How Do You Compare the Specified Power of Different Waste Heat Recovery Systems?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
The power specified for different waste heat recovery systems can be compared reliably only when it is clear what the figure represents, under what conditions the power is delivered and how much net power is available on board. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) may, for example, be specified by its thermal input power, its maximum gross generator output or its net electrical output. These quantities describe different parts of the energy conversion process and cannot be compared directly.
Even two installations with the same specified electrical power need not perform equally under a ship's heat and cooling conditions. A manufacturer may, for example, specify power at a relatively high source temperature with favourable cooling, while another supplier bases its figure on different temperatures or a wider system boundary. Both power specifications may be individually correct yet, without additional data, still give a misleading comparison. For a reliable assessment, the power figures must first be put on a common basis using equivalent definitions and system boundaries. The next step is to establish how much electrical power each system can deliver under the same relevant heat source, cooling and operating conditions. The highest rated power does not necessarily translate into the largest net contribution to the ship's energy supply.
Which Power Is Stated in a Technical Specification?
A waste heat recovery system uses heat rejected through, for example, exhaust gases or engine cooling water. For electricity production, some of this heat is converted through a thermodynamic cycle into mechanical power, after which a generator produces electricity. Several power figures describe different stages of this process. The thermal power of the heat source describes the rate at which heat is available under particular conditions. This is usually expressed in kilowatts thermal (kWth). For exhaust gases, this power depends on factors including temperature, mass flow rate and the extent to which the gas may be cooled. However, the total thermal power in the exhaust gas stream may exceed the rate at which heat can actually be transferred to a WHRS.
For the installation's thermal input power, the point to which the quoted value refers must also be clear. A power specification may, for example, apply to the heat that an exhaust gas heat exchanger absorbs, the heat transported through an intermediate circuit or the heat ultimately supplied to the working fluid of an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC). Between these points, heat losses may occur, and temperature differences are needed to transfer the heat. The thermal power specified on the hot side of an intermediate circuit therefore need not equal the rate at which heat is actually absorbed by the ORC. Two thermal power figures can be compared directly only when they have been determined at the same location and under equivalent conditions.
The generator power figure gives the generator's electrical output. This is often expressed in kilowatts electrical (kWe). In a gross power specification, the installation's own electrical consumption has not yet been fully deducted. In a net power specification, some of this consumption has already been accounted for. The technical specification must show which pumps, cooling equipment, controls and electrical losses are included. Without a clearly defined system boundary, the term net says too little about the complete installation's electrical contribution to the ship.
A distinction must also be made between power and energy. Electrical power is expressed in kW or kWe, while the amount of electricity produced over a particular period is expressed in kilowatt-hours (kWh) or megawatt-hours (MWh). A high generator power rating yields a corresponding amount of energy only if the power is available for enough operating hours and can be used.
For direct heat use, the comparison is different. An installation supplying hot water, steam or thermal oil to an existing consumer can be described by its useful thermal power. This is not directly equivalent to the electrical power of a steam turbine or ORC generator. To compare direct heat use with electricity production, it must therefore first be established which existing heat or electricity production can be replaced by recovery. For comparisons between electricity-generating waste heat recovery systems, net electrical power under the same technical conditions remains the main starting point.
Why Are Gross Generator Power and Net System Power Different?
Gross generator power is only one part of the power balance of an electricity-producing WHRS. A steam cycle or ORC needs additional equipment to absorb heat, circulate the working fluid and reject the remaining heat. This equipment may itself consume electricity. In an ORC, for example, the working fluid pump requires power to raise the pressure of the liquid working fluid again. If heat is supplied through a separate water or thermal oil circuit, additional circulation pumps may be needed. Cooling-water pumps, controls and other auxiliary equipment may also contribute to the installation's own electrical consumption.
How much net power remains depends on the auxiliary loads and on where the system boundary is drawn. Net module power may, for example, refer to the electrical power available at the ORC module's electrical connection after deducting certain internal loads. That figure may exclude pumps in an external intermediate circuit, additional cooling equipment and electrical losses between the module and the shipboard electrical system. Two suppliers may therefore both quote a net electrical power figure while their specifications cover different parts of the installation. One value may apply at the module connection, while the other describes the power delivered to the shipboard electrical system after deducting the power used by additional equipment. The figures are then not necessarily equivalent.
