How Do You Assess Whether a Waste Heat Recovery System Can Be Integrated into an Existing Ship?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
A waste heat recovery system can be integrated into an existing ship when sufficient suitable space is available and the necessary connections can be made safely without unacceptably affecting the ship's original functions. A retrofit of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) involves more than finding room for the main module. Heat exchangers, pipework, cooling, electrical equipment, foundations, maintenance access and the effects of additional mass also determine whether a retrofit is feasible.
Particularly for electricity production using an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), several existing shipboard systems must be integrated. A suitable heat source is therefore insufficient on its own. The hot-side connection must keep the engine within its permitted operating limits, the condenser must be able to reject sufficient heat, and the shipboard electrical system must be able to accept the electricity produced safely. The selected installation space must also be suitable for the working fluid used and the operating conditions on board.
The equipment must also be possible to move to its intended location and remain accessible during operation for operation, inspection and maintenance. The retrofit assessment therefore distinguishes between an installation that can be accommodated with limited changes, a design requiring additional technical modifications and a configuration that, within the existing ship's constraints, cannot be implemented in a technically acceptable manner. This establishes whether further engineering is worthwhile and which conditions must be checked first.
Why Is Available Engine-Room Space Not Automatically Suitable Installation Space?
An existing engine room may appear to offer sufficient free space for an ORC module, while the complete waste heat recovery system still does not fit in the intended position. The main module is only part of the arrangement. Heat exchangers, circulation pumps, connections, electrical equipment and other supporting services also need suitable locations. The assessment therefore starts with the actual engine-room layout. Engines, generators, pipe bundles, ventilation ducts and other existing equipment determine how much space remains available. A free area of deck may, for example, be large enough for the module, while the required connections may be obstructed by existing equipment.
The available height may also limit the options. Space may be needed above or beside the module for pipes, valves and components that must be removed during maintenance. An arrangement beneath a low deck or between existing structural members may therefore be less suitable than the available floor area suggests. The layout assessment must distinguish between the dimensions of the installed equipment and the clearance needed for operation, inspection and maintenance. A module that fits precisely between existing components may still be unsuitable if important connections are inaccessible. The same applies when a generator, expander or heat exchanger cannot later be replaced safely and practicably.
Existing access for personnel and escape routes must also be maintained. The new equipment and pipework must not unacceptably restrict safe access to necessary valves, firefighting equipment or other essential installations. The available space must therefore be assessed not only for normal maintenance, but also for situations in which crew members must be able to act quickly.
The position of the heat exchangers affects the rest of the layout. An exhaust gas heat exchanger must connect to a suitable part of the existing exhaust gas route, while the ORC condenser needs a connection to the available cooling arrangements. If these components are placed far apart, longer pipe runs and additional pumps or supports may be needed. This may affect the space required, heat losses, pressure losses and auxiliary electrical consumption. A compact arrangement of the main module is therefore not automatically the most favourable solution if the connection routes consequently become technically unfavourable.
Conditions at the installation location must also suit the selected design. Existing ventilation, ambient temperature, vibration and proximity to hot surfaces or electrical equipment may affect suitability. Depending on the properties of the organic working fluid, additional requirements may also apply to the space in which the ORC is installed.
On an existing ship, the original drawings may no longer match the current layout. During previous maintenance and shipyard periods, pipes may have been rerouted, machinery replaced or additional installations fitted. The available space must therefore be assessed on the basis of the equipment actually present. An initial assessment using drawings may be sufficient to select possible locations. Where space is limited, targeted dimensional checks or a current survey of the space may be needed. These checks establish the actual dimensions, connection points and clearances needed for installation and maintenance.
Suitable installation space is therefore more than space in which the equipment physically fits. It must also be possible to connect the complete system safely and retain adequate access for operation, inspection, maintenance and preservation of the engine room's original functions.
How Do Access Openings and Lifting Arrangements Determine Whether the Equipment Can Be Installed?
A suitable location must also be accessible to the equipment during installation. For a retrofit, the entire transport route from the deck to the installation space must therefore also be assessed. The dimensions, mass and available lifting points of the ORC module, heat exchangers and other large components determine which transport and lifting arrangements are needed. The assessment must cover existing engine-room hatches, deck openings, passageways and other access points through which the equipment must be moved.
