Which Waste Heat Recovery Provisions Should Be Included in the Ship Design at the Newbuild Stage?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
At the newbuild stage, provisions for waste heat recovery can be coordinated with the engine installation, the ship's cooling system, electrical supply and engine-room layout from the earliest design phases. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) requires more than a suitable heat source and sufficient space for the main equipment. The position of heat exchangers, pipe and cable routes, cooling capacity, foundations and maintenance access also determine whether the available waste heat can actually be used.
Making these provisions early in the design can avoid having to move or modify important shipboard systems later. The design approach depends on whether the WHRS will be installed at delivery or the ship is being prepared for possible installation later. For immediate installation, the connections and provisions can be designed for the selected equipment. Preparation for later use mainly involves keeping suitable spaces and connection options available and establishing sufficiently substantiated design assumptions.
Which provisions are worthwhile depends on the expected heat supply, electrical and thermal energy demand and what the new ship can technically accommodate. A reservation for future heat recovery has practical value only when it is clear which installation could fit within the design limits allowed for it. Early preparation can reduce later installation constraints, but does not guarantee that a future WHRS can be connected without additional engineering.
Which Heat and Energy Data Are Already Needed During Ship Design?
Preparation for waste heat recovery starts with the engine configuration and the ship's expected operation. During operation, main and auxiliary engines reject heat through exhaust gases, cooling circuits and other routes. The heat available depends on the load of each engine and the conditions under which it operates. Total installed engine power therefore provides insufficient information to define the required WHRS provisions. The first step is to identify which engines will run in each of the ship's passage and working modes. On a ship with several generating sets, the heat supply changes when additional engines are brought into or taken out of service. A propulsion engine may also operate at a markedly different load during manoeuvring or at a different ship speed than during normal passage.
The exhaust gas and cooling-water heat data must therefore match the operating modes relevant to the ship. For exhaust gases, these include temperature and mass flow rate at different engine loads. For engine cooling water, the available temperatures, flow rates and limits within which heat may be extracted are important. Both the amount of heat and its temperature matter. Exhaust gases generally contain heat at a higher temperature than engine cooling water. For electricity production using an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), these temperatures, together with the available cooling, affect how much electrical power can be produced.
When different heat sources are combined, their individual temperatures and flow rates must remain identifiable. Heat from an exhaust gas heat exchanger and heat from a cooling-water circuit cannot be combined as equivalent thermal inputs without further assessment. Existing heat demand also forms part of this early assessment. A ship may need heat for heating, hot-water supply, fuel treatment or other thermal applications. If this demand is already met by exhaust gas or cooling-water heat, the same heat may no longer be available in full for additional electricity production.
The heat balance must therefore show where the heat is originally released, which proportion is already used directly and how much heat may remain for a WHRS. The heat balance must match heat production and existing heat demand over the same operating periods. On the electrical side, what matters in particular is when the ship needs the electricity that an ORC could produce. The available heat supply and peak electrical demand need not occur at the same time. An installation receiving a large amount of heat therefore does not automatically make an equally large useful contribution to the electrical energy supply.
The intended operating strategy may also affect the heat supply. If WHRS electricity reduces the load on generating sets that themselves supply heat to the ORC, exhaust gas and cooling-water conditions may change. Engine load, available heat and electrical power distribution must then relate to the same final operating configuration. These data help determine which provisions are actually worthwhile at the newbuild stage. If exhaust gas heat from a propulsion engine running for long periods is the main heat source, the exhaust gas route and possible heat exchanger position can be matched to it.
If several engines or cooling-water circuits are relevant, space may instead be needed for separate heat exchangers and connections to a common or separate heat supply. Which arrangement is suitable depends on the heat conditions and engine combinations encountered during service. An early heat and energy balance need not yet include final ORC sizing. It must, however, be sufficiently clear which heat sources are promising, which operating modes govern recovery and what space and technical provision the ship design must allow for heat recovery.
