How Do EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime Affect the Business Case for Waste Heat Recovery?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime can improve the business case for waste heat recovery, but the two schemes affect costs in different ways. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) uses heat from sources such as exhaust gases or engine cooling water to supply electricity or useful heat. When less fuel is needed as a result, costs associated with greenhouse gas emissions may also be avoided alongside direct fuel costs.
Under the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS), lower emissions can mean that fewer emission allowances are needed. FuelEU Maritime, by contrast, assesses the average greenhouse gas intensity of the energy used. With the same energy mix and applicable emission factors, lower energy use does not automatically reduce this intensity, but it can affect the size of a compliance deficit or surplus.
Whether these changes actually generate financial value depends on the compliance position, how the obligations are settled and the contractual allocation of costs. The voyages involved, future emission allowance prices and remaining economic life also affect the outcome. A reliable WHRS business case therefore includes avoided fuel costs, possible ETS benefits and any FuelEU effects as separate, sufficiently substantiated cash flows. In doing so, it must remain clear which benefits arise directly from energy savings, which depend on regulation and which actually accrue to the party financing the installation.
Why Can EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime Change the Financial Value of a WHRS?
The economic value of waste heat recovery begins with the existing generation that the system displaces. When a WHRS supplies electricity that would otherwise be produced by fuel-fired generating sets, the fuel consumption of these engines can decrease. With direct heat use, by contrast, less fuel may be needed for an existing heating installation. Fuel cost savings are the first financial benefit. Their value depends on the actual quantity of fuel saved and the costs that would be associated with this consumption without a WHRS.
European emissions regulation can affect the financial value of those energy savings. Under EU ETS, the relevant greenhouse gas emissions within its scope are linked to an obligation to surrender emission allowances. When the WHRS reduces fuel consumption and the associated emissions, fewer emission allowances may be needed. The financial value then arises from a lower emission allowance obligation. Depending on the existing allowance position, this may mean that fewer allowances need to be purchased or that allowances already available are available for other use.
FuelEU Maritime works differently. Regulation (EU) 2023/1805 sets limits on the average greenhouse gas intensity of the energy used on board within its scope. The well-to-wake calculation includes relevant emissions from producing and supplying the energy and from using it on board. Lower fuel consumption does not automatically reduce greenhouse gas intensity per megajoule. However, lower energy use can change the size of the FuelEU compliance balance.
Its economic significance depends on the original compliance position. A smaller negative balance can, under certain circumstances, result in lower compliance costs, while a smaller positive balance may mean that less surplus remains available for future compliance or pooling. The way in which these balances are used is also important. A change in the compliance balance does not automatically represent a direct cash receipt or cost saving.
The two regulatory frameworks therefore do not provide a uniform financial bonus for every kilowatt-hour that an ORC produces. It must first be established how much fuel is actually saved and what consequences this has for the relevant emissions and energy used. The changes in the ETS obligation and FuelEU compliance position are then calculated separately. Only when it is clear which costs, revenues or future compliance options actually change as a result can these effects be valued in the WHRS investment appraisal.
Which Fuel Savings Form the Starting Point for the Financial Calculation?
To generate electricity using an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), waste heat is transferred to an organic working fluid. The vapour then flows through an expander that drives a generator. How much electricity can be produced in this way depends on the available heat supply, engine load, cooling conditions and technical characteristics of the installation.
For the financial assessment, it is not only gross generator power that matters. The WHRS itself consumes electricity for equipment such as the working-fluid pump, any intermediate circuit pumps, additional cooling and other necessary provisions. It must therefore first be established how much net electricity the complete installation actually delivers to the ship. The relevant auxiliary consumption must, in this assessment, be accounted for within a clearly defined system boundary. Electrical consumption already included in the net output figure must not be deducted again. Additional consumption outside that system boundary must, however, be included when it arises because of the WHRS.
It is then determined which existing generation the net ORC output displaces. When a generating set needs to deliver less electrical power, fuel consumption can decrease. The reduction depends on the original and new engine loads and the corresponding fuel consumption curves. The same quantity of net ORC electricity therefore does not yield the same fuel savings in every generator configuration. It also makes a difference whether several running generating sets are partly unloaded or whether a complete generating set can safely be taken out of service.
