Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Does a Different Fuel or Engine Configuration Affect the Suitability of an ORC System?

A different fuel or engine configuration may affect the suitability of an ORC installation because the quantity, temperature and distribution of the available waste heat change. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) based on the Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) uses heat from sources such as exhaust gases and engine cooling water to generate electricity. The thermodynamic principle remains the same when a marine engine uses a different fuel, but the heat-source conditions for which the system was designed may change.

A different engine design, a change in how power is shared or in how generating sets are used may also affect the heat supply. The heat exchangers, permitted engine operating conditions and ORC operating range must therefore be reassessed. Available cooling and electrical demand also remain decisive for net electricity generation.

An existing ORC may remain suitable under the new conditions, but may also deliver a different electrical output or require modifications to the heat exchangers, connections or controls. Whether a different ORC configuration is necessary depends on the technical differences between the original and modified engine installation. The fuel name or rated engine power alone provides insufficient information for this.

Why Can a Different Fuel Affect ORC Suitability?

An ORC uses heat released during engine operation. The organic working fluid circulates in a separate, closed cycle and absorbs energy from the available heat sources through heat exchangers. In this process, the fuel burned in the marine engine does not form a direct part of the ORC cycle. The same ORC technology can therefore be assessed for use with engines using different fuels. Examples include marine gas oil, heavy fuel oil, LNG, GTL, suitable biofuels and methanol. However, applicability does not depend solely on the fuel. Engine type, combustion technology, engine load and the available heat sources also determine which waste heat can be used.

A fuel change can involve two distinct situations. An existing engine may start operating on a different fuel under conditions that permit this. In a more substantial change, the engine itself is converted or replaced. When the same engine uses a different fuel, the heat-source conditions may change very little. This depends on fuel properties, engine control and whether the engine is approved for the fuel concerned without technical modifications.

In an engine conversion or replacement, the effects may be greater. Combustion conditions, air supply, turbocharger configuration and cooling-water distribution may change. A different amount of heat may consequently become available through the exhaust gases or cooling circuits at the same mechanical power output. The effects are therefore not the same for every fuel change. A switch to LNG or methanol, for example, does not automatically mean that exhaust gas temperature rises or falls. The actual temperature and available thermal power depend on the selected engine design and operating mode.

For an existing ORC, a key question is how the new heat-source conditions compare with the original design data. The installation may be suitable for a particular range of source temperatures and thermal power inputs, but need not deliver the same electrical output throughout that range. After a fuel change, the heat-source data at the relevant engine loads must therefore be established. It is then assessed how much heat the existing heat exchangers can absorb within acceptable technical limits and whether the ORC continues to function within its permitted operating range with that heat supply.

A different fuel may also change the exhaust gas composition and the treatment it requires. This may change the limits on exhaust gas cooling, the suitability of materials and where the heat exchanger can be placed in the exhaust system. The necessary modification therefore need not be within the ORC module itself. The existing module may remain suitable while the heat exchanger, intermediate circuit or controls may need to be adapted to the changed heat source.

Replacement of the complete ORC installation is therefore not automatically necessary. Conversely, it must not be assumed without a technical assessment that the original performance will be maintained when a different fuel is used.

How Do Exhaust Gas Temperature and Mass Flow Rate Change with a Different Fuel or Engine?

For heat recovery from exhaust gases, gas temperature, mass flow rate and how far the gas may be cooled are important factors. Together with the thermal properties of the gas, they determine how much heat can be extracted under the conditions concerned. When an engine starts operating on a different fuel, exhaust gas conditions may change. This is associated with factors including the combustion process, air-fuel ratio, required air supply and engine control.

With a different engine design, the turbocharger and the complete air and exhaust gas system may also have different properties. The available gas temperature and mass flow rate therefore cannot be derived solely from the fuel used. A higher exhaust gas temperature does not automatically mean that more heat becomes available to the ORC. If the gas flow rate decreases at the same time, the available thermal power may differ from what would be expected on the basis of temperature alone.

Conversely, a greater mass flow rate at a lower temperature may transport substantial amounts of thermal energy. However, this heat need not offer the same scope for electricity production as heat available at a higher temperature. For a reliable comparison, exhaust gas temperature and mass flow rate must therefore be established at the same engine operating point. Engine speed and the temperature measurement location also matter.

The temperature immediately downstream of the turbocharger, for example, need not equal the temperature at the heat exchanger. If the exhaust gases first pass through other equipment, some of the heat may already have been used or additional temperature requirements may apply. The maximum permissible cooling must also be reassessed. An exhaust gas stream may contain considerable thermal energy while only some of it can be recovered within engine operating and material limits.

