What Maintenance Is Required to Preserve the Performance of a Waste Heat Recovery System?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
To preserve the performance of a waste heat recovery system, the heat exchangers, cooling arrangements and other components must be checked regularly and maintained where necessary. In a waste heat recovery system (Waste Heat Recovery System, WHRS), fouling, wear, leakage and control deviations can reduce heat transfer or electrical output.
Particularly in waste heat recovery using an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), net electrical power depends on the condition of several components. A fouled heat exchanger may limit heat absorption, while reduced condenser performance may lower expander power. The working fluid, pumps, generator, valves and protective devices also require maintenance suited to their technical design and operating conditions.
However, lower electricity production does not automatically mean that maintenance is needed. Changes in engine load, available waste heat, cooling-water temperature and electrical demand can have the same effects without any technical deterioration of a component. Good WHRS maintenance therefore combines prescribed periodic work with condition monitoring and performance comparisons under sufficiently comparable operating conditions. In this way, it can be established where maintenance is needed and whether the installation subsequently operates within its expected operating range again.
Why Can WHRS Performance Deteriorate During Operation?
A waste heat recovery system is designed to recover a usable amount of energy under specified heat and cooling conditions. During prolonged operation, the condition of the system may change. Heat transfer surfaces may become fouled, mechanical components may wear and control devices may function less accurately. These changes need not immediately cause a fault. A heat exchanger may, for example, gradually transfer less heat while the installation otherwise appears to function normally. Under the same heat-source conditions, the ORC may consequently absorb less thermal power and then produce less electricity.
In an ORC, energy conversion begins with the transfer of waste heat to the working fluid. An expander then converts some of this energy into mechanical power for the generator, after which the remaining heat is rejected through the condenser. Pumps and controls ensure that the necessary circulation and operating conditions are maintained. The operation of these components is therefore closely interrelated. When one component functions less effectively, the operating point of the entire installation may change. Reduced heat transfer on the hot side may, for example, result in less heat input or different evaporating conditions. If the condenser rejects insufficient heat, the condensing pressure may instead rise and the available expansion range may decrease.
Both situations may reduce generator production, but they do not require the same maintenance work. Cleaning an exhaust gas heat exchanger, for example, does not help if the main limitation is caused by insufficient cooling-water circulation on the condenser side. The installation's own electricity consumption also plays a role. Gross generator production may remain relatively stable while net power decreases because pumps or other auxiliary equipment use more electricity. For a reliable assessment, both generator production and the relevant auxiliary consumption must therefore be included.
A distinction must also be made between performance loss and availability. A WHRS may continue to function for a long time with gradually declining net electricity generation. Conversely, the installation may perform well under suitable operating conditions but be available for fewer hours because of technical faults. Both effects influence annual energy output. Lower production during operation reduces the amount of usable energy per hour, while unplanned downtime limits the number of production hours. Maintenance must therefore support both technical performance and availability, without treating normal changes in operating conditions as deterioration of the installation.
How Does Exhaust Gas Heat Exchanger Fouling Affect Performance?
For exhaust gas heat recovery, the heat exchanger is a key maintenance item. The hot exhaust gases flow past heat transfer surfaces and release some of their thermal energy to the connected circuit. Depending on the fuel, combustion conditions and heat exchanger design, soot, ash and other deposits may form on these surfaces during operation. A layer of deposits creates additional thermal resistance between the exhaust gases and the medium receiving the heat. Heat transfer may consequently decrease, even if exhaust gas mass flow rate and gas temperature remain comparable. In an ORC, less heat may therefore become available on the hot side, as a result of which evaporation conditions and electricity production change without the ORC module itself being defective.
Fouling may at the same time increase flow resistance. If deposits narrow the available flow passages, the pressure drop across the heat exchanger may increase. This pressure drop contributes to the engine's total exhaust back pressure. The consequences may therefore extend beyond lower WHRS output, because an unacceptably high back pressure may also affect engine operation.
Both heat transfer and flow resistance must therefore be monitored during maintenance. The pressure drop across the heat exchanger and the relevant exhaust gas temperatures can help identify changes in technical condition. An increasing pressure drop at comparable gas flow rates may, for example, warrant checking for fouling. Decreasing heat transfer under sufficiently comparable heat-source conditions may also indicate fouling. For this purpose, the temperatures and flow rates of the receiving medium can be used to establish how much heat is actually transferred.
