Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Do You Determine the Additional Savings When Waste Heat Is Already Used for Other On-Board Applications?

The additional savings from waste heat recovery are determined by comparing the ship's energy consumption before and after installation, accounting for all existing uses of recovered heat. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can use heat from exhaust gases, engine cooling water or other suitable sources for heating or electricity production.

When a ship already uses some of this heat for applications such as hot-water production, fuel preheating or other thermal uses, the entire heat supply cannot simply be treated as available for additional recovery. A new Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) can produce electricity but at the same time change the quantity of heat that existing consumers receive. When additional heating becomes necessary as a result, this can offset some of the fuel savings. Conversely, a different distribution of heat can still be beneficial when the fuel saved by displacing electricity generation exceeds the extra fuel used to replace the heat.

The assessment must therefore be based on the existing heat and energy supply, the heat available at the relevant temperature levels and the energy consumption that actually changes after the expansion. Only by assessing total fuel consumption at comparable ship performance and under comparable operating conditions can it be established how much additional saving the new waste heat recovery delivers.

Why Does Existing Heat Use Determine How Much Additional Energy Can Be Saved?

A marine engine converts some of the energy supplied by the fuel into mechanical work. Another portion is rejected through the exhaust, engine cooling water and other cooling circuits. This heat may be available for recovery, but that does not mean that it is entirely lost under current operating conditions. Many ships already have equipment that uses some of the engine heat. An exhaust gas boiler can, for example, produce steam for heating or fuel treatment. Cooling-water heat can also be used for hot-water production or other suitable thermal applications.

When this heat reduces the load on a fuel-fired boiler or another heating installation, fuel may already be saved as a result. These savings form part of the ship's existing energy performance and must not be attributed in full to an additional installation again. When adding an ORC, the assessment must therefore not be based on a hypothetical baseline in which all engine heat was rejected unused. The relevant reference is the ship as it actually operates, including its existing heat exchangers, steam or hot-water circuits and other useful applications.

This distinction becomes particularly important when different installations use the same heat source. When a new ORC heat exchanger is incorporated into the exhaust system, the temperature or quantity of heat remaining available to an existing exhaust gas boiler may change. The effect depends on the position of the new heat exchanger, the exhaust gas conditions and the heat that the original consumers need. The ORC can consequently produce electricity while reducing the heat available for an existing use.

However, a reduction in available thermal power does not automatically mean that the entire difference must be generated again elsewhere. When the original heat demand is limited at that moment, some of the heat may remain unused. An existing heat exchanger may also have more capacity than the equipment it serves actually need. In such situations, a new ORC may be able to use additional heat without an existing thermal function being restricted.

When the available heat is necessary to meet the original heat demand, it must be established how this function will be maintained after the expansion. Additional fuel-fired or electrical heating may become necessary for this purpose. The energy balance must then account for both the new ORC output and the replacement heat. The additional energy consumption needed to maintain the existing heat supply must be included in the same comparison.

The actual additional savings are therefore not determined solely by the heat that the new installation absorbs. What matters is how much less fuel the ship consumes in the new configuration while the original thermal and electrical functions are maintained under comparable conditions.

How Do You Map the Existing Heat Sources and Heat Consumers?

A reliable assessment begins with a heat balance for the ship's existing systems. It identifies the heat sources, how the heat is transferred and which equipment needs it under the relevant operating conditions. The heat sources may comprise exhaust gases, high-temperature cooling water and other suitable hot circuits. For each source, the available temperatures, flow rates and heat release at the relevant engine loads must be sufficiently known.

The existing heat exchangers and distribution systems are also included in the assessment. An exhaust gas heat exchanger can, for example, supply heat to a steam system, after which the steam supplies several users. Heat can also be distributed through a closed water or thermal oil circuit. However, the energy in such a distribution circuit originates from the original heat source. When the same heat flows successively through a heat exchanger, intermediate circuit and the circuit serving the end user, it must not be added again at each transfer as separately available thermal power.

It is then established which thermal consumers are actually present. These may include heating systems, hot-water production, fuel treatment, cargo heating and other uses. The required temperature and quantity of heat may differ for each consumer. It must also be clear when the heat demand concerned occurs. A heating circuit may, for example, need heat mainly at lower outside temperatures, while the available engine heat depends mainly on engine load.