If a different fuel or engine configuration results in a changed exhaust gas composition, the conditions for condensation and corrosion may also change. The portion of heat that can be extracted within acceptable technical limits therefore need not change in the same proportion as the total available thermal power. Operating hours must also be considered alongside heat-source conditions. A new engine may supply sufficient exhaust gas heat at rated load, yet make less usable heat available during operation if it runs at part load more often or accumulates fewer operating hours.

This is particularly relevant when a fuel change is accompanied by a different operating strategy. The engine may, for example, be used at different loads or give way to another energy source during certain periods. The original ORC may consequently receive enough heat at a suitable temperature for fewer hours, even if the new engine still delivers appropriate thermal power at an individual design operating point. The available operating hours are therefore just as important as the properties of the heat source at rated load.

Rated exhaust gas data alone are therefore insufficient to assess suitability. Temperatures, flow rates and operating hours at the engine loads encountered during actual operation are also needed. If the new heat conditions remain within the operating range of the existing heat exchanger and ORC, it may be possible to retain the original installation. Net electricity generation may nevertheless change in this situation.

If temperatures, mass flow rates or permissible heat extraction fall outside the original design limits, the necessary changes to the heat exchanger or the other heat supply arrangements must be identified. The engine's technical limits remain decisive in this assessment.

What Effects Does a Different Exhaust Gas Composition Have on the Heat Exchanger?

A fuel change may alter not only the amount of available exhaust gas heat but also the composition of the exhaust gases. This affects the conditions under which an exhaust gas heat exchanger can function safely and reliably. Depending on the fuel and combustion conditions, differences may arise in sulphur-containing compounds, water vapour, unburned constituents, particles and other exhaust gas components. These differences may affect condensation, corrosion and the formation of deposits on heat transfer surfaces.

In this context, the effect does not depend solely on the fuel. Engine design, the combustion process and further treatment of the exhaust gases also determine which conditions arise at the heat exchanger. Cooling the exhaust gases can cause condensation and this must be taken into account. The local surface temperature of the heat exchanger is particularly important. This may be lower than the average gas temperature recorded at a measurement point.

If the exhaust gases contain sufficient sulphur-containing compounds, sulphuric acid condensation may occur under certain conditions and cause corrosion. The relevant condensation conditions depend in part on the exhaust gas composition, the water vapour present and pressure. When an engine starts operating on a fuel with a lower sulphur content, the conditions for sulphuric acid condensation may change. However, this does not mean that every form of condensation or corrosion disappears. Water vapour and other constituents present may also continue to play a role where conditions allow.

The original minimum exhaust gas temperature must therefore not be maintained or lowered without further assessment when the fuel changes. Permissible heat extraction must suit the exhaust gas composition and the actual temperatures in the heat exchanger. Material suitability must also be reassessed. The heat exchanger must continue to withstand the temperatures and the chemical and physical conditions occurring during normal operation and relevant abnormal operating modes.

A changed exhaust gas composition may therefore warrant reassessing the existing heat exchanger, even if the thermal power of the new heat source is comparable to that of the original engine. Deposit formation may also change. Soot, ash and other contaminants may limit heat transfer and increase flow resistance. Which deposits actually form depends on fuel properties, engine design and operating conditions.

A different fuel is therefore not automatically cleaner under all conditions or more suitable for every heat exchanger. A lower concentration of a particular contaminant does not mean that all possible fouling and corrosion mechanisms disappear. Maintenance needs and suitable cleaning methods may also change. A heat exchanger originally selected for a particular fuel must remain capable of transferring sufficient heat under the new conditions without unacceptable pressure losses or material degradation.

Alongside these material and maintenance considerations, exhaust back pressure remains important. An existing heat exchanger causes a certain pressure drop, but its effects may change if exhaust gas mass flow rate or the permitted engine limits change. In an engine replacement, it must therefore be established whether the existing heat exchanger and the rest of the exhaust gas path can still operate without exceeding the engine's total back-pressure limit. In this assessment, the relevant engine loads and the other components in the exhaust gas path must be included.

Any exhaust gas aftertreatment must also be reassessed. With a changed engine or fuel configuration, different emission control equipment may be present or existing arrangements may function in a different operating mode. An SCR system may, for example, require a suitable temperature range. Exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) may also affect heat distribution and the properties of the available exhaust gas streams. The heat exchanger position must therefore match the chosen engine and aftertreatment configuration.

