumetric flow rate cannot be used directly to determine thermal power.

The amount of heat that can be extracted then depends on the permitted temperature drop. Exhaust gases entering a heat exchanger at a high temperature cannot simply be cooled to ambient temperature. The required exhaust gas conditions and heat exchanger characteristics determine how far the gas temperature may be reduced. With cooling water, by contrast, a small permitted temperature difference may limit heat extraction even when the circulating water flow rate is high.

A connected WHRS cannot necessarily absorb all the calculated thermal power. Heat transfer requires a temperature difference between the hot and cold streams. As their temperatures converge, the driving force for heat transfer decreases. The amount of heat that can actually be transferred therefore also depends on the heat transfer area, the properties of the heat exchanger and the temperature profiles of both streams.

There is also an important difference between available thermal power and the ability to use it to generate electricity. Heat at a relatively low temperature may be well suited to a user who requires only moderately warm water. The same heat is less attractive for electricity production when the usable temperature difference between the heat source and the cold side is small. With a smaller temperature difference, the maximum achievable proportion of heat that can be converted into mechanical work is also lower. Two heat sources with the same calculated thermal power therefore do not necessarily offer the same opportunities for waste heat recovery. The temperature level, allowable temperature drop and heat-transfer conditions determine how much energy can actually be recovered and what it can be used for.

What Technical Limits Apply to Heat Recovery from Exhaust Gases, Cooling Water and Lubricating Oil?

The technical limits for heat recovery are closely related to the original function of the system carrying the heat. For exhaust gases, the allowable back pressure, permitted temperature drop and gas composition are particularly important. For cooling water and lubricating oil, the required temperature control and flow conditions must be maintained, together with their original cooling or lubricating functions. Exhaust gas heat may be attractive because of its relatively high temperature. However, a heat exchanger in the exhaust gas path creates additional flow resistance and thus contributes to the total exhaust back pressure. Existing pipes, silencers, exhaust gas boilers and any exhaust gas aftertreatment equipment also contribute. The total exhaust back pressure must remain within the limits permitted for the engine concerned.

During operation, fouling of the heat exchanger may further increase the pressure drop. A system that meets the permitted limits when clean must therefore also be assessed with an appropriate margin for fouling and ageing. Depending on the arrangement, equipment for cleaning or a suitable bypass may be needed. It must also be clear how the exhaust gas system will continue to function during faults, maintenance and shutdown of the heat recovery system.

The extent to which the exhaust gases are cooled must also be considered alongside back pressure. The fuel used and the gas composition influence the conditions under which condensation and corrosion may occur. With sulphur-containing fuels, acidic condensate may form when heat exchanger surfaces become sufficiently cool. This depends not only on the average gas temperature, but also on the local surface temperature and the conditions under which condensate can form.

An exhaust gas stream may appear suitable based on its measured temperature, yet excessive cooling can cause problems for the heat exchanger or the downstream installation. There is no universally safe minimum temperature for every engine, fuel and exhaust gas configuration. How far the exhaust gases may be cooled depends on the applicable manufacturer data, material selection and actual design conditions. A system specifically designed for condensing heat recovery requires a different technical assessment from a conventional non-condensing heat exchanger.

Existing exhaust gas aftertreatment may also impose additional temperature requirements. If, for example, an SCR system requires a particular exhaust gas temperature range, a new heat exchanger must not disrupt its operation. The location of heat extraction must therefore be compatible with the existing sequence of components and the temperature requirements of the equipment involved.

For engine cooling water, the emphasis is on preserving the original cooling function. The high-temperature cooling circuit removes heat from engine components that must operate within a specified temperature range. An additional heat exchanger for waste heat recovery must therefore work with the existing water-temperature and flow controls, including any bypass arrangements. Under suitable conditions, a new heat exchanger may absorb some of the heat that would otherwise be rejected through the existing coolers. The engine must continue to receive sufficient cooling water, and temperature control must maintain the specified operating conditions.

If the connection is poorly designed, the cooling water may become too cold, unwanted temperature fluctuations may occur or the available flow through the engine may be restricted. The original cooling system must therefore also continue to function when the recovery system is switched off or absorbs insufficient heat. The hydraulic connection, pressure losses and control arrangements are at least as important as the calculated thermal power.