A module may, for example, fit within the final installation space while an existing opening is too small for it to be brought inside in one piece. Even an opening that appears large enough on the basis of the external dimensions may cause problems during transport if the module has to be turned, tilted or moved past existing equipment. The transport route must therefore be assessed using the equipment dimensions in its transport configuration and the manoeuvring clearance required. Temporary supports, protection and space for lifting gear may also determine whether the move is feasible.
The existing lifting arrangements must also be suitable for the intended work. An existing engine-room crane or hoist cannot simply be used for every new component. The allowable lifting load, reach, available lifting height and load-bearing capacity of the supporting structure must suit the equipment to be moved. If the existing lifting equipment cannot accommodate the move, temporary lifting arrangements or additional structural measures may be needed. The assessment must also establish where a component can be set down temporarily during the move and what loads those locations must bear.
If the main module cannot be brought inside in one piece, a design with components that can be transported separately may make installation possible. The equipment is then brought on board in sections and assembled at its final location. Whether this is possible depends on the module design. Not every factory-assembled ORC installation can be dismantled and rebuilt without consequences for safety, testing or warranty. Modular installation must therefore be compatible with the equipment design and the supplier's requirements.
When the installation is assembled only after it is on board, additional assembly, connection and testing work may also be needed. Sufficient space must remain available for this work too. When access openings or structural members are modified, the ship's original functions must be maintained or restored. Temporary removal of a hatch, deck section or other fitting may be feasible, but requires an assessment of the boundary's structural, fire-resisting and watertight properties where relevant.
The installation sequence may also be decisive. Certain components may need to be brought in before new pipes, supports or electrical equipment are installed. If this sequence has not been investigated in advance, a technically suitable final arrangement may prove difficult to reach during installation. Access for future removal must also be considered. An expander, generator, pump or heat exchanger may need maintenance or replacement during its service life. If important components can be removed only through major work after the installation is complete, this represents a relevant operational limitation.
Technical feasibility therefore depends on more than the fully assembled installation. Bringing important components on board, lifting, assembling and later removing them must also be possible within the constraints of the existing ship.
Can a Heat Exchanger Be Incorporated into the Existing Exhaust Gas Route?
When a WHRS uses exhaust gas heat, the existing exhaust gas route provides an important starting point for the retrofit. An additional heat exchanger must have a suitable connection point without unacceptably affecting the original exhaust gas discharge or engine operation. Silencers, exhaust gas boilers, aftertreatment equipment and other equipment may already be installed between the turbocharger and the exhaust gas outlet. The new heat exchanger must be integrated into this existing configuration.
This involves more than the available length or diameter of a pipe section. The position of supports, expansion joints, existing connections and maintenance openings also determines where a heat exchanger can be placed in a technically acceptable manner. Exhaust back pressure is an important technical limit. The heat exchanger creates additional flow resistance, while the existing pipes, bends, silencers and any aftertreatment equipment also cause pressure losses. Total exhaust back pressure must remain within the limits permitted for the engine concerned.
If the existing installation already accounts for most of the permitted back pressure, there may be too little margin for an additional heat exchanger. The assessment must therefore cover the entire relevant exhaust gas route, rather than only the pressure drop across the new component. The engine loads at which the WHRS will operate and the expected maintenance condition must also be taken into account. Soot and other deposits may restrict the gas flow and increase the pressure drop in service. A heat exchanger that leaves enough back-pressure margin only when clean may prove unsuitable in service.
Alongside flow resistance, the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature limits how much heat can be recovered. Exhaust gases must not be cooled without limit because condensation and corrosion may occur, depending on the fuel, gas composition and local surface temperatures. Existing exhaust gas aftertreatment may also impose temperature requirements. If a catalyst or other equipment requires particular exhaust gas conditions, a new heat exchanger must not disrupt its operation.
The component sequence must therefore be assessed as a whole. A heat exchanger upstream of an existing exhaust gas boiler may reduce the heat available for existing steam or hot-water production. Further downstream, this effect may be smaller, but the new heat exchanger may receive exhaust gases at a lower temperature.