When a generating set is shut down, it is not only the fuel consumption of the engine concerned that changes. The load and consumption of the remaining generating sets can also change. The total saving must therefore be established for the complete generator configuration. The necessary electrical reserve and safe operation of the shipboard electrical system remain decisive in this assessment. The calculation must not assume a generator strategy that cannot safely be applied during actual operation.
A particular interaction arises when the ORC receives waste heat from the same generating sets whose loads are reduced by its electrical output. The lower engine load can reduce the available exhaust gas and cooling-water heat, thereby also reducing the heat supply to the ORC. The final fuel savings must therefore be calculated for a consistent set of values for engine load, heat supply and electrical output. The original heat production must not, without further assessment, be combined with the fuel consumption at a substantially lower engine operating point.
Additional system losses may also be relevant. An exhaust gas heat exchanger can cause extra back pressure and thereby, under certain conditions, affect fuel consumption. When heat already used elsewhere is diverted to the ORC, additional heat production may also be needed elsewhere. These consequences form part of the ship's overall energy balance. Positive net electricity generation from the ORC therefore does not automatically constitute evidence of an equally large net energy saving for the entire ship.
The common basis for the financial assessment is therefore the difference in actual fuel consumption with and without a WHRS, at comparable ship performance and under comparable operating conditions. It must then be clear which fuels are saved and during which voyages or port activities these savings arise. This is necessary because direct fuel costs, ETS coverage and the FuelEU calculation do not automatically have the same geographical and energy basis.
How Is the Reduced Need for ETS Emission Allowances Valued Financially?
The EU Emissions Trading System is based on Directive 2003/87/EC, as amended, among other acts, by Directive (EU) 2023/959. The responsible shipping companies must surrender allowances for relevant greenhouse gas emissions within the scheme's scope. From the 2026 emissions year, maritime EU ETS covers, for the cargo and passenger ships concerned, not only carbon dioxide (CO2) but also methane (CH4) and nitrous oxide (N2O). These emissions are converted, according to the applicable rules, into CO2 equivalents.
The allowance surrender requirement has been phased in. For the relevant emissions in 2024, a surrender percentage of 40% applied, and for 2025 a percentage of 70%. From the 2026 emissions year, the surrender requirement covers 100% of the relevant emissions within scope. Allowances for emissions in 2026 must be surrendered by the applicable deadline in 2027. In an economic assessment, a distinction must therefore be made between the year in which emissions are avoided and the point at which this has a financial effect.
For the WHRS business case, it is first established the reduction in greenhouse gas emissions attributable to lower fuel consumption. The fuels concerned, engine designs and applicable emission factors or other monitoring data are included in this assessment. It is then determined which proportion of this emission reduction falls under EU ETS. For ships within scope, the EU ETS generally covers all relevant emissions from voyages between ports in the European Economic Area (EEA). It generally also covers all relevant emissions during port stays within scope.
For voyages between an EEA port and a port outside the EEA, coverage of 50% of the relevant emissions applies in principle. The applicable exceptions and special provisions must be included in this assessment. The same quantity of fuel saved can therefore yield a different reduction in the emission allowance obligation on different routes. An ORC may, for example, during a long voyage outside the ETS scope, produce substantial electricity and thereby save fuel, without the full fuel saving reducing the number of allowances required.
Once the reduction in the number of allowances required is supported by evidence, its economic value can be determined. The relevant emission allowance price is an important factor in this assessment. This price may change over the economic life. A single fixed price therefore need not be representative of all future years, particularly when the payback period and net present value depend heavily on the ETS benefits.
The company's existing allowance position also plays a role. When fewer emission allowances need to be purchased, this can represent avoided expenditure. When the required allowances have already been purchased, a lower surrender obligation may mean that certain allowances remain available for later use or possible sale. Their economic significance then depends partly on the options for holding or selling the allowances and on the value they represent to the company.
However, the same allowance released by the lower surrender requirement must not, without further substantiation, be included both at both its full avoided purchase cost and its full sale value. The same financial value would thereby be attributed to the WHRS twice. The timing of a benefit also deserves attention. The fuel savings may be realized during the reporting year, while emission allowances are surrendered according to the annual compliance procedure.
An investment calculation based on future cash flows must therefore take account of the expected expenditure and when the lower surrender requirement affects cash flows. For the business case, it is thus determined for each relevant period what quantity of ETS emissions is avoided by the WHRS, how many fewer emission allowances are needed as a result and what economic value this reduction has for the company concerned.
