Sizing and Performance Assessment of Waste Heat Recovery Systems (WHRS) for Ships
Publication date:
A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) must be matched to the heat available in actual service. Rated engine power and peak heat output are each insufficient on their own for sizing. Main and auxiliary engines operate at varying loads in service. Both the temperature and the amount of available waste heat therefore change. A large installation can recover considerable energy at high engine load while using only a limited proportion of its capacity during prolonged part-load operation.
Sizing therefore also depends on the operating and load profiles, the performance of the selected recovery system and how much of the energy produced can actually be used. For electricity production, cooling conditions and the system's own electricity consumption are also decisive. A reliable performance assessment also requires a clear distinction between specified power, calculated annual energy output, measured production and contractually guaranteed performance. These values describe different aspects of the installation and cannot simply be compared with one another.
The Right Installation Size Follows from the Usable Heat Profile
Installed engine power indicates what mechanical capacity is available on board, but not how often it is used. A propulsion engine may, for example, run at a relatively low load for long periods, while higher loads occur only under particular operating conditions under way. Where several generating sets are installed, the number of engines running may also vary by operating mode. For sizing, the relevant engine loads must therefore be linked to the corresponding heat sources and operating hours.
For exhaust gas heat recovery, relevant factors include the gas temperature, mass flow rate and allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature. For engine cooling water, the specified engine conditions and existing temperature control must also be taken into account. An engine's maximum heat output may therefore exceed the rate at which a WHRS can absorb heat within acceptable technical limits. The duration of the heat supply also matters: during short periods of engine operation, an installation may spend much of the available time reaching the required process conditions. For the same total number of engine hours, the energy output may therefore differ from that during prolonged periods with a stable heat supply.
To determine which WHRS size suits the operational and load profile, the assessment must therefore compare the possible designs under the same relevant operating conditions. A larger module can recover more heat temporarily, while a smaller design may perform well for more of the hours spent in normal operation. For ships with several heat sources, a central or modular configuration can also be considered. Several smaller modules may offer scope to adapt the installation to a varying heat supply, but may require more separate equipment. The most suitable design therefore depends on the usable net energy over the operating profile. A general ratio between rated engine power and WHRS capacity cannot establish which design is best.
Part Load and Load Changes Determine Actual Power
The electricity production of a WHRS does not necessarily change in proportion to engine load. When a marine engine's load falls, both the amount and temperature of the available waste heat may change. Exhaust gas mass flow rate and temperature may vary differently with engine load. Heat rejection through the engine cooling water may follow a different pattern again. In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), the changing heat supply affects the process conditions under which the organic working fluid is heated and flows through the expander. The heat absorbed, available expansion range and performance of the individual components together determine electrical power.
The cold side also affects electrical output. At the same engine load, warmer cooling water may change the condensing conditions and lead to lower electricity production. The relationship between engine power and generator output alone therefore does not adequately describe actual ORC performance. This interaction determines how electricity production from a WHRS changes with varying engine load. The net power that remains available is particularly important during prolonged part-load operation. Certain pumps and controls continue to draw power when gross generator output decreases. Net power may therefore fall more sharply than the rate of heat absorption or gross generator power.
At a sufficiently low heat input, the system may also fall outside its permitted operating range or cease to provide a positive net electrical contribution. Where this limit lies depends on the selected design and the available heat and cooling conditions. No single percentage of engine load sets the lower limit for every WHRS. During rapid load changes, the system's response time also matters because heat exchangers and fluid circuits take time to respond to changes in engine load. A performance curve for steady operating points therefore does not automatically show how much electricity is produced during short transitions. In highly variable operation, these periods must be included separately in the output forecast.
Assessing Power Specifications at the Same System Boundary
Suppliers may use different definitions of power. Thermal power at the source is the rate at which heat is available. Thermal input power is the rate at which heat is actually supplied to the ORC. Gross generator output and the net power available to the shipboard electrical system are separate quantities. Even when two installations are both offered with a net electrical power figure, their figures may have been determined on different bases. For one module, internal pump consumption may already have been deducted, while for another installation, additional intermediate-circuit pumps, cooling or electrical conversion losses still fall outside the specified value.
For a comparison of the specified power of different waste heat recovery systems, the figures must therefore use the same technical and electrical system boundaries. The conditions under which the power was established must also be sufficiently equivalent. Generator power at a high source temperature and with relatively cold cooling water cannot be compared directly with a value determined under different heat and cooling conditions. Where an intermediate circuit is used, it also matters what temperatures are actually available at the WHRS module. The exhaust gas temperature at the source may differ from the temperature at which heat enters the thermodynamic process.
It must also be clear whether the power specification relates to a maximum achievable value, a rated design operating point, a calculated performance figure or a contractually guaranteed value. This distinction determines which conclusions can be drawn from the specification. The installation with the highest gross or rated power therefore need not deliver the most net power under the ship's usual conditions. For selection, what matters most is the performance of the complete installation in the same relevant operating modes.
Annual Net Energy Output as a Measure of Utilization
Electrical power in kilowatts describes the rate at which electricity is generated at a particular moment. Annual energy output in kilowatt-hours also depends on the number of hours during which that power is actually available. Anyone multiplying maximum generator power by all engine hours without further assessment may therefore obtain an incorrect picture of the expected output. For annual net energy output over the actual operational profile, the relevant operating periods must be considered separately. For each period, the assessment considers which engines are running, how much suitable heat is available and what power the WHRS can deliver under the corresponding cooling conditions.
