Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Do You Determine the Annual Net Energy Output From Waste Heat Recovery over the Actual Operating Profile?

The annual net energy output from waste heat recovery is determined by establishing, for the ship's relevant operating periods, how much usable energy the installation can actually deliver, taking account of additional energy consumption and operational limits. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) does not produce the same power throughout all hours under way. Available waste heat changes with engine loads and which engines are in use, while source temperatures, cooling conditions and energy demand on board may also vary.

For electricity production with an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), the calculation therefore establishes how much electrical power can be generated in each operating period under the heat and cooling conditions that occur together. It is then established how much remains available after deduction of the relevant auxiliary consumption and electrical losses and can actually be used. Periods with insufficient heat supply, start-up, maintenance and downtime must also be included in the annual balance. Annual net electricity generation follows from the combined contribution of these operating periods and therefore cannot be determined simply by multiplying rated generator power by total hours under way. For direct heat use, the useful thermal energy delivered is calculated separately. The resulting annual balance shows how much energy the selected WHRS configuration can deliver under the expected operating profile, which existing energy production can be replaced by that energy and which assumptions affect the outcome.

Why Does Rated WHRS Power Not Provide a Reliable Annual Output?

The rated power of a waste heat recovery system describes its performance under particular design conditions. For an ORC, relevant factors include the available thermal input power, source temperature and cold-side conditions. It must also be clear whether the stated electrical power relates to the generator or the net electrical power available. During actual operation, these conditions do not necessarily remain the same as at the design operating point. A propulsion engine may, for example, run for long periods below its rated power. As a result, exhaust gas temperature, exhaust gas mass flow rate and the amount of heat rejected through cooling water change.

Available heat need not decrease in proportion to the engine's mechanical power output. Engine efficiency and heat distribution between different circuits may change with load. A WHRS capable of delivering a given electrical power output at high engine load therefore need not be able to deliver that power during prolonged part-load operation. Cooling conditions also affect how much electricity is generated. If the available cooling-water temperature rises, the ORC condensing temperature may increase. The usable expansion range may narrow, reducing electrical output, even when the same thermal power remains available on the hot side.

Each WHRS also has a particular operating range. With insufficient heat input or an unsuitable temperature, it may be necessary to reduce production or take the installation out of service. Conversely, rated generator power may limit production when more heat is temporarily available than the installation can convert into additional electricity. Rated power also reveals nothing about start-up periods, maintenance or other times when the WHRS produces no electricity. Nor does the rating indicate whether the shipboard electrical system can make use of the full output in every operating period.

Anyone who multiplies rated generator power by total hours under way effectively assumes that the WHRS operates continuously under the stated design conditions. A variable operating profile usually provides little basis for that assumption. Rated power remains a useful indication of installation capacity, but annual output must be calculated from performance under the conditions occurring during actual operation.

What Data Are Needed from the Operational and Load Profile?

Representative operating and load profiles must show when the relevant engines run, how heavily they are loaded and how long the associated operating conditions last. Total hours under way alone do not provide that information. Different engines may be in service when the ship is under way, manoeuvring, in port or operating in other relevant modes, while the ship's electrical and thermal needs also change. The heat supply depends particularly on how the engines that serve as heat sources for the WHRS are operated. If the installation uses heat exclusively from the main engine, that engine's load and operating duration are decisive. For recovery from auxiliary engines, operation of the individual generating sets may instead determine the heat supply.

When several heat sources are used, it must also be known which engines run simultaneously. Heat production from individual engines cannot simply be combined if the associated operating conditions occur at different times. The necessary information may come from engine monitoring systems, electrical load records and other available operating data. The recording period must be checked for representativeness of the operation covered by the annual calculation.

A short measurement period may, for example, provide too little information if the ship sails different routes or carries out widely varying work during the year. Seasonal differences and changes in engine operation may also affect the heat supply. Available data must therefore match the use expected during the representative year. When compiling the annual profile, it must also be clear which periods form part of normal operation. Planned maintenance, port stays and other times when particular heat sources are unavailable may affect annual production. If these periods actually form part of expected operation, they must not be omitted without further assessment.