For a direct comparison, the same electrical system boundary must therefore be used for both installations. The comparison must identify the equipment needed to deliver the specified power under the relevant shipboard conditions. Existing auxiliary consumption must also be treated correctly. If a WHRS is connected to a cooling-water circuit whose pumps are already operating, the full pre-existing pumping load does not automatically count as an additional WHRS load. For the additional net contribution, what matters in particular is any new or changed electricity consumption caused by the installation.
If an existing pump requires more power after connection of the WHRS, that increase must be included. Unchanged original consumption is not attributed to the WHRS again without reason. The distinction between the original and new ship installation thus remains clear. Auxiliary loads must be deducted only once. If the specified net module power already includes working fluid pump consumption, the same pump load must not be deducted again. Conversely, a necessary pump outside the stated system boundary must not be ignored.
Connecting a generator through power electronics can also introduce conversion losses. Depending on the design, power at the generator terminals may consequently differ from power that becomes available at the connection point to the shipboard electrical system. For each installation, it must therefore be clear how much gross electrical power is produced and which additional loads and losses still need to be accounted for. Only when these data have been adjusted to the same system boundary can it be established how much net electrical power the different designs actually deliver to the ship.
Under Which Heat Conditions Does the Specified Electrical Power Apply?
The electrical power of a waste heat recovery system depends on the heat that can actually be supplied to the thermodynamic process. A specified maximum generator power therefore always applies under particular conditions on the hot side of the installation. For recovery from exhaust gases, gas temperature, mass flow rate and the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature are among the determining factors. At a high exhaust gas temperature, a system may absorb enough heat to reach a given electrical output, while at a lower temperature or a lower gas flow rate less power becomes available. The specified maximum may therefore be a valid performance figure under the original reference conditions without that power being available at the ship's actual engine load.
For engine cooling water, similar dependencies apply. Temperature, water flow rate and permitted heat extraction determine how much thermal power can be transferred. A high water flow rate at a relatively low temperature need not support the same electricity generation as a lower rate of heat transfer at a higher temperature. The locations at which the temperatures are determined also matter for the comparison. The exhaust gas temperature immediately after the turbocharger, for example, is not necessarily equal to the temperature of the heat supplied to the ORC module.
If exhaust gas heat is first transferred to a water or thermal oil circuit, the ORC receives the heat through this intermediate circuit. The original exhaust gas temperature must then not be treated as though the same temperature were available directly at the evaporator. The necessary heat transfer and any heat losses must be included in the assessment. The temperature at the heat source outlet also deserves attention. How much heat a heat exchanger can absorb depends not only on inlet temperature, but also on the allowable temperature drop and the temperature profile of the receiving fluid.
Two installations using the same heat source may therefore absorb different amounts of heat if their heat exchangers, required return temperatures or temperature differences differ. The heat that can actually be transferred must be determined for both designs under the same source conditions. A specified thermal input power range also requires careful interpretation. Such a range may indicate the limits within which a module can function, but does not mean that maximum electrical power is achievable at every heat input within that range.
Temperature remains decisive for how much heat can be converted into mechanical power. Two operating modes with the same thermal input power may therefore yield different electrical outputs if the source temperature or cold-side temperature changes. The technical limits of the original engine installation also remain in force. Exhaust gas heat extraction must stay within the limits on back pressure and the drop in exhaust gas temperature. For engine cooling water, specified engine temperatures and necessary circulation must be maintained.
A power comparison that assumes heat extraction outside these limits for one installation does not compare equally feasible applications. Both candidate installations must be assessed on the basis of the heat that the ship concerned can make available under the same operating conditions within acceptable technical limits.
How Does Available Cooling Affect the Power Comparison?
The cold side of a waste heat recovery system is at least as important as the available heat source. In a condensing steam cycle or ORC, the heat not converted into mechanical power must largely be rejected through the condenser. The cooling circuit's temperature and capacity therefore affect the thermodynamic process's performance. In an ORC, condensing temperature partly determines the pressure against which the expander operates. If the available coolant becomes warmer, condensing pressure may rise. The usable expansion range may consequently narrow and the electrical power generated may decrease, even when the same thermal power remains available on the hot side.
This may substantially affect comparisons between different power specifications. An installation whose maximum power was established at a low cooling-water temperature may produce less electricity under the ship's warmer cooling conditions. Another installation may have a lower maximum under the original reference conditions yet perform differently at the same actual cooling-water temperature. The individual maxima do not show which design delivers the most net power under those conditions.
