Installation, Maintenance and Regulations for Waste Heat Recovery Systems (WHRS) for Ships
Publication date:
A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) must fit safely into the ship's engineering systems and operate reliably in service. The ship must have enough recoverable waste heat and the system must be correctly sized. The positions of heat exchangers, pipe routes, cooling, electrical connections, structural loads and maintenance access also determine whether the system can be installed and operated safely.
For existing ships, the assessment starts with the equipment already on board and the space available for installation. For newbuilds, provisions for waste heat recovery can already be included during ship design. After entry into service, maintenance and technical monitoring help preserve performance and availability. Changes to engines or fuels may also warrant reassessing the installation's suitability. For ships to which international and European emissions requirements apply, it must also be established how the WHRS contribution is substantiated under the relevant rules. Technical integration, operational performance and legal compliance remain separate aspects of the assessment.
A Retrofit Requires More Than Sufficient Engine-Room Space
In a retrofit, a waste heat recovery system is added to a ship whose engine, cooling-water and electrical systems are already configured. An available space therefore gives only an initial indication of feasibility. The complete installation must fit within the existing ship structure and be capable of being connected safely. In a system based on the Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), the main module is only one part of the installation. Heat exchangers, pumps, any intermediate circuits, condenser and electrical equipment also need suitable locations. Sufficient space must also remain for operation, inspection, maintenance and removal of major components.
The route for bringing equipment to its installed position may also impose constraints. An ORC module may fit in the intended position, while existing engine-room hatches, passageways or lifting arrangements may lack the clearance or lifting capacity to get the module into place. Weight, foundation loading and the effects on the ship's centre of gravity must also be assessed where relevant.
For the technical integration of a WHRS into an existing ship, the existing ship systems also set constraints. An exhaust gas heat exchanger must function within the permitted back-pressure and temperature conditions. Engine cooling must maintain the required water circulation and temperature control. At the same time, the ORC condenser must be able to reject sufficient heat without reducing the cooling available to other equipment.
The electrical connection also requires an assessment of the switchboard, electrical protection and power management system. The existing power supply must remain reliable when WHRS output changes or is unexpectedly lost. Depending on the ship configuration, a retrofit may therefore be possible with limited changes, require additional modifications or prove infeasible for a particular design. An arrangement that appears suitable at a preliminary stage therefore does not yet constitute a final, approved installation design.
Newbuilds Offer Scope for a Coordinated Design
For newbuilds, the heat sources, engine-room layout and main technical systems can already be coordinated during design. The position of heat exchangers and any ORC module therefore need not be determined solely by the space remaining after the other systems have been installed. For exhaust gas heat, the heat exchanger position, available back-pressure allowance and connections to the exhaust gas system can be assessed early. Any exhaust gas aftertreatment and existing uses of the heat must also be considered when making that choice. For engine cooling water, the necessary connection points can be matched to the ship's pumps, coolers and temperature control.
The ship's central cooling and electrical distribution merit the same attention. An ORC condenser may change the total heat rejection duty, while the generator must be suitable for the shipboard electrical system and the required power reserve. Foundations, pipe routes, maintenance space and the means of bringing equipment to the installation location can also be incorporated into the design from the outset. Which provisions for waste heat recovery in a newbuild ship design are useful depends in part on whether the system is fitted during construction or may be added later.
For immediate installation, the provisions can be designed for the selected equipment and its associated heat, cooling and electrical conditions. When provision is made for a future installation, the final configuration may still be unknown. In that case, reserved installation spaces, accessible pipe routes and connection options backed by adequate engineering data may be more valuable than components fitted in advance whose eventual function is still uncertain. However, a reserved space or unused connection does not guarantee that every future WHRS can be installed without additional modifications. The preparation remains bound by the design limits on which it is based. If a different engine, fuel or ORC configuration is selected later, those assumptions must be checked again.
Safe Operation and Approval Remain Ship-Specific
A WHRS must not unacceptably affect the necessary engine, exhaust gas, cooling-water and electrical functions. This applies during normal heat recovery, but also during start-up, shutdown, maintenance and relevant fault conditions. When heat extraction is lost, the necessary engine cooling must be maintained. In the event of a loss of condenser capacity or electrical load, an ORC must be able to reduce output or shut down within the permitted process limits. The necessary isolation valves, controls and protection arrangements must therefore suit the actual connections and possible fault conditions.