However, these changes need not occur to the same extent. A deposit may noticeably limit heat transfer without immediately causing a large pressure increase. Conversely, a local flow restriction may increase pressure loss while thermal performance changes less markedly. Both properties must therefore be assessed separately. A higher pressure drop at a greater exhaust gas flow rate is not in itself evidence of fouling.
In certain exhaust gas heat exchangers and exhaust gas boilers, soot accumulation may also pose a safety risk. If sufficient combustible deposits are present and suitable ignition conditions arise, a soot fire may occur. Designs with heat transfer surfaces susceptible to this particularly require attention to the combination of fouling, high temperatures and the necessary circulation. This risk does not apply to every WHRS heat exchanger to the same extent. The required protective devices, inspections and cleaning arrangements must therefore suit the specific design and the manufacturer's requirements.
How and when the heat exchanger is cleaned depends on its susceptibility to fouling and its technical design. Depending on the design, soot-blowing equipment or other suitable cleaning methods may be provided. The chosen method must remove deposits without damaging the heat transfer surfaces, pipe connections or downstream exhaust gas equipment. Any aftertreatment equipment present may also affect the maintenance procedure. If deposits are released during cleaning, it must be assessed whether they could affect other components in the exhaust gas path. The work must therefore be suited to the complete exhaust gas installation.
Corrosion deserves attention alongside deposits. At sufficiently low local surface temperatures, condensates that attack certain materials may form, depending on the exhaust gas composition. Inspection must therefore focus not only on removing fouling but also on the condition of metal surfaces, connections and any condensate handling equipment. A fixed cleaning interval is not suitable for every installation. Fuel, engine load, exhaust gas conditions and heat exchanger geometry affect how quickly fouling develops. The maintenance requirements and the observed technical condition therefore jointly determine when inspection or cleaning is needed.
What Maintenance Do the Water Side and Other Heat Exchangers Require?
Fouling can also reduce heat transfer in recovery from engine cooling water or other water-based heat sources. Deposits on the heat transfer surfaces increase thermal resistance and may reduce the available flow area. The nature of this fouling differs from that on the exhaust gas side. Scale-like deposits, corrosion products and other contaminants may occur in water circuits. Which problems arise depends on water quality, operating temperatures, the materials used and the circuit arrangement.
A heat exchanger that gradually becomes fouled may transfer less heat at comparable temperatures and flow rates. The receiving medium may then absorb less heat than expected. In an ORC, this may affect the source temperature and the amount of heat ultimately available at the module. Pressure loss may also increase if deposits increase flow resistance. If the pump and its controls do not fully compensate for this change, the flow rate may decrease. The lower heat transfer may then be caused both by fouled surfaces and by reduced circulation.
To distinguish between these effects, temperatures, flow rates and pressure differences are assessed under comparable operating conditions as far as possible. A higher pressure drop need not result solely from deposits; it may also be associated with a greater flow rate or a different valve position. Water quality also deserves attention. Water treatment must suit the cooling-water installation concerned, the heat exchanger materials and the requirements of the engine and component manufacturers. Unsuitable water quality may promote corrosion and deposits, reducing heat transfer and reliability.
If the heat is transported through a separate water or thermal-oil circuit, the properties of that heat transfer fluid must also be assessed. Depending on the design, contamination, changes in fluid quality, leakage or insufficient circulation may affect heat transfer. In this context, a thermal-oil circuit does not automatically require the same maintenance as a water circuit. The medium used, operating temperatures, seals and any filters determine which checks are needed. The maintenance procedure must therefore suit the properties of the circuit concerned.
Internal leakage in heat exchangers also deserves attention. If a heat exchanger is damaged, fluid may pass from one circuit into the other, depending on the pressure difference between the circuits. This may affect the quality of both media, process operation and safety. Inspection must therefore not focus solely on visible external leakage. Changes in the quantity, pressure or composition of the medium may also, under certain circumstances, give reason to investigate the leak-tightness of a heat exchanger.
