How Does Electricity Generation From a WHRS Change with Varying Engine Load?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
Electricity generation from a waste heat recovery system changes when engine load rises or falls because the quantity and temperature of the available waste heat change. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) that converts heat from exhaust gases or engine cooling water into electricity therefore does not deliver the same power at every engine load.
In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), the heat supply affects the conditions under which the working fluid is heated and flows through the expander. The working fluid flow rate and available expansion work may consequently change. However, electricity production need not rise or fall in proportion to engine load. The heat exchangers, condensing conditions, the control system and the system's own energy consumption also determine how much net electrical power becomes available. At higher engine load, electricity production may increase until the installation reaches a thermal, mechanical or electrical capacity limit. At lower load, net power may instead decrease more sharply than the available thermal power, particularly if the system's own energy consumption remains relatively high. To establish this relationship reliably, the heat source, cooling and WHRS performance must be assessed at the same relevant engine operating points.
How Does Engine Load Affect the Quantity and Temperature of the Available Waste Heat?
A marine engine converts some of the fuel energy supplied into mechanical power. The remaining energy is rejected through the exhaust gases, engine cooling water and other cooling streams, among other routes. When engine load changes, the fuel supply, energy distribution and conditions under which this heat leaves the engine change. For recovery from exhaust gases, gas temperature and mass flow rate are particularly important. Together with the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature and the thermal properties of the gas, they determine how much heat can be extracted from the exhaust gas stream. At higher engine load, exhaust gas mass flow rate increases under many operating conditions, but temperature need not change by the same proportion.
How the temperature changes depends on factors including engine type, air supply, turbocharger configuration, rotational speed and engine control. In certain engines, exhaust gas temperature may change relatively little over part of the load range or follow a different pattern from the available thermal power. Measuring exhaust gas temperature alone is therefore insufficient to determine potential WHRS production. The mass flow rate and amount of heat that can actually be transferred within the permitted operating limits must also be known.
A higher exhaust gas flow rate also does not automatically mean that the WHRS can absorb all the available heat. The permitted exhaust gas back pressure, the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature and the capacity of the heat exchanger may limit heat extraction. For electricity production, the thermal power that can actually be delivered to the installation at the relevant engine load is therefore what matters.
The response to engine load is different for engine cooling water. The cooling system maintains engine temperatures within specified limits. In some engine designs, the cooling-water temperature may therefore remain relatively constant while the amount of heat rejected through cooling changes with engine load. Cooling-water flow rate, the operation of thermostatic devices and existing heat consumers also determine how much additional heat is available. The total thermal power that a cooling-water circuit rejects must therefore be assessed separately from the thermal power the ORC can use.
If a WHRS uses both exhaust gas heat and cooling-water heat, the two sources may respond differently to the same change in engine load. Exhaust gas heat is usually available at a higher temperature, while engine cooling water has different temperature and control requirements. How much heat each source can contribute to the thermodynamic process depends in part on where the heat is transferred. For a reliable assessment, temperatures, flow rates and available thermal power must therefore be established at each relevant engine operating point. Neither rated engine power nor a fixed relationship between engine load and waste heat provides enough information to establish those values reliably.
How Does the Operating Point of an ORC Change When Engine Load Changes?
In a conventional ORC, waste heat is transferred to an organic working fluid through one or more heat exchangers. The working fluid is heated and evaporated under pressure, after which the vapour flows through an expander. This converts some of the absorbed thermal energy into mechanical power to drive the generator. When engine load changes, the temperature and amount of heat available on the hot side of the ORC may change. The conditions under which the working fluid is heated and evaporated may consequently also change. The control system must adjust working fluid circulation and the relevant pressure and temperature conditions to the new heat supply.
At lower engine load, for example, less heat may become available at the evaporator. Depending on the design, less working fluid may consequently be evaporated or the cycle may operate under different evaporating conditions. Both changes may affect the mechanical power delivered by the expander. This power does not depend only on the amount of vapour flowing through the expander. The enthalpy drop across the expander and its performance also determine how much mechanical work it delivers. If inlet conditions, condensing pressure or expansion characteristics change, electrical power may consequently respond differently from thermal input power.
