How Do the Operating and Load Profiles Determine the Correct Size of a Waste Heat Recovery System?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
The operating and load profiles determine the correct size of a waste heat recovery system because they show at which engine loads, for how many operating hours and under what conditions sufficient usable waste heat is available. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) must therefore not be sized automatically on the basis of rated engine power or the highest available heat output. A large system may recover substantial heat at maximum engine load but receive too little heat to perform well during prolonged part-load operation. A smaller design may better suit the usual operating conditions but, at higher load, leave some of the available heat supply unused. Which design ultimately delivers more useful energy depends on the available heat sources and the installation's performance during the different operating periods.
For a WHRS producing electricity, a distinction must also be made between the thermal power that the installation can absorb and the generator's rated electrical power. The control range, available cooling and concurrent electrical demand also limit how much of the output can be used. The correct WHRS size therefore follows from a comparison of the annual net energy output of different designs, in which technical feasibility and the additional value of greater capacity are also taken into account.
Why Does Rated Engine Power Not Determine the Correct WHRS Size?
Installed engine power indicates what mechanical power an engine can deliver under the conditions specified for it. For WHRS sizing, however, the main consideration is the load at which the engine actually operates. A ship may, for example, have a propulsion engine with relatively high rated power, yet use only a fraction of that power in normal service. The remaining power may be needed for particular sailing conditions, operational requirements or the selected power reserve.
The available waste heat cannot be inferred directly from rated engine power. During engine operation, fuel energy is divided between useful mechanical power, heat in the exhaust gases, heat rejection through cooling water and other losses. This distribution changes with engine load and depends on the engine design. When the engine is less heavily loaded, the amount of heat rejected through the exhaust gases and cooling water usually also changes. Exhaust gas temperature and exhaust gas mass flow rate need not follow the same pattern. For a WHRS using exhaust gas heat, these quantities are particularly important. Together with the permissible drop in exhaust gas temperature, they help determine how much thermal power can be extracted within acceptable technical limits. Existing heat consumers also limit the amount available.
For recovery from engine cooling water, the assessment is different. Cooling-water temperature, flow rate and permissible heat extraction are decisive here. A high cooling-water flow rate does not mean that all the thermal power carried by the cooling water is available for an additional installation. The existing engine cooling must be maintained. Rated engine power can therefore provide, at most, an initial indication of the possible scale of the heat supply. Sizing the WHRS requires heat-source data at the engine loads encountered in service.
This distinction becomes particularly important when a WHRS is selected on the basis of heat production at high engine load. The heat exchangers and thermodynamic process may then be sized for a capacity that is underused for most operating hours. If the heat supply remains below the installation's minimum usable operating range for long periods, there may be periods with no electricity generation at all.
Conversely, a WHRS matched mainly to a typical low engine load may have insufficient capacity at higher load to absorb all the technically available waste heat. This need not be an unfavourable choice. If the higher load occurs only briefly, the additional energy output from a larger installation may be limited. Sizing must therefore reflect the distribution of usable heat across the engine loads encountered in service. The highest engine power stated on the nameplate provides insufficient information for this.
How Is the Operational and Load Profile Translated into Available Thermal Power?
Useful operating and load profiles show how the ship is used over the relevant operating period. Alongside total hours under way, the most important information is the engine loads and operating conditions during those hours. For a propulsion engine, long periods at a relatively constant load, sailing at lower speed and brief higher loads may be important. During manoeuvring or port operation, other engines may be running or the main engine may supply insufficient usable waste heat.
On ships with several engines, it must also be clear which engines actually run in each operating mode. Combined rated engine capacity reveals little about the heat supply when only some engines are used simultaneously. Linking the load of each relevant engine to its operating hours shows how the engines are actually used. Reliable operating data can show which loads occur regularly, which engine combinations are used at those loads and which conditions occur only briefly.
The corresponding heat-source data are then matched to these engine loads. For exhaust gas heat, temperature and mass flow rate are particularly important. The temperature must relate to the point at which the heat exchanger actually receives the exhaust gases. If the exhaust gases have already transferred heat to an existing exhaust gas boiler, both their temperature and the thermal power still available downstream will differ. For engine cooling water, the temperatures and flow rates of the relevant cooling-water circuits are needed. The assessment must establish how much heat can be extracted within the specified engine operating limits and what heat is already used by existing consumers.
The data used must always relate to the same engine load. If, for example, the highest exhaust gas temperature is combined with the largest gas flow rate from another operating mode, the calculated thermal power may be unrepresentative of actual engine operation. The temperature of the available heat must also be taken into account. Two heat sources with the same thermal power do not automatically offer the same opportunities for electricity production. Temperature partly determines how much heat can be transferred to the selected thermodynamic process.