As a result, an installation with high rated thermal power need not deliver useful heat at the same rate throughout the year. For the heat balance, it is therefore not only the installed power that is considered, but above all the heat used during actual ship operation.

For a water circuit with no phase change, temperature differences and liquid flow rates can be used to determine heat transfer. The relevant thermal properties of the medium must be taken into account in doing so. For steam circuits, a different assessment is needed. When steam condenses or water evaporates, heat transfer cannot be derived solely from the temperature difference. The mass flow rate and enthalpy of the steam and condensate flows involved must then also be included.

It must also be established which other energy sources support the existing heat supply. An exhaust gas boiler may, for example, at certain engine loads, produce insufficient steam, so that a fuel-fired boiler supplies additional heat. The fuel consumption of this boiler is important for determining the additional savings. When a new ORC changes the heat distribution, the quantity of heat that the boiler must produce may also change.

The heat balance must therefore show how much heat the existing consumers actually receive, which proportion of it is supplied by waste heat and which additional energy production remains necessary. Only when this distribution is sufficiently known can it be established how much heat remains available for further recovery or can be allocated to a new application under other conditions. This prevents heat already in use from being treated as wholly unused.

Why Must the Available Heat Surplus Be Determined for Each Operating Mode?

The amount of waste heat available for further recovery changes during operation. Both the heat supply from the engines and the demand from the existing thermal consumers may vary. At a higher engine load, the exhaust gas temperature, mass flow rate and available cooling-water heat can change. As a result, a different amount of thermal power may become available for the existing heat exchangers and additional recovery.

However, heat demand need not change in the same proportion. An existing heating circuit may, for example, have almost constant heat demand during certain periods, while propulsion engine load varies greatly. At high engine load, heat may then remain that the existing consumers do not need. At a lower engine load, the same heat demand may instead require a large proportion of the available waste heat.

A substantial heat surplus during one favourable operating mode must therefore not, without further assessment, be regarded as continuously available. For additional recovery, what matters above all is when the surplus is available and for how long. Conditions outside the engine room can also affect heat demand. Space heating, cargo heating and certain other thermal applications may depend on the outdoor temperature, cargo and operational use of the ship.

For a ship using different fuels, the need for fuel heating may also change. The available additional heat must therefore be established for the relevant combinations of engine load and thermal demand. For each operating mode, it is first determined how much heat the existing consumers need and which proportion of it can be supplied by the recovery installations present. The next step is to establish how much heat remains under those conditions.

The temperature level of this remaining heat is, in this assessment, at least as important as the total quantity. An exhaust gas flow may, after an existing heat exchanger, still contain substantial thermal energy, while the temperature is too low for a particular ORC configuration. Further cooling may also be limited by material temperatures, susceptibility to corrosion and the necessary functioning of the exhaust gas route. The available thermal power is therefore not automatically equal to the power that a new installation can absorb within acceptable technical limits.

For an ORC, the available cooling and electrical demand must also be included. When the cooling-water temperature is high, the condensing conditions may limit electricity production. Sufficient heat may also be available while electrical demand on board is too low to use the ORC's full output. In that case, the heat surplus does not automatically represent corresponding fuel savings.

The additional annual output therefore arises from the operating periods in which usable heat at the required temperature level, suitable cooling and sufficient demand for the recovered energy are available simultaneously. Without this assessment, the total quantity of waste heat rejected over a year is insufficient to determine the additional fuel savings. The heat must be recoverable within technical limits and available when it can be used.

How Does the Order of Heat Extraction Affect the Additional Output?

When several heat exchangers are connected to the same heat source, the order in which heat is extracted may affect the available temperatures and total useful energy output. In an exhaust gas route, for example, an existing exhaust gas boiler may be the first unit in the exhaust flow, producing steam for heating or other uses. When an additional ORC heat exchanger is incorporated downstream, it receives exhaust gases that have already been cooled by the original boiler.

The ORC must then be assessed on the basis of the exhaust gas temperature downstream of the boiler, mass flow rate and permitted further cooling. A heat exchanger originally selected for a higher source temperature need not, under these conditions, be able to deliver the same thermal power to the ORC.