The data can then be grouped into operating modes with similar engine loads, heat sources and cooling conditions. The hours spent in each mode over the representative year are then determined. The resulting breakdown preserves the main operational differences. Using only average engine load may give a distorted picture. An engine alternating between high and low load need not deliver the same usable waste heat as an engine running continuously at the average load. WHRS performance also need not change in proportion to engine power. In some operating modes, insufficient heat may be available for electricity production, while under other conditions the installation operates within a favourable range.

If the WHRS is sensitive to short operating periods or rapid load changes, a distribution showing only hours by load category may be insufficient. The sequence of the periods and how long each lasts without interruption then also matter. Several short periods with sufficient heat may yield a different amount of electricity from that generated during one long period of the same total duration. At each new start, time may be needed to reach the necessary process conditions. For an initial assessment, a representative distribution across different operating modes may provide enough information. With highly variable engine load or an installation with substantial start-up time, a time series may be needed to determine actual production more reliably.

The final operating profile must therefore not only describe engine operation and operating hours but also show which conditions occur together in sufficient detail. Only then can the performance of the selected WHRS be matched to actual operating conditions.

How Is Usable Waste Heat Established for Each Operating Period?

The first step for each relevant operating period is to identify the available heat sources and determine how much heat can be recovered within acceptable technical limits. A distinction must be made between the heat that the engine releases and the proportion that can actually be transferred to the WHRS. For exhaust gas heat recovery, relevant factors include the temperature and mass flow rate at the heat exchanger connection point. These data must correspond to engine load during the period concerned. How much heat can be extracted depends on gas flow rate, the gas's thermal properties and the temperature range over which heat transfer is possible.

However, not all the exhaust gas heat present is available without restrictions. The maximum permitted exhaust gas back pressure, the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature and any temperature requirements of aftertreatment equipment may limit heat extraction. Existing exhaust gas boilers and other heat consumers must also be included in the assessment. Heat already used by existing equipment may no longer be available in full to an additional WHRS. For the annual calculation, therefore, only the heat that can actually be transferred to the new system within the permitted engine and installation limits counts.

For recovery from engine cooling water, different conditions apply. Available heat is related to engine load, cooling-water circulation and existing temperature control. An additional heat exchanger must preserve the specified engine temperatures and the required water flow. A cooling-water circuit may transport substantial amounts of heat while only some can be transferred to an additional installation within acceptable technical limits. Heat extraction must therefore reflect the heat actually available from the cooling water and the operation of the existing coolers and thermostatic arrangements.

When a WHRS uses different heat sources, their properties must be established separately. Exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat are usually available at different temperatures. Their thermal power outputs therefore cannot simply be added together as though all the heat could be supplied to the thermodynamic process under the same conditions. The selected heat exchangers, any intermediate circuits and required temperature differences determine how much heat can actually be transferred. Where the heat enters the process also affects how useful it is at each temperature level.

The same heat must also be counted only once in the energy balance. A water or thermal oil circuit transporting heat from an exhaust gas heat exchanger, for example, is not an additional original heat source. The same energy is transferred through another circuit. Temperatures, flow rates and heat consumers must also relate to the same operating period. If individually favourable conditions from different engine loads are combined, the resulting heat supply may be one that never occurs in service.

The result for each operating mode is usable thermal power with its associated temperatures and technical limits. These data form the thermal input for calculating how much electricity the selected WHRS configuration can generate under those conditions.

How Is the Available Heat Supply Translated into Electrical Production?

When a WHRS produces electricity through an Organic Rankine Cycle, the usable heat supply for each operating period must be linked to the selected installation's performance. Electrical power cannot be inferred directly from the amount of thermal energy that can be extracted from the heat source. The ORC uses heat to warm and evaporate an organic working fluid. After expansion in a turbine or another expander, the remaining heat is rejected through the condenser. The amount of electricity generated depends on factors including heat input, source temperature, condensing conditions and the properties of the individual components.