Which cleaning method is suitable depends on the type of heat exchanger and the nature of the fouling. In certain plate heat exchangers, cleaning without complete dismantling may be possible, while other circumstances require mechanical inspection or cleaning. The cleaning agents used and the work performed must suit the materials, seals and manufacturer's requirements. A method suitable for one heat exchanger may cause damage or leakage in another design.
Lower heat transfer must also not automatically be attributed to fouling. If the engine produces less heat or temperature control functions differently, the same heat exchanger may transfer less heat without its technical condition having deteriorated. Targeted maintenance therefore begins with an assessment of the heat source, circulation and heat transfer. Determining what has actually changed is a prerequisite to deciding whether to investigate fouling, leakage or another technical problem.
How Do You Keep the Condenser and Ship Cooling System in Good Condition?
The condenser directly affects ORC electricity production. After expansion, the working fluid must be cooled enough to condense back into a liquid. The condenser transfers the heat that must be removed for this purpose to the available cooling medium. If this heat transfer decreases, the condensing temperature may rise. Depending on the cycle, the condensing pressure may consequently also increase and the available expansion range may decrease. The generator may then deliver less electrical power while almost the same thermal power remains available on the hot side.
Condenser fouling can therefore limit electricity production. In performance monitoring, the cold side consequently deserves as much attention as the heat exchangers through which the original waste heat is absorbed. The maintenance required depends on the cooling-water configuration. In a water-cooled condenser, deposits, corrosion and the condition of the heat transfer surfaces may be important. Filters, strainers and other equipment present may also require maintenance if fouling limits water circulation.
If surrounding water flows directly through a heat exchanger, biofouling and other contamination may occur, depending on the operating area and the design. In a closed freshwater circuit, water quality and the condition of the connected central cooling arrangements are particularly relevant. The circulating pumps must also continue to function adequately. A lower cooling-water flow rate may limit heat rejection even when the condenser itself is clean. Deviations affecting pumps, valves or hydraulic distribution may therefore have effects similar to heat exchanger fouling.
If the ORC is connected to the ship's central cooling system, other equipment on that circuit also affects cooling conditions. If engines or other equipment reject more heat to the same circuit, the cooling-water temperature at the ORC condenser may rise. This does not automatically mean that the condenser needs maintenance. The available cooling-water temperature must therefore be distinguished from the technical condition of the condenser. A higher temperature while under way in warmer seawater may reduce electricity production without any component having deteriorated.
A possible need for maintenance becomes clearer when the condenser transfers less heat under sufficiently comparable heat load, cooling-water inlet temperature and water circulation conditions. An increasing pressure drop or an abnormal condensing pressure may also warrant investigation. Other possible causes should also be considered. Depending on the ORC configuration, deviations in the working-fluid circuit or control may, for example, also affect condensing conditions. A higher condensing pressure therefore is not in itself evidence that the condenser is fouled.
During condenser maintenance, the necessary ship cooling must also be maintained. If the ORC is connected to cooling circuits that also serve engines or other essential equipment, valve operation, cleaning work or changes in circulation must not unintentionally interrupt these functions. Maintenance must therefore cover both the condenser and the connected ship cooling system. Only through a combined assessment of heat transfer, water circulation and actual cooling conditions can it be established whether lower cold-side performance is caused by fouling, insufficient circulation or normal operating conditions.
What Checks Are Needed on the ORC Working Fluid, Pumps and Expander?
An organic working fluid circulates within an ORC, absorbing heat, flowing through an expander and then condensing back into a liquid in the condenser. The condition of this fluid and the operation of the main cycle components help determine whether the installation can operate within the permitted pressure and temperature range. The working fluid must remain suitable for the conditions for which the ORC was designed. Depending on the fluid and technical design, leakage, contamination or thermal degradation may warrant investigation.
Organic working fluids have thermal stability limits. If a fluid susceptible to thermal degradation is exposed to unsuitable temperatures for a sufficiently long time, its composition may change. Depending on the fluid and the conditions, this may affect its thermodynamic properties, heat transfer and the operation of the components concerned. This does not mean that the working fluid in every ORC must be replaced at a fixed interval. The required checks, any sampling and the criteria for replacement depend on the fluid used, the operating temperatures and the manufacturer's requirements.