When the new ORC heat exchanger is instead placed upstream of the existing exhaust gas boiler, the ORC may receive higher-temperature heat for electricity generation. However, this need not be more favourable for the ship's total energy supply. The exhaust gases may be cooled by the first heat exchanger to such an extent that the existing boiler produces less steam. When this steam remains necessary, additional fuel-fired heat production may become necessary.

Higher ORC output may therefore coincide with a reduction in the existing fuel savings. The additional electricity production must then not be assessed separately without including the consequences for the original steam supply.

The applications can also be supplied through separate heat exchangers or separately controlled heat flows. In that case, the pipework layout, available heat exchanger capacity and controls determine how much heat flows to the different consumers during each operating mode. In this assessment, the distinction between heat quantity and temperature level is important. Equipment using the heat may, for example, require a minimum supply temperature. Heat becoming available below this temperature cannot, despite substantial thermal power, automatically fulfil the same function.

For an ORC, the temperature difference between the hot and cold sides affects how much mechanical work can be obtained from the heat absorbed. The same quantity of heat may therefore, at a different supply temperature, lead to different net electricity output.

Using heat in stages can, under suitable conditions, be attractive. A heat flow may first serve an application at a higher temperature level, after which the remaining heat may still be used for another function. However, the best sequence varies by installation. It depends on the available temperatures, actual heat demands, heat exchanger performance and limitations of the engine and ship systems.

Recovering heat rejected by the ORC condenser is another option to assess. When the condenser heat is available at a usable temperature level, it can, under certain conditions, support an existing thermal consumer. However, the consequences for electricity production must be taken into account in doing so. When, for a higher useful heat delivery temperature, the ORC condensing temperature must also rise, the available expansion range may narrow.

The assessment must account for the interaction between electrical and thermal output before assuming that both can reach their maxima at the same time. The selected condenser conditions must suit the combination of heat use and electricity production actually being investigated. The order and distribution of heat extraction must ultimately be chosen on the basis of the combined net energy savings. In doing so, the necessary temperature and operating limits of the existing engines and heat consumers must be maintained.

When Does a New ORC Reduce Existing Useful Heat Use?

A new ORC can absorb heat that already served an existing use on the ship. This may happen, for example, when the ORC cools the exhaust gases upstream of an existing exhaust gas boiler or extracts heat from a common hot-water circuit. The existing users may therefore receive less heat. However, this does not mean that every reduction in available thermal power automatically leads to additional fuel consumption.

When an existing consumer needs little heat during the period concerned, reducing the available power may have no direct consequence. The original heat exchanger may also supply more heat than is actually being used at that moment. A partial reduction in heat transfer may then leave enough heat to meet demand. The relevant question is how much useful heat the existing consumers actually lose and whether an additional energy source must consequently be used.

When the original heat demand can no longer be met in full, it must be established how the ship will make up the shortfall. A fuel-fired boiler can, for example, produce additional steam or hot water, but electrical heating or another heat source can also be used. The additional energy required depends on the shortfall in useful heat and the characteristics of the replacement installation. For a fuel-fired boiler, for example, the efficiency and actual load at which the additional heat is produced must be taken into account.

The quantity of additional fuel energy is therefore not automatically equal to the useful heat that the boiler supplies. The conversion losses and operating conditions of the boiler concerned must be included in the assessment. For electrical heating, it must be determined which source supplies the additional electricity. When this electricity is supplied by fuel-fired generating sets, the additional load can offset some of the fuel savings achieved by the ORC.

The existing boiler controls can also affect the outcome. A boiler may, for example, with a lower heat supply, need to fire more often to make up the shortfall or remain in operation for more hours. Fuel consumption may consequently change differently from what would be expected solely on the basis of the difference in heat demand. When several thermal consumers are connected, the distribution of heat may also change. The control may give certain applications priority, while other consumers temporarily receive less heat.

In the assessment, it must therefore be established which thermal functions are necessary and which heat demand must actually be met during the different operating modes. A new ORC must not be used solely for higher calculated electricity production when necessary heating or engine functions remain insufficiently available as a result. Technical feasibility and preservation of the original ship functions remain the guiding considerations.

The additional energy savings must therefore be determined for a configuration in which the required heat supply is maintained within operating limits. Only then can it be established whether the changed heat distribution actually leads to lower total fuel consumption.