How Does the FuelEU Compliance Balance Change with Lower Energy Use?
FuelEU Maritime sets limits on the annual average greenhouse gas intensity of the energy used on board within the scope of Regulation (EU) 2023/1805. The intensity is expressed in grams of CO2 equivalent per megajoule and calculated according to the prescribed well-to-wake methodology. When a WHRS reduces fuel consumption without changing the relative shares of the energy sources used or their applicable emission factors, the quantity of energy used and the associated greenhouse gas emissions decrease. However, the ratio of emissions to energy then remains the same.
The average greenhouse gas intensity therefore does not automatically change. Nor does an ORC qualify for a general intensity credit for electricity produced from engine heat already available. Nevertheless, lower energy use can affect the FuelEU compliance balance. According to Annex IV to the regulation, the compliance balance for greenhouse gas intensity is calculated from the difference between the permitted and actual intensities, multiplied by the relevant quantity of energy used.
The result may be positive or negative. The sign of the balance indicates whether the calculated average intensity is below or above the applicable limit, while its size also depends on the quantity of energy to which the difference relates. When the actual greenhouse gas intensity is higher than the permitted limit, a negative compliance balance arises. If the WHRS reduces the relevant energy use with all other conditions unchanged, the same negative intensity difference is multiplied by a smaller amount of energy.
As a result, the magnitude of the compliance deficit can fall. However, the ship does not thereby automatically meet the intensity requirement, because the average greenhouse gas intensity remains above the prescribed limit as long as the energy mix or other relevant calculation factors do not change sufficiently.
With a positive compliance balance, the same reduction in energy use works differently. A positive balance arises when the actual greenhouse gas intensity is lower than the permitted limit. When energy use subsequently decreases while the average intensity remains unchanged, the same positive intensity difference is multiplied by a smaller amount of energy. The absolute size of the compliance surplus may therefore become smaller.
This does not mean that the ship's energy efficiency deteriorates. On the contrary, the ship uses less energy and, under the assumed conditions, produces fewer greenhouse gas emissions in total. The smaller positive compliance balance is a consequence of the way in which FuelEU Maritime calculates the magnitude of the surplus. This calculated result must therefore not be confused with a deterioration in technical or operational energy performance.
For the financial assessment, this distinction is important. A smaller negative balance can result in lower compliance costs when less surplus is needed to cover the deficit or a lower penalty is payable. A smaller positive balance, by contrast, may mean that less surplus remains available for future compliance or pooling. Whether this actually has financial consequences depends on how the company can and wishes to use the balance.
The change in the compliance balance is thus an input to the financial appraisal that does not in itself establish a return or cost saving. For this, the expected settlement of the compliance balance must also be assessed.
When Does a Changed FuelEU Compliance Balance Have Financial Value?
The economic significance of a changed FuelEU compliance balance depends on the way in which the ship or responsible company meets the compliance obligations. FuelEU Maritime provides various flexibility mechanisms for this purpose, including banking, borrowing and pooling.
With banking, a compliance surplus can be carried forward to the next reporting period, subject to the applicable conditions. The surplus can then be used for future compliance. With borrowing, a company can, under certain conditions, borrow an advance compliance surplus from the next reporting period. The balance for that next period is reduced as prescribed by the regulation.
Pooling allows the compliance balances of different ships to be combined in a pool under the applicable conditions. Its financial significance may depend on agreements between the companies involved.
When a ship has a negative compliance balance, a WHRS can reduce that deficit. This can have financial value when less surplus is needed from other ships as a result or when the company incurs lower commercial costs under a pooling agreement. However, the actual outcome depends on the agreements made. A smaller individual compliance deficit, for example, does not automatically lead to a correspondingly lower pooling fee when the existing agreement uses a fixed price or another settlement method.
When a negative balance remains after the permitted flexibility mechanisms have been applied, a FuelEU penalty may be payable. A reduction in the deficit may then affect the amount payable. However, the amount of this penalty follows from the specific calculation rules in Annex IV to Regulation (EU) 2023/1805. In this calculation, it is not only the size of the compliance deficit that matters, but also the relevant intensity data and any consequences of consecutive periods of non-compliance.