The leak-tightness of the cycle must also be monitored. A closed circuit limits exchange with the surroundings but does not completely rule out leakage. Deviations in the amount of working fluid, pressure behaviour or other process readings may, under certain circumstances, warrant checking the system for leaks. However, a change in process pressure does not independently prove that working fluid is being lost. Pressures also change with temperatures and engine loads. The relevant process values must therefore be assessed together before a deviation is attributed to leakage.
Depending on the working fluid, leakage may also pose safety or environmental risks. Detection and remedial work must be carried out in accordance with the procedures applicable to the installation and fluid concerned.
The working-fluid pump raises the liquid working fluid to the required pressure and provides the necessary circulation through the cycle. If the pump delivers insufficient pressure or flow, the ORC operating point may change and electricity production may decrease. Pressure build-up, circulation and pump electrical power input are therefore among the important factors in the assessment. Depending on the design, seals, bearings, lubrication and other moving parts may also require maintenance.
Abnormal vibration, leakage or changes in electrical power input may warrant further investigation. Unfavourable suction conditions may also affect pump operation. The measured data must therefore be interpreted in light of the pump's actual operating point. Not every abnormal pump reading indicates wear. The flow rate may also change because of control, a different pressure ratio or changed process conditions. For a maintenance decision, it must therefore first be clear whether the pump functions differently from what is expected under comparable conditions.
The expander also requires maintenance suited to the technology used. A turbine and a screw expander have different design characteristics and may impose different requirements for bearings, seals, lubrication and inspection. Mechanical condition affects both availability and, potentially, efficiency. Changes in vibration, bearing temperatures, relevant pressures and other operating values may indicate that further investigation is needed.
However, lower generator output does not prove that the expander has become less efficient. If evaporating or condensing conditions change, even a technically sound expander may deliver less power. To assess expander condition, the relevant process conditions must therefore be sufficiently known. If abnormal power output remains apparent at comparable pressure ratios, working-fluid flow rates and other operating conditions, targeted investigation of the expander may be justified.
Maintenance of the ORC cycle thus requires more than replacing components after a specified number of operating hours. The quality and quantity of the working fluid, the leak-tightness of the circuit, circulation and the mechanical condition of the components must also be monitored appropriately.
Why Do the Generator, Valves and Instrumentation and Control Equipment Require Maintenance?
Alongside the heat exchangers and ORC components, the generator, valves and controls also affect WHRS performance and availability. If these components do not function properly, electricity production may decrease or the system may have to be derated or shut down sooner. The generator converts the mechanical power of the expander into electricity. Its electrical and mechanical condition must remain suitable for the operating conditions concerned. Depending on the design, cooling, electrical connections, the condition of the insulation, bearings and other parts requiring maintenance may need periodic checks.
In an installation with power electronics, the condition of the converters, their cooling and the associated electrical connections may also be relevant. A deviation may limit the available generator power or result in automatic shutdown. Maintenance must therefore suit the technical design and the conditions under which the generator interacts safely with the shipboard electrical system.
Shut-off and control valves, in turn, affect heat distribution and circulation. If a valve does not reach the commanded position or fails to seal properly, the WHRS process may operate under conditions different from those the control system intends. Electricity production may consequently decrease without deterioration of the heat exchanger or expander itself. Instrumentation and control equipment also play an important role here. The ORC control system uses temperature, pressure and other process data, among other inputs, to keep heat absorption, working-fluid circulation and expansion within the permitted limits.
If a sensor reading gradually drifts away from the true value, the control system may hold the process at the wrong operating point. Electricity production may consequently be limited while the heat source and main ORC components still function adequately. Functional checks and appropriate calibration can help identify such deviations. Which work is needed depends on the instrument's function, the required accuracy and the consequences that an incorrect measured value may have.
The protective devices must also continue to function reliably. In the event of loss of cooling, unsuitable process pressure, loss of electrical load or other relevant faults, the installation must respond in the way for which it was designed. Depending on the design, overpressure protection, expander monitoring, leak detection and automatic shutdown functions may form part of the safety concept. The functions to be checked depend on the equipment fitted and the applicable requirements.
