How Do You Define What Is Measured Under a WHRS Performance Guarantee?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
A performance guarantee for a waste heat recovery system can be verified reliably only if the guaranteed performance, the measurement point and the operating conditions covered by the guarantee are defined in advance. For a waste heat recovery system (WHRS), the stated power may refer to gross electrical power at the generator, net power at the module or the electrical power the complete system delivers to the shipboard electrical system. These values are not necessarily equivalent.
The available heat supply, cooling conditions and the system's own electricity consumption also affect measured performance. A lower electrical power reading during an acceptance test therefore does not automatically mean that the installation is underperforming. The conditions may differ from those on which the guarantee is based. Conversely, a shortcoming in the supplied installation must not be attributed to unsuitable test conditions without further assessment.
The guaranteed quantity, system boundary, reference conditions, measurement procedure and assessment rules must therefore be aligned in advance. It must also be clear which party is responsible for the equipment needed to carry out the agreed test. This establishes what the supplier must demonstrate, under what conditions and when the measurements provide enough evidence to assess whether the guarantee has been met.
What Performance Is Guaranteed for a Waste Heat Recovery System?
A waste heat recovery system uses heat from exhaust gases or engine cooling water, for example. To generate electricity, a thermodynamic process converts some of that heat into mechanical power to drive a generator. Electrical power can be measured at different points in the installation. A power guarantee is therefore incomplete unless it specifies which quantity is guaranteed.
For an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), gross generator output may, for example, be guaranteed. This is the power the generator produces before the full allowance for the system's relevant electrical consumption is made. For net performance, the consumption of the working fluid pump, any circulation pumps and other necessary equipment must also be taken into account. However, a guarantee of net module power may cover a different output from a guarantee of net power for the complete WHRS. If an ORC module does not include certain pumps or cooling equipment, these may fall outside the stated net value. It must therefore be clear whether the guarantee relates to the module's electrical connection or to the complete system as used on board.
Electrical power and electrical energy must also be distinguished. A power guarantee in kilowatts electrical (kWe) describes what power the installation must be able to deliver under defined conditions. A guarantee for energy generation, expressed in kilowatt-hours (kWh), relates to electricity production over a particular period. The energy delivered depends on operating duration, part-load performance and any interruptions as well as the available power. Guaranteed power at one operating point is therefore not automatically a guarantee for annual electricity production. Annual output depends in part on engine load, available heat, cooling conditions and periods in which the installation cannot operate. If annual energy production is also guaranteed, the corresponding operating hours, availability and other assumptions must be defined separately.
A fuel savings guarantee covers a different measure of performance. Measured net electricity generation does not directly demonstrate how much less fuel the ship consumes as a result. This requires establishing which existing generation is displaced and how fuel consumption changes in the engines affected. Additional losses or changes in other shipboard systems may also affect the result. For direct heat use, the guarantee may relate to useful thermal power transferred. That requires a different basis for measurement from the one used for electricity generation. For a steam-based WHRS too, thermal and electrical performance must remain separately identifiable.
For an ORC-based WHRS, a guarantee for net electrical power under clearly defined heat and cooling conditions may provide a useful starting point. The performance actually guaranteed depends on the agreed scope of supply and contract terms. The promised performance must therefore be described as an unambiguous, measurable quantity. The definition must specify whether the guarantee covers power that must be maintained over an agreed test period, an amount of energy produced or another specifically defined performance measure.
Why Must the Electrical System Boundary Be Defined in Advance?
The electrical system boundary determines which equipment and energy flows form part of the guaranteed performance. This is particularly important if the WHRS consists of a separate ORC module, additional heat exchangers, circulation pumps and equipment connected to existing shipboard systems. A generator may, for example, deliver a given electrical output while the installation simultaneously uses electricity to circulate the working fluid. If only generator power is measured, the installation's own consumption is excluded from the result. For a net electrical power guarantee, it must therefore be clear which loads are deducted and where the net electrical power must be available.
In some designs, the necessary auxiliary components are housed within the module. Other installations have separate intermediate circuit pumps, additional cooling-water pumps or other equipment. Net module power may consequently cover different equipment depending on the configuration. The system boundary must therefore be linked to the actual electrical single-line diagram. The diagram must show where generator output is measured, which auxiliary loads are recorded separately and at which connection point the net electrical contribution is determined.