The low-temperature cooling circuit may also carry heat that could be recovered. Its temperature is usually lower than that of the high-temperature circuit, which may limit the opportunities for transferring heat to a new application. The low-temperature circuit may also absorb heat from various components, such as charge-air coolers and lubricating-oil coolers. A reliable assessment of the available thermal power requires a clear understanding of which heat flows are already included in the common cooling-water circuit.

Heat from charge-air cooling can also be used under suitable conditions. However, an additional heat exchanger must not prevent sufficient cooling of the air flowing to the engine. Changes in charge-air temperature may affect engine performance and the operating conditions for which the engine was designed. The opportunities for recovery therefore depend on the existing cooling stages and the permitted air and cooling-water temperatures.

Heat from lubricating-oil cooling can also be considered for recovery, but the lubricating oil must continue to provide essential lubrication within the specified temperature and pressure limits. One option to examine is whether heat can be recovered from the cooling side of an existing lubricating-oil cooler without disrupting the necessary oil circulation. If the lubricating oil cooler already transfers heat to a low-temperature cooling circuit, that same heat must not be counted again as a separate additional energy source.

When Does a Heat Source Remain Usable During Actual Ship Operation?

The heat rejected by a marine engine is not constant. The amount of available waste heat changes when engines operate at a different load, are started or are shut down. A heat source that provides sufficient power at a particular operating point therefore does not necessarily remain suitable for waste heat recovery throughout operation.

For exhaust gases, both temperature and mass flow rate change with engine load, but these quantities do not necessarily change in the same proportion. The exhaust gas temperature profile depends in part on the engine type, turbocharger configuration and engine control. At part load, the available thermal power may be considerably lower than at rated load, even when the exhaust gas temperature itself still appears attractive.

Engine cooling water does not necessarily follow the same pattern. Heat release, cooling-water circulation and temperature control depend in part on the engine design and the operation of the existing cooling systems. Thermostatic control may keep the cooling-water temperature within a narrow range, while the amount of heat rejected through the coolers changes with engine load. The thermal power available from cooling water may therefore follow a different pattern from the thermal power available in the exhaust gases.

A heat source may be attractive at high engine load but provide too little thermal power or too low a temperature at the lower loads commonly encountered in service. Knowing the number of operating hours at each relevant load is therefore more important than looking only at the rated engine power. A source that supplies a relatively constant amount of usable heat over long periods may yield more recoverable energy over a year than a source with a higher peak power that is available only briefly.

It is not only the total number of operating hours that matters, but also the duration of individual operating periods. With frequent load changes, a waste heat recovery system may repeatedly have to start up, reduce output or stop. The temperature and flow rate must remain within the required operating range for long enough for the heat to be transferred and used. The time needed to bring the connected system up to operating temperature may also play a role.

On a ship with several engines, it must also be clear which engines actually run in the different operating modes. The total installed engine power says little about the heat available at any one time when only some of the engines are used. The calculation must therefore reflect the combinations of engines used during operation, including any differences between passage, manoeuvring and time in port.

Changes in operation may also affect the heat supply. Changes in the operating profile, engine control or fuel may alter the temperatures and flow rates of the streams carrying the heat. The original design conditions may therefore no longer match the ship's current or future use. For a reliable assessment, temperature, mass flow rate and operating duration must relate to the same relevant operating conditions. Combining the highest measured temperature with the highest flow rate from another operating mode may produce a heat supply that never occurs in actual operation. The thermal power available during representative operating periods therefore forms the basis for a realistic calculation of annual recovery.

How Does Existing Heat Use Affect the Opportunities for Waste Heat Recovery?

On many ships, some engine heat is already used. An exhaust gas boiler may, for example, supply steam for heating, while heat from the engine cooling water is used for the hot-water supply or a freshwater generator. These existing applications help determine how much heat remains available for an additional waste heat recovery system.

If exhaust gas heat is already used for steam production, a new heat exchanger cannot simply use that same heat. If the new heat exchanger is installed upstream of the existing exhaust gas boiler, the temperature of the exhaust gases reaching the boiler may fall. Less heat may then remain for the original steam production. Recovering heat downstream avoids diverting heat from the boiler directly, but the remaining temperature and thermal power are usually lower.

A similar consideration applies to engine cooling water. A high-temperature cooling circuit that already supplies a freshwater generator or other heat users does not necessarily have enough remaining capacity for an additional system. What matters is not just the total thermal power in the circuit, but primarily how much heat remains after existing demand has been met, without compromising the required engine temperatures.