It is therefore incorrect to multiply every reduction in the magnitude of the compliance balance, without further calculation, by a single arbitrary price per gram of CO2 equivalent. For the business case, it must be established how much the compliance costs actually expected under the conditions examined change.
With a positive compliance balance, the financial question is different. A surplus can have value when it is carried forward to a subsequent period or used within a valid pool. However, FuelEU Maritime does not provide a general guaranteed selling price for positive compliance balances. The commercial value of pooling follows from the agreements between the companies involved and the surplus that is available for use in the pool.
When the WHRS reduces the positive compliance balance through lower energy use, less surplus may remain available for future periods or pooling. That may reduce the economic value of the surplus without causing a direct financial loss. When the surplus is not expected to be used and no sufficiently substantiated commercial value exists, a smaller positive balance need not lead to a corresponding cash outflow.
For a reliable investment calculation, it is therefore not only the difference in the compliance balance that is established. It must also be clear which specific payment obligations, future compliance options or contractual revenues change as a result. Only then can it be determined whether the FuelEU contribution of the WHRS is positive, negative or financially immaterial. The compliance position thus forms a necessary starting point for valuation, but does not by itself determine the financial outcome.
When Can an ORC Also Change the FuelEU Greenhouse Gas Intensity?
An ORC does not automatically reduce the average FuelEU greenhouse gas intensity, but it can, under certain circumstances, indirectly change the mix of energy sources used. This may happen, for example, when the ship uses different fuels and the ORC mainly replaces electricity production from generating sets that run on one specific fuel.
When these generating sets use less fuel, the share of that fuel in total energy use may decrease. If the applicable well-to-wake emission factors differ, the weighted average greenhouse gas intensity can consequently also change. The direction of this effect depends on the energy actually replaced. If the reduction mainly affects fuel with a relatively high greenhouse gas intensity, the intensity of the remaining energy mix may become more favourable.
When, conversely, less energy with a relatively low intensity is used and the share of an energy carrier with a higher intensity consequently increases, the average intensity may, under certain circumstances, become less favourable. The ORC's effect on FuelEU intensity is therefore not automatically positive. The engine configuration may also be relevant. The FuelEU methodology takes account of specific emission data for certain fuels and engine designs.
For gaseous fuels, for example, the treatment of methane emissions and methane slip may depend on the applicable data and the type of fuel-burning equipment. When ORC generation changes which engines are used, it must therefore be established whether this affects the relevant energy mix and emission calculation. However, a changed generator load does not by itself justify changing prescribed emission factors at the operator's discretion. The calculation must be consistent with the data and methods that the regulation permits for the fuels and engine configurations concerned.
Other energy carriers can also affect the average intensity. When, for example, the amount of shore power used remains unchanged while less fuel energy is needed on board, the proportions of the different energy sources may change. The outcome must then be determined according to the specific rules for the energy sources concerned and the geographical and technical scope of FuelEU Maritime.
For the business case, a distinction must therefore be made between two effects. The first is the reduction in the total quantity of energy used, which can affect the size of the compliance balance without the intensity changing. The second effect is a possible change in the weighted average greenhouse gas intensity because the relative shares of the energy sources or other permitted calculation parameters change.
When both effects occur, the average intensity and compliance balance must be recalculated for the revised operating conditions. In doing so, the effect of the changed energy mix must not be assessed separately from the lower quantity of energy. The financial value subsequently arises only when it is clear which compliance costs or options for using the balance are actually affected by these changes.
Who Actually Benefits from Lower ETS and FuelEU Costs?
For the WHRS business case, it is important that the financial benefits accrue to the party bearing the investment or that sufficiently clear agreements exist on this point. After all, the registered shipowner, the company responsible for technical management and the commercial operator need not be the same company. Nor need the party paying for fuel be the one purchasing an ORC installation. When, for example, a shipowner finances the WHRS while a charterer bears the fuel costs, the direct fuel cost savings may accrue mainly to the charterer.
For EU ETS, a further distinction must be made between formal compliance responsibility and the economic allocation of emission costs. The ETS obligation rests with the designated shipping company. This may be the registered shipowner or a company authorized under the applicable rules that is responsible for implementing the International Safety Management Code (ISM). This company remains responsible for surrendering the required emission allowances.
Article 3gc of Directive 2003/87/EC also provides for an entitlement to reimbursement when another party, under the relevant contract, is ultimately responsible for purchasing fuel or for the commercial operation of the ship. For this purpose, operating the ship means determining the cargo carried or the route and speed. The statutory entitlement to reimbursement does not change which company remains responsible for ETS compliance.