The existing ORC module need not automatically become unsuitable as a result of these changes. Modification of the exhaust gas heat exchanger, its placement or the connection to the heat circuit may be sufficient. For each proposed solution, however, it must be demonstrated that the heat exchanger can absorb sufficient heat under the new conditions. In this context, engine operation, exhaust gas aftertreatment and the required exhaust gas flow must not be affected unacceptably.

How Does a Different Engine Configuration Affect the Heat Supply to the ORC?

A changed engine configuration may alter the available heat supply without a change in the fuel used. The number of engines, their technical design and the way they are used determine which heat sources are available during ship operation. A ship with one propulsion engine running for long periods, for example, has a different distribution of heat sources from a ship on which several engines together supply mechanical or electrical power. The possibilities for heat recovery are therefore linked to the complete engine configuration and the associated operating profile.

If an engine is replaced with a design having different technical properties, a different amount of heat may be released through the exhaust gases and cooling circuits at the same mechanical power. Engine efficiency and the distribution of energy losses depend on the engine design and operating point. The original thermal design data for the ORC may therefore no longer correspond to the new engine installation. A heat exchanger may, for example, have been selected for different exhaust gas temperatures and flow rates from those the new engine delivers during the usual operating modes.

In an installation with several engines, it must also be established which heat sources are available simultaneously. If the required power is distributed across a different number of running engines, the load per engine may change. The individual exhaust gas and cooling-water conditions may change accordingly. Installing more engines therefore does not automatically mean that more usable waste heat is also available to the ORC.

An engine that is out of service does not deliver continuous heat from combustion. An engine running only for short periods may also deliver less usable thermal energy than another engine that remains in operation for a long time. For an existing ORC, the continuity of the heat supply in particular may change as a result. If the installation originally received heat from an engine that ran almost continuously, a different engine configuration may result in that heat source being shut down more often or operated at a lower load.

This may affect not only the average available thermal power but also how often the ORC starts up or shuts down. An installation that remains technically suitable at a stable operating point may have to reduce output or stop more often under the new operating profile. The physical heat supply arrangements may also require modification. If heat from several separate exhaust gas paths must be used, separate heat exchangers and a common intermediate circuit may be an option.

In this context, the exhaust gas streams from different engines must not be combined directly without further assessment. The original functions of the exhaust systems must be maintained, and unwanted interaction or reverse flow must be prevented. In a common heat circuit, the temperatures and flow rates of the different heat sources must also be assessed. Combining heat flows may affect the temperature ultimately available at the ORC.

A different engine layout may also necessitate longer pipe runs and additional circulation arrangements. Temperature losses, pressure losses and the electrical consumption of the heat recovery auxiliaries may consequently change. ORC suitability must therefore be determined from the heat that the selected engines can jointly deliver during the actual operating periods. Total rated engine capacity provides, at most, an initial indication for this.

The decisive factor is whether the changed engine operation still makes sufficient heat available at the required temperature. The existing or modified heat supply arrangements must also be capable of transferring this heat to the ORC within acceptable operating limits.

What Changes in Cooling-Water Heat with a Different Engine Installation?

Alongside exhaust gas heat, an ORC can use heat from engine cooling water or other suitable hot circuits. When engines are replaced or reconfigured, the amount of heat available through these circuits may also change. The distribution of engine heat between exhaust gases, high-temperature cooling and other cooling streams depends on engine design. A new engine therefore need not reject the same amount of heat to the same circuits, even if the rated mechanical power remains comparable.

Cooling-water temperatures, flow rates and temperature controls may also change. This is particularly important when an existing ORC receives heat from an original engine cooling circuit through an intermediate circuit. A lower supply temperature may reduce the available temperature difference in the heat exchanger. Less heat may consequently be transferred under otherwise comparable conditions.

A greater water flow rate cannot simply compensate for a temperature that is too low. The available temperature differences must support heat transfer within the ORC's permitted operating range. With a different engine configuration, the hydraulic arrangement of the cooling-water circuits may also change. A new engine may have different connection points, thermostatic arrangements or prescribed water flows from the original design.

A previously suitable connection to the high-temperature cooling circuit must therefore be reassessed. The presence of a cooling-water pipe at a comparable temperature does not prove that the same amount of heat can be extracted within acceptable technical limits. Maintaining the required engine cooling takes priority. Heat extraction for the ORC must not disrupt the prescribed engine temperatures, cooling-water circulation or temperature control. Even when the ORC is out of service, the original cooling functions must be maintained.