A distinction must be made here between normal performance control and independent or designated safety functions. A deviation in process control may lead to lower electricity production, whereas a defective protective device may directly jeopardize safe operation. A safety function must therefore not be disabled or set to be less sensitive in order to achieve higher WHRS output. Maintenance and any modifications to protective devices must be carried out in accordance with the prescribed procedures and verified where necessary.
Checks on the generator, valves and instrumentation therefore do not serve solely to preserve electrical power. The system must also respond correctly to changing operating conditions and faults for a reliable and safe WHRS.
When Does Lower Electricity Production Actually Indicate a Need for Maintenance?
Lower electricity production may be an initial indication that the WHRS is operating differently from expected. However, it is not clear from that decrease alone whether maintenance is needed, let alone which component must be investigated. Available waste heat changes with engine load. When an engine delivers less power, exhaust gas temperature, gas flow rate and heat rejection through the cooling-water circuits may change. Lower ORC output may be a normal consequence.
The cold side also affects electricity production. With warmer cooling water, the condensing pressure may rise, causing the expander to deliver less power. This does not, by itself, indicate fouling or wear. The shipboard electrical system may also limit production. If electrical demand is too low, the power management system may reduce WHRS output. The measured generator output may then be lower than the power that would be technically available under the same heat and cooling conditions.
In the event of an unexpected production decrease, it must therefore first be established under which conditions it occurs. Data on engine load, the heat source, cooling water, operating status and any electrical output limit are needed for this purpose. It must also be clear whether the deviation concerns gross or net output. If gross generator output changes little while the net contribution decreases, the auxiliaries may be drawing more power.
The observed production is then compared with the performance that can be expected under sufficiently comparable conditions. A performance characteristic from commissioning or a sufficiently substantiated reference model may, for example, be used for this purpose. Rated generator power alone is an insufficient benchmark. Lower electrical power at part load or with warmer cooling water need not, after all, indicate technical deterioration. If net production demonstrably decreases under comparable conditions, a targeted investigation can be made into which component is responsible for this.
An increasing pressure drop across the exhaust gas heat exchanger may warrant checking for fouling. Lower heat transfer on the water side may be associated with deposits or insufficient circulation. At a higher condensing pressure, investigation of the condenser and the connected ship cooling system may be needed. Abnormal pump data, process pressures and control actions may also help identify the cause. An incorrect sensor value or a valve that responds inadequately may limit electricity production without the heat exchanger or expander itself needing maintenance.
However, these readings are diagnostic clues and cannot establish a specific fault on their own. A higher pressure drop may, for example, result from a greater flow rate. Less heat may also be transferred because the heat source makes less thermal power available. The indication of a need for maintenance becomes stronger when several measured data points indicate the same possible cause. If the information provides insufficient clarity, a targeted inspection or additional measurement may be needed before components are cleaned or replaced.
This helps avoid unnecessary maintenance when output falls because of normal changes in engine load, cooling or electrical operation.
How Do You Combine Preventive and Condition-Based Maintenance?
A suitable WHRS maintenance programme combines prescribed periodic work with checks arising from the observed technical condition of the installation. Preventive maintenance includes inspections, calibration, cleaning and replacement required under the manufacturer's documentation and applicable maintenance conditions. The frequency may depend on operating hours, calendar periods, the number of starts or other characteristics of use.
The applicable criteria vary by component. An exhaust gas heat exchanger may have different maintenance needs from a water-side heat exchanger. A turbine, screw expander, working-fluid pump and generator also each require checks suited to their construction and operating conditions. One general maintenance interval for the complete WHRS is therefore insufficient. The programme must suit the components actually installed, the media used and the conditions in which the installation operates.
Condition-based maintenance also uses trends in relevant operating readings. If, for example, pressure drop, heat transfer, pump power consumption or another operating parameter changes gradually, this may give reason to investigate a component further. A reliable starting point is needed for such monitoring. Data from commissioning or an earlier check may serve as a reference, provided that it is known under which heat source and cooling conditions these values were established.
