How Is the Contribution of Waste Heat Recovery to CII Tracked in the SEEMP?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
The contribution of waste heat recovery to the Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) is tracked within the Ship Energy Efficiency Management Plan (SEEMP) by linking the energy actually recovered to the ship's fuel consumption and operational energy performance. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can, for example, use heat from exhaust gases or engine cooling water to generate electricity. In a system based on the Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), this electricity can reduce the load on existing generating sets, which may reduce fuel consumption.
However, net electricity generation is not included as a separate deduction in the annual CII calculation. In principle, the contribution is reflected in the fuel consumption recorded under the applicable IMO rules and the resulting CO2 emissions calculated for the ship. The SEEMP can document how the WHRS is operated, which aspects of energy performance are monitored and how the results are used to assess the effectiveness of the measure. Measured net electricity generation, separately determined fuel savings and the official annual CII remain distinct quantities.
For ships to which SEEMP Part III applies, waste heat recovery may form part of the three-year CII implementation plan. Monitoring then shows whether the installation actually delivers the expected energy savings and what contribution this measure can make to the ship's overall energy balance.
How Does Waste Heat Recovery Affect Operational CII?
The CII assesses the annual operational carbon intensity of ships to which the relevant requirements apply. The calculation links CO2 emissions determined using the IMO methodology to a prescribed measure of transport work over a calendar year. In the usual method, CO2 emissions are calculated from recorded fuel consumption and the applicable CO2 conversion factors. The calculation includes fuel used for propulsion and by other relevant equipment on board.
For transport work, the existing CII methodology uses a prescribed proxy based on ship capacity and total distance travelled. Depending on the ship type, deadweight in tonnes or gross tonnage is used, for example. The 2026 amendments to the CII calculation guidelines clarify that total distance travelled refers to the distance travelled during the calendar year, including distance covered both while recorded as under way and at other times. The cargo actually carried therefore does not automatically form the denominator of the existing official CII calculation.
The attained annual CII is then compared with the required CII and the applicable boundaries for ratings A to E. The result thus provides an assessment of the operational carbon intensity of the whole ship under the prescribed method.
Waste heat recovery can affect this result because some of the energy required is supplied from heat already released during engine operation. When an ORC supplies electricity to the shipboard electrical system, an existing generating set may need to produce less electrical power. That engine's fuel consumption may consequently decrease. If the fuel savings are realised, the CO2 emissions calculated using the CII methodology may also be lower. With the other CII data unchanged, a more favourable attained annual CII may result.
This treatment differs from the technical energy efficiency indices EEDI and EEXI. For those indices, an effective electrical power contribution may be included under the applicable conditions using a prescribed calculation method. For operational CII, a separate WHRS power value is not deducted from the result in the same way. The potential improvement arises through actual fuel consumption and the other data used in the annual CII calculation.
The fuel consumption characteristics of the generating sets concerned must be taken into account. A reduction in generator output does not necessarily lead to a proportional fall in fuel consumption, because specific fuel consumption also depends on engine load. The WHRS may also affect fuel consumption in other ways. An exhaust gas heat exchanger may, for example, affect exhaust back pressure, while pumps and other auxiliary equipment consume electricity. These effects may alter the final net fuel savings.
Annual CII also depends on more than the presence or performance of an ORC. Total propulsion fuel consumption, the fuels used, distance travelled and any permitted corrections or voyage adjustments also affect the calculated value. A WHRS can therefore demonstrably help save fuel without necessarily securing a particular annual CII rating. For the assessment, the technical contribution of the recovery system must be distinguished from changes in the CII of the whole ship.
What Place Does Waste Heat Recovery Have Within the SEEMP?
The SEEMP is the ship-specific plan through which energy efficiency and operational carbon intensity are managed. The obligations are set out in MARPOL Annex VI, while the International Maritime Organization (IMO) has established additional guidelines for developing, implementing and assessing the plan. The applicable guidance is the 2024 Guidelines for the Development of a Ship Energy Efficiency Management Plan, adopted by resolution MEPC.395(82), as amended by MEPC.401(83) and MEPC.413(84). The consolidated version is published as MEPC.1/Circ.925.