In an installation using both exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat, a different engine configuration may change how heat is supplied at different stages of the ORC. Cooling-water heat may, for example, be used to preheat the organic working fluid, while exhaust gas heat is supplied at a higher temperature. Whether and how the two sources can be combined depends on the selected ORC configuration.

If the ratio between the available heat sources changes, the original combination of heat exchangers may no longer operate under the same conditions. Even if the combined thermal power remains comparable, the temperature distribution may be less suitable for the existing cycle. Heat at a lower temperature cannot necessarily replace heat originally supplied at a higher temperature.

Exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat must therefore be established separately. The assessment must also identify where each heat source supplies heat to the ORC. If the new heat distribution remains within the original design limits, the installation may be able to function without major changes. With larger changes, modifications to the heat exchangers, intermediate circuit or process control may be needed.

Does the ORC Installation Continue to Function Within Its Technical Operating Range?

An ORC module is designed for a defined range of heat-source and cooling conditions. Within that operating range, the heat exchangers, working-fluid pump, expander and condenser must jointly be capable of maintaining suitable process conditions. If the fuel or engine configuration changes, the temperature and amount of heat available on the hot side may change. The ORC may consequently function at a different thermodynamic operating point from that for which the original performance was established.

At a lower source temperature, the available temperature difference for heat transfer may decrease. Less heat may consequently be supplied to the working fluid or different evaporating conditions may arise. Lower thermal input power may also affect working-fluid flow rate and the mechanical work of the expander. In this context, electricity production need not change in proportion to the heat absorbed, because conversion efficiency and the performance of individual components may also change at part load.

Conversely, if more heat becomes available under the new engine conditions, this does not automatically mean that the ORC can produce more electricity. The heat exchangers, expander and generator have limited capacity and a permitted operating range. Additional heat may consequently remain unused once the maximum thermal or electrical capacity has been reached. Permitted process pressures, temperatures or working-fluid flow rates may also make it necessary to limit heat absorption.

The assessment must therefore go beyond whether the ORC can still be started. What matters is whether the installation can operate steadily under the new heat-source conditions, stay within its permitted limits and deliver enough usable net electricity. Its own electricity consumption must be included in this assessment. If gross generator power decreases while certain pumps and control devices still use electricity, net output may fall proportionally more than gross output.

An ORC that remains operational may still fail to deliver a positive or economically significant net electrical contribution in every new operating mode. Particularly during prolonged low heat input, this may affect its ultimate suitability. The control system must also be capable of handling the changed conditions. A different heat supply may require modified settings or a different control strategy for the working-fluid pump, expander and heat transfer.

Such modifications must remain within the limits of the existing components. Higher temperatures or pressures must not be permitted solely to regain the original electricity production. The organic working fluid used also remains decisive for the permitted process conditions. A changed engine heat source does not automatically mean that a different ORC working fluid is needed. However, it must be established whether the new temperatures and heat input suit the existing fluid and the cycle designed around it.

If the new heat conditions remain within the original operating range, it may be sufficient to reassess expected performance. With larger changes, modifications to the heat supply or control may become necessary. Only when the changed heat sources cannot be used in a technically acceptable manner within the capabilities of the existing ORC is there reason to assess a different module or cycle configuration.

What Does Dual-Fuel Operation Mean for ORC Performance?

Different fuels or operating modes can be used in dual-fuel engines. Available waste heat may consequently change not only when engine load changes, but also when the engine operates in a different fuel mode at a comparable load. In certain dual-fuel engines, the combustion processes differ between gas operation and operation on liquid fuel. This may affect exhaust gas temperature, mass flow rate and the distribution of heat across the cooling circuits.

The magnitude and direction of these differences depend on engine design. An engine that operates according to a different combustion principle in gas mode from that in diesel mode, for example, need not deliver the same exhaust gas conditions as an engine using a comparable combustion process in both modes. For a connected ORC, this means that a given engine-load percentage does not necessarily correspond to a fixed heat supply. The active fuel mode must therefore also be included in the determination of available heat.

ORC performance established during gas operation at a particular engine load cannot be used without further assessment as the expected performance for operation on liquid fuel. The heat-source conditions and corresponding ORC operating point may, after all, differ. In the technical assessment, the heat-source data are therefore assessed separately for each relevant fuel mode. It must also be known which modes are actually used during operation and how many hours the engine operates in each mode.