A reduction in the heat absorbed therefore need not lead to the same percentage reduction in electricity generation. Thermal conversion efficiency may change when the ORC operates outside its rated design operating point. The heat exchangers also affect this relationship. If the working fluid flow rate changes, heat transfer coefficients and temperature differences may change with it. The heat that the ORC actually absorbs therefore need not follow the same pattern as the total thermal power that the engine releases to the original heat source.
Each expander also has its own operating range. A turbine, screw expander or other expander type may operate at a different efficiency from its rated-condition efficiency as flow rates and pressure ratios change. The resulting performance depends on the specific design and how it is controlled. Within certain limits, the ORC control system can influence the process conditions by adjusting the working fluid pump or expander load, for example. In some configurations, evaporating pressure may change with load. Other control strategies seek to keep particular pressures within a selected range.
Not every change in heat supply therefore immediately leads to the same change in evaporating pressure or electrical power. However, the control capabilities remain limited by the characteristics of the heat exchangers, expander, condenser and other components. For a turbine, the state of the working fluid at the inlet must also remain suitable for the selected machine. The control system must keep vapour conditions and other operating parameters within permitted limits when seeking higher power.
Electrical power ultimately follows from the heat absorbed, the thermodynamic operating point and the performance of the complete ORC. A fixed conversion factor between thermal input power and electrical output power is sufficient only if the relevant conversion losses actually remain almost the same under the conditions examined.
Why Does Electricity Production Not Always Increase in Proportion to Engine Load?
As engine load rises, more waste heat may become available. An ORC operating within its usable range may consequently produce more electricity. However, the increase in power depends on both the change in heat supply and the system's performance at the new operating point. Within a particular load range, electricity production may rise relatively sharply if more thermal power is available and evaporating conditions improve. At another load, the exhaust gas flow rate in particular may increase, while temperature and the usable expansion range change less.
Thermal conversion efficiency need not remain constant either. An installation with a favourable balance between heat transfer, expansion and condensation at one operating point may convert a smaller or larger proportion of the absorbed heat into mechanical power at another load. A distinction must be made between electrical power and conversion efficiency. Generator power may increase while thermal efficiency decreases if the amount of heat absorbed rises sufficiently. Conversely, efficiency may be higher under certain part-load conditions while total electricity production remains lower because less heat is available.
With a further increase in engine load, capacity limits may also be reached. Heat exchangers have limited transfer capacity, the expander has a permitted operating range and the generator can deliver electrical power only up to its load limit. Once one of these limits becomes decisive, additional available heat can no longer be used in full to generate more electricity. Depending on the selected design and control strategy, the WHRS must then limit heat absorption or process power.
In certain installations, some of the available heat may, for example, be routed past the recovery system. Another possibility is that the ORC continues to operate at an operating point subject to those limits. Existing engine functions must be preserved and the WHRS must remain within its operating limits. As engine load increases, electrical power may therefore rise and then level off. This need not indicate a fault or declining thermal efficiency. The installation may simply have reached its rated generator capacity or another permitted capacity limit.
Conversely, electricity production need not increase with every further rise in engine load, even before the generator reaches its limit. Warmer cooling water, changing heat transfer or a less favourable ORC operating point may limit net performance. Higher engine power therefore does not guarantee higher net electricity generation if the other operating conditions also change. For a reliable assessment, it must be clear over which load range the available heat determines output, where changes in cycle performance matter and at what point a technical capacity constraint limits any further increase in power.
How Do the Condenser and Cooling-Water Temperature Affect Electricity Production at Part Load?