Cooling-water temperature alone does not describe all cold-side conditions. The required water flow rate, cooling-water temperature rise and heat transfer in the condenser also matter. A favourable cooling-water inlet temperature offers insufficient assurance if the ship's existing cooling system cannot provide the required flow rate or necessary heat rejection. If the WHRS is connected to a shared cooling circuit, the other users of that circuit must also be taken into account. Engines, lubricating oil coolers and other installations may use the same cooling-water pumps and central coolers. The capacity remaining for the WHRS then depends partly on the simultaneous load on these systems.
It also makes a difference which heat source the WHRS uses. For electricity production from exhaust gas heat, heat that previously left the ship through the funnel may now be rejected through the condenser to the ship's cooling system. For recovery from engine cooling water, by contrast, some existing heat rejection may be transferred from the original engine cooler to the ORC condenser. How much additional cooling capacity is needed therefore depends on the selected heat source and how the installation is connected.
For a reliable power comparison, both candidate installations are therefore assessed under cooling conditions that can actually occur at the relevant engine loads. Cooling-water inlet temperature, required flow rate and available heat rejection must all be included in the assessment. Combining the highest heat production from one operating mode with exceptionally favourable cooling conditions from another may give a calculated electrical output that cannot be achieved during actual ship operation.
Generator power figures are therefore comparable only when cold-side conditions have also been established on the same basis. Otherwise, differences between power specifications may be caused partly by the cooling conditions used rather than by the installations' own performance.
What Do Maximum, Rated and Guaranteed Power Mean?
Technical power specifications may have different meanings. Maximum electrical power is the highest power output a system can achieve under particular conditions. This need not be the same as the power that remains available for long periods during normal operation. Rated power usually describes an established design or reference value. Its precise meaning depends, however, on the manufacturer's definition for the installation concerned. Without the associated heat and cooling conditions, it is therefore unclear whether two power ratings were determined under equivalent conditions.
A distinction must also be made between power that can be delivered continuously and power that can be delivered only for a short time. An installation may reach a particular peak power under favourable conditions, while thermal, mechanical or electrical limits determine which power may be delivered over longer periods. For the comparison, it must therefore be clear whether a specified maximum refers to a stable operating point, a temporarily achievable value or the rated capacity for which the installation was designed.
Guaranteed power has a different meaning. In this case, the performance and the conditions under which it must be delivered are contractually defined. The guarantee may, for example, relate to net electrical power at a particular heat input, source temperature, cooling-water temperature and electrical system boundary. The verification method must also be sufficiently clear. A performance guarantee must state under which conditions measurements are taken, which measurement uncertainty or permitted deviation applies and how measurement results are adjusted, where applicable, to the agreed reference conditions.
A power value in a product brochure is not automatically a contractual guarantee. The same applies to a calculated performance figure quoted by a supplier at a favourable design operating point. The basis for such a figure must therefore be established separately. Results from a factory test and measurements during commissioning on board are also not necessarily equivalent. The heat source, cooling and additional equipment on board may differ from the conditions under which a standalone module was previously tested.
A successful factory test therefore does not automatically prove that the same net electricity generation is achieved on the ship. For this, actual operating conditions and the agreed system boundary must match the conditions on which the performance is based. A calculated maximum, a substantiated design value, a measured result and a contractually guaranteed power figure carry different evidential weight. These concepts must not be used interchangeably.
For a fair comparison, it must first be clear which type of power specification each supplier uses. Only then can it be established whether the values are technically equivalent and what additional verification is needed to assess the net power actually available.
How Does Available Electrical Power Change at Part Load?
In service, a waste heat recovery system does not run continuously at the operating point used to specify its maximum power. Heat output from marine engines changes with load, so available temperatures and flow rates may also differ from the nominal reference values. At a lower engine load, for example, exhaust gas mass flow rate may decrease while gas temperature follows a different pattern. The amount of heat that can be transferred to the WHRS therefore need not fall in proportion to engine power.
Available cooling-water heat may also change differently from exhaust gas heat. When an engine operates at part load, each heat source's properties determine how much thermal energy remains available and at what temperature. How the WHRS responds to this depends on the selected design. The heat exchangers, control system, expander and condenser together determine how much electrical power is possible at the new operating point.
A module with the highest gross generator power under rated conditions therefore need not retain the same advantage during prolonged part-load operation. Performance away from the design operating point must be established separately for each installation. At part load, auxiliary consumption and gross generator power may change by different proportions. Certain pumps and controls may remain necessary when the ORC produces less electricity. Net power may consequently decrease more sharply than gross power.