If later changes to the engine concept, fuel choice or propulsion installation are expected, their possible consequences for the heat sources must be taken into account. Preparation based solely on the original engine data may become less suitable if the final engine configuration changes. The provisions can thus be matched to the ship's expected operation, rather than to a general reservation for an installation whose required heat supply and operating range are not yet known.
How Do You Prepare the Exhaust Gas Route for Heat Recovery?
For recovery from exhaust gases, the arrangement of the exhaust gas route is an important design choice. A heat exchanger must have a suitable installation point without the engine's exhaust gas discharge or the operation of other connected equipment being unacceptably affected. At the newbuild stage, exhaust gas pipes, silencers, any exhaust gas boilers and aftertreatment equipment can be positioned together from the outset. Space can thus be provided for a heat exchanger without having to reroute much of the pipework later.
The available height, supporting structures and access for installation and maintenance can also be included directly in the engine-room layout. A suitable heat exchanger position needs room for the equipment, connections, any bypass arrangements and access for inspection or cleaning. The position in the exhaust gas route also depends on technical constraints. A heat exchanger creates flow resistance and thus contributes to total exhaust back pressure. The engine must continue to operate within its permitted limits, with allowance for the pressure losses of all the other components in the exhaust gas route.
The design must therefore establish how much additional flow resistance the selected or future heat exchanger may create. The available margin below the exhaust back pressure limit depends on the engine design, exhaust gas conditions and other equipment incorporated into the same route. Expected fouling during operation must also be taken into account. Soot and other deposits may increase a heat exchanger's flow resistance. An exhaust gas route that remains within the permitted back pressure only with completely clean heat transfer surfaces may leave too little margin in service.
Limits also apply to exhaust gas cooling. A high gas temperature offers scope for heat recovery, but the gas must not be cooled without limit. Condensation and corrosion may occur, depending on the fuel used, gas composition and local metal temperatures. The presence of exhaust gas aftertreatment also affects possible positioning. Some aftertreatment equipment requires a specific operating temperature range. A heat exchanger placed upstream of this equipment may disrupt its operation if the exhaust gases are cooled too far.
Further downstream, the effect on aftertreatment may be smaller, but the exhaust gases may already have cooled. The available temperature and amount of heat may therefore be different there. Existing exhaust gas boilers and other heat consumers must also be taken into account in the selection of the heat exchanger position. At the newbuild stage, these dependencies can be investigated before the exhaust gas route is finalized. This helps keep the most suitable position free of other equipment and preserves the space needed for heat extraction within acceptable technical limits.
Mechanical support also requires attention. During operation, exhaust gas pipes and heat exchangers become hot and expand relative to the surrounding structure. The positions of fixed supports, pipe connections and any expansion joints must therefore suit the selected arrangement. If thermal movements are not adequately accommodated, undesirable loads may be transmitted to the heat exchanger, turbocharger or other connected components. The pipe route and supports must therefore be designed together.
For a WHRS installed at delivery, the heat exchanger, connections and any bypass arrangements can be matched directly to the selected configuration. The original exhaust gas discharge must be maintained when heat extraction is reduced or switched off. For a possible future installation, keeping a suitable part of the exhaust gas route clear may be sufficient. The pipework can also be arranged so that a heat exchanger can be incorporated later without major relocation of other equipment.
This does not mean that a bypass, unused exhaust gas connection or empty pipe section must automatically be installed during newbuild construction. Such provisions must function safely even without a WHRS connected and must not adversely affect the original exhaust gas discharge. If the future heat exchanger is not yet known, the assessment must establish which preparatory work is technically justified. Reserving space and suitable pipe routes may then be more useful than installing components in advance whose final pressure losses and connection conditions are still unknown.
Useful preparation therefore consists of more than an unobstructed section of pipework. The design must provide sufficient space for heat extraction, comply with the limits on back pressure and exhaust gas cooling, and preserve the scope for maintenance and the engine's original functions.
Which Provisions for Engine Cooling Water and Intermediate Circuits Do You Include?