The electricity production of an ORC does not depend solely on the conditions on the hot side. The condenser also helps determine the thermodynamic operating point. After expansion, the working fluid must be cooled sufficiently to condense back to liquid and return to the hot side of the cycle. The temperature of the available cooling medium affects condensing conditions. As the cooling water becomes warmer, condensing temperature and consequently condensing pressure may rise. The usable expansion range may therefore decrease, with consequences for the expander's mechanical power and the generator's electrical output.
An ORC may therefore deliver different levels of electrical power at the same engine load if cooling-water temperature changes. Anyone comparing two measurement periods solely on the basis of engine load may therefore misjudge the effect of engine load on electricity generation. Cooling-water flow rate and the available heat rejection capacity are also important. If more heat is supplied to the ORC at higher engine load, the condenser must be able to reject the remaining process heat. With insufficient cooling capacity, the installation cannot maintain its original operating point and electricity production may have to be limited.
The available cooling may also change indirectly with engine load. If the ORC is connected to an existing central cooling-water system, higher engine load may also increase heat rejection from other connected equipment. Less cooling capacity may consequently remain for the ORC, even if the temperature of the water outside the ship stays the same. The effects depend on the cooling-water circuit and how it is controlled. If sufficient cooling capacity remains available, a greater heat supply may allow more electricity production. If the cold side becomes limiting, electrical power may rise less sharply, level off or even decrease under certain conditions.
Favourable cooling conditions may also support cycle performance at lower engine load. At a lower condensing temperature, a smaller hot-side heat input may still be converted relatively efficiently. However, this does not mean that net electrical power remains high. The quantity of available heat and the system's own energy consumption must also be taken into account.
To investigate the effect of engine load specifically, ORC performance can first be compared under the same specified cooling conditions. This helps identify how much of the change in power results from the heat supply and the changed thermodynamic operating point. For actual ship operation, calculations must then be made using the cooling-water temperatures and heat loads that occur at the same time as the relevant engine loads. Under highly variable conditions, a performance map may therefore be needed in which both engine load and cooling conditions vary.
Why Does Net Electricity Generation Change Differently from Gross Generator Power?
Gross generator power is the electrical output of the generator driven by the expander. For the net contribution to the ship, it must also be established how much electricity the WHRS itself and its associated auxiliary equipment consume. In an ORC, components that consume electricity include the working fluid pump and any intermediate circuit pumps. Depending on the design, additional cooling-water pumps, fans, control equipment and electrical conversion equipment may also be relevant.
Net electrical power is determined by subtracting the relevant auxiliary electrical loads and electrical losses from gross generator power within the selected system boundary. For existing shared shipboard systems, it must be established which additional energy consumption arises because of the WHRS. Original consumption that remains unchanged must not be attributed to heat recovery again without justification. When engine load changes, gross generator power may rise or fall. However, auxiliary consumption need not change in the same proportion. Some pumps may run at reduced output, while other equipment must maintain a particular minimum circulation or operating function.
At lower engine load, the system's own consumption may consequently account for a larger share of gross generator power. The ORC may then still produce electricity while its pumps and other equipment still use a relatively large share of the output. Under those conditions, net power may fall more sharply than gross power. In other designs, controllable auxiliary components may instead reduce their electricity consumption substantially. A lower working fluid flow rate or less circulation in an intermediate circuit may then help maintain net production at part load. Whether this is possible depends on the control and the minimum flow rates needed for safe operation.
Auxiliary consumption may also change at higher engine load. If the ORC absorbs more heat, additional pumping power may be needed or the load on the cooling equipment may increase. Net electrical power may therefore rise less sharply than gross generator power. A favourable gross power curve therefore does not automatically mean that the installation also delivers the greatest net electrical contribution across the full load range. For this, the relationship between gross output and the system's own consumption must be established under the relevant operating conditions of the complete WHRS.
When using performance data, it must also be clear which auxiliary consumption is already included in a stated net module power. That consumption must not be deducted again. Required additional loads outside the module boundary must, however, be included if they are needed for operation on board. For net electricity generation, therefore, how much heat the engine supplies at each load is not the only important factor. Generator output and the system's own electricity consumption must also be determined at the same ORC operating point.