How Do You Compare Additional Electricity Production with Replacement Heat Production?

When a new ORC produces electricity but at the same time reduces the heat available to existing users, both effects must be assessed within one consistent energy balance. It is first established how much net electricity the ORC actually delivers to the ship. The relevant electricity consumption of working-fluid pumps, any intermediate circuit pumps and additional cooling provisions must be clearly accounted for.

It is then determined which existing generation this net output displaces. When existing generating sets need to deliver less power, the fuel savings are established on the basis of their revised loads and corresponding fuel consumption curves. The same quantity of net ORC electricity therefore need not yield the same fuel savings in every generator configuration. The possibility of shutting down a complete generating set can also affect total fuel consumption.

It is then assessed whether the original thermal consumers need additional energy because of the new heat distribution. When, for example, a fuel-fired boiler must produce additional heat because the ORC uses some of the existing exhaust gas heat, the additional fuel consumption required for this is established. The additional fuel savings then consist of the fuel saved through reduced output from the existing generators, less the additional fuel needed for the replacement heat supply. Any other associated losses must also be included in this assessment.

When no additional heating is needed, there is no corresponding increase in fuel consumption for heating. This may be the case, for example, when the ORC uses only heat that was not needed for the existing thermal consumers in that operating mode. When the missing heat is produced using electricity, the additional electrical demand must be linked to the generators or other energy sources supplying it.

In doing so, it must be ensured that the same electrical energy is not used twice in the calculation. An ORC may, for example, supply electricity to the shipboard electrical system, while some of it becomes necessary for replacement electrical heating. In that case, only the net effect on the ship's energy supply determines how much fuel is actually saved. The gross or net electricity generation from the ORC cannot separately be treated in full as displaced output from existing generators when some of that electricity meets a new electrical load.

It is also incorrect to equate one kilowatt-hour of useful heat, without further assessment, with one kilowatt-hour of electrical energy. Although both can be expressed in the same unit of energy, they can serve different uses and the systems that supply them have different conversion losses. The avoided and additional energy production must therefore be translated into the fuel consumption of the installations concerned. In this way, the comparison is based on the actual reduction in the energy that the ship needs from fuel.

A new ORC can, under certain conditions, still save additional fuel when an existing heat consumer needs more boiler heat. This is the case when the fuel savings from displacing existing electricity generation exceed the additional fuel consumption for the replacement heat supply and any other losses. In another situation, the additional boiler load may offset most of the possible savings. The outcome depends on the actual heat distribution, generator dispatch and characteristics of the replacement energy supply.

The assessment must therefore not show only how much electricity the ORC produces or how much existing heat is lost. What matters is the change in the ship's total fuel consumption, with the electrical and thermal functions fulfilled under the same relevant operating conditions.

Which Additional Losses and Technical Interactions Count?

Alongside the distribution of useful heat, additional technical losses can affect the additional fuel savings. These arise, for example, when the new WHRS causes changes in the operation of the engine, ship cooling or electrical energy supply. In an ORC with an exhaust gas heat exchanger, additional flow resistance may arise. When total exhaust back pressure increases as a result, this can affect the fuel consumption or operation of the engine concerned.

The size of this effect depends on the engine design, existing exhaust gas installation and pressure drop across the heat exchanger. Fouling during operation can also change the flow resistance. The new heat extraction must therefore not only be thermally suitable, but must also remain within the permitted engine and exhaust gas conditions. Any additional engine fuel consumption must be included when it arises because of the WHRS.

Additional loads may also occur on the cold side. An ORC rejects most of its unused heat through the condenser. Existing cooling circuits can be used for this purpose, but additional circulation pumps or other cooling provisions are sometimes needed. When these provisions use additional electricity, this consumption must be included in the net energy balance.

With shared ship cooling, a distinction must be made between existing pump demand and any change caused by the new installation. The full existing pump power does not automatically constitute a new WHRS load. It must also be ensured that the same auxiliary consumption is not deducted several times. When the working-fluid pump's consumption is already included in the net ORC output, this consumption must not be included again as a separate loss item.