The SEEMP consists of three parts with different functions. The scope of application varies by part. SEEMP Part I focuses on improving energy efficiency during operation. For ships of 400 GT and above to which the relevant MARPOL provisions apply, this part provides a framework for planning, implementing, monitoring and evaluating energy-saving measures. A WHRS can be included as a measure to reduce the load on existing generators or thermal systems. Whether the recovered energy actually makes a useful contribution can be monitored.
SEEMP Part II describes the method by which the prescribed fuel consumption data and other relevant data for the IMO Data Collection System (DCS) are collected and reported. This part applies, within the relevant scope, to ships of 5,000 GT and above. The DCS data form an important basis for the annual CII calculation, but serve a different purpose from the separate technical monitoring of an ORC. Recording net ORC electricity generation therefore does not replace the prescribed collection of data on the ship's fuel consumption.
SEEMP Part III sets out how ships of the designated types at 5,000 GT and above are to achieve the required operational CII. It describes, among other things, the calculation method, the required CII for the next three years, the planned measures and the procedure for self-evaluation and improvement. Not every ship with a WHRS therefore automatically falls within the operational CII requirements. For a ship to which SEEMP Part III does apply, waste heat recovery may be part of the three-year implementation plan.
Simply stating that an ORC installation is present is insufficient. What matters is the role of the recovered electricity within the energy supply and how it is expected to reduce fuel consumption and operational carbon intensity. Technical monitoring of the WHRS can provide additional information for this purpose. The effectiveness of the measure can thus be assessed, while the official annual CII is determined separately on the basis of the prescribed ship data.
How Do You Document a WHRS as a CII Measure in SEEMP Part III?
When waste heat recovery is part of the CII improvement plan, it must be clear which measure is being implemented, when it is available and how its expected contribution to energy efficiency is assessed. A general statement that the ship has an ORC installation does not provide sufficient information for this purpose. The presence of the installation does not in itself show how much usable electricity is produced over the actual operational and load profile.
The description therefore starts with the heat sources used for recovery. The description identifies which engines supply heat and the operating conditions in which the WHRS is expected to work. It then explains how the recovered energy is used on board. For electricity generation, this may mean that the ORC takes over part of the electrical load from existing generating sets.
The expected contribution must correspond to the periods when there is enough usable waste heat, cooling capacity and electrical demand at the same time. An ORC that delivers sufficient electrical power at a particular propulsion load may deliver a different output during manoeuvring, port operations or prolonged part-load operation. The technical substantiation can therefore be based on expected net electricity generation over a representative operating profile. It must be clear which auxiliary loads are already accounted for in the net figure.
Periods with insufficient heat supply, start-up, maintenance and any electrical output limits also affect annual output. Expected electricity production must therefore be based on the operating hours during which the installation can actually deliver useful energy. Expected fuel savings are then determined separately. For this purpose, it must be established which generating sets will supply less electricity as a result of WHRS generation and how the fuel consumption of the engines concerned changes under the altered load.
This fuel analysis forms the link between the technical performance of the WHRS and its possible contribution to future CII. Net electricity generation is an important starting point, but is not automatically equivalent to a particular quantity of fuel saved. The guidelines for SEEMP Part III call for a ship-specific three-year implementation plan that is sufficiently specific, measurable and practicable. The plan sets out how the measures will be implemented, their expected combined effect on CII, who is responsible and what obstacles may arise.
For a WHRS, the availability of the installation and the date of entry into service also matter. When a new ORC becomes operational partway through a calendar year, the expected savings must not be treated without further substantiation as though the installation had produced electricity throughout the year. It must also be clear who is responsible for implementation and monitoring. The engineering crew may, for example, record the operating data, while a responsible shore-based department uses the results for energy management and SEEMP evaluation.
The precise allocation of responsibilities must fit the existing organization and the ship's safety and management system. It must also be known how the results are assessed and what can be done if performance falls short of expectations. Possible technical and operational obstacles also merit attention. A persistently lower engine load may reduce the available waste heat, while insufficient cooling capacity, low electrical demand or temporary technical downtime may limit expected electricity production.