The mechanical connection must also be suitable. Exhaust gas pipes expand during operation and may be subjected to loads from vibration and ship motions. The heat exchanger and connected pipework must therefore be adequately supported without transferring unacceptable forces to the turbocharger or other existing components. It must also be practicable to fit and access any condensate handling equipment, inspection and cleaning openings, and insulation for hot surfaces. A heat exchanger that can barely be maintained may cause problems during operation, even when the installation meets the technical limits at delivery.
On ships with several engines, it must be clear which individual exhaust gas routes are used. The exhaust gases from different engines must not be combined directly without further assessment. Depending on the configuration, unwanted backflow and other interactions may make additional protection or a different arrangement necessary. Even when the WHRS is out of service, the original exhaust gas function must be maintained. Depending on the design, bypass arrangements or other control options may be needed for this. The associated pressure losses and flow conditions must also remain within the permitted engine limits.
An exhaust gas heat exchanger is therefore suitable for retrofit only when a feasible installation location is available and the complete exhaust system can continue to function within the specified engine, temperature and flow limits. If a different pipe route or arrangement is needed for this, the structural consequences must also be assessed. If the necessary technical limits prove unattainable, the exhaust gas configuration under consideration is unsuitable for the intended recovery.
Is the Existing Ship Cooling System Suitable for an ORC Installation?
In an ORC-based WHRS, only part of the heat supplied is converted into mechanical and then electrical power. Most of the remaining heat must be rejected through the condenser. Sufficient cooling capacity is therefore a separate requirement for a feasible retrofit. An existing ship generally has cooling circuits for engines and other technical installations. The presence of these circuits does not, however, automatically mean that the ORC condenser can also be connected without modifications.
It must first be established which cooling circuit is suitable and which temperatures and flow rates are available under the relevant operating conditions. A central cooler may, for example, have sufficient total heat transfer capacity, while the selected pipe branch or circulation pump offers insufficient capacity for a new connection. The hydraulic effects must also be investigated. The condenser creates additional flow resistance and may change the distribution of cooling water. Where several consumers use the same circuit, the necessary flow rates and temperatures must be maintained at all the installations concerned.
It must also be determined how much heat the cooling system actually has to reject after WHRS installation. That cooling load depends on the original heat source. When the ORC uses exhaust gas heat, heat previously released to the surroundings through the exhaust gases may now be directed largely through the condenser to the ship's cooling system. The total cooling load may therefore increase.
For recovery from engine cooling water, the situation is different. Some of the engine heat supplied to the ORC might already have been rejected through the existing coolers without heat recovery. The WHRS can partly shift this heat rejection to the ORC condenser. The condenser's total heat load therefore need not equal the additional load on the ship's cooling system. The heat balance must show where the heat was originally rejected and through which circuits it is released after installation.
That distinction does not remove the hydraulic limitations. Even when the total cooling load barely increases, a particular pipe branch, pump or heat exchanger may be more heavily loaded because of the changed heat distribution. For the condenser, the available cooling-water temperature and flow rate primarily determine how much heat can be rejected. If the cooling water becomes warmer, the ORC's condensing temperature may rise and electricity production may decrease.
The assessment must therefore take account of the operating area and the operating conditions in which the installation will function. A central cooler with sufficient capacity with cold intake water may offer less capacity when the ship operates in warmer waters. The cooler's condition and the load from other equipment using the same cooling water at the time may also limit the available capacity. The rated cooling capacity of an existing heat exchanger therefore does not, on its own, provide sufficient evidence that the ORC condenser can function under all the required conditions.
The original engine cooling must also be maintained when the WHRS stops unexpectedly. The necessary engine and cooling-water functions must not become dependent on an additional recovery system unless the complete cooling system has been specifically designed and approved for this purpose, with suitable standby capacity and protection. If the ORC fails, the engine heat no longer rejected through recovery must again be removed by the available cooling system. The existing temperature control and any bypass arrangements must make this transition controllable.
The ship's cooling system is therefore suitable when the condenser can reject sufficient heat within the available thermal and hydraulic capacity while the original cooling-water functions are maintained. If additional pumps, different pipe routes or more cooling capacity are needed, it must also be established whether these changes can be accommodated in the existing ship. An available cooling-water connection does not in itself establish that the complete ORC cooling arrangement is technically feasible.