As the heat supply changes, the relationship between heat input and electrical power output need not remain constant. Part-load performance may differ from performance at the rated design operating point. For an annual calculation, performance data are therefore needed that sufficiently reflect the different heat source conditions under which the WHRS must function during operation. A single power figure at rated load is insufficient for this purpose if the ship sails for long periods under other conditions. Ideally, the calculation uses data for the selected WHRS design at different combinations of heat input, source temperature and cooling conditions. It must be clear which performance values are supported by measurements and which are based on calculations.

Available cooling-water temperature in particular may significantly affect electricity production. If cooling water becomes warmer, the condensing temperature may rise and the ORC may deliver less electrical power even when the same thermal power remains available on the hot side. Heat supply and cooling conditions must therefore be assessed for the same operating period. Combining the highest heat output with the lowest cooling-water temperature from another period may produce a favourable operating point that never occurs during actual ship operation.

Separate annual averages for source and cooling-water temperatures also need not give a representative picture of the conditions in which the WHRS actually operates. The assessment must therefore determine the electrical power the selected system can deliver within its permitted operating range in each relevant mode. This includes the limits of the heat exchangers, circulation equipment and condenser. A thermodynamic cycle can deliver the calculated power only if the connected equipment enables the necessary heat transfer.

Rated generator power also sets an upper limit. If more heat is available than the selected module can use at its maximum electrical power, the remaining heat must not be counted as additional electricity production. Under other conditions, too little suitable heat may instead be available. If the source temperature or heat input falls below the minimum required, or other operating requirements are not met, electricity production may cease completely. These periods must also remain identifiable in the performance profile.

This gives the electrical power achievable in each operating mode given the available heat, cooling conditions and installation limits. The calculation then accounts for operational limits and the electrical demand the system can serve to establish how much of the output can contribute to the ship's energy supply.

Which Auxiliary Consumption Must Be Deducted for Net Energy Output?

Gross electricity generation from a WHRS is not automatically equal to the net amount of electricity that becomes available to the ship. The installation itself needs energy to function and may also cause electrical conversion losses. In an ORC, components including the working fluid pump, pumps in intermediate circuits, additional cooling-water pumps, controls and other auxiliary systems may consume electricity. Losses may also occur between the generator and the connection to the shipboard electrical system, for example in power electronics, transformers or other electrical equipment.

For net energy output, it must therefore first be clear which system boundary is used. Electrical power at the generator output may differ from the net power delivered by the complete WHRS to the shipboard electrical system. Without this boundary, different performance figures cannot be compared reliably. This is particularly important when a supplier quotes a net electrical power figure. It must be clear which auxiliary loads and electrical losses are already included in the stated performance.

If, for example, an ORC module powers its own internal pumps and controls and the stated net power has already been determined after deducting this consumption, the same consumption must not be deducted again. Conversely, module performance may give an overly favourable picture if additional pumps, cooling or electrical conversion equipment fall outside the stated system boundary. For the actual net contribution, all relevant energy loads must therefore be assessed within a consistent boundary, without counting the same losses or consumption twice.

In an existing shipboard installation, it also matters whether an auxiliary load was already present or is needed exclusively for the WHRS. If a central cooling-water pump was already running before the WHRS was added, the pump's entire pre-existing consumption does not automatically count as an additional WHRS load. However, it must be established whether the additional condenser heat load requires more pumping power or makes additional pumps necessary. The operation of existing coolers and other shared equipment may also change. For assessing additional energy output, the difference in energy consumption between the original and new configurations therefore matters.

Auxiliary consumption must also reflect actual operating conditions. A pump need not draw the same power at every WHRS load. Some auxiliaries run only during electricity generation, while others may also be needed during start-up, shutdown or standby. Auxiliary consumption at rated conditions is therefore insufficient to calculate annual net electricity generation. Energy consumed by required WHRS equipment when the generator provides no useful output may also form part of the annual balance.