The implementation plan must therefore state more than just expected savings. The conditions on which this expectation depends must also be sufficiently clear for the measure to be assessed during operation.
Which WHRS Performance Data Are Needed for Monitoring?
To track waste heat recovery within the SEEMP, it must be clear how much energy the installation actually delivers to the ship. For electricity generation with an ORC, net electrical energy is an important starting point. The generator produces gross electrical power, but the WHRS also consumes electricity for its own operation. Depending on the design, the working-fluid pump, intermediate-circuit pumps, additional cooling equipment and electrical conversion equipment may be relevant, among other components.
For a reliable net value, it must therefore be established which energy flows fall within the selected system boundary. Gross generator output alone is insufficient to determine the electrical contribution of the complete installation to the ship. When a supplier already states a net module power, it must be known which auxiliary loads the figure already accounts for. This consumption must not be deducted again, while necessary additional equipment outside the module must be included.
Existing ship systems that also serve the WHRS may also be relevant. When an existing cooling-water pump uses more electricity because of the WHRS, that additional load may reduce the net electrical contribution to the ship. Alongside net power in kilowatts, the electrical energy actually delivered in kilowatt-hours is particularly important. This indicates how much electricity was supplied during the period under consideration.
For the annual assessment, the energy data are linked to operating hours and the periods when the WHRS actually functions. An ORC may deliver sufficient power during stable operation yet make a limited contribution over the year if the engines concerned run infrequently or the installation is regularly out of service. Start-up periods, downtime, maintenance, curtailment and other output limits can therefore also be recorded. This information helps distinguish inadequate technical performance from fewer generating hours due to the way the ship is operated.
Conditions at the heat source must also be sufficiently well known. For exhaust gas heat, gas temperature and mass flow rate may change with engine load. For recovery from engine cooling water, the available temperatures, coolant circulation and limits on heat extraction govern performance. When an engine makes less suitable waste heat available, the ORC may produce less electricity without its technical condition having deteriorated. Lower production therefore does not automatically indicate a need for maintenance or a defect.
The same applies to the cold side. Warmer cooling water may change the condensing conditions, leaving less electrical power available. The cooling capacity available in the operating mode concerned may also affect performance. The shipboard electrical system may also limit electricity production. When electrical demand is too low or running generating sets must remain within their permitted operating range, the power management system may reduce ORC output.
A reliable performance overview therefore links net electricity generation to the relevant engine load, heat source conditions, cooling-water temperatures and operating status. This helps explain why output varies between operating periods. Not every internal process quantity needs to be included separately in SEEMP Part III. Above all, the plan must make clear how the effectiveness of the WHRS measure is monitored and which data are used for this purpose.
Detailed technical records can remain part of the existing onboard monitoring or energy management system. They constitute additional monitoring information and must not, without further grounds, be presented as separate mandatory reporting fields for the official annual CII.
How Is Net WHRS Electricity Translated into Avoided Fuel Consumption?
Net electricity generation from a WHRS is not automatically equivalent to the amount of fuel the ship saves as a result. To determine the savings, it must be established which existing generation is displaced by the recovered electricity. When an ORC supplies electricity to the shipboard electrical system, one or more generating sets may need to produce less electrical power. The fuel savings then follow from the difference between fuel consumption at the original generator load and at the new load.
The fuel consumption characteristics of the engines concerned must be taken into account. The fuel consumption of a generating set does not necessarily change in proportion to the electrical power delivered. It is therefore insufficient to multiply the recorded WHRS kilowatt-hours by a single generic fuel savings factor without further assessment. The calculation must correspond to the generating sets and the operating conditions in which the electricity is actually delivered.
The electrical operating strategy also affects the result. When several generating sets continue running in parallel, the WHRS electricity may reduce the individual engine loads. With a different operating strategy, it may be possible to shut down one generating set entirely. These situations may yield different fuel savings. The necessary power reserve and safe operation of the shipboard electrical system must be maintained.
A generating set must therefore not be shut down solely to increase the calculated WHRS savings when the electrical operating arrangements do not provide sufficient scope for this. Engine dispatch must meet reliability requirements and account for the reserve available. A particular interaction arises when the ORC uses heat from the same generating sets whose loads are reduced by the ORC's output. The lower engine load may change the exhaust gas and cooling-water heat, potentially also leaving less heat available for the ORC.