Engine cooling water can be a suitable heat source for direct heat use or electricity production with an ORC installation designed for that purpose. At the newbuild stage, the cooling-water circuits and connection options can take account of a possible additional heat consumer from the outset. The design must distinguish between the different cooling circuits. The high-temperature circuit, often referred to as the HT or jacket-water circuit, operates under different temperature conditions from a low-temperature circuit. The amount of heat available and the heat consumers already connected may also differ.
It must therefore first be established which circuit is suitable for the intended heat recovery. The highest cooling-water temperature does not automatically identify the best connection position. The position of the temperature control, flow direction and hydraulic characteristics also determine where heat can be extracted within acceptable technical limits. Preserving engine cooling takes priority. Cooling-water circulation must continue to reject sufficient heat to keep the engine within the specified temperature limits. An additional heat exchanger must not disrupt the necessary water flow or existing temperature control.
At the newbuild stage, suitable connection points and positions for heat exchangers can be provided. The arrangement must be compatible with the thermostatic controls, pumps and coolers of the selected engine installation. If a heat exchanger is placed in series with an existing cooling circuit, the additional flow resistance may increase the pressure loss and thereby affect the available pump flow. For a parallel connection, it must instead be established how the cooling water is distributed between the individual branches. These effects can already be taken into account during cooling-water system design. The pumps, pipe diameters, connections and control can then be assessed together so that the necessary circulation through the engine is maintained.
Transport of the recovered heat also deserves attention. Engine heat need not be transferred directly to the closed loop containing the organic working fluid. A separate water or thermal-oil circuit can absorb heat from the engine circuit and transport it to the ORC module. Such an intermediate circuit may allow more flexibility in siting the module and allow hydraulic separation between the systems concerned. This comes with additional heat exchangers, pipework and circulation pumps, and requires additional temperature differences for heat transfer.
The positions of the heat source and ORC module must therefore be assessed together. A location that appears to fit well need not be technically favourable if it requires long or complex runs of pipework for the hot fluid. Heat losses, pressure losses and circulation-pump electricity consumption may affect the installation's final net contribution. Particularly with heat at a relatively low temperature, additional temperature differences may further restrict the usable difference between the hot and cold sides of the ORC.
For immediate installation, the connections, isolation valves, control arrangements and any bypasses can be designed for the selected heat exchanger and actual operating conditions. The necessary engine cooling must remain available when the WHRS is switched off or stops unexpectedly. For future use, certain connection options and pipe routes can be reserved. The final design then remains dependent on the heat quantities, flow rates and temperature conditions for which the later WHRS is selected.
A connection point prepared without a specific ORC design in mind therefore does not guarantee that every future ORC module can be connected without modifications. During the later system selection, the original cooling-water functions and hydraulic effects must be reassessed. Unused connections must also remain a safe part of the original cooling system. Where branches are installed during newbuild construction, it must be possible to isolate them properly. They must not create unwanted flow routes or pipe sections that are difficult to control.
Considering engine cooling water and any intermediate circuits early in the design helps coordinate heat sources, connection points and installation space. Even without a WHRS connected, the preparatory work must continue to meet the requirements of the engine and original cooling system.
How Do You Allow for ORC Condenser Cooling at the Newbuild Stage?
Alongside a suitable heat source, an ORC needs sufficient capacity to reject the remaining process heat. After the working fluid has passed through the expander, it must be cooled and condensed back into a liquid. The heat released in this process must be transferred to a suitable cooling medium. The available cooling-water temperature and heat rejection capacity affect how much electricity the ORC can produce. If cooling is insufficient, the condensing temperature may rise and electrical output may have to be limited.
At the newbuild stage, the required condenser capacity can be included in the design of the ship's central cooling system. The design must establish which circuit the condenser can be connected to and which temperatures, flow rates and pressure conditions are available during the intended operating modes. The design must also account for other equipment served by that circuit. Engines, generators, lubricating oil coolers and other equipment remain dependent on the ship's cooling system. The central coolers, circulation pumps and pipes must be able to handle the combined heat load without restricting the necessary cooling of these consumers.