Another important interaction arises when the ORC uses heat from generating sets whose loads are reduced by the ORC's own output. The lower generator load can change the exhaust gas temperature, mass flow rate and available cooling-water heat. This can reduce both the heat supplied to the ORC and the heat available for existing uses. The new heat distribution must therefore be determined for the final generator load.

Existing controls can also respond to the additional heat extraction. When, for example, the temperature of a common hot-water circuit falls, an existing heating installation may automatically begin to supply more heat. The additional fuel consumption may consequently arise without a separate new heating installation being installed. The existing controls and the energy supplied in response must therefore remain part of the assessment.

The available condenser capacity can also limit ORC production. When the condenser cannot reject sufficient heat because of the total load on the ship's cooling system, the ORC may have to reduce output. The electrical production actually available may then be lower than was expected on the basis of the heat supply alone. The total energy balance must therefore also encompass the possible limitations on the cold side.

When engine heat from existing cooling circuits is used, the heat already rejected through ship cooling before the expansion must also be taken into account. Some of it may be transferred by the ORC to another location in the same cooling system. The condenser duty therefore need not increase the existing cooling load by the same amount. The heat distribution before and after installation must show which load actually changes.

The combined heat and energy balance must therefore be based on a technically feasible configuration in which the engines, existing heat consumers, ORC, cooling and electrical systems can function simultaneously. Only when these interactions have been sufficiently accounted for can it be established how much additional fuel the new waste heat recovery actually saves.

How Do You Prevent Double Counting of Existing and New Energy Savings?

When a ship already uses waste heat, a distinction must be made between the existing energy savings and the additional contribution of a new WHRS. An exhaust gas boiler may, for example, already save fuel because an existing heating boiler needs to produce less heat. These savings form part of the ship's existing energy performance.

A new ORC must not count the same existing savings again in full as additional savings attributable to it. It is therefore first established which energy the ship actually consumes before the new installation is added. This starting point encompasses the heat recovery already present, existing thermal consumers, existing generator dispatch and any supplementary heating installations.

The new ship configuration is then assessed. Net ORC electricity production, the changed generator load and the consequences for the existing heat supply are accounted for together in this assessment. When the new ORC takes heat from an existing useful application, any energy needed to replace that heat is also included. The difference between total fuel consumption in the two situations constitutes the actual additional savings.

A comparison with a hypothetical ship on which no heat recovery is present at all gives a different answer. Such a comparison may be relevant when the combined contribution of all recovery provisions present is being investigated. However, it is not automatically suitable for establishing the incremental benefit of a new ORC on a ship that already puts heat to good use. For that purpose, the existing ship configuration remains the correct reference.

Separate saving percentages must also not be added together without further assessment. When two installations use the same heat source, the output of one installation may depend on the heat extracted by the other. A separate calculation may then assume a heat flow that is no longer fully available in the combined configuration. The combined output may consequently differ from the sum of the two separately calculated results.

For each saving percentage, it must also be clear which original fuel consumption is used as the reference. A saving relative to the fuel consumption of one heating boiler is, for example, based on a different denominator from the same fuel saving expressed as a percentage of the ship's total consumption. When such percentages are added together without a common basis, an incorrect picture of the total savings may arise. The underlying quantities of fuel avoided must therefore first be assessed within the same energy balance.

The heat itself must also not be counted several times as separately available energy. Heat transferred through an exhaust gas heat exchanger to an intermediate circuit and then supplied to the ORC still originates from the same heat source. Transport through different circuits does not create additional thermal energy. The heat balance must therefore follow the same energy flows from the original source to their final useful application or rejection.

In this way, it remains clear which proportion of existing heat use is maintained and which additional energy production is actually made possible by the new installation. The additional savings can then be established without counting existing benefits or the same quantity of heat again.

How Do You Determine the Additional Annual Savings Across the Operational Profile?

The additional fuel savings possible during one operating mode do not automatically constitute a representative value for the entire operation. Engine load, existing heat demand, cooling-water temperature and electrical demand may change substantially over the year. The additional savings are therefore determined for the ship's relevant operating periods. For each operating mode, it is first established how much heat the engines concerned make available and at what temperature this heat can be used.

It is then investigated how much heat the existing thermal consumers actually need under the same conditions. This demand may change because of the outdoor temperature, operating area, fuel used or activities the ship performs. Existing heat storage and steam systems can also affect the distribution of heat over time. The heat balance must therefore be consistent with the way in which the existing provisions actually function during the operating periods concerned.