Electricity production and fuel consumption must then be assessed at the engine load that results from using the WHRS. A calculation based solely on the heat supply before the generating sets were unloaded may otherwise overestimate the savings. The effect on other ship systems may also be relevant. An exhaust gas heat exchanger may, for example, cause additional back pressure, so that under certain conditions the engine needs more fuel than without the extra flow resistance.
When the WHRS uses heat that was already being used for another purpose, it must also be established how the original heat demand is then met. If additional fuel-fired heating is needed for this purpose, the net fuel savings may decrease. The same energy benefit must therefore not be counted in full simultaneously as a replacement for existing heat production and as a replacement for electricity production. The available heat and the different useful applications must be assessed within one consistent energy balance.
The WHRS's own electricity consumption must also be accounted for correctly. Auxiliary electricity consumption already deducted from gross generation to determine net electricity generation must not be counted again as the same loss. From these data, the amount of fuel saved can be determined. When the savings are attributed to a particular fuel type, the applicable factor can then be used to calculate the corresponding reduction in CO2 emissions.
However, the reliability of the result depends on the baseline without the WHRS. That case is not always directly measurable during normal operation with heat recovery enabled. When fuel savings are therefore estimated using a model or comparison, it must be clear which data have actually been measured and which results follow from assumptions or calculations. The separate fuel savings thus remain sufficiently traceable.
Such an analysis can substantiate the WHRS's contribution to energy efficiency. However, the calculated savings do not constitute a separate deduction automatically applied to the official annual CII.
How Do WHRS Data Relate to the IMO DCS and Annual CII?
The official annual CII is determined from data collected and reported under MARPOL Annex VI and the applicable IMO guidelines. The IMO Data Collection System provides key inputs, including annual fuel consumption, distance travelled and other prescribed ship data. SEEMP Part II describes how these data are collected, checked and reported. Supplementary WHRS monitoring serves a different purpose and must therefore remain clearly separate from official data collection.
Net ORC generation records show how much electrical energy was recovered from waste heat. It can thus be assessed whether the installation makes the expected contribution and which existing generation it may displace. However, the official CII calculation does not automatically deduct these recorded kilowatt-hours as a separate saving. When the WHRS actually helps save fuel, this is in principle reflected in the fuel consumption reported under the applicable rules.
The official fuel data and supplementary WHRS performance data must therefore remain separately identifiable. Electricity measurements help explain changes in energy use, but do not replace the prescribed fuel records. Data collection within the IMO DCS has also been expanded to include a more detailed breakdown of fuel use by equipment type and additional operating data. A distinction can be made, among other things, between fuel consumption by main engines, auxiliary engines, boilers and other consumers.
This breakdown may be valuable for internal analysis, for example when the WHRS mainly reduces the load on auxiliary engines supplying electricity. This can help establish how changes in generator dispatch relate to recorded ORC output. However, the measurement and calculation methods used must correspond to the data collection plan in SEEMP Part II. When fuel consumption by a particular item of equipment cannot be measured directly and separately, the alternative methods permitted for it must be applied correctly.
Technical ORC monitoring thus provides additional information about possible causes of lower fuel consumption. It does not replace the prescribed data collection for the IMO DCS.
Distance records must also comply with the applicable CII guidelines. The resolution adopted in May 2026, MEPC.412(84), clarifies that the existing CII calculation continues to use a proxy for transport work based on ship capacity and total distance travelled. Under the amended guideline, this total distance includes both the distance travelled during periods when the ship is recorded as under way and the distance actually travelled during other periods.
Resolution MEPC.413(84) amends the SEEMP guidelines to reflect this clarification. The reporting distinguishes total distance from distance travelled by operating status. This does not mean that the cargo actually carried automatically replaces the existing official CII denominator. The IMO has made the more detailed data on actual transport work available in part for further analysis of the CII methodology.
For the applicable annual calculation, the prescribed capacity measure and total distance remain determining factors, alongside any permitted corrections or voyage adjustments. The fuels used and their associated conversion factors must also be accounted for under the applicable rules. Annual CII thus remains an assessment of the whole ship. The value is not determined by looking solely at the ORC's electrical performance.