Alongside total operating hours, the duration of individual operating periods also matters. A breakdown of hours by load category shows how often particular engine loads occur, but not necessarily how long the engine runs continuously under those conditions. This distinction may be decisive when the WHRS needs time to start up or the heat supply regularly falls below the minimum needed for operation. Many short operating periods may therefore yield a different usable energy output from one long, continuous period with the same total operating hours.
For an initial assessment, a representative distribution of engine loads may provide enough information. With highly variable operation, it may be necessary to use a time series of engine load so that start-up periods, shutdowns and control losses are also included. The resulting heat profile shows, for each relevant operating mode, how much heat is technically usable, at what temperature, from which engines and for how long. This profile forms the basis for comparing possible WHRS capacities.
Why Is the Highest Heat Output Not Automatically the Correct Sizing Point?
An engine's highest heat output is usually not available throughout all operating hours. If a WHRS is selected solely for this maximum heat supply, the installation may have to operate at a considerably lower load for most of the ship's operating time. Whether this is unfavourable depends on the control range and performance characteristics of the selected WHRS. A larger installation can absorb more thermal power when enough heat is available, but must also remain operable under normal service conditions.
In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), the evaporation conditions, expansion of the working fluid and efficiency of individual components may change when less heat is available. Net electricity generation therefore need not decrease in proportion to heat input. If the heat supply falls below the minimum needed for operation, the ORC may have to reduce its output or stop temporarily. Where this limit lies depends in part on source temperature, the available cooling conditions and the chosen control strategy.
A smaller design may perform better during prolonged operation at lower engine loads if its control range better suits the available heat supply. However, the performance data for the modules under consideration must support this. A smaller ORC is not automatically more efficient at part load. At high engine load, a different situation arises. When more heat is available than the installation can absorb, the remaining heat must be rejected through the existing arrangements. For recovery from exhaust gases, some gas may, for example, be routed around the recovery installation if the selected configuration has suitable provision for this.
The generator's rated electrical power may also limit output. Once an ORC module reaches its electrical power limit, additional available heat cannot simply be converted into more electricity. For this purpose, the installation must have sufficient additional electrical and thermodynamic capacity. The choice between a smaller and larger WHRS therefore concerns the additional useful electricity that the larger design can actually produce during the relevant operating periods. Higher peak power has value only insofar as enough heat is available for long enough to use that capacity.
The most common engine operating point is an important starting point, but is not automatically the best sizing point. Less frequent loads may also contribute substantially to annual energy output if they occur for sufficiently long periods. Suitable installation size therefore follows from the complete heat profile and the actual performance of the different WHRS designs. No universal percentage of rated engine power or maximum heat supply gives the correct size for every shipboard installation.
Why Do Source Temperature and Technical Limits Also Determine WHRS Capacity?
Not all the heat that an engine releases can be absorbed by a WHRS. How much heat is actually available depends in part on the technical limits of the engine and existing ship installation. Exhaust gas heat recovery must account for the permitted exhaust gas back pressure, the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature and any temperature requirements of existing aftertreatment equipment. The heat exchanger may extract heat only while these conditions are maintained at the relevant engine loads.
When engine load changes, both exhaust gas flow rate and temperature may change. As a result, the total thermal power changes, and so may the proportion that can be recovered within the permitted pressure and temperature limits. For sizing, exhaust gas temperature at rated engine load is therefore insufficient. The heat exchanger must be suitable, both thermally and in terms of flow resistance, for the gas flow rates and temperatures occurring during the main operating periods.
For recovery from engine cooling water, different limits apply. The specified engine temperatures, necessary water circulation and original temperature control must be maintained. When the engine produces less heat, the thermostatic control may already have substantially reduced heat rejection through the existing coolers. Under those conditions, the WHRS must limit additional heat extraction to keep the engine within its permitted temperature range. The power actually recoverable may therefore be considerably less than the thermal power that would be expected on the basis of total cooling-water flow rate.
The temperature of the receiving medium also affects how much heat can be transferred. For this purpose, there must be a sufficient temperature difference between the heat source and the medium absorbing the heat. In an ORC, this partly determines the extent to which the organic working fluid can be heated and evaporated under the selected cycle conditions. Two heat sources with the same thermal power therefore need not allow the same electricity production. Heat at a lower temperature may offer less scope for generating mechanical power, particularly when the temperature difference between the heat source and the available cooling medium is small.
When exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat are combined, their separate temperature levels must remain identifiable in the assessment. Heat from the two sources cannot simply be added together as though all the energy were available at the same temperature. The heat sources must also be available simultaneously. The maximum thermal power available from exhaust gas at one engine load must not simply be combined with the maximum available from cooling water in a different operating mode. WHRS capacity must therefore be matched to the heat that can be extracted within acceptable technical limits under the same relevant operating conditions and actually transferred to the selected thermodynamic process.
How Do Part Load, Start-Up and Varying Load Affect Module Size?
A waste heat recovery system must be able to handle changes in the available heat supply during operation. The extent to which this is possible depends on the selected installation, component characteristics and permitted control range. For an ORC, sufficient heat must be available for the thermodynamic process to function within the specified conditions. The temperatures, pressures and circulation flow rates of the working fluid cannot be adjusted independently of one another.
When heat input decreases, the state of the working fluid and the available expansion may change. The control system must adjust the pump, expander and heat transfer accordingly. The performance curve for the design therefore shows how much net electricity the ORC can produce at part load. For module selection, rated power is important, but so is the minimum heat input at which the installation can function. This minimum need not represent the same thermal power under all operating conditions. The available source temperature and condensing conditions partly determine the usable operating range.
A larger module may therefore operate differently from a smaller design when the heat supply is limited. To establish which module better suits the operating profile, the actual performance of both configurations must be compared. Rated electrical power alone does not show which module is the better fit.
Alongside steady-load performance, start-up behaviour plays a role. When an engine is started, the heat associated with the load it eventually reaches is not necessarily available in full immediately. The engine, heat exchangers and any intermediate circuits must first warm up sufficiently. The WHRS can deliver usable electricity only once the thermodynamic process and generator connection meet the required operating conditions. With short engine operating periods, start-up may therefore take up a substantial share of the potential generating period.
When an engine is started and stopped regularly, the WHRS may repeatedly need to warm up, reduce its output or shut down. Total engine hours are then an unreliable guide to how many hours the recovery installation actually produces electricity. Rapid load changes also deserve attention. Heat exchangers, fluids and other components have thermal mass, so the WHRS may respond with some delay to changes in the engine operating point. This stored heat can partly smooth short-term changes, but is not a continuing energy source when the engine provides less waste heat for a prolonged period.
During sizing, a distinction must therefore be made between thermal power at steady engine load and the energy that can actually be used during transitions. Start-up duration, control behaviour and any periods without electricity production must be included in the annual output calculation. A WHRS for a ship with long, steady operating periods may therefore require a different module size from a WHRS for a ship with frequently changing engine load. Which design fits best depends on the actual operating profile and the performance of the available modules.
When Is One Larger WHRS Module or a Modular Design Suitable?
On ships with several engines, the combined heat supply may change substantially with the number of running engines and their individual loads. A WHRS sized for the total rated heat production of all engines may therefore be too large for operating modes in which only some engines are used. If several engines supply suitable waste heat simultaneously for long periods, a central WHRS can be considered. Heat is then supplied to the system through separate heat exchangers and, where applicable, a common heat transfer circuit.
Such a central design requires adequate temperatures and flow rates. The installation must also be able to respond when engines are brought into or taken out of service. Hydraulic distribution, pipe routes and control must therefore suit the different engine combinations occurring during operation.
A modular design offers other options. Available heat can be distributed among several smaller modules, or particular engines and heat sources can be connected to separate modules. When less heat is available, some modules may be able to remain out of service while the others operate within a favourable range. With a greater heat supply, more modules can then be used.
Whether this actually yields more net electricity depends on the minimum and maximum heat input, part-load performance and energy consumed by the auxiliaries of the individual modules. The ability to bring modules into or take them out of service does not in itself prove that a modular configuration is more efficient. Heat distribution between modules must also be assessed. A common circuit can combine heat from different sources, but additional heat exchangers, pipes and pumps may cause extra temperature differences, heat losses and energy consumption.
A central installation can make shared use of some equipment. For a modular design, more separate components, connections and control arrangements may instead be needed. Technical complexity may consequently increase even when the installation can respond more flexibly to the available heat supply. For heat sources at different temperatures, the way the sources are connected also matters. A common heat transfer circuit need not provide equally favourable conditions for every source and module. During selection, it must therefore remain clear which heat is available at which temperature and how it is transferred to the individual modules.