When Does Engine Load Become Too Low for Usable Electricity Production?
A waste heat recovery system needs sufficient thermal power and suitable temperatures for the selected cycle to function within the permitted operating limits. As engine load falls, both the quantity and temperature of the available heat may decrease. In an ORC, there may therefore be too little heat to maintain the required working fluid flow rate under suitable evaporating conditions. The required pressure ratio, expander limits and the control system may also restrict a further reduction in power.
However, the minimum usable engine load is not the same for every installation. An ORC designed for a broad heat-input range may perform differently at lower heat input from a design suited mainly to a relatively stable design operating point. The lower limit also does not depend solely on the available thermal power. A heat source may still contain sufficient thermal energy while its temperature is too low to achieve the required process conditions. The available cooling also affects the conditions under which electricity production remains possible.
The cycle's minimum operating point must be distinguished from the threshold for positive net electrical output. Under some conditions, the system may still operate while producing very little usable electricity. An ORC may, for example, still deliver gross electrical power while pumps, control equipment and other auxiliary components consume a large proportion of it. If the system's own electrical load equals or exceeds gross generator power, no positive net electrical contribution remains.
This need not mean that there is a technical fault. The selected design may simply move outside the range in which continued generation yields a worthwhile energy output. The control system may then initiate a controlled shutdown, provided that the necessary engine and safety functions are maintained. Conversely, an ORC must not remain in operation solely because of a calculated positive net output if the required vapour conditions, pressures or other technical limits are not met. The system can operate only within the permitted process conditions.
There is therefore no universal percentage of rated engine power below which every WHRS ceases to produce usable electricity. The relevant threshold depends on the actual engine load profile, available heat sources, condensing conditions, control range and auxiliary consumption of the selected installation. Particularly on ships operating at low engine load for long periods, this limit may strongly affect how many operating hours actually yield positive net electricity output.
What Happens to Electricity Production During Rapid Load Changes?
At a steady engine operating point, the heat source and WHRS have had sufficient time to reach a relatively constant operating state. During actual operation, however, engine load may change faster than the temperatures and heat flows within the recovery installation. As engine load rises, exhaust gas mass flow rate and gas temperature may change. The heat exchanger and any intermediate circuit must then respond to the new heat supply. The amount of heat reaching the ORC working fluid therefore does not necessarily change at the same time or at the same rate as engine power.
The metal parts of heat exchangers, the fluids and the pipework store thermal energy. This thermal mass may partly smooth short-term changes, but also causes a delay before temperatures and heat transfer settle at their new levels. The control system also needs time to adjust working fluid circulation, pressure conditions and expander load. After a rapid increase in engine load, electrical output may temporarily remain below the power achievable under the new steady conditions.
During a rapid reduction in engine load, the reverse may occur. The continuous heat supply from the engine decreases while energy remains temporarily stored in heat exchangers and fluid circuits. The ORC may therefore receive more heat during the transition than the new engine load alone would suggest. However, this stored heat is not a continuing additional energy source. Once the installation reaches a new steady operating state, heat transfer must match the heat supply that remains available at the lower engine load.
During such transitions, temperatures, pressures and the state of the working fluid must remain within the permitted operating range. If the heat supply changes too quickly, the control system may have to limit heat absorption or electricity production temporarily. Depending on the design, bypass arrangements or other control options may be used for this purpose. The existing engine functions take priority. For exhaust gas heat, the limits on exhaust gas back pressure and the drop in exhaust gas temperature must be observed. For engine cooling water, the specified engine temperatures and necessary circulation must be maintained, even when WHRS output is reduced or the system is shut down.
With frequent load changes, actual electricity production may consequently differ from the output calculated solely from steady operating points. Start-up and shutdown periods may also cause additional auxiliary consumption while the generator is not yet producing electricity or is no longer doing so. A performance curve based on steady engine loads therefore does not automatically describe how the WHRS functions during rapid changes. On ships with many short operating periods or frequent load changes, it must also be established how quickly the installation responds to the changing heat supply and how much net electricity actually remains available during these transitions.