Can the Existing Shipboard Electrical System Accept the Recovered Electricity?
Alongside the heat source and cooling, the electrical installation must also be suitable for the WHRS generator. It must be possible to supply the electricity safely to the shipboard electrical system without impairing the reliability of the existing energy supply. The assessment starts with the ship's electrical configuration. The assessment must identify a generator connection point and establish whether the switchboard can accommodate the new source.
Depending on the ORC design, the generator can be connected directly or through power electronics. The required AC voltage and frequency or DC voltage and the conditions for parallel operation must be compatible with the existing distribution system. The physical connection must also be feasible. Switchgear, cable routes, protection and any transformers or converters must fit within the available space in the electrical installation.
Adding a generator may also change power flows and fault current conditions. It must therefore be assessed whether the existing distribution equipment and protection remain suitable for the new configuration. Interaction with the power management system (PMS) is another important aspect. When the WHRS supplies electricity, existing generating sets may no longer need to produce as much power. The PMS must be able to handle that change while maintaining the necessary generating reserve and keeping engines within their permitted load ranges.
Electrical demand on board also matters. When the ship needs little electricity during certain operating modes, WHRS production may have to be limited. A technically suitable generator connection therefore does not automatically mean that the full rated power can be put to use in every operating hour.
The shipboard electrical system must also be prepared for unexpected WHRS failure. If recovery suddenly stops supplying electricity, other energy sources must be able to make up for the lost power. If insufficient generation is available for this, the electrical load must be reduced in accordance with a suitable operating strategy. This requires enough margin to adjust output and sufficient power reserve. A generating set that has yet to start cannot immediately supply power to the shipboard electrical system. Electrical integration must therefore cover both normal power distribution and the relevant fault conditions.
If the WHRS uses heat from the same generating sets whose load falls when the WHRS supplies electricity, the available heat supply may also change. The resulting engine load and WHRS output must therefore relate to the same operating configuration. For an initial retrofit assessment, the main question is whether a suitable generator connection and the necessary control and protection functions can be implemented. Detailed protection coordination and the electrical power balance can then be established as the selected configuration is developed.
A technically suitable connection to the shipboard electrical system is therefore a necessary condition, but does not yet, in itself, constitute proof that the complete WHRS retrofit can function safely and usefully.
Which Structural Modifications and Pipe Routes Are Necessary?
A waste heat recovery system adds mass and new loads to the ship. Not only the available installation space but also the structure on which the equipment is placed must therefore be assessed. An existing engine-room floor or foundation may offer sufficient space for an ORC module without necessarily being suitable for the associated mass and operating loads. Suitable supports must transfer these forces to the existing ship structure.
Alongside the equipment's own weight, loads from ship motions, vibration and the operation of rotating components matter. The foundations and mountings must withstand these loads without transmitting unacceptable forces to adjacent equipment or structural members. The current condition of the existing structure must also be taken into account. Previous modifications, corrosion or local weakening may affect the available load-bearing capacity. An assessment based solely on the original drawings may therefore be insufficient.
The additional mass also affects the ship as a whole. The ship's total weight and centre of gravity may change as well. The ORC module, heat exchangers, pumps, pipes, working fluid and all supporting equipment must therefore be included together in the weight assessment. Both the total added mass and where it is located on board matter.
An installation high in the ship may, for example, have a different effect on the vertical centre of gravity from the same mass low in the engine room. Its distribution along the ship's length may also affect trim and the position of the longitudinal centre of gravity. Depending on the extent of the modifications, ship type and applicable regulations, it may be necessary to reassess or amend the existing stability information. The additional equipment must therefore not be assessed solely in terms of the strength of the local foundation.
Even when the added mass is limited in itself, previous modifications to the ship may be relevant. The combined effects on the ship's weight and stability data must be understood. Alongside structural support, pipe routes are an important condition for integration. Exhaust gas pipes, hot-water or thermal-oil circuits and cooling-water pipes must be capable of being routed safely between the existing equipment.
In hot pipes, temperature changes can cause considerable expansion. If that movement is not adequately accommodated, unwanted forces may arise on heat exchangers, pumps and existing pipe connections. The pipe route must therefore allow space for suitable supports, thermal expansion and maintenance access. The shortest connection between the heat source and ORC module is not automatically the best route if mechanical loads or access consequently become unfavourable.