For a WHRS investment, this means that a reduced need for emission allowances does not automatically yield an equally large financial saving for the shipowner. When ETS costs are passed on to another party, the economic value of a lower emission allowance obligation may also accrue to a significant extent to that party. The outcome depends on the statutory rules, actual allocation of costs and applicable commercial agreements. A lower formal emission allowance obligation must therefore be distinguished from the cash savings that actually accrue to the investor.
FuelEU Maritime likewise distinguishes between formal compliance responsibility and the contractual allocation of costs. Within this regulatory framework, the responsible company is the entity that has assumed ISM responsibility for the ship. This may be the shipowner, but also another organization. This company remains responsible for FuelEU compliance and payment of any penalties. The regulation leaves room for contractual agreements under which commercial operators or fuel suppliers, under certain conditions, reimburse the company concerned for FuelEU penalties.
The allocation of pooling costs, the commercial value of a positive compliance balance or other agreed benefits may also depend on the contract terms. For the WHRS business case, it must therefore be established who finances the equipment, who pays for maintenance, who bears the fuel costs and which party receives any ETS and FuelEU benefits.
An installation can create economic value for the ship as a whole while the financial benefit to the investing owner remains more limited. Conversely, sufficiently clear agreements on sharing savings or reimbursements can improve the investment position. However, the financial assessment must be based on agreements in force or sufficiently supported by evidence. A theoretical benefit at ship level must not automatically be included as a cash flow for the party financing the WHRS.
How Do You Prevent Double Counting of Fuel, ETS and FuelEU Benefits?
The physical energy savings from a WHRS arise because the ship needs less energy from its other sources. When less fuel is consumed as a result, the fuel saved is a single physical saving. That result can, however, have different financial consequences. The quantity of fuel to be purchased may decrease, while fewer ETS emission allowances may also be needed. In addition, the FuelEU compliance position may change.
The business case may therefore include these distinct financial effects. After all, EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime entail separate statutory obligations that can exist alongside direct fuel costs. However, the same cost reduction must not be valued several times. For this purpose, it must be clear for each cash flow which costs would arise without a WHRS and which proportion is actually avoided by the installation.
For fuel costs, it must therefore be known which components are included in the price used. When the calculation is based, for example, on a contractual fuel price or energy surcharge in which certain emission costs have already been included, it must be established whether a separate ETS benefit may still be counted separately. The contractual settlement of emission allowance costs also requires attention. When a lower ETS obligation already leads to lower cost reimbursement from a charterer, the same reduction cannot, without further assessment, be included again as a full financial benefit for the owner.
The same applies to the company's emission allowance position. When emission allowances already purchased remain available because of a lower surrender obligation, their economic value can be assessed. However, those same allowances must not simultaneously be valued as full purchase costs avoided and as separate full sale proceeds. Both approaches may concern the value of the same allowances.
With FuelEU Maritime, a distinction must above all be made between the compliance balance and its financial settlement. A smaller negative balance may, for example, mean that less surplus is needed from other ships in the pool or that a lower residual FuelEU penalty becomes payable. When the business case already takes account of lower pooling costs for the same deficit, the full theoretical penalty reduction must not automatically be added as well. Pooling and penalty payment may be different ways of settling the same compliance deficit.
The financial calculation must therefore be consistent with the compliance strategy actually expected. With a positive balance, it must likewise be established whether the surplus can actually be used through banking or pooling. A theoretical positive compliance balance does not automatically equal guaranteed sale proceeds. Its commercial value must be distinguished from the size of the balance itself.
The net electricity generation from the ORC must also be accounted for consistently. When electrical auxiliary consumption has already been included in the net energy output, that consumption must not be counted again when estimating fuel savings. Any auxiliary power use or other losses outside the stated system boundary must still be accounted for. Otherwise, the physical savings and hence the financial return may be calculated too favourably.
In this way, a consistent technical basis is established for estimating the fuel actually saved. The direct fuel costs, change in ETS costs and any FuelEU cash flows are then derived separately from it. The aim is not to add together as many theoretical benefits as possible. What matters is which additional financial value the WHRS can actually realize without including the same energy, emission allowances or compliance costs more than once.