When gross generator power and auxiliary electrical loads are known for each operating mode, net power within the selected system boundary can be established. If the performance data used are already net, only additional consumption and losses not yet included in those data are accounted for. Annual electrical output is expressed as energy, such as kilowatt-hours or megawatt-hours. A possible increase in main-engine fuel consumption due to additional exhaust gas back pressure is not electrical auxiliary consumption that can be deducted directly from generated electricity without further conversion.

That effect is relevant to the ship's total net fuel savings, however. Net electrical WHRS output and the amount of fuel ultimately saved must therefore be assessed separately.

How Are Start-Up, Standstill and Maintenance Included in the Annual Calculation?

A WHRS can produce energy only when the required thermal, mechanical and electrical operating conditions are met. Engine operating hours are therefore not automatically equal to the hours during which the recovery installation delivers electricity. During start-up, the heat source, heat exchangers and any intermediate circuits must warm up sufficiently. An ORC's thermodynamic process must also reach its permitted operating conditions before the generator can produce usable electricity. Some engine operating time may therefore pass without WHRS electricity production.

The start-up time required depends on the installation, initial temperatures and available heat. The annual calculation must therefore use actual start-up behaviour or a well-supported estimate. This is particularly important when the ship or engines concerned are started and stopped regularly. A heat source available during many separate short periods need not allow the same electricity production as a heat source operating steadily for long periods over a comparable total number of hours.

Load changes may also temporarily lead to lower production. If the heat supply falls below the ORC's minimum usable input, the installation may have to reduce output or stop. If the heat supply subsequently increases again, time may be needed before the desired production is restored. An annual calculation based solely on hours at each engine load may represent these effects inadequately. If such transitions have a significant effect, the calculation must also account for how engine load changes over time.

Planned maintenance must also be taken into account. Inspection, cleaning or work on necessary components may result in the WHRS being temporarily out of service. Unexpected faults may also reduce annual energy output. If reliable in-service availability data are lacking, the assumptions about availability must be stated clearly. Expected downtime cannot be established with the same certainty as operating hours already measured.

The consequences of maintenance and faults must be linked to the periods when the WHRS would otherwise actually have produced energy. Maintenance during a period without suitable waste heat, for example, does not cause a corresponding loss of generator output. A general availability percentage applied to total theoretical annual production without further assessment may therefore give an inaccurate result. The calculation method must reflect the actual or expected distribution of production periods.

Double deduction must also be avoided. If start-up periods and maintenance have already been excluded from effective production hours, the associated lost production hours must not be deducted again as a separate correction. The same applies if measured performance data already include certain start-up or output-reduction losses. Only effects not yet accounted for then require an additional correction. Auxiliaries may still consume electricity during downtime. If, for example, control or protection equipment use energy while the generator is not producing electricity, this consumption belongs in the annual balance insofar as it falls within the selected system boundary.

The calculation must therefore distinguish between total engine operating time, the periods during which the WHRS is technically available and the time during which electricity is actually produced. Lost production and relevant auxiliary consumption can thus both be accounted for consistently.

When Can the Electricity Produced Actually Be Used on Board?

A WHRS can generate electricity under suitable heat and cooling conditions, although the ship may be unable to use all the potential output. Electrical demand on board changes between operating modes, including passage, manoeuvring, loading and unloading. Depending on the shipboard installation, electricity may be supplied by diesel generating sets, shaft generators, battery storage, shore power or other energy sources. When the WHRS supplies power to the shipboard electrical system, its output can replace part of the existing generator output.

How much of the WHRS output the shipboard electrical system can actually accept depends on the permitted load range of the generating sets in service, available power reserve and control of the shipboard electrical system. A generating set may, for example, have a minimum permitted load. If the WHRS would reduce that generator's load too far, WHRS output may need to be limited. Shutting down a generating set completely may allow a different allocation of load. For this, however, the remaining energy sources must retain sufficient power and a suitable reserve to accommodate load changes and faults. Usable WHRS output must therefore fit the ship's actual electrical operating strategy.