The official CII data and supplementary WHRS measurements must therefore be sufficiently consistent with one another to support an explanation of the energy savings. The different reporting purposes must not be confused, and a permitted CII correction must not be replaced by an arbitrary deduction for WHRS electricity.
How Do You Assess Whether the WHRS Actually Contributes to a Better CII?
A more favourable annual CII after installation of a WHRS does not automatically mean that the entire improvement was caused by waste heat recovery. The CII depends, after all, on total fuel consumption, distance travelled and the applicable ship data. Changes in operation may therefore affect the annual result even when the ORC's technical performance remains the same. When, for example, a ship starts operating at a different speed after installation of the WHRS, propulsion fuel consumption may change.
Different routes, weather conditions, waiting times and changes in engine dispatch may also affect annual energy performance. Changes in CII must therefore be assessed in relation to the conditions in which the ship actually operated. Other energy-saving measures may also have been implemented. When these are applied at the same time as the WHRS, the entire reduction in fuel consumption must not be attributed to recovery without further substantiation.
For a separate assessment, it is therefore first established how much net electricity the WHRS actually delivered and which existing generation it displaced. It is then investigated how much fuel would have been needed without this contribution under sufficiently comparable conditions. Differences in electrical load, engine dispatch or other operating conditions must be accounted for to avoid distorting the estimate. A calculation based on ORC electricity and the fuel consumption characteristics of the generating sets concerned may be useful for this purpose.
The reliability of this calculation depends on the available measurement data and the extent to which the reference case without the WHRS can be adequately established. When that case has not been measured directly, the separate fuel savings remain a calculated result. This distinction must remain visible in the internal SEEMP evaluation.
The technical condition of the ORC must also be assessed separately. An installation that delivers less electricity than expected under comparable heat source and cooling conditions may need maintenance or further technical checks. By contrast, when the ORC produces less electricity because the engines concerned make less suitable waste heat available, its technical condition may still be unchanged. The lower production may then be a normal consequence of the changed engine load.
Electrical demand may also limit output. When electrical demand on board is low, the power management system may reduce WHRS output. These causes call for different follow-up steps within the SEEMP. A technical deviation may call for maintenance, whereas a lasting change in the operational profile may mean that the original production and savings forecasts must be revised.
Interaction with other energy-saving technologies also merits attention. An improvement to the hull or propulsion may, for example, reduce the required engine power, causing the main propulsion engine to release less waste heat. The WHRS may consequently produce less electricity while the ship's total fuel consumption still falls. In that case, a lower ORC output does not automatically mean that overall energy efficiency is deteriorating.
The separate savings forecasts must therefore not simply be added together. The combined result must relate to the actual configuration and operating conditions under which the measures work together. A distinction thus remains between the technical contribution of the WHRS and changes in annual CII. An ORC can function as expected while the CII becomes less favourable because of other conditions.
Conversely, the CII may improve while the WHRS delivers less electricity than originally anticipated. Annual CII alone is therefore not a sufficient measure of the technical effectiveness of the waste heat recovery system.
How Is the WHRS Contribution Used in the Three-Year CII Implementation Plan?
For the ships concerned, SEEMP Part III contains a three-year implementation plan setting out the measures for achieving the required annual CII. A WHRS may be included when the installation is expected to help reduce fuel consumption and operational carbon intensity. The technical substantiation starts with the net electricity that the WHRS can deliver during the relevant operating modes. The available heat supply, engine load, cooling and electrical demand are assessed together.
It is then established which generating sets can supply less electricity as a result and how much fuel may be saved under the expected conditions. These savings can be linked to the fuel types used and the associated CO2 conversion factors. This provides a basis for estimating the potential effect on operational carbon intensity. This contribution must then be assessed in relation to the other measures and the ship's expected operation.
The required CII also changes over time. Under resolution MEPC.400(83), further reduction factors have been established for 2027 to 2030. A WHRS that contributed sufficiently to a favourable rating in an earlier year therefore does not guarantee that the same energy performance will remain sufficient in later years.