How Is the Relationship Between Engine Load and Net Electricity Generation Established Reliably?
A reliable assessment starts with the engine load range in which the WHRS must function during actual operation. The assessment must cover high engine loads as well as the lower and intermediate loads at which the engines spend many operating hours. For each relevant engine operating point, the properties of the available heat sources are then established. For exhaust gas heat, these include temperature, mass flow rate and the heat that can be extracted within the permitted engine limits. For engine cooling water, temperature, circulation and the heat that can be transferred within technical limits are important.
These data must relate to the same engine load and the actual WHRS connection point. If the highest exhaust gas temperature from one operating mode is combined with the highest gas flow rate from another, the calculation may predict a heat supply that does not occur in service. For each engine load, it is then determined how much heat the selected WHRS can actually absorb. This must account for the heat exchangers, any intermediate circuits and the temperatures and flow rates available to the thermodynamic process.
The corresponding ORC operating point is then established. Evaporating and condensing conditions, working fluid circulation and expander performance determine how much gross electrical power is possible under those conditions. The cold side must be included on a consistent basis. To investigate the effect of engine load separately, performance can first be compared at the same defined cooling conditions. For actual operation, performance data are also needed at the cooling-water temperatures and available cooling capacity that occur at the same time as the engine loads concerned.
At each operating point, the relevant auxiliary consumption is then accounted for. The comparison must align the system boundaries used for gross generator power, net module power and the final net electrical contribution of the complete WHRS. This gives a performance curve showing how much net electricity is available at different engine loads. The curve can show at which loads power rises sharply, where production is limited by rated capacity and when insufficient usable heat or net electrical power remains at lower load.
It must also be clear what the performance data are based on. A calculated performance curve may be suitable for technical selection, but does not automatically prove that the same electricity production has been measured on board or is contractually guaranteed. The basis for the performance figures must therefore remain clear. During measurements on board, gross generator power, the relevant auxiliary electrical loads and engine load must be recorded over the same periods. The corresponding heat source and cooling conditions then identify the thermodynamic operating point at which the electricity was generated.
To establish a performance curve for steady engine loads, sufficiently steady measurement periods are needed. If engine load changes rapidly, those data must be assessed separately as transient measurements. Otherwise, the thermal lag of the WHRS may give an incorrect picture of the power available at a particular steady engine operating point. It must also be checked whether the shipboard electrical system could actually accept the power the WHRS was capable of producing. If the power management system limited electricity production during measurement, the measured power may not represent the maximum technically available performance under the same heat and cooling conditions.
If the WHRS uses heat from generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity the WHRS generates, the resulting engine load must also be taken into account. WHRS production may then change the load and heat release of the generating sets concerned. The relevant performance point is the operating mode in which the available heat supply and electrical power distribution correspond. The established performance can then be linked to the operating and load profiles to calculate annual net electricity generation. For the assessment of varying engine load, it is particularly important that it becomes clear how much net electrical power the WHRS can deliver at the different engine operating points and which thermal or electrical limits apply at those points.
The electricity production of a WHRS therefore does not vary in fixed proportion to engine load. The engine determines how much waste heat becomes available and at what temperature, while the heat exchangers, thermodynamic operating point, cooling, the control system and the system's own electricity consumption determine how much of it is converted into net electrical power. A reliable performance curve shows this relationship across the relevant engine load range. It shows when electricity production increases, where the installation reaches its maximum capacity and at which lower loads no usable net electricity generation remains.
This Article in the Series
With varying engine load, the available heat changes, as do conversion efficiency and the share accounted for by the system's own energy consumption. How these changes are established in practice is discussed in measuring net WHRS electricity production on board. For a verifiable performance agreement, it must also be clear which performance levels and measurement conditions are covered by a WHRS performance guarantee. This relationship between engine load, net power and verification forms an important part of WHRS sizing and performance assessment.