Particularly during periods of low electrical demand, the available demand may limit output. A large amount of waste heat may then technically support high generator power while the shipboard electrical system can accept only some of it. If no suitable additional use or storage is available, the WHRS must produce less electricity. The energy associated with the curtailed output must be excluded from useful electricity delivered in the annual calculation.

With battery storage, it must be established how much energy the battery can actually take in. Available storage capacity, state of charge and permitted charging power limit how much temporary surplus generation can be stored. When this electricity is subsequently used, charging, discharging and conversion losses may occur. The same electricity must also not be counted as a separate energy output first during charging and again during use. The selected system boundary must make clear where the energy is recorded as a useful contribution.

The assessment must also establish whether the WHRS can supply electricity on board while the ship is using shore power, and under what conditions. A shore-power connection does not mean that export to the shore grid is automatically possible or permitted. The applicable connection requirements and electrical installation arrangement determine which power flows are permitted.

WHRS electricity production may also affect the available heat supply itself. This happens, for example, when the installation uses heat from generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity produced by the WHRS. Lower engine load may change how much heat is available from the exhaust gas and cooling water and, in turn, the power the WHRS can deliver. Heat availability and electrical power distribution must therefore be assessed at the same resulting engine load. Otherwise, a calculation based on original heat production may predict an output that is no longer fully available after generator load is reduced.

For each operating period, it must therefore be clear how much net WHRS electricity can actually be delivered to the ship's energy supply. Electricity used and fuel saved must still be treated separately. Even if all WHRS electricity is used, it must be determined separately which existing generator output is displaced and how much fuel is saved under the new operating conditions. Electrical energy output provides a necessary basis for this, but is not automatically equal to fuel savings.

How Is Annual Net Energy Output Calculated from All Operating Periods?

Annual net energy output is determined by combining the contributions from all relevant operating periods. The calculation first requires the operating modes for the representative year and the hours assigned to each. For each operating period, it is established which engines run, which heat sources are available and how much heat can be transferred to the WHRS within the technical limits. Existing heat consumers and the connections that can actually be made are also taken into account.

Heat-source data are then combined with the corresponding cooling conditions and the selected installation's performance. For an ORC, this gives the electrical power achievable given the available heat input, condensing conditions and permitted operating range. The generator's rated power limit must also be respected. If more thermal energy is available than the ORC can process under those conditions, the extra heat must not be counted as additional electricity production.

Available electrical demand must also be taken into account. If the shipboard electrical system can accept only some of the possible WHRS power, actual production must be adjusted to that limit. The power the generator can produce may exceed the power that can usefully be delivered. Relevant auxiliary consumption and electrical losses are then accounted for. This gives the net electrical power for each operating period within the selected system boundary and shows how much electricity is actually available to the ship.

If conditions remain sufficiently stable during an operating period, net electrical energy can be calculated by multiplying power in kilowatts by the corresponding duration in hours. The result is the energy for that period, expressed in kilowatt-hours. Adding the contributions from all relevant periods gives annual net electricity generation. This method is reliable only when the selected operating periods sufficiently reflect actual WHRS operation. If large differences in engine load, source temperature and cooling conditions are combined into one average operating mode, important information may be lost.

Particularly when the WHRS has to stop or reduce output under certain conditions, an average value may give a misleading picture. A period in which the heat supply alternates between meeting and falling short of the minimum needed for operation, for example, cannot simply be treated as though the installation operates continuously at the average heat input. If heat supply changes rapidly and the WHRS responds with a delay, a calculation using shorter time intervals may be necessary. Net power is then determined for successive operating conditions, including relevant start-up and transition periods.