A measurement at the generator output may give a different value from a measurement downstream of the power electronics or at the connection point with the shipboard electrical system. Whether transformer losses and other electrical losses are included must therefore also be apparent from the agreed system boundary. If all relevant energy flows pass through one common connection point, a suitable bidirectional energy meter can record the net electrical exchange at that point. If certain auxiliary components are connected through other supplies, their consumption must be measured separately or accounted for using a method agreed in advance.
Existing shipboard equipment raises a further question about how to account for its consumption. A cooling-water pump may, for example, have been operating before the WHRS was installed. If this pump consumes more electricity because of the new connection, the change in its consumption is particularly relevant to the additional net contribution. Attributing the pump's entire existing electrical load to the WHRS without further assessment may underestimate that additional contribution. Conversely, extra consumption must not be disregarded because the pump was already present. It must therefore be agreed in advance whether the total electricity consumption of such equipment falls within the guarantee or only the additional load that arises because of the WHRS.
If that change cannot be measured directly, the calculation method must also be defined. For the calculation, the reference conditions are important because the consumption of existing pumps may also change with different engine loads, cooling-water flow rates or temperature controls. The allocation of shared auxiliary consumption must be agreed before the test. An allocation decided retrospectively may affect the result of the guarantee assessment. The agreed method must therefore already be clear before the performance measurement.
The same consumption must be deducted only once. If a net module measurement already includes the working fluid pump's electricity consumption, that pump's consumption must not be deducted again. Other necessary loads outside this measurement boundary must, however, be included if the guarantee relates to the net contribution of the complete system. The limits of the scope of supply must be defined alongside the electrical measurement boundary. If a supplier provides only the ORC module and the shipowner is responsible for certain pumps or cooling equipment, it must be clear which performance falls within the supplier's responsibility and under which conditions the other shipboard systems are assessed.
The scope of supply and the electrical system boundary need not coincide. A guarantee for the complete electrical contribution may, for example, also depend on existing equipment supplied or managed by another party. The parties must agree in advance how to account for that dependency. A technically verifiable guarantee therefore links the promised performance to both the physical measurement points and the agreed responsibilities. This establishes which energy flows are measured, which corrections are permitted and what the supplier must demonstrate.
Which Heat Source Conditions Apply to the Guaranteed Performance?
The electrical power of a WHRS depends on the heat that can actually be supplied to the thermodynamic process. A performance guarantee therefore cannot be considered separately from the conditions under which this heat is available. For recovery from exhaust gases, relevant factors include the gas temperature, mass flow rate and allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature. Together, these determine how much thermal power can be extracted from the exhaust gas stream. A high exhaust gas temperature alone provides insufficient information because the gas flow rate and the allowable temperature drop also matter.
Engine load provides an important starting point, but does not fully describe the heat conditions. Two engines delivering similar power may have different exhaust gas flow rates and temperatures. Even for the same engine, changes in engine speed, control or operating conditions may affect the available heat supply. The guarantee must therefore state which heat source conditions apply as the reference. If a particular net electrical power is guaranteed at a defined engine load, the assumed temperature, flow rate and heat available within technical limits must also be known. Specifying engine load as a percentage alone may be insufficient to establish later whether the agreed thermal conditions were present during the test.
The location of the measurement points is also important. Exhaust gas temperature immediately after the turbocharger may differ from the temperature at a heat exchanger further downstream. If intervening equipment already absorbs heat or requires a particular temperature, this affects the heat the WHRS actually receives. For an ORC with a separate water or thermal-oil circuit, it must therefore be clear the point at which the heat supply conditions for the guarantee are determined. Exhaust gas temperature at the primary heat exchanger is not the same as the temperature of the medium supplied to the ORC module through the intermediate circuit.
Temperature differences are needed for heat transfer between these points, and heat losses may occur. The thermal power extracted from the original heat source may consequently differ from the thermal power ultimately transferred to the ORC working fluid. The guarantee may relate to defined conditions at the original heat source or to the state of the medium supplied to the ORC module. Both approaches may be technically valid, but have different implications for the assessment of the intervening heat exchangers and equipment.
Different data are relevant for recovery from engine cooling water. The available temperature, flow rate and permissible heat extraction determine how much heat can be transferred to the installation. The specified engine temperatures, necessary cooling-water circulation and original temperature control must be maintained. A performance guarantee must therefore not assume heat extraction that would require the engine to operate outside its permitted operating conditions. The reference conditions must be compatible with the technical limits of the existing engine installation.