When the installation is already on board, historical operating data can help determine its future contribution more realistically. Recorded net electricity generation, operating hours, availability and reasons for any output limits show what may be expected under comparable operating conditions. When the WHRS has yet to be installed, its expected contribution depends in part on the planned entry into service and the technical performance data on which the calculation is based.
An ORC delivered partway through the second year of the implementation period must not, for example, be credited with the same savings for the full three-year period without additional assumptions. Expected operating hours must reflect the actual schedule. Possible obstacles must also be included in the implementation plan. A changed engine load may make less waste heat available, while insufficient cooling capacity may limit electricity production.
Maintenance, faults and low electrical demand may also reduce the hours in which useful output can be delivered. The plan must therefore make sufficiently clear how such constraints are managed and what effects they may have on the expected CII contribution. Combinations with other energy-saving measures also require attention. Changes in ship speed, engine dispatch or the technology used may change both total fuel consumption and the amount of available waste heat.
The CII forecast must therefore be based on the combined effect of the measures. Simply adding individual savings percentages determined under different conditions provides insufficient certainty for this purpose. Monitoring throughout the year then shows the extent to which the expected WHRS contribution is actually achieved. The results can be used to align the implementation plan more closely with the ship's current operation.
What Role Does WHRS Monitoring Play in the Annual SEEMP Evaluation?
The SEEMP is intended as an ongoing energy management tool. The effectiveness of a measure is therefore not assessed solely at installation or during preparation of the three-year plan. The guidelines provide for monitoring and periodic self-evaluation. The review examines whether the measures implemented contribute to the intended improvement in energy efficiency and operational carbon intensity.
For waste heat recovery, this evaluation starts with the recorded technical performance. The review examines how much net electricity the ORC delivered during the period and under what operating conditions. The number of operating hours is also important. When the engines concerned have run for fewer hours than expected, the WHRS may have produced less energy without any deterioration in the system's technical performance.
When the ORC delivers less electricity than could be expected under the relevant conditions, the cause must be investigated. A lower heat supply may, for example, be associated with a different engine load or a change in generator dispatch. A higher cooling-water temperature may also change condenser conditions and thus electricity production. Maintenance, fouling, faults or electrical output limits may also affect availability and net energy output.
The cause determines which next step is appropriate. When the available heat supply has persistently decreased because of a changed operational profile, it may be necessary to revise the original annual forecast. When, instead, fouling or abnormal control behaviour limits electricity production, maintenance or further technical investigation may be needed. The aim is then to restore operation within the installation's expected operating range.
It may also become apparent that the ORC produces sufficient electricity while the expected fuel savings are not fully achieved. This may happen, for example, when the generating sets operate less efficiently at the new load than assumed. Another possibility is that the electrical operating strategy provides insufficient scope to shut down a running generating set. Electricity production by the WHRS does not then necessarily lead to the same fuel savings as originally calculated.
The SEEMP evaluation must therefore go beyond comparing measured ORC kilowatt-hours with an original target value. What matters is whether recovery makes the intended contribution to the ship's energy supply and fuel consumption. The results are then linked to changes in annual CII. It must remain clear which part of the assessment is based on measured energy data, which fuel savings have been calculated and which operating conditions have affected the official CII.
The measures in the three-year implementation plan are also evaluated periodically. When the expected results are not achieved, the original assumptions can be adjusted or additional measures may be needed. This self-evaluation does not need to wait until the ship receives an unfavourable CII rating. The available operating data can already be used during operation to improve the way the WHRS is operated and adjust subsequent energy planning.
The SEEMP thus remains based on the ship's actual performance and operating conditions, rather than solely on expectations from the original design or investment phase.
What Happens When the CII Does Not Improve Sufficiently Despite the WHRS?
A waste heat recovery system may perform well and help save fuel while the ship still receives an unfavourable annual CII rating. Operational CII, after all, assesses the performance of the whole ship. Propulsion, distance travelled, fuel choice and other operating conditions also affect the final value. The required CII may also become more stringent in later years, so that the same operational energy performance may lead to a different rating.