For a relatively stable operating profile, a breakdown into representative operating modes may be sufficient. How detailed the calculation must be depends on heat-supply variation and the selected installation's dynamic behaviour. Operating hours must be accounted for consistently. If start-up, maintenance and downtime have already been excluded from effective production hours, these periods must not be deducted again as a separate production loss.

The same applies to electrical auxiliary consumption. If the power data used are already net of the consumption of certain internal loads, these are not deducted again. Additional auxiliary consumption during periods without generator production must, however, be included if it has not yet been accounted for in the annual balance. A period without electrical production may thus still make a small negative contribution to the net annual electrical balance.

When battery storage is used, energy accounting must also remain consistent. A distinction must be made between electricity delivered directly to the shipboard electrical system and electricity first stored and used later. Any storage and conversion losses are accounted for at the correct point, without counting the same energy twice.

The result is the annual net electrical energy that the selected WHRS makes available under the representative operating profile. If electrical demand has already been applied as a limit on output, this annual result also describes the usable electrical contribution within the selected system boundary. If calculated net production has not yet been limited by actual electrical demand, both results must be shown separately. Technically possible annual production and the amount of electricity actually put to good use are then not the same.

The reliability of the annual balance therefore does not depend only on the accuracy of WHRS performance data. Operating hours, auxiliary consumption, output limits and actual electricity use must also be accounted for consistently within the same system boundaries.

How Is Direct Heat Use Distinguished from Electricity Production?

Not every waste heat recovery system converts heat into electricity. Waste heat can also be used directly for a suitable thermal application on board. Annual output is then determined by the amount of heat actually delivered to the consumer concerned. For this purpose, available heat supply, temperature and the heat demand of the connected application at the same time are all important. A heat exchanger may make sufficient thermal power available, but if the receiving installation needs no heat, no useful heat is delivered.

An existing consumer may also be able to absorb only some of the available thermal power. For the annual calculation, it must therefore be established how much heat is actually transferred during the relevant operating periods, taking account of any heat losses in pipes and intermediate circuits. Additional electrical consumption by pumps and other equipment must also be included. However, this consumption cannot, without further conversion, be deducted directly from the useful thermal energy delivered as though electricity and heat served the same function.

Both forms of energy can be expressed in kilowatt-hours, but they are not automatically equivalent when determining energy savings. Electricity can supply different types of equipment, while heat is directly usable only for applications compatible with the available temperature. If a WHRS both produces electricity and supplies heat, these contributions must therefore be established separately. The same energy flow must be counted only once as useful output.

Heat supplied to an ORC forms the thermal input to the cycle. The electricity produced from it is a separate energy output. The entire thermal input must therefore not be presented alongside the electricity produced as though both amounts independently supply useful energy to the ship. If the remaining heat from the ORC condenser is actually used for heating or another thermal application, that heat can provide a separate useful contribution. This requires knowing how much heat the consumer actually receives and which existing energy production it displaces.

The annual energy balance must therefore clearly distinguish how much net electricity becomes available and how much useful heat is delivered. Expressing these contributions as fuel savings requires establishing how much less fuel the original generators, boilers or other energy systems require under sufficiently comparable conditions.

How Reliable Is a Calculated Annual Net Energy Output?

The reliability of a calculated annual output depends on the quality of operating data, how representative the operating profile is and the selected waste heat recovery system's performance data. Even a detailed calculation may remain uncertain if future engine loads are insufficiently known or the available WHRS performance data describe only a limited part of the expected operating range. A more detailed calculation does not automatically make uncertain assumptions more reliable.

The distinction between measured data and calculated assumptions is particularly important. On an existing ship, historical engine loads, operating hours, temperatures and electrical consumption can be recorded. By contrast, the performance of a WHRS that has not yet been installed must be predicted from the selected equipment and expected operating conditions. Such a prediction is not a measured operational result.

The future operating profile may also differ from historical use. Changes in ship speed, route or engine use, as well as other energy-saving measures, may affect the available heat supply. It must therefore be assessed whether existing operating data are sufficiently representative of the period in which the WHRS will actually operate. Cooling conditions are another possible source of uncertainty. If the annual calculation assumes more favourable cooling-water temperatures than occur during actual operation, electricity production may be overestimated.