In an ORC, the organic working fluid also imposes requirements on the installation. Depending on the selected fluid, flammability, the risk of harmful exposure, operating pressure and thermal stability may be important. The installation space must therefore be suitable for the associated ventilation, pressure protection, any leak detection and safe handling during maintenance. Even after electrical shutdown, an ORC may still be hot and pressurized. Before work takes place, components must therefore be capable of being safely isolated, cooled and, where necessary, depressurized.
The technical documentation, inspections and tests required depend on the selected configuration and the applicable requirements of the classification society, flag State and other competent parties. Product approval for an individual module does not mean that every ship-specific connection is permitted without further assessment. A distinction must remain between safe commissioning and verification of a stated energy performance figure. An installation can be correctly installed and function safely without a particular net annual output or contractual performance having already been demonstrated.
Maintenance Must Distinguish Actual Performance Loss from Normal Variation
During operation, fouling, wear and irregularities in the control system may affect the energy output of a WHRS. In exhaust gas heat exchangers, soot and other deposits may reduce heat transfer and increase flow resistance. Less heat may consequently be recovered while exhaust back pressure increases.
On the water side, deposits, corrosion and insufficient circulation may limit heat transfer. In an ORC, the condenser also has a major influence on the available electrical power. When heat rejection decreases, condensing conditions may change and the expander may deliver less power. The organic working fluid, working-fluid pump, expander, generator, isolation valves, instrumentation and protection arrangements must also be checked appropriately. The work needed depends on the technical design, the media used and the operating conditions.
For the maintenance needed to preserve WHRS performance, it is important to distinguish normal changes in output from technical deterioration. Generator output may, for example, fall because the engine supplies less waste heat, the cooling water becomes warmer or the shipboard electrical system limits production. A drop in electrical output alone therefore gives insufficient grounds for deciding whether maintenance is needed. Relevant temperatures, flow rates, pressures, pressure differences and auxiliary consumption must be assessed under sufficiently comparable conditions. An increasing pressure drop under comparable exhaust gas conditions may warrant checking for fouling. A higher condensing pressure may instead call for checks on the condenser, cooling-water circulation or process control.
Prescribed periodic work is therefore combined with condition monitoring. After maintenance, it must be established whether the problem that prompted the work has been resolved. The fact that the installation can restart does not in itself demonstrate that its previous net performance has been restored. During the work, the affected essential ship systems must remain operational. A heat exchanger or pump must not be isolated without a suitable procedure when, for example, engine cooling or exhaust gas discharge would consequently be restricted unacceptably.
Fuel and Engine Changes May Alter the Original ORC Selection
An ORC is designed for particular heat source temperatures, flow rates and operating conditions. When a marine engine later starts operating on a different fuel, is replaced or is used differently, these original assumptions may change. For exhaust gas heat, this concerns gas temperature, mass flow rate and the composition of the exhaust gases, among other factors. The achievable heat transfer, limits on exhaust gas cooling and material or maintenance requirements for the heat exchanger may consequently also change. For engine cooling water, the available temperatures, flow rates and original connection options may change.
For dual-fuel engines, the difference between fuel modes merits particular attention. The same engine load does not necessarily produce the same heat-source conditions in gas and liquid-fuel modes. The ORC must therefore suit the modes in which the ship actually operates and the transitions between those operating modes. When assessing the effect of a different fuel or engine configuration on the suitability of an ORC, the key question is whether the new heat sources still fall within the existing system's permitted operating range.
A fuel change does not automatically mean that a different ORC module is needed. The module may remain suitable while a heat exchanger, intermediate circuit or control system requires modification. The installation may also remain technically unchanged but deliver a different annual electrical energy output because heat is available for fewer hours or at a different temperature. Only when heat from the new sources can no longer be used within the original system's operating limits is there reason to consider a different module or system configuration.
EEDI and EEXI Use a Technical Reference Performance
For seagoing ships within the scope of MARPOL Annex VI, electricity generation from waste heat may contribute to calculated technical energy efficiency. The Energy Efficiency Design Index (EEDI) and Energy Efficiency Existing Ship Index (EEXI) use prescribed calculation conditions and parameters that differ from the ship's actual operating and load profile. For innovative energy efficiency technologies, the IMO also distinguishes different types of energy savings. For eligible systems that generate electricity from high-temperature waste heat, an effective power contribution, PAEeff, can be determined under category C-1.
In the treatment of electricity generation from waste heat in EEDI and EEXI calculations, the maximum stated ORC generator power must not be used as an effective contribution without further calculation. The IMO methodology contains its own definitions of electricity production, power conversion and the power needed to run the recovery system itself. It must also be established whether the specific ORC configuration falls within the applicable methodology. The described C-1 treatment does not automatically apply to every installation that uses only heat at a relatively low temperature. The selected heat sources, technical design and required verification remain determining factors.