The available heat is then linked to the selected additional ORC configuration. In doing so, it is established how much thermal power the ORC can absorb and how much net electricity it can supply under the corresponding heat and cooling conditions. Sufficient electrical demand must also remain available. After all, a thermally suitable operating mode need not automatically yield an equally large useful electrical contribution when the shipboard electrical system must limit production.

The consequences for the existing thermal consumers are then assessed. When the new heat distribution means that a heating boiler must supply more energy, the additional fuel consumption during the same operating period is established. The change in generating-set fuel consumption is also calculated for the electrical load after the ORC's contribution is accounted for. The resulting generator dispatch and relevant fuel consumption curves must be taken into account in this assessment.

In this way, the difference in total fuel consumption with and without the new installation can be determined for each operating mode. These savings are then linked to the number of hours during which the operating mode concerned occurs. In doing so, not all original engine hours may be treated as hours of full ORC output. During certain periods, insufficient suitable waste heat may be available or electrical demand may limit production.

Start-up, maintenance and faults can also affect the annual contribution. The expected availability must therefore suit the selected installation and the conditions in which it is used. The existing heat supply must continue to function adequately during these periods. An ORC that, under normal conditions, uses some of the available heat must not, on failure, unintentionally interrupt an essential heating function.

The controls and any bypass or other heat distribution equipment partly determine how the new configuration functions during different operating modes. This operation must be consistent with the ship's original thermal requirements. Heat storage also requires an assessment of when heat is stored and used. A buffer tank or other storage provision can keep heat available temporarily when supply and demand do not occur simultaneously.

However, storage does not create additional heat. The quantity stored, temperature level, losses and available periods for charging and discharging remain decisive for the energy that can actually be put to good use.

The additional annual savings ultimately follow from the sum of the fuel savings across the individual operating periods. In this assessment, the starting point is always the existing uses of recovered heat and the changes caused by the new ORC. The annual calculation thus shows how much additional fuel is actually avoided, rather than solely how much new electricity can be generated under favourable operating conditions.

How Do You Reliably Demonstrate the Actual Additional Savings?

A reliable reference case is needed to demonstrate the additional fuel savings. For a ship on which heat is already put to good use, this reference must fully encompass the existing heat supply. The baseline is the ship's energy system as it operated before the new ORC, including any heat already recovered. In this assessment, the available heat sources, existing thermal consumers, generator operation and any supplementary heating installations are recorded.

The relevant engine loads, heat demands and operating conditions must also be sufficiently known. Without these data, a later difference in fuel consumption cannot reliably be attributed to the new installation. The next step is to assess the system after installation. In doing so, it is established how much heat the ORC actually absorbs and how the heat supply to the existing consumers changes as a result.

Temperatures, flow rates and pressure data can help to determine heat transfer in the different circuits. For water circuits without a phase change, it can, for example, be calculated from the liquid mass flow rate, specific heat capacity and temperature difference. For steam circuits, enthalpy and any phase changes must also be included. An assessment based solely on the temperature difference may, during evaporation or condensation, provide insufficient information about the actual heat transfer.

When an existing heating boiler must supply more heat, the change in its fuel consumption or the energy required for this is established. For the ORC, net electricity generation and the relevant heat and cooling conditions are recorded. This electricity production is then linked to the changed load and fuel consumption of the other electrical energy sources. In this way, it is not only the technical ORC production that is determined, but also the fuel actually saved as a result.

In this assessment, the original and new operating conditions must be sufficiently comparable. When the ship operates at a different engine load or has a different heat demand during one period, total fuel consumption may change without this being caused solely by the ORC. The same applies when electrical demand, fuel choice or the use of other ship systems changes. These factors must therefore be sufficiently known to distinguish the effect of the new heat recovery.

The relevant operating conditions are recorded and, where necessary, included in the comparison using a suitable method. A measurement at one stable engine load can provide insight into operation under those specific conditions. However, to demonstrate the additional annual savings, the other relevant operating periods must also be included. The result at one favourable operating point does not automatically describe what is achieved over a full year.