How much additional cooling load the WHRS causes depends in part on the origin of the recovered heat. For an ORC using exhaust gas heat, heat previously released largely to the surroundings through the exhaust gas route may now be directed through the condenser to the ship's cooling system. For recovery from engine cooling water, the situation is different. Some of the heat that the ORC receives might already have been rejected through the same shipboard cooling system without recovery. The ORC can partly shift this heat rejection while another part of the heat absorbed is converted into mechanical and electrical power.
The full condenser heat load must therefore not automatically be added to all the original cooling loads in every configuration. The heat balance must be based on the actual distribution of heat when the WHRS is operating. This does not mean that the existing cooling-water distribution will necessarily remain suitable. Even when the total heat load changes little, certain pumps, pipes or heat exchangers may be more heavily loaded. The point at which condenser heat is released to the cooling circuit may therefore be decisive for feasibility.
Cooling-water temperatures during future operation must also be assessed. A condenser with sufficient capacity when intake water is cold may be unable to maintain the same condensing conditions in warmer waters. The newbuild design must therefore take account of the relevant combinations of intake-water temperature, engine load and concurrent cooling-water loads. The highest individual heat load and warmest surrounding-water condition need not necessarily occur simultaneously. The selected design conditions must, however, correspond sufficiently to the operating range for which the installation must be suitable.
The original cooling capacity must also be maintained when the WHRS stops absorbing heat or is taken out of service. The engines and other essential consumers must still receive sufficient cooling. For an ORC used from delivery, condenser capacity, pumps, pipes and control arrangements can be matched to the selected installation. The additional electricity consumption of the cooling arrangements can then also be included in the assessment of net energy output.
For future use, space and pipe routes can be reserved for a condenser and any additional cooling arrangements. If the future ORC has not yet been selected, however, the required condenser capacity and cooling-water temperature may still be unknown. An available connection to the central cooling circuit therefore does not prove that sufficient cooling capacity will be available later. During the actual WHRS selection, the heat balance must be re-established for the engines, coolers and other consumers present at that time.
Good preparation therefore preserves the space and technical possibilities for future condenser integration while preserving essential cooling functions and leaving scope to address the eventual performance requirements.
Which Electrical Provisions Do You Prepare for WHRS Electricity Production?
When a WHRS produces electricity, its generator must be able to operate safely alongside the other energy sources on board. At the newbuild stage, this capability can be incorporated into the design of the electrical distribution and power management system (PMS). Preparation starts with the ship's electrical architecture. The voltage, frequency and distribution arrangement determine which generator connections are possible. Depending on the expander and generator design, the WHRS can be connected directly to an alternating-current system, or power electronics may be needed.
This choice affects the switches, cables, protection and any converters or transformers required. The electrical installation must also remain suitable for the changed power flows and fault conditions. If the WHRS is installed at delivery, these provisions can be designed for the selected generator, expected power and intended operating strategy. The connection and protection must then be compatible with the ship's other energy sources and electrical distribution.
For a future installation, suitable cable routes, accessible installation space and options for an additional switchboard connection can be reserved. An available cable route or free position in the switchboard does not, however, automatically mean that every future generator can be connected safely. Electrical load capacity, possible short-circuit currents and protection coordination must later be assessed for the design actually selected.
The capabilities of the PMS must also be taken into account at an early stage. When the ORC supplies electricity, existing generating sets may need to produce less power. The control system must account for this additional generation while retaining the necessary power reserve and keeping the engines within their permitted load ranges. A WHRS remains dependent on the available heat supply. Production may decrease when engine load changes or insufficient cooling is available. The PMS must therefore be able to respond to changes in WHRS production and any unexpected failure.
A future WHRS must not be regarded as fully available generator reserve without further assessment. In accordance with the applicable operating strategy, the other energy sources must be able to continue supporting the necessary electrical functions. Simultaneous electrical demand also determines how much WHRS electricity can be used on board. When the ship needs little power during certain operating modes, recovery output may have to be reduced. During preparation, the assessment must therefore identify when enough waste heat and sufficient electrical demand can coincide.