A reference value from a favourable design operating point cannot be used directly to judge performance during prolonged part-load operation. The conditions must be sufficiently comparable, or a suitable performance model must be used to account for relevant differences. In a WHRS, net electricity generation, heat transfer, pressure differences, condensing conditions and auxiliary electrical consumption are among the quantities that can be monitored. Which data are most useful depends on the selected heat sources and technical design.
How a deviation develops is also important. A sudden change may have a different cause from gradual deterioration. If a deviation recurs during several comparable operating periods, this generally provides stronger grounds for investigation than one measured value without sufficient context. However, condition-based maintenance does not automatically replace the prescribed periodic work. Certain inspections, safety checks and maintenance operations remain necessary even when no noticeable performance loss occurs.
Conversely, not every minor deviation calls for immediate cleaning or replacement. It must first be assessed whether the change is technically significant, how the condition is developing and what consequences further deterioration may have for performance, safety or availability. Where possible, maintenance planning can be aligned with periods when the ship or the relevant engine installation is already out of service. Additional downtime can thus be limited, as long as the prescribed maintenance limits and necessary safety conditions are respected.
The work carried out must also be recorded. The condition found, parts used, any measurements and the results after maintenance provide valuable information for subsequent checks. From this, it can be established whether a deviation recurs and whether the maintenance programme is sufficiently suited to actual use. A useful maintenance programme therefore describes both mandatory and planned work and the criteria for additional condition-based investigation. The aim is not to carry out as much maintenance as possible, but to keep the WHRS in good condition, safe and capable of useful performance.
How Do You Carry Out WHRS Maintenance Without Disrupting Necessary Ship Functions?
A waste heat recovery system is connected to existing engine, exhaust gas, cooling-water and electrical systems. WHRS maintenance may therefore affect equipment that remains necessary for safe ship operation. It must consequently be clear how the recovery installation can be taken out of service in a controlled manner and how the individual components can be isolated safely. Which arrangements are needed for this depends on the selected installation and the connections to the existing ship systems.
During work on an exhaust gas heat exchanger, account must be taken of the temperature, flow and operating status of the exhaust gas path concerned. Depending on the configuration, it may be necessary to take the engine out of service or isolate the heat exchanger from the active exhaust system using suitable arrangements. During permitted operating modes, the necessary exhaust gas discharge must be maintained. A bypass or shut-off arrangement must therefore not be operated without further assessment in a way that causes unacceptable back pressure or reverse flow.
During the cleaning of fouled exhaust gas equipment, the installation must also be in a safe condition for the work. In this context, hot surfaces, deposits and residual heat must be taken into account. The permitted cleaning methods and operating conditions follow from the manufacturer's requirements and the ship-specific procedures. During maintenance of water-side heat exchangers or intermediate circuits, it must be known how the circuit concerned can be isolated without interrupting the necessary engine cooling.
If pumps or pipes also serve other essential equipment, their function must be maintained. If this is not possible, the installations concerned must be taken out of service in accordance with a suitable procedure. For work on an ORC module, the pressure, temperature and properties of the organic working fluid are important. An installation that has been electrically switched off is not automatically depressurized or sufficiently cooled.
Thermal energy may still be present in heat exchangers, pipes and fluid circuits. The working fluid may also be at elevated pressure. Before components are opened, the necessary isolation, depressurization, cooling and measures to prevent inadvertent start-up or energization must therefore have been completed. Depending on the working fluid, additional measures may be needed for ventilation, leak detection, containment or safe handling of released liquid and vapour. The manufacturer's requirements and applicable safety procedures remain the governing basis in this context.
The working fluid must not be drained, mixed or replaced without further assessment. The properties of the fluid and the technical design of the installation determine which operations are permitted and what expertise is needed for them. Electrical components must also be capable of being isolated safely. During maintenance of the generator, converters, pumps and control equipment, components must be prevented from becoming unexpectedly energized or being started automatically.
Practical feasibility also depends on access to the components. If a heat exchanger can only be cleaned after other large components have been removed, this may cause considerably more downtime than a design with sufficient direct maintenance access. In planning, account must therefore be taken of inspection points, unobstructed working space, lifting provisions and the routes along which larger components can be removed if necessary.