In doing so, it must remain clear which data have been measured directly and which results follow from calculations or a reference model. A calculated saving has a different evidential basis from a directly measured change under sufficiently similar conditions. The accuracy of the measurements also deserves attention. When the new ORC yields relatively small additional fuel savings compared with large existing heat and fuel flows, measurement uncertainty may be large relative to the calculated difference.

Particularly when the savings are determined from the difference between two large energy totals, uncertainties in temperatures, flow rates and fuel measurements can affect the outcome. The reliability of the difference must therefore be assessed in relation to the size of the expected savings.

Measured net ORC electricity production does not in itself constitute evidence of equally large additional fuel savings. It must also be established whether the existing heat supply fulfilled the same necessary functions during the period investigated. When the ORC produces more electricity but an existing thermal consumer receives less heat, the comparison is incomplete until that loss of heat is accounted for.

For a reliable assessment, propulsion performance, electrical demand and the necessary heat supply must be sufficiently similar. Only then can the difference in total fuel consumption be meaningfully linked to the changed heat recovery. The measurements can be supplemented with substantiated calculations when certain data are not directly available. In doing so, it must remain identifiable which assumptions are used and how sensitive the outcome is to them.

The additional fuel savings are the difference in the ship's total fuel consumption with and without the new recovery system, assessed under comparable operating conditions.

When Does Additional Waste Heat Recovery Actually Deliver Extra Value?

Additional waste heat recovery delivers extra energy value when it further reduces the ship's total fuel consumption relative to the baseline that includes existing uses of recovered heat. For this purpose, it must first be established how much heat is actually available during the relevant operating periods and which thermal functions are already served by that heat. It is then assessed which proportion can be put to additional use without unacceptably affecting the original functions.

A new ORC may, for example, use heat that is still present in the exhaust gases downstream of an existing exhaust gas boiler. When this remaining heat is available at a suitable temperature level and the ORC can deliver sufficient net electricity, additional fuel savings may be possible without restricting the original heat supply. However, the same outcome is not possible with every ship configuration. When the new ORC extracts heat that an existing heating installation needs, it must be established how much additional energy is needed to meet that demand.

This does not mean that every competing extraction of heat is automatically unfavourable. A different heat distribution may instead lead to lower total fuel consumption when the fuel saved by reducing existing generator output exceed the additional fuel needed for the replacement heat supply. The assessment must therefore concern the ship's complete energy supply, not the separate thermal or electrical output of one installation.

A combination of heat use at different temperature levels can also, under suitable conditions, be of interest. The technically suitable distribution depends on the temperatures of the heat sources, the required temperatures at the existing consumers and the available cooling and electrical demand. The largest quantity of heat absorbed or highest gross ORC output therefore need not correspond to the largest additional fuel savings. The consequences for existing boilers, pumps, generators and other ship systems must also be included.

The financial value of a new ORC may likewise differ, depending on which energy production is actually replaced and which costs are necessary for the additional installation. However, for determining the additional energy savings, the change in total fuel consumption is the initial focus.

In this assessment, the existing ship installation, including all existing uses of recovered heat, forms the reference. The new configuration is compared with it while maintaining the necessary thermal and electrical functions. Any additional boiler or generator fuel consumption and relevant system losses are accounted for in the same comparison. In this way, it becomes clear which benefit actually arises on top of the energy savings already present.

The additional savings follow from the difference in total fuel consumption between the two situations, assessed under the same relevant operating conditions and over the same period of use. In this way, it is ensured that heat savings already achieved are not attributed to a new ORC again and that a redistribution of heat is not automatically presented as additional energy savings.

Additional waste heat recovery is therefore worthwhile in energy terms when it demonstrably reduces total ship fuel consumption beyond the savings already achieved with the existing heat recovery equipment. The decisive factor is not how much additional heat is absorbed or electricity produced, but how much additional fuel is actually avoided as a result.

This Article Within the Series

When waste heat on board is already put to good use, additional ORC electricity may coincide with a higher fuel requirement for existing heat consumers. Only the change in total fuel consumption therefore determines the additional savings. These savings also form the starting point for the financial effects of EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime. In addition, the possible Energy Investment Allowance for an ORC on board may affect the investment assessment. Both aspects must be assessed without double counting within the business case and investment decision for WHRS installations.