Pressure losses and heat losses also matter. A longer pipe route may require more pumping power and change the temperature available at the ORC. The structural and thermal consequences must therefore be assessed together. When new pipes or cables are routed through decks, bulkheads or other structural boundaries, the original function of these parts must be maintained. Depending on the location, requirements may apply to watertightness, fire resistance or structural strength. New penetrations must not compromise these properties without appropriate protective measures. The same applies to existing closures and other safety arrangements affected by the modifications.
Structural integration therefore involves more than a foundation for the main module. The total mass, centre of gravity, pipe supports, thermal movements and necessary penetrations must also be assessed together.
Which Safety and Maintenance Conditions Affect Suitability for Retrofit?
The safety conditions for a waste heat recovery system depend on the selected technology, operating conditions and the location where the equipment is installed. For an ORC, the properties of the organic working fluid are particularly important. Although the fluid circulates in a closed loop, this does not mean that leakage or other deviations can be ruled out completely.
Depending on the selected working fluid, flammability, potentially harmful exposure, operating pressure and thermal stability may determine the safety arrangements required. Not every organic working fluid has the same properties. Installation space requirements therefore vary by ORC design. For certain working fluids, additional measures may be needed for ventilation, leak detection, containment and control of ignition risks. The selected location must allow these measures to be implemented safely.
Proximity to hot exhaust gas pipes, electrical equipment and existing fuel systems must also be assessed. Where leakage could lead to hazardous conditions, the position and protection of the components concerned must be matched to that risk. The required safety measures depend on the working fluid's properties, the risk assessment and the applicable regulations. It therefore cannot generally be assumed that every ORC can be installed in an existing engine room without additional conditions.
Existing fire safety provisions and escape routes must also be maintained. New equipment must not unacceptably restrict access to firefighting equipment, emergency shut-off valves and key operating controls. For new penetrations or modifications to existing boundaries, the required fire-resisting function must also be maintained.
Pressure protection and safe isolation of installation components also deserve attention. When an ORC is taken out of service, thermal energy remains in heat exchangers, pipes and fluid circuits for a time. If cooling is lost, the condenser may reject insufficient heat. The generator may also cease to deliver power during an electrical fault while heat remains available on the hot side. The control and protection arrangements must be able to handle such situations while keeping the installation within its permitted operating limits.
In these situations, the original engine, exhaust gas and cooling-water functions must be maintained. A WHRS must not create an unwanted dependency in which a necessary ship function is safely available only while recovery remains active. An exception is possible only when the complete system architecture has been specifically designed and approved for that dependency.
Alongside the safety arrangements, maintenance access determines whether the location is suitable in practice. Exhaust gas heat exchangers may foul and must remain accessible for inspection and cleaning. Water-side heat exchangers also require sufficient maintenance access. For an ORC, the pumps, expander, generator, valves, instrumentation and control equipment must also remain accessible. Depending on the design, space is also needed to safely isolate, drain and, where necessary, remove components.
An installation that can be maintained only after other essential equipment has largely been dismantled may therefore be less suitable than an arrangement requiring slightly more permanent space but retaining sufficient maintenance access. For each ship, it must also be established which assessment and approval by the classification society, flag State or other competent bodies are necessary. The selected working fluid, installation location and modifications to existing ship systems help determine which requirements apply.
An existing product or module approval does not automatically mean that the complete installation can be used on every ship without further assessment. Integration on the particular ship and the consequences for existing safety functions must be assessed separately.
How Do Existing Ship Operations Affect the Execution of a WHRS Retrofit?
A waste heat recovery system may be technically feasible to fit even if the work substantially affects the ship's operations. Work on existing engine, cooling-water and electrical installations, in particular, must be scheduled for times when these systems can be modified safely. For installation of an exhaust gas heat exchanger, parts of the existing exhaust gas route may need to be removed or altered. Such work cannot simply take place while the engine concerned is operating normally.
Modifications to cooling-water circuits may also require pipes to be isolated or drained. For electrical connections, the assessment must account for safe electrical isolation of the equipment and the availability of other necessary ship functions. The nature of the work partly determines whether a planned shipyard period is needed. Not every WHRS retrofit has to be carried out entirely during a docking period. Certain structural modifications or temporary shutdowns may, however, require a shipyard or maintenance period.