Under certain conditions, the existing temperature control may actually provide scope for additional recovery. If a new heat user draws heat from a thermostatically controlled cooling-water system, less heat may need to be rejected through the central cooler. The new heat user then takes over part of the original cooling load. However, this does not mean that the full rated capacity of the central cooler is available at every engine load.

Existing heat demand also changes during operation. During some operating periods, much of the available heat may already be absorbed by other consumers, while at other times more waste heat remains. Existing heat use and heat production must therefore be assessed for the same operating modes. A heat balance that includes both the original heat sources and the existing consumers shows how the heat is distributed. This reveals how much heat is already put to good use, what proportion is rejected unused and what effects a new connection may have on other consumers.

Existing heat use does not, however, automatically rule out further recovery. Under suitable conditions, the remaining heat may still be supplied to an additional consumer, provided the heat is still at a high enough temperature and the existing heat supply is maintained. A different distribution of the available heat may also be technically possible. This requires an assessment of the simultaneous heat demand and the consequences for the existing system.

When Do Heat Transfer and Cooling Limit Suitability for Heat Recovery?

A heat source may be available for enough operating hours at a suitable temperature and mass flow rate, yet prove less suitable if the heat cannot be transferred effectively to the intended application. This requires suitable heat exchangers, pipes and connections that can function within the technical limits of the ship's existing installation.

An exhaust gas heat exchanger must have sufficient heat-transfer area to transfer the required thermal power. During operation, fouling may reduce heat transfer while increasing the pressure drop. A heat source that offers enough power on paper may therefore be less suitable in practice. The heat exchanger must not only be thermally suitable, but must also remain within the permitted pressure and temperature limits and be sufficiently accessible for inspection and cleaning.

Where heat is carried by water, the flow rates, temperature differences and available connection options determine how much heat can be transferred. The heat exchanger must be able to transfer the required thermal power without adversely affecting the original cooling-water circulation or temperature control. The temperature difference between the two sides of the heat exchanger is also important, as it helps determine the heat transfer area required. A small temperature difference may make the system larger or less attractive, even when the source's calculated thermal power is considerable.

A separate heat-transfer fluid is sometimes used to carry heat from the source to the waste heat recovery system. A water or thermal oil circuit may, for example, absorb heat from an exhaust gas heat exchanger and carry it to a system installed further away. This offers greater flexibility in siting the equipment, but the additional heat-transfer step entails further temperature differences, heat losses and pumping energy demand. The temperature at the engine may therefore differ from the temperature at which heat can be supplied to the final user. The assessment needs to establish how much heat actually remains after the necessary heat transfer and transport, and at what temperature it becomes available.

For electricity production, the cold side of the system also plays an important role. A condensing steam cycle or Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) converts only part of the heat supplied into mechanical and then electrical power. Most of the remaining heat must be rejected through the condenser. A large heat supply on the hot side therefore does not automatically produce a high electrical output.

This requires sufficient cooling capacity and suitable cooling-water temperatures. A heat source at a relatively low temperature may become less attractive when the temperature difference between the source and the available coolant is small. Even with a larger heat supply, only part of the heat may be usable if the condenser cannot reject enough of the remaining heat.

The cooling conditions must also correspond to the operating periods in which the heat source is used. High water temperatures outside the ship or heavy demand from other users of the cooling-water system may limit the available cooling capacity. If favourable cooling conditions that do not coincide with the relevant heat supply are used in the calculation, the expected electrical output may be overestimated.

For an electricity-generating WHRS, it is also important to distinguish gross electrical power from the net power available after deducting auxiliary electrical loads. Circulation pumps, any additional cooling pumps and other auxiliary equipment may consume some of the electricity generated. It must also be assessed whether heat extraction causes additional energy consumption or changes engine performance, for example through additional exhaust back pressure. Only after accounting for these effects and the ship's use of the electricity generated can the actual energy savings be determined.

Alongside the thermal and operational requirements, it must also be physically possible to fit the system. A favourable exhaust gas temperature offers little benefit if the required heat exchanger cannot be fitted safely within the permitted limits of the exhaust system. For other circuits carrying heat, existing pipe routes, pump capacities, isolation options and maintenance access may determine feasibility. Depending on the system and the nature of the modifications, the applicable requirements of the classification society and flag State must also be taken into account.

What Data Are Needed to Establish Whether a Heat Source Is Suitable?