The calculation then determines how much electricity remains after accounting for the relevant auxiliary consumption and electrical losses. The shipboard electrical system must also actually be able to accept the electricity produced. Limited electrical demand can reduce the usable energy output below what the system could technically deliver. The contribution of each operating period is then linked to its duration. Start-up, output reduction, maintenance and downtime must be included in the annual balance without deducting the same losses more than once. If maintenance periods have already been excluded from effective production hours, for example, they must not be counted again as a separate production loss.
For a WHRS that directly supplies useful heat, annual thermal energy output is determined separately on the basis of the heat that the connected consumer actually absorbs. When electricity production and heat use are combined, the two forms of output are accounted for separately, and the original heat is not counted again as independent output. The calculated annual output also remains dependent on the ship's expected operation. A different operating area, lower engine load or a change in how the generating sets are operated may alter the output without any decline in the system's technical performance.
Demonstrating Net Electricity Generation on Board
Once the system is in service, electrical measurements can demonstrate how much electricity the WHRS actually produces. To establish net performance, however, it must be known which loads fall within the measurement boundary. A meter at the generator output shows gross generation, but does not automatically record the electricity that all the necessary pumps, cooling equipment and control equipment use.
For measurement of net electricity generation from a WHRS on board, the electrical connection diagram shows where the relevant energy flows can be recorded. If all flows of generated and consumed electricity pass through one suitable connection point, a bidirectional energy meter can measure the net exchange with the shipboard electrical system. Where supplies are separate, additional measurements or well-supported calculations are needed. Existing shared shipboard systems may also be relevant. If a cooling-water pump would already be running without the WHRS, its entire pre-existing consumption does not automatically count as a new load. It must, however, be established whether the pump uses more electricity because of the additional condenser heat load.
The active electrical energy produced and consumed must be recorded over the same period. Data on engine load, heat sources, cooling-water temperature and operating status help explain the measured performance. Lower generator output need not indicate deteriorating performance if less waste heat is available or the cooling water is warmer at the time.
The purpose of measurement also determines what can be inferred from the results. A measurement at a steady operating point can demonstrate the net power delivered under particular conditions. A record over a complete voyage shows how much energy was actually produced during the different operating modes. Both results are useful, but answer different questions. Measured net electricity generation also does not directly prove how much fuel has been saved. A separate assessment must establish how the WHRS has reduced the load on the existing generators or other energy sources.
Performance Guarantees Require Measurement Conditions Established in Advance
A contractual performance guarantee must make clear which quantity the supplier must demonstrate and under what conditions. A guarantee for gross generator power differs from a guarantee for net module power or net electrical power from the complete installation. Guaranteed power at one operating point is also different from a guarantee for annual energy output. It must therefore be agreed in advance which performance is measured under a WHRS guarantee and how the result is assessed. The agreement must be compatible with the actual heat source, available cooling, electrical connection and required auxiliary equipment.
The measurement period and the conditions for a valid test must also be established. If the engine supplies insufficient waste heat during an acceptance test or the condenser receives warmer cooling water than agreed, the resulting electrical output may differ without demonstrating a technical performance shortfall. For such deviations, it must be clear in advance whether the measurement remains valid and which correction method, if any, may be applied. That method must be compatible with how the system actually performs and permitted operating range. A general percentage correction for a different engine load or cooling-water temperature may provide insufficient assurance that the correction is valid.
Measurement uncertainty, any performance tolerance and the acceptance criterion must also be established separately. An inconclusive measurement differs from a valid test showing that the guaranteed performance was not achieved. The scope of testing also matters: a factory test of an individual module does not necessarily demonstrate the same performance as a performance test of the complete installation on board. When the guarantee also covers additional heat exchangers, pumps or electrical equipment, verification must cover the complete agreed system boundary.
From Capacity to Verifiable Ship Performance
Sound sizing starts with the heat supply that remains available during the relevant operating hours. The selected installation must be able to operate within that range and deliver sufficient net energy. A reliable performance assessment then makes clear under which conditions output is expected, how it can be measured and which performance, if any, is contractually guaranteed. For ORC-Based Waste Heat Recovery Systems (WHRS) for Ships, we support the assessment and selection of suitable designs together with a specialist international partner. The assessment relates the performance data to the engine loads, cooling conditions and electrical demand that can occur on the ship.
If the heat sources or technical connections are still uncertain, the first step is to assess system selection and integration of waste heat recovery systems in more detail. Comparing power figures is of limited value until it is clear how much heat can safely be made available. The selected capacity then provides a starting point for installation, maintenance and regulations for waste heat recovery systems. That assessment considers how the system can be integrated on board and how its performance can be maintained in service.
The financial significance of net annual energy output forms part of the business case and investment decision for waste heat recovery. This concerns not only the kilowatt-hours produced, but also the actual reduction in the energy the ship needs and the costs it incurs. Within waste heat recovery systems (WHRS) for ships, this performance assessment shows the difference between a quoted power figure and an evidenced contribution to the ship's energy supply. Installation size must be selected on the basis of actual operation, while for measurements and guarantees, it must remain clear under what conditions the performance was established. This gives a verifiable basis for further engineering and decision-making.