For EEDI and EEXI, the effective power contribution and associated ship data must be accounted for under the applicable calculation and verification rules. For existing ships, for example, the engine power values used and any power limitations may affect the relevant reference conditions. A more favourable index value therefore does not by itself demonstrate a specific annual fuel saving. It describes the technical efficiency contribution under the prescribed calculation framework.
Operational CII Requires a Different Evidence Base
The Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) assesses the annual operational carbon intensity of ships to which the relevant IMO requirements apply. EEDI and EEXI can account for WHRS generation as a separate effective power deduction. The annual CII calculation includes no such deduction. An ORC can, however, improve CII when the recovered electricity actually reduces fuel consumption. In principle, that effect is reflected in the reported fuel data and the CO2 emissions calculated from those data under the applicable rules. Within the monitoring of waste heat recovery for CII and SEEMP, recorded net electricity generation, separately calculated fuel savings and the official annual CII therefore remain distinct quantities.
The Ship Energy Efficiency Management Plan (SEEMP) provides a framework for monitoring the effectiveness of energy-saving measures. For ships to which SEEMP Part III applies, a WHRS may form part of the three-year CII implementation plan. The plan records the expected contribution, how the system will be operated and how its performance will be evaluated. The technical WHRS records can then show how much net electricity has been delivered and under what engine, heat-source and cooling conditions. These data help explain why production changes, but do not replace the prescribed fuel and distance records for the official CII calculation.
A more favourable CII after installation of a WHRS must not automatically be attributed entirely to recovery. Ship speed, engine dispatch, routes and other energy-saving measures also affect the annual result. Conversely, an ORC may function technically as expected while the ship does not achieve a more favourable CII rating because of other conditions. The SEEMP evaluation must therefore assess both WHRS operation and changes in the ship's total energy use.
EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime Have Different Bases for Compliance
Waste heat recovery may also affect European emissions and compliance obligations. For this purpose, it must first be established how much fuel the ship actually saves and which greenhouse gas emissions it avoids. The effect on compliance then depends on the rules of the scheme in question. Under EU ETS, the relevant absolute emissions within the scope determine how many allowances must be surrendered. When a WHRS reduces fuel consumption and thus emissions, the emission allowance obligation may decrease.
FuelEU Maritime, by contrast, sets requirements for the average greenhouse gas intensity of the energy used under a well-to-wake approach. When energy use decreases while the relative shares of the energy sources and their applicable emission factors remain the same, intensity per megajoule does not necessarily change. This explains why waste heat recovery affects EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime differently. Under FuelEU Maritime, lower energy use may affect the size of the compliance balance without necessarily bringing average intensity within the limit. Lower energy use may shrink an existing deficit or reduce the surplus available to a ship with a positive balance.
When an ORC does not reduce consumption of different fuels in the same proportions, the weighted average FuelEU intensity may also change. The direction of this effect depends on the actual energy mix and applicable emissions parameters. Waste heat recovery does not automatically qualify for a separate intensity adjustment. The scope and geographical coverage must also be established for each scheme and ship activity. Without this breakdown, the same worldwide fuel savings do not form a sufficient basis for both European compliance calculations.
From Installation to Performance That Remains Demonstrable
A WHRS project must be more than technically feasible. The ship's existing functions must also remain available and safe, and the installation must be accessible for maintenance and checks throughout operation. Which statutory assessment applies then depends on the ship, the selected design and the rules under which the energy or emissions contribution concerned is substantiated. For ORC-based waste heat recovery systems for ships, we work with a specialist international partner to support the assessment, engineering and integration of suitable systems for retrofits and newbuilds. The physical and technical possibilities are matched to the existing or planned ship systems.
When the heat sources and connections still need to be assessed, the first step is system selection and integration of waste heat recovery systems. The appropriate capacity and the evidence for actual net power are then covered in sizing and performance assessment of waste heat recovery systems. The costs of ship modifications, maintenance and any benefits arising from regulation are assessed as part of the business case and investment decision for waste heat recovery. A technically suitable installation is not necessarily an economically attractive investment.
Within waste heat recovery systems (WHRS) for ships, this part of the series focuses on what it takes to install the selected system and keep it working in service. The system must be installed safely, maintenance must keep it in sound condition, and the relevant energy and emissions contributions must be assessed under the applicable evidential and regulatory requirements. The distinction is thus maintained between a WHRS operating safely and the performance that can actually be demonstrated during service.