Some of the work may be prepared before the main module is installed. Foundations may, for example, be fitted, pipe routes prepared or certain electrical equipment installed. Whether the work can be phased depends on the existing shipboard systems. Preparatory work must not disrupt necessary functions and must be compatible with the safety measures applying during normal operation.
The sequence of the installation work must also be clear. A heat exchanger, for example, can be connected only after the pipe route has been prepared. Other equipment may need to be brought in before new pipes or supports restrict the available openings. The installation sequence must therefore be matched to the access and lifting arrangements. A technically suitable final arrangement does not in itself establish that the installation sequence is feasible.
Temporary openings, structural modifications and work involving an increased fire risk must also be included in the planning and safety assessment in advance. Afterwards, the ship parts concerned must retain their specified structural and safety functions. A planned docking or shipyard period may provide an opportunity to combine the WHRS retrofit with other work. The availability of such a period does not, however, automatically mean that all the required modifications can be completed within the same time.
After installation, the new pipes, heat exchangers, electrical connections and control arrangements must be checked before the installation is brought fully into operation. The checks must establish, among other things, whether the original engine, cooling-water and electrical functions are maintained. The response when WHRS output is reduced or the system is switched off must also be appropriate for the selected installation.
Which tests are needed depends on the components used, installation architecture and requirements of the classification society concerned. Any leak and pressure tests, checks of electrical protection and functional tests must be matched to the modifications actually made. Successful technical commissioning does not, however, automatically prove that the installation delivers a particular net energy output. Demonstrating safe operation and verifying any guaranteed power are separate assessment objectives.
For a feasible retrofit, therefore, more than just the installation work must be possible. The necessary inspections, checks and tests must also be able to take place safely under the available operating conditions. If the work requires essential ship systems to be taken out of service for a long period, this may strongly affect practical feasibility. A different arrangement, modified module construction or changed installation sequence may still make the retrofit feasible.
Which Data Are Needed to Establish Technical Feasibility?
An initial retrofit assessment starts with an accurate understanding of the existing shipboard systems and the main characteristics of the proposed WHRS. Current general arrangement and engine-room drawings are needed for the layout assessment. The available installation positions, access openings, pipe routes and important structural members must be sufficiently clear from these drawings. On an existing ship, it must be checked whether the drawings correspond to the actual arrangement. Previous modifications to pipes, machinery and supports may have changed the possibilities for the new installation.
Where space is limited, a targeted onboard survey may be necessary. The actual dimensions, clear openings and space for installation and maintenance can be established through dimensional checks or a suitable spatial survey. The dimensions and mass of the main module and additional components of the proposed WHRS must be known. The positions of their centres of gravity, required maintenance clearances and available lifting and transport arrangements are also important.
This information is compared with the existing ship structure. The comparison must establish whether additional foundations or reinforcement are needed and whether the mass and position of the equipment affect the ship's weight and stability data.
For the hot side, data on the heat sources and connection options are needed. For exhaust gas heat, these include the existing exhaust gas route, relevant engine loads, gas temperatures, mass flow rates and permitted back pressure and the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature. It must also be known which existing equipment is present in the exhaust gas route and which functions must be maintained after installation. An available position for a heat exchanger has little value if the necessary engine or aftertreatment limits are exceeded as a result.
For recovery from engine cooling water, the circuits, temperatures, flow rates and control arrangements concerned must be known. The proposed heat extraction must remain within the specified engine conditions and must not disrupt the original cooling function. For the condenser, the available cooling-water circuits, heat exchanger capacities, pump data and relevant surrounding-water conditions are investigated. The assessment must include existing cooling-water loads to establish how much capacity remains under the relevant operating conditions.
On the electrical side, the current single-line diagram, available connection points and main data for generators, switchgear and the PMS are relevant. These data help establish whether the WHRS generator can be connected to the existing shipboard electrical system and which modifications are needed. The properties of the selected ORC working fluid and the associated safety arrangements must also be sufficiently known. These data may determine which installation space is suitable and whether additional ventilation, detection or protection arrangements are necessary.