How Do ETS and FuelEU Benefits Change over the Service Life?
An investment in waste heat recovery is usually assessed over several years of operation. The financial consequences of EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime may change during this period, even when the technical performance of the WHRS remains comparable. With EU ETS, the price of allowances is a major uncertainty. The market value of emission allowances may change, so that the same quantity of avoided greenhouse gas emissions represents a different financial value in different years.
For the business case, it must therefore be clear which price expectations are used. It must also be investigated how the financial outcome responds if prices differ from the forecast. The operational profile may also change. When the ship carries out a greater proportion of its activities within the ETS scope, a larger share of the total WHRS emission reduction may become relevant to the emission allowance obligation.
When fewer activities fall within that scope, the financial ETS value may, conversely, decrease. The technical fuel savings need not change in the same proportion. Regulatory coverage may also change. For offshore vessels of 5,000 GT and above, for example, an extension of the ETS emission allowance obligation is envisaged from the 2027 emissions year, according to the applicable rules.
The business case must therefore be consistent with the ship type and the years in which the ship is expected to operate. A statutory obligation that only becomes applicable later must not, without further substantiation, already be attributed to earlier operating years.
FuelEU Maritime provides for progressively tighter limits on greenhouse gas intensity. From 2025, a reduction of 2% relative to the reference value of 91.16 g CO₂e/MJ applies. From 2030, this reduction is 6%, after which the required reductions are tightened further in later periods. As a result, a ship's compliance position can change over its economic life. A ship that initially still has a positive compliance balance may, with stricter limits, have a smaller surplus or develop a deficit.
The possible financial value of waste heat recovery may also change as a result. A WHRS that, in a particular year, mainly reduces the size of a positive balance may, under different circumstances in a later year, instead help to reduce a deficit. However, these future financial effects are not automatically fixed. The fuel mix, engine configuration, pooling agreements and commercial operation may also change.
The geographical scope also deserves separate attention. For EU ETS, Norway and Iceland are included in the relevant EEA framework. For FuelEU Maritime, a different situation applies in November 2026, because the regulation has yet to be incorporated into the EEA Agreement for those countries. Norwegian and Icelandic ports are therefore provisionally treated as third-country ports for FuelEU Maritime. The Norwegian Maritime Authority reported in August 2026 that FuelEU Maritime could enter into force in Norway no earlier than 1 January 2028.
As a result, a voyage between, for example, the Netherlands and Norway may have different geographical coverage under the EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime. For the financial assessment, this current situation must be taken into account, while future changes in applicability must be checked again.
The timing of cash flows may also differ. The fuel savings arise during operation, while ETS emission allowances are surrendered according to the annual compliance procedure. FuelEU Maritime likewise has an annual reporting, verification and settlement cycle, with its own deadlines for matters including pooling and any penalty payment. The financial consequences of the two systems therefore need not arise at the same time.
For an investment calculation based on net present value, this difference may be relevant. The timing of avoided expenditure or revenue also affects the present value of that cash flow. The business case must therefore be based on both the expected technical energy savings and the financial and regulatory circumstances throughout the entire economic life.
How Do You Include ETS and FuelEU Effects in the Payback Period and Net Present Value?
The financial assessment begins with the full WHRS investment and the quantity of energy actually saved during operation. The appraisal relates project costs to net generation, the fuel saved and the relevant additional operating and maintenance costs. This starting position forms the basis for assessing the financial contribution of EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime separately. It must first be clear which net financial value the installation can realize from direct energy savings.
It is then determined for each relevant period what quantity of ETS emissions can be avoided by the WHRS. Their value is linked to the applicable geographical coverage, the expected emission allowance price and how the lower surrender requirement affects the company's finances. For FuelEU Maritime, it is established separately how lower energy use and any change in the fuel mix affect the compliance balance.
It is then determined whether this change leads to lower expected compliance expenditure, a different pooling fee or a sufficiently substantiated change in the value of available compliance capacity. A smaller negative balance must not automatically be treated as a proportionate reduction in the FuelEU penalty. When pooling is expected, the financial valuation must be consistent with the agreements concerned.
When a residual penalty is likely, the possible reduction is determined according to the applicable penalty calculation. The chosen financial treatment must therefore suit the compliance strategy actually expected. The contractual allocation of costs and savings must also be known. A saving that arises for the commercial operator cannot automatically be included as a cash flow for the owner when the owner finances the WHRS.