The exhaust gas composition may also change between operating modes. In an engine capable of operating on both gas and liquid fuel, sulphur loading, deposit formation and the conditions for exhaust gas cooling may, for example, differ. It must therefore be established whether the existing heat exchanger continues to function within the permitted material, temperature and back-pressure limits in all relevant fuel modes.

Any exhaust gas aftertreatment may also be used differently in each operating mode. The presence or operation of SCR, EGR or other arrangements may affect exhaust gas conditions where the WHRS connects to the exhaust system. The existing heat exchanger position and the amount of heat extracted must therefore remain suitable for the engine and aftertreatment configurations actually used.

Transitions between fuel modes also deserve attention. During changeover, engine and heat conditions may change temporarily. Heat exchangers, any intermediate circuits and the ORC cycle each respond with a thermal lag. Electrical power therefore need not immediately match the value associated with the new stable fuel mode. Depending on the design, the ORC control system may have to adjust heat absorption or generator output temporarily.

An ORC that is technically suitable under steady conditions in both fuel modes must therefore also be capable of responding appropriately to the conditions encountered during actual changeovers. The permitted engine and fuel modes remain the governing conditions in this context. The ORC must not unacceptably affect the necessary fuel changeover, exhaust gas discharge or engine cooling.

For a realistic assessment, ORC performance is therefore established for the relevant combinations of engine load and fuel mode. Total usable electricity production then depends on the operating hours in each mode and the way the installation functions during changeovers.

How Do the New Heat Conditions Affect the Condenser and Shipboard Electrical System?

A changed fuel or engine configuration may also affect the cold side of the ORC. If the amount of heat supplied to the thermodynamic process changes, heat rejection through the condenser may also change. In an ORC, part of the thermal input is converted into mechanical work and then into electrical energy. Most of the remaining heat is rejected through the condenser.

If the ORC absorbs more heat under the new engine conditions, it must therefore be established whether the condenser and connected cooling system can continue to reject this heat adequately. Cooling-water temperature, flow rate and available cooling capacity are important here. The heat load from other equipment on the same cooling system must also be included. A new engine or different load distribution may, after all, change how much heat the ship's existing cooling system must reject.

This can also change how much cooling capacity is available to the ORC condenser. The condenser must therefore be assessed in conjunction with the complete heat balance of the modified engine installation. The origin of the recovered heat must remain identifiable in this assessment. If the ORC uses exhaust gas heat, heat previously lost largely through the exhaust gas path may now be rejected to the ship cooling system through the condenser.

In recovery from engine cooling water, some heat rejection may instead be transferred from an existing engine cooler to the ORC condenser. Part of the original cooling duty then moves to the condenser, while some of the absorbed heat is converted into mechanical and electrical energy. The full condenser heat load must therefore not automatically be added to all original cooling loads as an entirely new heat load. The new heat balance must show where the heat concerned is actually rejected before and after the change.

Electrical integration may also change. A different engine configuration may affect generating-set use and electrical demand during the various operating modes. If the ORC delivers a different net electrical power, it must be established whether the shipboard electrical system can make use of that output. Low electrical demand or generator reserve requirements may make it necessary to limit WHRS output.

A particular interaction arises when the ORC receives heat from the same generating sets whose loads are reduced by the ORC's electrical output. The lower generator load may then change heat release from the engines concerned. The available thermal power and WHRS electrical output must therefore be assessed at the same final engine load.

If a generating set is shut down completely, continuous heat production from that engine is also lost. The remaining generating sets may simultaneously be loaded differently, as a result of which their heat release also changes. Net electricity generation from the ORC therefore cannot be determined reliably from the original engine dispatch alone. The resulting load distribution across engines and the resulting heat sources must be included in the same calculation.

After a fuel change, the ORC module itself may also remain technically unchanged while the available cooling or electrical demand allows a different net contribution. The assessment of the new heat conditions must therefore be linked to condenser performance, additional auxiliary consumption and the electrical energy supply of the complete ship.

When Does an ORC Remain Suitable and When Are Modifications Needed?

ORC suitability after a fuel or engine change is determined by comparing the original design data with the heat and operating conditions arising under the new configuration. What actually changes is established first. A different permitted fuel in an otherwise unchanged engine may require a different assessment from a complete engine replacement or a new configuration with several engines.

Data on engine design, fuel or fuel modes, engine loads and operating hours are needed for the new situation. For exhaust gas heat, these include, among other things, temperature, mass flow rate, exhaust gas composition and permissible heat extraction. Data on engine cooling water and other connected heat sources must also be reassessed. Available temperatures and flow rates, prescribed engine conditions and existing uses of the heat are relevant here.