An additional interaction may arise when the WHRS uses heat from generating sets whose load falls when the WHRS supplies electricity. The lower generator load may change heat release. The design must then be based on engine load, heat supply and WHRS production relating to the same resulting operating mode. The electrical supply to auxiliary services also forms part of preparation. Working-fluid pumps, intermediate-circuit pumps, additional cooling and control equipment may themselves use electricity. The electrical installation must therefore not be assessed solely on gross generator power.
For immediate installation, the power balance, auxiliary supplies, protection and PMS functions can be matched to the selected WHRS configuration. The net contribution to the electrical energy supply can thus also be determined. For future use, it can be recorded which connection options and design margins are available. The final generator, any power electronics and the control strategy must later be checked again against the electrical installation present at that time.
Useful electrical preparation therefore takes account of more than a possible generator connection. The necessary space, system data and control capabilities must also be retained so that future WHRS electricity can be accepted safely by the shipboard electrical system.
How Do You Reserve Space, Foundations and Pipe Routes for Waste Heat Recovery?
The engine-room layout partly determines which WHRS configurations can be used. At the newbuild stage, the position of an ORC module can therefore be selected in relation to the engines, heat exchangers, cooling circuits and electrical equipment. The layout must account for more than the main module's external dimensions. Pumps, control cabinets, connecting sections and maintenance space also form part of the complete installation.
A suitable position provides sufficient overhead clearance and access to components that must be inspected or replaced during service. Larger components in particular, such as an expander, generator or heat exchanger, may require additional space for dismantling and transport. At the newbuild stage, access openings, lifting routes and the position of surrounding equipment can be designed together from the outset. Constraints that are more difficult to resolve during a later retrofit can thereby be avoided.
For a ship designed to allow heat recovery to be added later, these transport options are particularly important. A reserved installation position has little practical value if large components can no longer be brought inside after ship construction is complete. The route to the installation location must therefore also remain suitable. Deck openings, engine-room hatches, available lifting height and the space to manoeuvre equipment may limit the dimensions of a future module.
The selected location also affects pipe routes for hot and cold media. A relatively short connection to the heat source can help limit heat losses and pressure losses. At the same time, sufficient space must remain available for valves, pipe supports and thermal expansion. Exhaust gas pipes and pipes carrying hot media in particular may undergo substantial temperature changes during operation. If the resulting expansion is not adequately accommodated, unwanted forces may arise on heat exchangers, engine components and the ship structure.
A suitable pipe route is therefore not necessarily the shortest connection. Support, room for thermal movement and maintenance access must also be taken into account in the choice. Structural integration can also be prepared during newbuild construction. When the mass, dimensions and operating loads of the selected WHRS are known, foundations and load-bearing structural members can be matched to them. The equipment's own weight, vibration, ship motions and any forces from connected pipes also affect the design. The foundation must be able to transfer these loads safely to the ship structure.
The added mass and its position may also affect the ship's overall weight distribution and centre of gravity. Where these effects are relevant, they must be included in the ship and stability assessment. In preparation for a future installation, the final loads may not yet be known. A design envelope can then be reserved on the basis of assumptions about possible module dimensions, mass and position. Such a reservation is useful only when there is sufficient evidence that the structure can support the assumed loads. A deck area kept clear does not prove that every future module can be placed there without an additional foundation calculation.
Pipe and cable penetrations also deserve attention. At the newbuild stage, suitable routes can be provided before other equipment restricts access. The structural, watertight and fire-resisting functions of the decks and bulkheads concerned must be maintained. If the future penetration is not yet known, reserving the necessary space without already making an opening may be sensible. When the work is carried out later, an actual penetration must still be checked against the applicable requirements.
The reserved installation space and pipe routes must also remain identifiable as construction progresses. If an intended WHRS location is later used for other equipment or a pipe route is blocked, the original preparation may lose its value. These reservations must therefore remain part of design coordination. Changes to the engine-room layout must be assessed for their consequences for the planned or future WHRS.
A useful reservation must cover an installation area within the engine-room layout. It is a coordinated installation area in which equipment, foundations, pipe routes, transport options and maintenance access can actually fit together.