The financial effects determined in this way are then combined with the original fuel savings and the additional operating costs. When the ETS and FuelEU benefits actually accrue to the investor, they can increase the annual net cash flows. This can shorten the simple payback period. The size of the effect depends on the full investment, the size of the annual net savings and the point at which the financial benefits are realized.
However, a simple payback period does not take account of the time value of money. Important future maintenance costs or changes in the compliance position may also be missed as a result. The net present value can therefore provide a more complete picture. With this method, expected future cash flows are discounted to present value at an appropriate rate.
The direct fuel savings, avoided ETS costs, any FuelEU cash flows and additional operating costs are, in this calculation, accounted for on a consistent basis. The full investment expenditure must also be included according to the same financial principles. The ship's remaining economic life matters to this calculation. A financial benefit that arises only after the expected sale or withdrawal from service cannot, without further substantiation, be attributed in full to the current investor.
When the regulatory benefits are uncertain, the appraisal must make that uncertainty explicit. A WHRS may, for example, already be economically attractive on the basis of direct fuel savings. In that case, avoided ETS costs and possible FuelEU benefits constitute additional financial value. The situation is different when the net present value only becomes positive with high future ETS prices or pooling fees that have not yet been agreed. The investment is then more dependent on external market and compliance circumstances.
The net present value shows how much these cash flows contribute to the expected financial outcome, but does not prove that all projected benefits will actually arise. The underlying assumptions therefore remain important for interpreting the result. The direct energy savings and additional regulatory value must remain separately identifiable within the financial assessment. In this way, it becomes clear which value the WHRS derives independently from lower energy use and which proportion depends on future emission and compliance costs.
Which Scenarios Reliably Show the Financial Contribution of EU ETS and FuelEU?
A reliable WHRS business case considers more than one forecast of future allowance prices and FuelEU compliance costs. The financial outcome may change because of market prices, compliance balances, operational profiles, fuel choice and the contractual allocation of costs. These factors must therefore be assessed in a sensitivity analysis. The starting point is the expected net energy production of the WHRS under the relevant operating conditions.
Engine load, available waste heat, cooling conditions, the system's own auxiliary consumption and the electricity that can actually be used are included together in this assessment. It is then established how much fuel is actually avoided by this electricity production. These fuel savings form the technical basis for the subsequent financial scenarios. The amount of fuel saved should change only if new technical evidence supports it. A different allowance price or compliance value alone does not justify changing the fuel estimate.
It is first assessed which cash flows arise from avoided fuel costs, without assuming additional regulatory benefits. In this way, it becomes visible which financial value the installation can realize directly from ship operation. The sufficiently substantiated ETS effects can then be added. In doing so, it is investigated how the value changes under different assumptions about emission allowance prices and the proportion of operation that falls under EU ETS.
A higher ETS price does not change the technical fuel savings, but it can increase the value of the reduction in allowances required. A different operating area, by contrast, can change which proportion of the total emission reduction falls within the ETS scope.
For FuelEU Maritime, the expected compliance position matters most. With a negative balance, it is investigated whether a smaller deficit leads to lower pooling costs, a lower residual penalty or another sufficiently substantiated financial saving. With a positive balance, it is assessed whether a smaller surplus actually has consequences for future compliance or commercial pooling agreements. A smaller positive compliance balance is, in this assessment, not automatically treated as a direct financial disadvantage.
Further tightening of the intensity limits can also be included in the scenarios. After all, a ship may have a different compliance position during a future period than in the first year in which the WHRS is used.
The fuel mix is also an important variable. When a ship switches to another fuel during its economic life, the direct fuel costs, ETS emissions and FuelEU intensity may change. The financial value of the same quantity of net ORC electricity may consequently also differ. With such a change, it must also be assessed whether the available waste heat and technical ORC performance remain sufficiently comparable.
The contractual allocation of costs and savings is a separate uncertainty. A financial benefit for the ship as a whole only has the corresponding value for the investing party when that party actually receives the benefit or can use it through a sufficiently substantiated agreement. The cash flows must therefore be consistent with the expected operating and charter agreements. A theoretical reduction in emission or compliance costs must not automatically be attributed to the wrong party.