If several heat sources are combined, their conditions when used together must also be known. An ORC receiving both exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat may perform differently at the same total thermal power if the heat is distributed differently between the sources. The temperatures and locations at which heat is transferred to the working fluid affect the thermodynamic operating point. It must therefore be clear which heat sources must be available simultaneously during the acceptance test.
For a ship with several engines, the assumed combination of engines and distribution of load for the guaranteed performance must also be recorded. During the test, it must be possible to establish whether those conditions actually occur. If the WHRS uses heat from generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity the WHRS generates, engine load may also change. In that case, the actual electrical and thermal operating point at which performance is assessed must be clear. The assumed heat availability must correspond to the engine operation that occurs during the test.
Finally, the reference conditions must be achievable within the ship's permitted operating limits. Without additional agreements, a guarantee dependent on heat conditions that cannot be achieved within acceptable technical limits during the intended operation does not provide a suitable basis for acceptance. The required heat source conditions, responsibility for making them available and treatment of any deviations must therefore be defined together.
How Are Cooling Conditions and Electrical Offtake Defined?
Cooling conditions also affect the electrical power a WHRS can deliver. In a condensing steam cycle or ORC, most of the heat not converted into mechanical power must be rejected through the condenser. In an ORC, condensing temperature partly determines the pressure against which the working fluid expands. If the cooling water becomes warmer, condensing pressure may rise. The usable expansion range may narrow and electrical output may fall, even if the available heat on the hot side remains the same.
Guaranteed electrical power must therefore be linked to defined cooling conditions. Relevant conditions include the cooling-water inlet temperature, the available flow rate, the required heat rejection and any other relevant temperature requirements. The location at which these data are established must also be clear. The water temperature outside the ship may differ from the cooling-water temperature at the condenser inlet. If the WHRS is connected to a central cooling-water system, other equipment using the same cooling system may affect the temperature and the cooling capacity available.
The reference conditions must therefore relate to the cooling actually available at the condenser. Lower electricity production with warmer cooling water does not automatically mean that the WHRS fails to meet the guarantee if the guarantee is based on a different, defined cooling-water temperature. Conversely, a test under exceptionally favourable cooling conditions may give a higher electrical power reading than during normal operation. Such a result must also be assessed according to the agreed reference conditions.
The electrical load must also be sufficient to use the available output. A WHRS can deliver the technically available generator power only if the shipboard electrical system can accept that output and the electrical operating strategy permits it. At low electrical demand, the power management system may limit WHRS production. A lower power reading then need not reflect the maximum output that would be possible under the same heat and cooling conditions.
The electrical operating conditions required for the acceptance test must therefore be specified. If the guarantee relates to maximum net power, the test must allow the WHRS to deliver that power within the permitted electrical operating limits. If the usual onboard load is insufficient for this, a suitable additional electrical load may be applied. This requires a separate assessment of the electrical installation, connections and safety. A temporary load must not be connected to the shipboard electrical system without further approval.
It must also be defined how a limitation imposed by the shipboard electrical system is identified. The measurements must show whether lower electrical power results from insufficient heat, limited condenser capacity, a technical WHRS limit or insufficient electrical load. The allocation of responsibility is important here. If the supplier also provides the condenser and necessary cooling equipment, insufficient cooling may have a different significance from a case in which the cooling capacity must be provided by the ship under the agreement.
The guarantee test therefore has combined requirements for the hot side, the cold side and electrical load. During acceptance, it must be established whether these conditions were present, whether deviations can be corrected using the agreed method and which party is responsible if necessary equipment does not function according to the agreement.
What Must Be Included in the Measurement and Acceptance Protocol in Advance?
A technically verifiable performance guarantee requires a measurement and acceptance protocol defined with sufficient precision before testing. This ensures that the parties decide before the test which data count, which corrections apply and which operating conditions qualify as representative. The protocol starts with the guaranteed quantity and system boundary. The electrical measurement points, auxiliary loads to be recorded and method for calculating net power follow from these. It must also be clear whether the guarantee relates to average power over a particular measurement period, an amount of electrical energy or another agreed performance measure.
The reference conditions and requirements for a valid test are then defined. For a power guarantee under steady operating conditions, it may be necessary for engine load, heat supply, cooling and electrical load to remain sufficiently constant throughout the assessment period. How steady these conditions must be depends on the characteristics of the selected installation. An ORC that stores a substantial amount of heat may, for example, need time to reach a new steady operating point after a change in the heat source.