Which Safety and Maintenance Provisions Do You Already Include During Newbuild Construction?
In an ORC, an organic working fluid circulates in a closed loop. The properties of this fluid affect which safety arrangements are needed and where the installation can safely be placed. Depending on the working fluid, relevant factors may include flammability, potentially harmful exposure, operating pressure, material compatibility and thermal stability. Not every organic working fluid has the same properties. The required safety arrangements and requirements for the installation space may therefore differ between ORC designs.
If the ORC is selected during newbuild construction, the safety arrangements can be matched to the fluid concerned and the actual installation. Depending on the design, these may include suitable ventilation, pressure protection, leak detection where needed, containment and safe access for operation and maintenance. The position relative to hot exhaust gas pipes, electrical equipment and other engine-room installations must also be assessed. The selected location must be appropriate for the risks associated with the working fluid and operating conditions.
In preparation for a future installation, not all properties may yet be known. If the working fluid and ORC design have not yet been selected, it cannot be established without further substantiation which ventilation, detection or other safety equipment will ultimately be needed. The newbuild design can, however, identify spaces where these measures could be installed later. Reserving a suitable location may then have more value than installing safety equipment in advance whose application remains uncertain.
The original fire safety provisions, escape routes and other safety functions must also be maintained. A future ORC must not be planned for a position where necessary safety provisions become inaccessible or required boundaries cannot safely be modified. Operation during faults is another design condition. When the ORC stops while the engine is still releasing heat, thermal energy remains in heat exchangers, pipes and fluid circuits for a time.
If cooling capacity is lost, the condenser may reject insufficient heat. An electrical fault may also cause the generator to stop delivering power while heat remains available on the hot side. Under such conditions, the installation must be able to reduce output or shut down in a controlled manner. The pressure, temperature and process protection required must be matched to the selected ORC and the properties of the working fluid.
For the ship design, it is particularly important that the original engine, exhaust gas and cooling-water functions remain available when the WHRS is out of service. This may affect bypass arrangements, valves and the points at which heat exchangers are connected. Maintenance access must also be taken into account from the design stage. Exhaust gas heat exchangers may foul, reducing heat transfer and increasing flow resistance. The equipment must therefore remain accessible for inspection and any cleaning.
In an ORC, the working fluid pump, expander, generator, valves and control equipment may also need periodic maintenance or inspection. The arrangement must provide sufficient space to safely isolate, check and, where necessary, replace these components. The specific provisions must be matched to the selected technology. Product approval for an individual ORC module does not automatically mean that every onboard arrangement is permitted without further assessment.
For each ship, it must therefore be established which requirements of the classification society, flag State and other competent parties apply. At the newbuild stage, installation and safety conditions can be included in the design assessment in good time. This helps identify any lack of space for safety measures or unsuitable location for the working fluid before the engine-room layout is fixed.
Which Measurement Provisions Are Useful for Later Performance Checks?
When a WHRS produces electricity, it must be possible to identify the heat and cooling conditions during generation. At the newbuild stage, suitable measurement provisions can therefore already be included in the heat, cooling and electrical systems. On the hot side, measurement points may be needed for temperatures and flow rates. For exhaust gas heat, data on the relevant gas conditions help establish how much heat the heat exchanger receives. For engine cooling water, the temperatures and water flows of the circuits concerned are particularly important.
The measurement locations must suit the selected heat transfer arrangement. If an ORC is supplied through an intermediate circuit, the temperatures of the hot fluid at the module may be needed to determine the actual ORC operating point. The original exhaust gas temperature then cannot by itself show how much heat the ORC receives or at what temperature. The measurement points must therefore correspond sufficiently to the location at which heat is transferred to the thermodynamic process.
Suitable measurement provisions are also important on the cold side. The cooling-water temperature and available flow rate affect condenser conditions and thus electricity production. On the electrical side, the design can specify where to measure gross generator power and the relevant auxiliary consumption. A distinction can thus be made later between gross electricity production and the net contribution of the complete installation to the shipboard electrical system.