For an initial retrofit assessment, not all detailed calculations need to have been completed yet. The main technical limitations must, however, be sufficiently clear for a preliminary installation concept to be assessed. The assessment must distinguish between conditions already substantiated by available data and aspects for which measurements, inspections or additional engineering are still needed.
A preliminary layout may, for example, appear viable while the strength of a foundation or the available cooling capacity has not yet been demonstrated conclusively. Technical feasibility then remains dependent on the results of these outstanding checks. It must also be established in good time which drawings, calculations and approvals specific to the ship are needed. Involving the classification society and, where relevant, the flag State at an appropriate stage can avoid major changes later in the design.
The initial assessment therefore produces a substantiated retrofit concept that can inform detailed engineering. This shows where the installation can be placed, how the main connections can be made and which technical conditions still need to be confirmed.
When Is a WHRS Retrofit Technically Feasible?
A waste heat recovery system is technically feasible for retrofit when the selected configuration can be accommodated within the existing ship and the necessary connections can be made without unacceptable consequences for the ship's original functions. Depending on the available space and modifications required, the assessment may lead to different outcomes. An installation may be feasible with limited changes when sufficient installation space, suitable heat and cooling arrangements and a feasible electrical connection are available. Suitable foundations, access for moving equipment, maintenance clearances and safety measures must also be practicable.
For another ship configuration, additional technical modifications may be necessary. A heat exchanger may, for example, require a revised exhaust gas route, while the ORC module must be placed elsewhere to retain sufficient maintenance access. Additional cooling capacity, new pumps, structural reinforcement or changes to the shipboard electrical system may also become part of the retrofit. Such modifications do not automatically mean that the installation is technically unsuitable. What matters is whether the changes can be made safely within the ship's structural constraints and applicable operating limits.
The situation is different when a necessary technical condition proves unattainable. If no suitable position for the exhaust gas heat exchanger can be found without exceeding the permitted engine conditions, the exhaust gas configuration under consideration may be unsuitable. The same applies when the required cooling capacity cannot be provided in a technically acceptable manner, the equipment cannot reach the installation location or necessary safety provisions cannot be accommodated within the existing ship layout.
Structural limitations and constraints affecting the ship as a whole may also rule out a particular design. A module may, for example, be adequately supported locally while the total added mass or the centre of gravity has unacceptable consequences for the ship that cannot be resolved with appropriate modifications. The assessment must therefore always cover the complete installation. An ORC module that fits in the engine room is not a suitable retrofit if the necessary heat exchanger, condenser or electrical connection cannot be integrated in a technically acceptable manner.
If a particular configuration proves unsuitable, another layout or design may still be feasible. Modified module construction may, for example, simplify transport, while a different pipe route or heat source connection may reduce certain physical limitations. A modification that resolves one problem must, however, be reassessed for its consequences for other shipboard systems. More space around the main module must not, for example, lead to unacceptable pressure losses or loss of necessary maintenance access elsewhere.
For an existing ship, it must therefore become clear which technical conditions have already been sufficiently substantiated and which still depend on further inspection, engineering or approval. A provisionally feasible installation concept is also not automatically ready for installation. The final configuration must meet the applicable requirements of the engine manufacturer, classification society, flag State and other parties concerned.
Technical feasibility must also be distinguished from the expected energy benefit and economic case. A WHRS may be integrated into the ship in a technically acceptable manner while the available heat supply, annual electricity production or investment costs independently provide reasons not to develop the application further. The technical retrofit assessment must therefore first establish whether the installation can be integrated physically, thermally, hydraulically, electrically and safely. It is then determined which modifications are needed for this and whether feasibility can be demonstrated sufficiently.
Only when these conditions have been substantiated together can the selected WHRS configuration be considered a technically promising retrofit option. This provides a reliable basis for further engineering, ship-specific approval and final assessment of usable energy output.
This Article in the Series
A WHRS may be able to use sufficient waste heat yet prove unsuitable for retrofit when space, connections or safety provisions are inadequate. The technically achievable configuration partly determines which performance can be specified in a WHRS performance guarantee. Existing ships impose constraints on installation. By contrast, preparation for waste heat recovery in the newbuild design allows the necessary provisions to be incorporated earlier. Both situations fall within installation, maintenance and regulations for WHRS installations.