The measurement duration is therefore also determined in advance. An instantaneous power reading may be affected by brief control adjustments and changes in heat supply. An appropriate measurement period allows assessment of the performance that the installation must be able to maintain under the agreed conditions. There is no universal measurement duration suitable for every WHRS. The selected period must match the purpose of the test and the dynamic behaviour of the system being tested.
The protocol also defines which data are recorded simultaneously. Depending on the configuration, engine load, hot-side temperatures and flow rates, cooling-water data, gross generator power, relevant auxiliary consumption and WHRS operating status may be necessary. The measuring instruments must be suitable for the agreed performance and the electrical and thermal characteristics of the installation. Calibration, measurement range, accuracy and the locations of measurement points must be known in sufficient detail for the results to be processed reliably.
If data from different measurement and monitoring systems are combined, their timestamps must also be aligned. Generator power, auxiliary consumption and the associated heat and cooling conditions must be established over the same assessment period. The protocol must also state how to account for start-up, reduced output and shutdown. For a guarantee of net power during steady operation, these periods may fall outside the assessment window, provided that this has been agreed in advance. For a guarantee of energy production over a longer period, the same operating phases may instead form part of the guaranteed performance.
The test period must not be selected retrospectively solely on the basis of the times with the highest electricity production. It must therefore be clear in advance when the assessment period starts and ends and under which conditions a measurement is interrupted or must be repeated. The treatment of missing, invalid or anomalous measurements must also be defined. If certain values are estimated or reconstructed, it must be clear whether the agreed acceptance method permits this.
A factory test and an acceptance test on board do not necessarily demonstrate the same performance. A Factory Acceptance Test (FAT) can demonstrate that the supplied module or particular components function under the agreed conditions. However, the complete WHRS on board may include additional heat exchangers, pumps, electrical connections and cooling equipment. If the guarantee relates to complete-system performance, testing on board may therefore be necessary, for example during the Site Acceptance Test (SAT) or a separately agreed performance test. The test must correspond to the installation and system boundary covered by the guarantee.
It must also be clear who carries out the test, which parties are permitted to check the results and how the original measurement data are made available. If an independent witness or assessor is involved, their role must be defined in advance. Finally, the protocol describes how to derive the agreed result from the measurements and which decision rule to apply. The correction method, measurement uncertainty and any performance tolerance must be consistent with the predefined acceptance criterion.
The measurement and acceptance protocol therefore links the promised performance to the actual evidence. The instruments matter, and particular attention must be given to the agreed rules for conducting the test, deciding which data are valid and assessing the result.
How Are Deviations from the Reference Conditions Assessed?
During an acceptance test, actual operating conditions may differ from the reference conditions on which the performance guarantee is based. Engine load may, for example, be lower than expected, with less waste heat becoming available as a result. Cooling-water temperature may also be higher than the agreed value, so that the ORC operates under different condensing conditions. Electrical output may therefore change even if the WHRS is performing as expected. Comparing measured net power directly with the guaranteed value may then lead to an incorrect judgement.
It must therefore be agreed in advance how deviations from the reference conditions are handled. One possibility is that a measurement is valid only if operating conditions remain within defined limits. Another is to adjust the measured performance to the reference conditions using a method agreed in advance. Such a correction must match how the system actually performs. In an ORC, electrical power does not necessarily change in proportion to thermal input power. The effects of cooling-water temperature, flow rate and condensing pressure also depend on the particular cycle and control strategy.
A general percentage correction for every deviation in engine load or cooling-water temperature therefore provides insufficient technical assurance. The correction method must be substantiated with suitable performance data or a calculation model whose range of applicability is known. The assessment must establish which quantities have actually changed. If exhaust gas temperature differs during the test, gas flow rate may also be different. A correction based solely on temperature may then be insufficient to describe the change in available heat supply.
The same applies to the cold side. If both flow rate and cooling-water inlet temperature differ from the reference values, the assessment must determine whether the agreed correction method still applies to the actual condenser conditions. The range over which the correction is valid matters. A performance model substantiated for a particular heat and cooling range must not be used without further verification for conditions clearly outside that range.
A correction must not assume performance that the installation cannot deliver within its technical operating limits. If maximum generator capacity or permitted process pressure imposes a limit, for example, that limit must not be disregarded by applying a theoretical correction. The protocol must therefore distinguish between measurements that can be compared directly with the guarantee, measurements requiring a permitted correction and measurements that are unsuitable for assessing the guarantee.