In other designs, certain pumps or other auxiliaries may be run at reduced output. As a result, additional electricity consumption may decrease when less heat is available. The effect on net power depends on the components used and how they are controlled. A fixed auxiliary consumption percentage across the full power range is therefore not necessarily suitable for a technical comparison. For this comparison, it must be clear how much electricity the relevant equipment actually use in the different operating modes.
Lower limits may also apply for stable operation. If the heat source provides insufficient thermal power or too low a temperature, the system may fall outside its permitted operating range. A specified minimum thermal input power is therefore meaningful only in conjunction with the required source temperature and cooling conditions. For a reliable comparison, performance data are needed that show what gross and net electrical power is possible under different heat and cooling conditions. The limits for heat input, generator power and expander operation must also be clear.
A single maximum power value does not adequately describe performance at typical engine loads. Nor can it be deduced from the expander type alone which design performs most favourably at part load. The comparison must therefore concern the complete installations and their net performance within the same relevant operating range. Only then does it become clear whether a difference in rated power also matters during actual operation.
Why Are Power Specifications for Different ORC Designs Not Directly Comparable?
ORC-based waste heat recovery systems may use different expanders and system configurations. Some designs have a turbine, while others use a screw expander. The expansion principle affects technical characteristics but does not on its own determine how much net electricity the ship receives. In particular, the way a design is described in technical documentation can lead to a misleading comparison. A turbine module may, for example, be offered with its maximum gross generator power, while for a screw-expander module a net electrical power is stated instead. Comparing these two values directly would compare figures based on different definitions of power.
Suppliers may also include different equipment in their modules. In one design, certain pumps, heat exchangers and controls form part of the module, while in another installation they are installed separately. Rated module power then does not show how much electricity the complete installation itself needs or how much power ultimately remains available at the connection point to the shipboard electrical system. External equipment must also be included within the same system boundary.
Connections to heat sources may also differ. One module may be supplied from a suitable hot-water circuit, while another design needs a separate exhaust gas heat exchanger and intermediate circuit. The specified temperature range may therefore refer to hot water at the module rather than the original exhaust gas temperature. These temperatures are not interchangeable. Heat transfer between the original source and the ORC must be included in the comparison.
Even when two ORC modules have the same stated net electrical output, the required thermal input, source temperature and cooling conditions may differ. Under actual conditions on board, they therefore need not deliver the same power. For installations with several modules, the heat available to the modules together also matters. The sum of the individual modules' maximum power outputs is achievable only when every module simultaneously receives sufficient heat and the necessary cooling capacity also remains available.
When several modules use the same heat source, heat extraction by one module may change conditions for another. Combined thermal input and electricity production must therefore be assessed for the complete configuration. Auxiliary consumption may also differ from that of individual modules. Certain pumps and cooling equipment may be shared, while others are needed separately for each module. Total net electrical power therefore does not necessarily follow from simply adding module values based on different system boundaries.
For comparisons between turbine and screw-expander designs, what ultimately matters is how much net electrical power the complete installation can deliver under the same relevant heat and cooling conditions. A general preference based on the expansion principle or the module's nominal rating is insufficient for this. Performance data must demonstrate which design can deliver the largest usable electrical contribution under the ship's actual operating conditions.
When Can the Ship Actually Use the Specified Electrical Power?
A waste heat recovery system makes a useful electrical contribution only when the shipboard electrical system can accept the electricity generated. Available generator power must therefore be distinguished from the power that can actually contribute to the ship's energy supply in the relevant operating mode. When sufficient electrical demand exists, recovered electricity can replace part of the existing generator output. If electrical demand is lower than net WHRS power output, it may be necessary to reduce that output.
In that case, the maximum deliverable power remains a characteristic of the WHRS, although the ship cannot make full use of it. A higher specified power does not then automatically lead to more useful electricity being delivered. Interaction with existing generating sets may also limit the usable contribution. The shipboard electrical system must retain sufficient power reserve and suitable control capabilities when WHRS output changes or is lost unexpectedly.
As a result, some of the theoretically available WHRS power cannot be used under certain conditions. How much power the shipboard electrical system can accept depends on factors including the minimum load of generating sets in service and the possibility of shutting down a set within acceptable technical limits. If the WHRS uses heat from generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity the WHRS produces, an interaction also arises between electricity production and the available heat supply.