Alongside energy output, available engine-room space, weight, maintenance access and the required pipe and cable routes determine which design is practicable. A modular configuration may offer certain installation options, but does not automatically require less total space or maintenance. The comparison between one larger module and a combination of smaller modules must therefore be made for the same operating modes and heat conditions. Only then does it become clear which design delivers more net usable electricity and whether the additional complexity of a modular configuration is justified.
How Do Cooling Capacity and Electricity Use Limit the Appropriate WHRS Size?
For a WHRS producing electricity, sufficient waste heat is only part of the required energy supply. The thermodynamic process must also be able to reject the heat remaining after conversion through the condenser. The temperature and flow rate of the available cooling water affect the condensing conditions. As cooling water becomes warmer, the condensation temperature may rise. The expander may consequently deliver less power even when the same amount of heat remains available on the hot side.
A large ORC module therefore cannot produce its rated electrical power under all conditions. During sizing, the available heat-source conditions must be combined with the cooling conditions occurring during the same operating periods. On ships operated in different waters, the temperature of the water outside the ship may affect cooling capacity. Simultaneous heat rejection from engines and other equipment also determines how much capacity remains for the WHRS condenser.
Alongside cooling, electrical demand on board may limit useful WHRS production. The shipboard electrical system must be able to accept the electricity generated without the other generating sets moving outside their permitted operating range or the necessary power reserve being lost. A ship may, for example, have sufficient waste heat available for long periods while electrical demand is relatively low. If, under those conditions, the WHRS can produce more electricity than can usefully be accepted within the selected generator configuration, production must be limited.
In that case, the constraint is on the electrical side. In this operating mode, a larger system delivers no additional useful electricity unless there is additional electrical demand or another permitted use for the output. WHRS production may also affect heat availability itself. When the WHRS recovers waste heat from generating sets, the electricity it produces can reduce their load and change the heat they give off. Sizing must therefore be based on the generator load that actually results after the WHRS enters service.
The highest heat output, most favourable cooling-water temperature and greatest electrical demand also need not occur simultaneously. When these individually favourable conditions are combined, a WHRS size may be selected that is seldom fully used during actual operation. Appropriate capacity is therefore limited by the net electricity that can actually be delivered with simultaneously available heat, cooling and electrical demand. Higher rated generator power has additional value only when there is a useful load for that power often enough.
How Do You Compare Different WHRS Sizes Using the Actual Operating Profile?
A reliable comparison starts with representative operating and load profiles for the ship. These record the relevant operating modes, which engines are in use and the corresponding operating hours. For each operating mode, it is then determined which heat sources are available and how much heat can be used within acceptable technical limits. For exhaust gas heat recovery, relevant factors include temperature, mass flow rate and the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature. For engine cooling water, temperatures, flow rates and the limits of the original engine cooling must be included.
Existing heat consumers must also be included in this heat balance. The total thermal power that the engine releases may not all be available to the new WHRS. When several heat sources are combined, it must also be clear which heat becomes available simultaneously during the same operating periods.
The possible WHRS sizes can then be compared. For each design, it must be known what thermal input power is required for the stated electrical capacity and the source and cooling temperatures at which those performance figures apply. Minimum usable heat input, maximum heat input, rated generator power and permitted control range must also be included. For an ORC, performance away from the rated operating point is particularly important because the heat supply may change during operation.
A comparison based solely on generator power ratings is therefore insufficient. A design with a higher stated electrical power rating may perform differently at lower source temperatures, with warmer cooling water or with limited heat input than at its rated operating point. The electrical power each WHRS design can actually deliver is calculated for each relevant operating mode. Available heat, the scope for heat transfer, cooling conditions and thermodynamic process limits must be assessed together.
When the heat supply exceeds a module's thermal or electrical capacity, production is limited by that capacity. The remaining heat must not be counted as additional electricity production. The relevant energy consumption of each design is then accounted for. Pumps, any intermediate circuits, additional cooling and electrical conversion equipment may use some of the energy generated. For a reliable comparison, the same boundary between gross generator power and net electrical power must therefore be applied to every WHRS.
The electrical demand that the WHRS can serve also determines how much production is actually useful. If the shipboard electrical system cannot accept all the power the WHRS could technically deliver, the energy corresponding to the unused power must be excluded from the total actually used. This gives the usable net electrical power for each operating mode, subject to the prevailing heat-source, cooling and electrical conditions. These values can then be linked to the corresponding operating hours to calculate annual energy production for each WHRS design.
Start-up periods, shutdowns and other times without useful production must be accounted for correctly. If these periods have already been excluded from effective production hours, the associated losses must not be deducted again. With highly variable operation, a time-dependent simulation may be needed to establish these effects with sufficient reliability.