These agreements must be in place before the test. If a different correction factor or calculation method is selected after a disappointing result, the outcome may become dependent on the desired assessment rather than a reproducible technical method. Deviations from the reference conditions therefore do not automatically mean that a test has failed. It must first be established whether the conditions still fall within the agreed assessment limits and whether a valid correction is possible.
If no valid correction can be applied, a further measurement under more suitable conditions may be needed. A separate assessment must establish why the required conditions were absent during the original test and which contract terms apply.
What Role Do Measurement Uncertainty and Acceptance Criteria Play?
Even if the correct measurement points are used and operating conditions correspond sufficiently to the reference conditions, every measurement still carries uncertainty. The accuracy of electrical measuring instruments, the recording of operating data and any calculations of auxiliary consumption affect the reliability of the net power figure. For a WHRS, net performance may be determined as the difference between gross generator power and the relevant auxiliary electrical loads. If the two quantities are measured separately, the uncertainties of those measurements propagate into the calculated net result.
This is particularly important if the difference between the measured power values is relatively small. Even a small uncertainty in each measurement may then be large relative to the net power. Measurement uncertainty also becomes important if measured performance is close to the guaranteed value. Actual performance cannot be inferred from the measurement data with unlimited accuracy.
The electricity meter's accuracy class is only one contributor to uncertainty. Current and voltage transformers, electrical connections, calibration, measurement duration, timekeeping and any correction calculations may also contribute to total uncertainty. If additional consumption by shared auxiliary equipment is not measured directly but determined by comparing operating conditions, that method also introduces uncertainty. The calculated contribution must be sufficiently traceable and consistent with the agreed system boundary.
For a formal performance guarantee, measurement uncertainty, performance tolerance and the acceptance criterion must therefore be clearly distinguished. Measurement uncertainty indicates how closely the measured result can be expected to represent the actual performance. Any performance tolerance indicates which deviation from the promised value is permitted under the agreement. The acceptance criterion sets the rule for deciding whether measured performance meets the guarantee.
These concepts serve different purposes. Measurement uncertainty does not automatically constitute a permitted performance tolerance. Nor does a measurement result close to the guarantee limit mean, without further assessment, that the installation has been accepted or rejected. A decision rule describing how the measured value, any corrections and measurement uncertainty are used must therefore be defined in advance. Depending on this rule, a result may provide sufficient evidence for acceptance, demonstrate a performance shortfall or provide insufficient certainty for a definitive conclusion.
The parties must also agree what to do if a result is inconclusive. It may, for example, be necessary to repeat the measurement under more suitable conditions or collect additional data. There is no universal measurement uncertainty or performance tolerance that automatically applies to every WHRS performance guarantee. The accuracy needed depends on the guaranteed performance, measurement method and agreed acceptance conditions.
The assessment must also remain verifiable. The final judgement must be traceable to the original measurement records, the corrections applied, the uncertainty calculation and the decision rule agreed in advance. A performance guarantee therefore does not become more reliable through accurate measuring instruments alone. Above all, the combination of suitable measurements and predefined acceptance rules determines whether the outcome can be assessed objectively.
When Is an Acceptance Measurement Invalid, and When Is the Guarantee Not Met?
In WHRS performance verification, a distinction must be made between a measurement that is unsuitable for assessing the guarantee and a valid measurement showing that the agreed performance was not achieved. An acceptance measurement may, for example, be unsuitable if the required heat source conditions are absent. If the engine supplies less heat during the test than assumed in the guarantee, that may explain the lower electrical output. If the deviation falls outside the agreed limits and no valid correction method is available, the measurement may provide insufficient evidence to establish whether the guaranteed performance was achieved.
Insufficient electrical load may also limit the assessment. If the shipboard electrical system limits WHRS output, the maximum power technically achievable under the available heat and cooling conditions may not be measured. Errors in the measurement arrangement or data recording may also make a reliable comparison impossible. If the consumption of a required auxiliary cannot be established or the measurement data do not relate to the same period, it may be impossible to determine net power under the protocol.
However, these circumstances do not automatically release the supplier from the performance obligation. It must first be established why the necessary test conditions were absent and which party is responsible for those circumstances under the agreement. If the engine cannot provide the agreed heat source conditions because of circumstances outside the agreed WHRS scope of supply, a different test period or a permitted correction may be needed.