These data are then linked to the engine combinations and operating modes actually expected under the new configuration. In this way, it becomes clear which heat sources are available simultaneously and how long the ORC can use them. It is then investigated whether the existing heat exchangers remain suitable. The assessment covers thermal power, heat transfer, pressure losses, material suitability, permissible exhaust gas cooling and any requirements of the aftertreatment equipment.

In recovery from engine cooling water, the necessary engine temperatures and cooling-water circulation remain decisive. The original engine functions must not be affected unacceptably by modifications to heat recovery. The new source temperatures and thermal power inputs are then assessed against the ORC operating range. Working-fluid circulation, evaporating and condensing conditions, and expander performance determine how much gross electrical power is possible under these conditions.

It must also be established how much net electricity remains available after the relevant auxiliary consumption has been deducted. It also matters during which operating periods this electricity can be used on board. If the new heat conditions remain within the original design range, the connections are suitable and the installation can function safely, it may be possible to retain the existing ORC. Electricity production may nevertheless differ from the original performance in this situation.

Lower electrical output after a fuel or engine change does not in itself indicate a deterioration in the ORC's condition. It may be a normal consequence of less heat or of heat becoming available under different temperature conditions. In other situations, the ORC module may remain suitable while the heat exchanger, intermediate circuit, connections or control must be modified. The change then need not encompass the complete thermodynamic cycle.

This may be the case, for example, if the new exhaust gas conditions require a different heat exchanger or if the ratio between exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat has changed. The heat supply to the existing ORC must then be adapted to the new conditions. A different distribution across several engines may also necessitate modification of the heat supply. If individual engines supply heat, the connections must remain safe and controllable for the engine combinations actually encountered during operation.

A more substantial change may be needed if the new heat sources do not adequately match the operating range of the existing ORC. If source temperatures are consistently too low, insufficient heat remains available during the relevant operating hours or the permitted process conditions cannot be maintained, a different ORC module or system configuration may be necessary to make effective use of the remaining heat.

In this context, the assessment must not be based solely on the original rated generator power. A smaller or differently designed ORC may be better suited to the available heat supply under changed conditions, while a larger design does not automatically deliver more useful electricity. Available cooling and electrical demand must also suit the new configuration. A different ORC module may, after all, cause a different condenser heat load and change how much electrical power the auxiliaries consume.

For a planned fuel or engine change, it is therefore preferable to carry out this assessment before the existing heat exchangers and connections are retained or modified without further checks. If the change has already been made, suitable operating measurements can help establish the actual heat-source conditions. The exhaust gas and cooling-water data must then relate to the same engine loads and fuel modes.

The measured values can then be compared with the original design data and the permitted ORC operating range. It must also become clear whether changed electricity production results from the new heat supply or from a technical deviation in the recovery installation. Higher or lower measured generator output does not, by itself, provide sufficient evidence that ORC operation has improved or deteriorated. The associated heat, cooling and electrical operating conditions must be included for that purpose.

The suitability of an ORC installation with a different fuel or engine configuration is thus determined by the complete heat and energy balance. Not only the amount of heat is important, but also its temperature, distribution across the heat sources and the periods during which they are available. A changed fuel need not make the closed ORC cycle unsuitable, but may impose different conditions on the heat exchangers, exhaust gas cooling and aftertreatment. A different engine configuration may also change the number of heat sources, their individual loads and the duration of heat availability.

The existing ORC remains technically suitable if the new heat conditions fit within the permitted operating range and the necessary engine, cooling and electrical functions are maintained. Whether the installation also delivers sufficient usable net electricity in this situation must be assessed separately. If the original configuration is no longer suitable, it must be established which components actually require modification. It may be possible to modify the heat supply or control while the ORC module itself remains suitable. With greater differences, a different module or cycle configuration may be needed.

In this way, waste heat recovery is matched to the ship's modified systems, without automatically assuming retention or replacement of the original system. The decision follows from the new heat conditions, the technical limits of the ORC and the net electricity that can usefully be produced under the future operating profile.

This Article in the Series

A different fuel or engine configuration may change not only the heat supply but also the fouling and corrosion exposure of heat exchangers. This may also change the maintenance requirements for preserving WHRS performance. What implications a changed electrical output has for the treatment of WHRS electricity in EEDI and EEXI calculations depends on the applicable calculation rules. Both aspects come together within WHRS installation, maintenance and regulations.