The design must identify the pumps, cooling equipment and other electrical loads within the WHRS boundary. For shared existing services, the additional electricity consumption caused by the WHRS may also be relevant to the assessment of actual energy savings. The electrical measurement points must therefore correspond to an identifiable system boundary. Measurement of generator production alone is not automatically sufficient to demonstrate net electricity generation from the complete installation.
Recording engine load and operating status may also be necessary. Lower WHRS production does not necessarily indicate a technical problem when the available heat supply or cooling conditions have changed. Recording the relevant data over the same periods helps establish whether operating conditions explain changes in electricity production.
For a future performance guarantee, additional requirements may apply to measurement points, measurement accuracy and the acceptance procedure. A general metering arrangement for operational monitoring is not automatically sufficient to demonstrate contractually guaranteed net power. If the WHRS is selected during newbuild construction, the measurement points can be matched to the final installation and any performance agreements.
In preparation for future use, not all measuring instruments need already be present. Nevertheless, the design can allow for accessible measurement points, electrical data logging and data connections. These preparations must also remain safe while no WHRS is yet connected. Unused measurement or pipe connections must not unacceptably affect the ship's original installations.
Early preparation is particularly valuable because suitable measurement provisions can be retained. A future WHRS can thus not only be connected, but its technical performance can also be assessed under the operating conditions actually encountered on board.
What Is the Difference Between Immediate WHRS Installation and Preparation for Future Use?
At the newbuild stage, a clear distinction must be made as to whether a waste heat recovery system forms part of the ship from delivery or whether only provisions for a possible future installation are prepared. When a complete WHRS is to be installed at delivery, the ship design can be matched to the selected heat exchangers, ORC module and other equipment. The required temperatures, flow rates, electrical power ratings, dimensions and masses can then be used as concrete design parameters.
The heat source connections, foundations, pipe routes, cooling and electrical provisions are then designed for the selected installation. The safety measures can also be matched to the selected working fluid and required operating conditions. The installation can be incorporated into the coordinated technical documentation during construction. After installation, the connections, control arrangements and safety functions can be tested and the selected WHRS commissioned.
In preparation for future use, important data may still be missing. The final ORC module type, required condenser capacity, generator design or working fluid may, for example, still be undecided. In that case, the emphasis is on provisions that preserve future possibilities without already assuming a particular installation. A suitable installation space can, for example, be reserved while the exhaust gas route retains sufficient scope for a later heat exchanger.
Pipe and cable routes can also be kept accessible for future connections. If the intended type of installation is sufficiently well defined, substantiated design margins or structural provisions can also be included. Preparation for future waste heat recovery therefore requires a documented design basis. The design basis sets out which heat sources are envisaged, which installation space remains available and what possible dimensions, masses, connection conditions and power ratings have been assumed.
It must also be clear which provisions have actually been installed during newbuild construction and which have only been allowed for in the layout or technical design. This distinction determines what is already available later and which components still need to be designed or installed. A heat exchanger position kept clear does not, for example, mean that the exhaust gas route has already been approved for an unknown future heat exchanger. Pressure losses, permissible cooling and the other engine conditions must later be assessed for the selected design.
The same applies to a reserved connection to the ship's cooling system. While the future condenser heat load remains unknown, it cannot be guaranteed that sufficient cooling capacity remains available. A free position in the switchboard likewise does not prove that every future WHRS generator can be connected without modifications. Electrical load capacity and protection coordination must later be established for the actual generator configuration.
If branches, valves or other provisions are already installed during newbuild construction, they must function safely while the WHRS has not yet been installed. Preparation must not create unnecessary dependency, an unwanted flow route or another limitation on the ship's original systems. Its value also depends on future operation. If the engine configuration, fuel choice or operational profile changes, heat source conditions may also differ from the original design assumptions.
During the later WHRS selection, these assumptions must therefore be checked again. The reserved space and connection options may remain valuable, but the final installation still requires its own engineering, a safety assessment and, where applicable, ship-specific approval. A ship prepared for future WHRS use is therefore not automatically suitable for every installation available later. Preparation has particular value when the design limits are recorded sufficiently concretely and the associated possibilities are preserved during construction.