The assessment is different if a heat exchanger provided by the supplier transfers insufficient heat, a supplied pump fails to achieve the required flow rate or the WHRS control system unnecessarily limits electricity production. The cause may then lie within the supplied installation itself. The same situation may therefore both affect the validity of a particular power measurement and provide a reason to investigate technical performance or supply obligations separately. It must therefore be clear which party is responsible for the heat source, cooling, electrical load and other necessary test equipment.
The parties must also agree in advance what happens if one of these conditions is not met. An invalid or inconclusive measurement does not in itself prove that the guarantee has been met, but neither does it prove that the supplier has fallen short. The cause of the deviation and the agreed responsibilities must be assessed before drawing a conclusion.
If the test conditions do meet the agreed requirements, a valid measurement may demonstrate that the guaranteed performance has not been achieved. If net power established using the agreed method remains below the applicable acceptance limit, this provides a technical basis for identifying a performance shortfall. The permitted corrections and agreed treatment of measurement uncertainty must be applied. A momentary drop in power, for example, is not automatically sufficient if the guarantee relates to average net power over a defined measurement period.
The cause of a confirmed performance shortfall may also be technically relevant. Lower net production may be associated with insufficient heat transfer, different process conditions, higher auxiliary consumption or cold-side limitations. The measurement data must help distinguish these causes. The consequences of a confirmed performance shortfall depend on the agreement and the responsibilities of the parties concerned. The technical measurement results provide the supporting evidence for this, but do not determine all contractual consequences on their own.
A test that cannot be used to assess the guarantee may need to be repeated. The protocol must describe under which conditions a test is repeated, which data must be recorded again and how the results are assessed. If a performance shortfall has been demonstrated, other agreed next steps may apply. This may involve repairing the system and repeating the acceptance test. The specific rights, obligations and consequences follow from the applicable agreement.
An invalid test, an inconclusive result and a demonstrated performance shortfall must therefore not be confused. These outcomes describe different situations and may lead to different next steps. A reliable guarantee assessment first establishes whether the measurement is valid under the agreed protocol. The necessary corrections and assessment rules are then applied. Only then is there a basis for a technical conclusion and an assessment of what it means under the agreement.
How Do You Make a WHRS Performance Guarantee Technically Verifiable?
A technically verifiable WHRS performance guarantee starts with an unambiguous description of the promised performance. For electricity production, it must be clear whether this means gross generator power, net module power or net electrical power from the complete installation. If the guarantee relates to energy produced, the assessment period and associated operating conditions must also be defined. The electrical system boundary is then determined. The measurement points, auxiliary loads and any existing shipboard equipment must be described so that net performance can be established using one predefined method.
The reference conditions and responsibilities are then agreed. The heat source, available cooling and electrical load must match the conditions under which the guaranteed performance is expected. It must also be clear which equipment the supplier provides and which falls under the responsibility of other parties involved. The measurement and acceptance protocol links these conditions to the conduct of the test. The measurement period, required stability of the operating conditions, data recording and treatment of transient periods must be described in advance. The same applies to any corrections if operating conditions differ from the agreed reference conditions.
The acceptance criteria determine how the measured result is assessed. Measurement uncertainty, any performance tolerance and the conditions for a valid test must be clear enough to apply in the assessment. It must also be defined what happens if the test cannot be carried out, is inconclusive or demonstrates a performance shortfall.
The difference from an ordinary performance measurement is therefore fundamental. An electrical measurement shows how much power or energy the WHRS delivered under particular conditions. A performance guarantee defines in advance what performance must be demonstrated, under what conditions and which rule is used to assess the result.
A carefully defined WHRS performance guarantee therefore prevents confusion between gross and net power and between different heat and cooling conditions. It also establishes the conditions for a valid assessment and who is responsible for any deviations. The technical value of the guarantee therefore does not lie solely in the promised number of kilowatts. What matters is that the guaranteed performance can be established in a repeatable and verifiable way under achievable conditions agreed in advance. Only then can a valid test establish conclusively whether the guarantee has been met.
This Article in the Series
A WHRS performance guarantee is verifiable only when net power, reference conditions and measurement boundaries have been defined unambiguously in advance. The assessment must account for electricity production under varying engine load, because the available heat supply affects the measurement results. Whether the required heat exchangers, connections and measurement arrangements can actually be provided is discussed in the article on integrating a WHRS into an existing ship. In this way, WHRS sizing and performance assessment links the promised performance to what can be achieved in practice.