The number of suitable WHRS operating hours may also change. When less waste heat is available, net electricity generation can decrease, reducing both fuel savings and the ETS emissions avoided. For FuelEU Maritime, the relevant quantity of energy used may change at the same time, with possible consequences for the average intensity and compliance balance. These effects must be assessed on the basis of the same changed ship configuration.
The scenarios must therefore remain technically and financially coherent. A lower engine load must not, for example, be combined with the original maximum ORC output without substantiation. Nor must an avoided FuelEU penalty and an avoided pooling fee for the same compliance deficit automatically be added together as two independent benefits. The calculation must be consistent with the way in which the deficit concerned would actually be settled.
The sensitivity analysis must above all show how much the additional regulatory value contributes to the investment and which assumptions are most important for this. When the WHRS offers sufficient financial prospects even without ETS and FuelEU benefits, the economic basis is less dependent on future changes in these rules and costs.
When the investment only becomes attractive with high future ETS prices or favourable FuelEU pooling agreements, the substantiation of these cash flows requires extra attention. The results are then assessed over the remaining economic life and according to the investor's financial criteria. In this way, it becomes visible whether the direct fuel savings offer sufficient value and to what extent the expected regulatory benefits affect the investment outcome.
When Are EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime Truly Valuable to the WHRS Business Case?
EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime can increase the financial value of waste heat recovery, but only insofar as the installation demonstrably changes the relevant obligations and costs. Under EU ETS, a possible benefit arises when the WHRS saves fuel and thereby reduces the emissions for which allowances must be surrendered. The financial value depends on the quantity of avoided emissions within scope, the relevant emission allowance price and the party that actually bears the costs.
Under FuelEU Maritime, the situation is different. With an unchanged energy mix, lower energy use may leave the average greenhouse gas intensity unchanged, while changing the magnitude of the compliance balance. With a negative compliance balance, a WHRS can reduce the deficit. This can have financial value when less pooling capacity is needed as a result or a lower residual FuelEU penalty arises.
With a positive balance, the same energy savings may instead reduce the size of the available surplus. However, any possible financial disadvantage must be based on the actual opportunities for banking or pooling, not on an assumed guaranteed selling price.
The financial consequences of the two systems are therefore not directly comparable. EU ETS links avoided emissions to a lower emission allowance obligation, while FuelEU Maritime connects energy use with the average greenhouse gas intensity and the size of the compliance balance. The actual compliance strategy then determines which financial consequences arise from this FuelEU calculation. The same change in the balance may therefore have a different economic significance for different companies.
For a sound investment decision, the net energy output of the WHRS is first established and used to determine how much fuel is actually saved. The relevant auxiliary loads, changed engine load and any additional system losses must be sufficiently accounted for in this assessment. The direct fuel costs, possible ETS benefits and separate FuelEU effects are then calculated for each relevant period. The geographical scope, applicable emissions accounting rules and contractual allocation of costs remain decisive in this assessment.
It must also remain clear which benefits are sufficiently certain, which depend on future market prices or compliance agreements and which cash flows actually accrue to the investing party. The different financial consequences of the same energy savings may be included when they arise separately. In doing so, however, it must be ensured that fuel costs, emission allowances or compliance balances are not valued several times as the same benefit.
The sufficiently substantiated ETS and FuelEU effects can then be included in the payback period and net present value of the full WHRS investment. Additional operating costs, possible changes in the compliance position and the remaining economic life are also included in this assessment.
Economic attractiveness is therefore not determined solely by the number of kilowatt-hours the installation produces or the quantity of greenhouse gases it helps to avoid. What matters is which direct energy costs and additional compliance costs are actually saved during the economic life and to what extent these benefits are available to the party financing the investment.
By separately establishing the technical fuel savings, statutory obligations and actual cash flows, it becomes clear how much EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime actually contribute to the business case for waste heat recovery. On this basis, it can also be assessed whether the investment independently generates sufficient financial value or remains substantially dependent on future emission allowance prices and FuelEU compliance agreements.
This Article Within the Series
Avoided fuel does not automatically have the same financial value under EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime. Whether these benefits outweigh the investment also depends on the sensitivity to fewer operating hours and higher installation costs. When engine heat is already put to good use, the calculation of additional savings with existing heat use also requires attention. After all, not every new extraction of heat yields additional fuel savings. This relationship between energy use, compliance costs and investment is central to the business case and investment decision for WHRS installations.