When Must the WHRS Provisions Be Defined in the Ship Design?
Preparation for waste heat recovery has the greatest influence on the ship design while the engine configuration, engine-room layout, exhaust gas routes and main technical systems can still be modified. The assessment therefore starts with engine selection and the expected operating and load profiles. On that basis, it is established which heat sources may be available and which form of recovery appears technically worthwhile.
This initial heat and energy balance guides subsequent design choices. If exhaust gas heat is an important source, the design team must establish early where a heat exchanger can be incorporated within the permitted engine limits. For ORC electricity production, it must also become clear where the module can be placed, how heat is supplied and which cooling and electrical connection are needed. These choices affect the engine-room layout and must therefore be assessed together sufficiently early.
Once the main equipment is known, the installation positions and necessary pipe and cable routes can be developed in more detail. The dimensions, masses, foundations, maintenance clearances and means of bringing equipment on board must suit the selected design. The ship's cooling system must also be assessed in good time. The required condenser heat rejection depends on the available heat supply and selected ORC configuration. If WHRS capacity changes, the required cooling-water flow rates, pipe diameters and heat exchanger capacities may also change.
The electrical connection must likewise be compatible with the ship's expected power and operating strategy. The available heat, cooling capacity and electrical demand must be assessed for the same relevant operating modes. If the hot side, condenser and generator are each matched separately to different favourable conditions, a configuration may arise that does not meet all the assumptions simultaneously during actual ship operation. The different system components must therefore be assessed as one coordinated installation.
Before the engine-room layout and main pipe routes are finalized, it must be clear which spaces and connection options are needed for the WHRS. For a system to be installed immediately, this concerns the actual equipment and associated provisions. In preparation for a future installation, the necessary reservations must remain identifiable as construction progresses. The arrangements must be specific enough to prevent a reserved installation position, transport opening or pipe route from later being used for other equipment without this being noticed.
The allocation of responsibilities between the ship designer, shipyard, engine supplier and any WHRS supplier also deserves attention. An exhaust gas heat exchanger may, for example, use part of the allowable back-pressure margin, while an ORC condenser changes the heat balance of the ship's central cooling system. If these interfaces are investigated only after the pipes, pumps or switchboards have been finally selected, major design changes may still be needed.
The technical design assumptions must therefore be kept up to date throughout design and construction. Changes in engine design, fuel choice, cooling-water configuration or electrical distribution may affect both the selected and reserved WHRS provisions. For a WHRS installed at delivery, further engineering is based on the selected equipment. This includes the necessary technical assessments and any approvals specific to the ship.
Where only preparation for future use takes place, the provisions actually installed and the reservations retained must remain identifiable in the final handover documentation. It can thus be established later what the design already allows for and which aspects must be investigated again. The main design decision is therefore not to install extra connections everywhere in advance during newbuild construction. What matters is which provisions are technically worthwhile on the basis of the expected heat supply, how much space and capacity may be needed for them and how these possibilities are preserved during construction.
For immediate WHRS installation, this means that heat sources, exhaust gas routes, cooling, electrical distribution, structure and safety are matched together to the selected equipment. In preparation for future use, suitable installation spaces, pipe routes and connection options are reserved in good time and in a verifiable way, without assuming that an installation selected later has thereby already been fully designed or approved.
Provisions for waste heat recovery can thus form an identifiable part of the ship design from the newbuild stage. The original technical and operational functions are maintained, while it is clear which possibilities actually exist for immediate installation or later use.
This Article in the Series
At the newbuild stage, space, connections and foundations can be prepared early, whereas for integration of a WHRS into an existing ship, these provisions often have to be adapted to existing constraints. Alongside the technical connections, access also deserves attention, including for the maintenance needed to preserve WHRS performance. How these design choices relate to maintenance access and approvals specific to the ship is addressed within installation, maintenance and regulations for WHRS installations.