The same applies to assumptions about WHRS control range, part-load performance, start-up time and availability. If reliable data on these characteristics are limited, it must remain clear which performance figures are based on assumptions. The effect of such uncertainties can be investigated by varying the main assumptions within technically defensible limits. This shows how sensitive the calculated annual net output is to changes in engine load, operating hours, cooling-water temperatures or assumed availability.

This need not result in a single general uncertainty percentage for every WHRS calculation. Which uncertainties are decisive varies with the ship, heat source, installation and available data. The presentation of the result must also reflect the reliability of the assumptions. If engine loads and availability are known only approximately, an annual energy output with many decimal places may suggest more certainty than the calculation warrants.

Once the system is in service, the energy actually delivered can be established through suitable measurements. For electricity production, these cover generator output, relevant auxiliary consumption and the amount of electricity made available within the agreed system boundary. These data must be recorded over the same periods. Engine load, source temperatures, cooling conditions and operating status are also needed to explain differences between expected and actual production.

Lower measured annual production does not automatically mean that the WHRS performs less well technically than predicted. The ship may, for example, have sailed fewer hours, operated at different engine loads or experienced warmer cooling water during the recording period. Electrical demand may also have caused production to be limited more often.

To assess the WHRS's technical performance, the measured results must therefore be compared with the performance that could have been expected under sufficiently similar conditions. This separates differences in system performance from changes in operating conditions.

Measured annual net output describes how much energy was delivered during the recording period concerned. A prediction for a future year remains dependent on the expected operating profile and its underlying assumptions. That distinction must be maintained even when operational data are used to improve the original calculation method.

How Do You Determine Annual Net Energy Output from Waste Heat Recovery?

Annual net energy output from waste heat recovery is determined by linking the representative operating and load profiles to the performance and additional energy consumption of the selected WHRS configuration. First, it is established which engines operate during the relevant operating periods and which heat sources are available at those times. For each operating mode, the corresponding temperatures, flow rates and technically permitted heat extraction are determined.

The next calculation establishes how much energy the system can produce under the heat and cooling conditions that occur together. The permitted control range, rated power limit and any heat exchanger and condenser limitations remain decisive. For electricity production, a distinction is made between gross generator power and the net electrical contribution after deduction of relevant auxiliary consumption and electrical losses. It must also be established how much electricity the shipboard electrical system can actually accept during the operating periods concerned.

Net energy is then determined for each operating period from its corresponding duration. Start-up, output reduction, maintenance, downtime and periods with too little suitable heat or too little electrical demand are accounted for without counting the same effects twice. The combined electrical energy over all relevant operating periods, after accounting for any additional auxiliary consumption outside generating hours, constitutes the annual net electrical WHRS output within the selected system boundary.

Any useful heat delivered directly is calculated separately. Electricity and thermal energy thus remain identifiable as distinct contributions, and double counting of the same heat flow is prevented. How reliable the calculated annual output is depends on the operating profile used, the heat source data and the selected installation's performance. Uncertainties about future operating conditions, cooling conditions and availability must therefore remain clear in the annual forecast.

Annual net energy output therefore follows not from rated WHRS power alone, but from the energy that can technically be produced and used during actual operating periods, after relevant additional energy consumption has been accounted for. This gives a well-founded annual energy balance for the selected WHRS configuration. The resulting fuel savings are then determined separately by assessing the ship's energy supply without and with the WHRS under sufficiently similar conditions.

This Article in the Series

Calculated annual net output forms an important basis for selecting an appropriate WHRS size, with actual engine loads and operating hours being particularly important. For a reliable comparison of alternatives, it must also be clear which power figures suppliers specify and which reference conditions, system boundaries and auxiliary loads apply. This relationship between installation capacity, net energy output and comparable performance is central to the sizing and performance assessment of WHRS installations.