Where appropriate, several tasks may be carried out during the same shutdown. Additional maintenance time can thus be limited, provided that the technical condition of the installation and the manufacturer's requirements leave sufficient scope for this. After maintenance, the circuits, protective devices and connections concerned must be returned to service and checked in accordance with the applicable procedures. In this context, it must be established that both the WHRS and the affected essential ship systems are once again operating as designed.
A good maintenance plan therefore takes account of more than the work on the recovery installation. The availability of the original engine, cooling-water and electrical functions must also be maintained while the WHRS is temporarily out of service.
How Do You Establish Whether Maintenance Has Restored Performance?
After maintenance, it must be established whether the technical deviation that prompted the work has actually been remedied. Simply observing that the WHRS is running again is insufficient for this if the maintenance was intended to remedy a performance loss. The check begins with the original deviation. If an exhaust gas heat exchanger has been cleaned because of an increasing pressure drop, the check should establish whether flow resistance has fallen under sufficiently comparable gas conditions. It can also be assessed whether heat transfer has returned to the expected level, taking account of the relevant temperatures, flow rates and engine loads.
When servicing a water-side heat exchanger or condenser, heat transfer, water flows and pressure differences can be checked again. Better condenser performance may, for example, become apparent in more favourable condensing conditions under comparable heat load and cooling-water supply conditions. After maintenance of the working-fluid pump or expander, other values may be important. Pressure build-up, circulation, vibration and relevant temperatures must suit the equipment concerned and the operating point at which it functions.
If instrumentation or control equipment has been repaired, it must be checked whether the signals and control actions function correctly again. For components with a safety function, an appropriate functional test may be needed before the installation is returned to normal service. In the assessment of electrical performance, the heat supply, cooling conditions and the installation's own auxiliary consumption must be included. Higher generator output after maintenance does not automatically mean that technical performance has improved if the engine simultaneously supplies more waste heat.
The results before and after maintenance are therefore preferably assessed under sufficiently comparable operating conditions. If these conditions differ, a suitable performance model can help distinguish the effects of engine load, source temperatures and cooling. In this context, it must remain clear which data were measured directly and which results follow from calculations or normalization. An adjusted performance comparison and a direct measurement under the same conditions provide different kinds of evidence.
The distinction between gross and net electricity generation also remains important. A pump repair may, for example, reduce electrical auxiliary consumption without gross generator power changing substantially. The net electrical contribution may nevertheless improve as a result. Conversely, a cleaned heat exchanger may transfer more heat while another technical constraint still limits net electrical output. An improvement in one aspect of performance therefore does not automatically mean that all the original performance losses have disappeared.
A maintenance action has achieved its intended result when the deviation concerned has been remedied, the installation functions within the permitted operating limits and performance under comparable conditions has returned to its expected range. In this context, the work carried out, the condition found and the relevant measurement results must be recorded. If a heat exchanger becomes fouled more quickly than expected or a particular deviation recurs regularly, this may warrant a review of the maintenance programme or the underlying operating conditions.
In this way, maintenance is assessed not only on whether the installation is available again, but also on the restoration of the technical performance that prompted the work.
To preserve the performance of a waste heat recovery system, periodic inspections, appropriate cleaning, checks on the working fluid and mechanical components, maintenance of instrumentation and protective devices, and reliable condition monitoring are therefore needed. The work required depends on the selected WHRS configuration, the components present and the conditions in which the ship is used.
In this context, it remains important not to treat lower electricity production automatically as technical deterioration. Only through a combined assessment of the heat supply, cooling conditions, process operation and electrical auxiliary consumption can it be established whether maintenance is needed and where the cause lies.
A maintenance programme that links these data to the requirements for each relevant component helps identify actual performance loss in good time and avoid unnecessary work. Useful net energy production and WHRS availability can thus be preserved as effectively as possible throughout operation.
This Article in the Series
Good maintenance begins early, with the provisions included in the ship design during newbuilding, including accessible heat exchangers and sufficient space for inspection and cleaning. During operation, performance loss due to fouling or wear must be distinguished from changing operating conditions. With a different fuel or engine configuration, the heat-source conditions and heat exchanger loads may also change. These considerations come together within WHRS installation, maintenance and regulations.