The annual rating is determined on a scale from A to E under the applicable IMO methodology. When a ship receives a D rating for three consecutive years or an E rating for one year, a plan of corrective action must be included in the SEEMP under MARPOL Annex VI. The revised SEEMP must then be submitted for verification to the Administration or an organization authorized by it. Under the SEEMP guidelines, this takes place no later than one month after reporting the attained annual CII.
The corrective action plan must be ship-specific and describe the measures to be taken to achieve the required CII. The causes of the unfavourable rating, the effectiveness of existing measures and the expected effects of additional actions must be assessed. The plan must also clearly record who is responsible, the implementation deadlines and any possible obstacles. The proposed measures must be technically and operationally practicable.
A WHRS may form part of such a corrective action plan, but only when opportunities actually exist to improve its contribution further. When the installation already uses almost all technically usable waste heat, it cannot be assumed without substantiation that a different setting will yield substantially more electricity. The ORC may also depend on engine loads that rarely occur during operation. In that case, a higher annual output cannot simply be achieved by switching on the installation more often.
Technical monitoring helps establish whether opportunities for improvement exist. When fouling, faults or insufficient availability limit production, restoring the original performance may be an appropriate measure. By contrast, when the heat source persistently delivers less energy, there may be little scope to improve ORC output without additional changes to the installation or operation. The cause of the lower output determines which measures are technically useful.
Generator dispatch can also be reviewed, provided that the necessary reserve and safe operation of the shipboard electrical system are maintained. A different generator combination must not be selected solely to increase the calculated savings if this would undermine operational reliability. When further WHRS optimization offers insufficient scope, other suitable measures within the ship's overall energy management must be assessed.
A corrective action plan must therefore not rely on additional ORC savings that would be achievable only under unrealistic heat, cooling or operating conditions. The measures must correspond to the ship's actual use. The aim is practicable improvements through which the required annual CII can be achieved under the applicable rules, not a theoretical increase in WHRS output without sufficient operational substantiation.
How Do You Use WHRS Results to Improve the SEEMP?
The contribution of waste heat recovery to CII is tracked within the SEEMP by linking the WHRS's technical performance to fuel consumption and changes in the ship's operational carbon intensity. It is first established how much net electricity the installation actually delivered during the relevant operating periods. Engine load, heat source conditions, cooling, electrical demand and any downtime are included so that production can be assessed correctly.
It is then investigated which existing generation this electricity displaced and how much fuel has consequently been saved under sufficiently comparable conditions. A distinction must remain between directly measured electricity and fuel savings calculated from engine fuel consumption data and a reference case without the WHRS.
The official annual CII is determined separately under the applicable IMO methodology, using the prescribed fuel and distance data and any permitted corrections. Recorded WHRS electricity is therefore not deducted from the CII as a separate item.
Within the SEEMP evaluation, the results are then compared with the expectations in the implementation plan. When the installation has produced less electricity than anticipated, it must be established whether this results from technical constraints, maintenance, electrical output limits or changed operating conditions. It may also become apparent that the WHRS functions as expected while annual CII does not improve sufficiently. In that case, it must be investigated which other aspects of the ship's energy use and operation explain the result.
The results may warrant changing how the ORC is operated, carry out targeted maintenance, reassess expected fuel savings or include additional measures in the SEEMP. Waste heat recovery is thus not mentioned solely as an installed technology. It becomes a measure whose implementation, performance and effectiveness are monitored throughout operation.
The key distinction remains that measured net ORC generation shows how much electricity has been made available, the separate fuel analysis determines which savings can be attributed to it, and annual CII assesses the operational carbon intensity of the whole ship.
By recording these data separately and evaluating them together, the SEEMP can provide a substantiated account of the contribution waste heat recovery actually makes. At the same time, it becomes clear which further improvements are technically and operationally useful for improving the ship's energy performance and operational carbon intensity.
This Article Within the Series
Whereas the treatment of WHRS electricity in EEDI and EEXI calculations is based on prescribed technical reference conditions, the CII tracks operational carbon intensity based on recorded fuel consumption, among other data. Those same fuel savings do not automatically have the same effect under EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime, because the two schemes assess different quantities. These differences in calculation, monitoring and regulation come together within the installation, maintenance and regulation of WHRS installations.