An initial assessment begins with data on the heat source and the conditions under which it is available during ship operation. For heat recovery from marine engines, the engine type, engine configuration, fuel used and relevant load conditions are important. These data can be used to establish how much waste heat the engines concerned can supply during different operating periods.

For exhaust gas heat, the key data required are the temperatures and mass flow rates at the relevant engine loads. It must be clear which point in the exhaust gas path these values relate to. The existing exhaust gas configuration, any existing heat users, the permissible back pressure and the limits on exhaust gas temperature reduction must also be known. If exhaust gas aftertreatment is present, its effect on the available heat and possible installation locations must also be taken into account.

For engine cooling water, relevant data include the supply and return temperatures, flow rates, pressure conditions and existing temperature control. It must also be clear which cooling-water circuits are present, which consumers are connected to them and how the original cooling function is provided at different engine loads. Similar data are needed for lubricating-oil cooling, charge-air cooling and other warm circuits, tailored to the properties and original function of the medium concerned. Temperature alone provides insufficient information when the required return temperature, flow or existing heat use is unknown.

The assessment also needs the operating hours at each engine load. An engine datasheet showing performance only at rated load does not indicate how much heat becomes available during normal operation. The load profile, operating duration and conditions under which the heat sources concerned can be used must also be known.

Manufacturer data may provide a suitable starting point, provided that the specified conditions match the engine variant and configuration actually installed. On an existing ship, the heat exchangers, pipework and controls actually installed, together with any previous modifications, must also be examined. The original drawings do not always match the current installation.

If important data are missing or insufficiently reliable, targeted measurements may be necessary. Temperatures and flow rates must then be established at suitable measurement points and under representative, sufficiently stable operating conditions. A temperature measurement without reliable information on the corresponding flow rate and engine load provides an insufficient basis for calculating the available thermal power accurately.

The measured and calculated values must also relate to the same operating period. Combining temperatures, flow rates and loads from different, non-comparable operating modes may produce a heat balance that does not match the actual installation. The data collected can be used to draw up an initial heat balance for each relevant operating mode. This distinguishes the thermal power available at the original source from the portion that can be extracted within the technical limits and the portion available to the new system after heat transfer. Existing heat consumption and the technical restrictions on both the hot and cold sides must also be taken into account.

Combining the thermal power that can be transferred within the applicable limits in each representative operating mode with the corresponding operating hours provides an initial estimate of the thermal energy available each year. It must then be established during which periods the intended application can actually absorb this heat. For electricity production, this calculation does not yet constitute a prediction of annual net electricity generation. The performance of the selected conversion cycle, the cooling conditions and the system's own energy consumption are also needed.

At the initial technical selection stage, the heat exchangers, pumps and pipework of a proposed WHRS do not all need to be fully sized. However, the available heat, permissible heat extraction and main operating limits must be known with sufficient reliability. If these particular data remain uncertain, a detailed performance prediction may appear more accurate than the available information warrants.

When Is a Heat Source Actually Suitable for Waste Heat Recovery?

A heat source is actually suitable for waste heat recovery when its temperature and mass flow rate provide sufficient usable heat, this heat remains available during the relevant operating periods and the required heat extraction can take place within the technical limits of the ship's existing installation. Exhaust gas heat may be attractive for this purpose when sufficient thermal power is available without exceeding back-pressure limits, overcooling the exhaust gases or disrupting the exhaust system. Engine cooling water and other circuits carrying heat may be suitable when heat transfer is compatible with the required temperature control and the original cooling or lubrication function is maintained.

The available heat must also be transferable to an application suited to its temperature. Direct heat use requires sufficient heat demand at the time the heat is available. For electricity production, the temperature difference between the source and the cold side, available cooling capacity and expected net electrical power must also be assessed. Suitability is therefore not determined by a high temperature, a high cooling-water flow rate or the rated engine power alone. What matters is how much waste heat can be extracted without exceeding the applicable technical limits under the ship's actual operating conditions, how much of it reaches the intended application and whether that energy can actually be used.

Once these conditions are sufficiently well understood, the assessment can identify which waste heat recovery system suits the heat source. A technically suitable heat source therefore provides a necessary basis for a WHRS, but is not yet evidence of a particular electrical output, fuel savings or economic feasibility.

This Article in the Series

The suitability of a heat source provides the technical starting point for the choice between direct heat use, a steam cycle and ORC. On ships with several engines, the available heat supply also depends on simultaneous engine operation and load distribution. How these conditions relate to the other ship systems is discussed in WHRS system selection and integration.