A lower generator load may change exhaust gas temperature, gas flow rate and cooling-water heat. The available WHRS power may consequently also decrease or be distributed differently. In this situation, electricity production must therefore be assessed at the resulting engine load. A calculation based on heat production before the load on the generating sets is reduced may yield a power value inconsistent with the new combined operating point.
This interaction differs when the heat comes from a propulsion engine whose load does not change as a result of WHRS electricity. With unchanged propulsion load, the heat supply may remain largely independent of the reduction in load on individual auxiliary engines. For a reliable comparison, it must therefore be clear how much electrical power is technically available and which portion of it the shipboard electrical system can actually accept under the relevant operating conditions.
The useful electrical contribution may be smaller than the technically available power without the WHRS itself underperforming. The limit then comes from electrical demand or the ship's operating strategy. The net electricity that can actually be used then provides a basis for assessing energy savings. Specified electrical power does not, however, establish how much fuel will be saved. For this, it must be established separately which existing electricity production is reduced and how the fuel consumption of the engines concerned changes under the new operating conditions.
Which Data Make Power Specifications for Different Installations Comparable?
A reliable comparison starts with the exact meaning of the specified power. For each installation, it must be clear whether this is thermal power available at the source, thermal input power, gross generator output, net module power or the net electrical power that the complete installation delivers to the shipboard electrical system. The location to which the value refers must also be defined. Without a common system boundary, individually correct power specifications may still give a misleading impression of relative performance.
Hot-side conditions are then established. Available temperature, mass flow rate or water flow rate and thermal power must relate to the same relevant operating mode. If an intermediate circuit is used, it must be clear how much heat reaches the WHRS module and at what temperatures. Original heat source conditions must not be equated with conditions after heat transfer and transport.
On the cold side, cooling-water inlet temperature, required flow rate and necessary condenser heat rejection are assessed on a comparable basis. These data must also match the conditions the ship can actually provide at the engine load concerned. Then, for each design, the relevant auxiliary consumption is established. It must be clear which pumps, cooling equipment and electrical losses are already accounted for in the stated net value and which additional loads still fall outside that specification.
The distinction between existing and additional energy consumption must also be treated in the same way for both installations. A pump already running for an existing shipboard function must not be counted in full as additional WHRS consumption for one candidate while remaining outside the comparison for the other. The next step is to establish what the power figures represent and what evidence supports them. A maximum power, a rated design value, a calculated part-load performance and a contractually guaranteed value are not necessarily equivalent.
If a supplier offers a power guarantee, the reference conditions, system boundary, measurement method and acceptance conditions must be sufficiently clear. For measured performance, the test conditions and measurement uncertainty must remain identifiable. For an initial technical comparison, it can then be determined what net electrical power each installation delivers under the same representative heat and cooling conditions.
If the selected operating point falls outside a candidate's permitted operating range, the specified maximum cannot simply be extrapolated to those conditions. Additional performance data are then needed, or the design concerned proves unsuitable under those conditions. Performance at other regularly occurring engine loads must also be compared. Two installations may deliver comparable net power at the rated design operating point while their performance diverges during prolonged part-load operation or with warmer cooling water.
The comparison must therefore cover enough of the relevant operating range to prevent selection from being determined solely by one favourable maximum value. Calculation of annual net electricity generation then forms a separate step. For this, the net power outputs in the different operating modes are linked to the hours during which those conditions occur. Electrical power in kW and energy produced in kWh remain distinct quantities.
An installation with a lower specified maximum power may ultimately be more suitable if its net electrical contribution is greater during usual operating conditions or if more operating hours fall within its usable operating range. Conversely, a design with a higher maximum power may be preferable if that power is available sufficiently often under actual heat and cooling conditions and the relevant auxiliary consumption and technical limits have been correctly included.
The power specified for different waste heat recovery systems therefore cannot be compared reliably on the basis of the highest figure in a product specification. Power definitions, system boundaries and reference conditions must first be equivalent. Actual heat supply, available cooling, additional energy consumption and electrical demand then determine how much net power is actually usable. Only once these data have been assessed on the same basis can it be established which installation can deliver the largest usable electrical contribution to the ship's energy supply under the relevant operating conditions.
This Article in the Series
The highest specified generator power is not automatically the best basis for comparison when reference conditions, system boundaries and auxiliary consumption differ. For the calculation of annual net energy output, what matters particularly is what power is available during actual operating hours. After installation, net electricity generation on board can be established using suitable measurement points and consistent accounting for the installation's own consumption. This links supplier specifications to in-service measurements within the sizing and performance assessment of WHRS installations.