The comparison then shows how much additional electricity a larger WHRS can actually produce relative to a smaller design. It also becomes apparent at which engine loads the additional capacity is used and for how many hours it remains unused. A larger installation may therefore generate more net electricity over the year, but need not be the most economically attractive choice. The additional capacity may increase the costs of equipment, heat exchangers, cooling, integration and maintenance.
For an economic assessment, it must therefore be determined how much additional energy is saved relative to those higher costs. The comparison depends on how much fuel the net WHRS electricity actually displaces. This depends in part on how the generating sets are operated before and after installation and how much fuel the engines consume at the changed loads. The WHRS size with the highest annual electricity production therefore need not be the design with the most favourable balance between investment and savings.
Uncertainty in the future operating profile must also be taken into account. If a substantial share of the expected additional output depends on brief periods of high engine load, a small operational change may reduce the value of the extra capacity. A sound comparison therefore goes beyond rated generator power and peak output. In particular, usable annual net energy, the operating conditions in which it is produced and the additional output of each larger design determine which capacity is actually worthwhile.
What Influence Do Future Changes in the Operational Profile Have on WHRS Size?
A waste heat recovery system is selected for use over an extended period. The current operating and load profiles provide an important starting point, but operation need not remain unchanged throughout the remaining service period. If a ship starts sailing different routes, maintains a lower speed for long periods or is used for different work, the distribution of engine loads may change. Temperatures, flow rates and operating hours of the available heat sources may consequently also change.
Energy-saving measures may have the same effect. A hull or propulsion improvement may, for example, reduce the engine power required at the same ship speed. A WHRS that was matched to the original heat supply may consequently have to operate more often at lower heat input. Changes to the engine installation or generating-set operation may also alter heat availability. Even if rated engine power remains similar, exhaust gas and cooling-water conditions need not remain the same.
When selecting a new WHRS, known changes in the operating and load profiles and anticipated changes that are sufficiently well defined must therefore be taken into account. This does not mean that the installation must be made suitable for every conceivable future operating configuration. If future engine load is uncertain, it may be useful to compare several plausible operating profiles. The assessment then shows how annual net energy production and the number of usable operating hours for each WHRS size vary under those conditions.
An installation that is attractive only under one favourable assumption about the heat supply may be more sensitive to operational changes. Another design may, across several relevant operating profiles, continue to deliver sufficient usable energy, even when its rated power is lower. The final choice still depends on the heat sources actually available, the installation's performance data and the economic significance of the differences between possible designs.
What Is the Correct WHRS Size for a Given Operational and Load Profile?
The correct size of a waste heat recovery system is determined by the heat that can be usefully recovered within acceptable technical limits during the relevant operating hours. Rated engine power and the highest heat output are insufficient on their own for sizing. The operating and load profiles show which engines run in the different operating modes, how heavily they are loaded and how long the corresponding heat sources remain available. It can thus be established how much thermal power actually becomes available at the required temperature.
A larger WHRS can recover more heat at high engine load, but need not be the best choice when this heat supply occurs only briefly. A smaller installation may better suit prolonged part-load operation, while at higher loads some of the available heat remains unused. Selection therefore depends on rated thermal and electrical capacity as well as minimum heat input, part-load performance and the system's start-up behaviour. On ships with several engines, it must also be investigated whether one central installation or a modular design better matches how the engines are used.
Available cooling capacity and electrical demand also limit the appropriate size. A large heat supply does not yield a corresponding amount of usable electricity if the condenser cannot reject sufficient heat or the shipboard electrical system cannot accept the electricity generated. Suitable capacity therefore follows from a comparison of different WHRS designs under the same relevant heat source, cooling and operating conditions. For each operating mode, the assessment establishes how much net electricity can be used and how much energy this yields over the complete operating period.
The design with the highest annual net electricity generation need not be the best economic choice. The additional energy output from a larger installation and the additional investment required for it must therefore be assessed separately. A WHRS must therefore not be selected to be as large as possible, but must be matched to the heat supply available for sufficiently long periods during actual operation. This avoids selecting the system mainly for a favourable peak operating point when most operating hours occur at other engine loads.
This Article in the Series
A WHRS sized for the maximum heat supply may leave much of its capacity unused during prolonged part-load operation. That risk changes when other energy-saving measures affect the available waste heat. Which installation size delivers the greatest output over the complete operating period becomes clear from the calculation of annual net energy output. This assessment forms an important part of WHRS sizing and performance assessment.