Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Do You Measure the Net Electricity Generation of a Waste Heat Recovery System on Board?

The net electricity generation of a waste heat recovery system is determined by measuring the electricity actually generated and subtracting the relevant electricity consumed by the system itself. In a waste heat recovery system (WHRS), the generator may produce electricity while pumps, cooling equipment and other components consume energy at the same time. Gross generator output is therefore not automatically equal to the net contribution to the shipboard electrical system.

For a reliable measurement, the electrical measurement points, system boundary and relevant auxiliary loads must be defined in advance. The active electrical energy generated and consumed are then recorded over the same period. If all relevant energy flows pass through one suitable connection point, the net exchange can be measured directly. With separate supplies or shared shipboard systems, additional measurements and calculations may be needed.

Engine load, available waste heat, cooling conditions and operating status must also be recorded to explain the measured performance. These records show how much electricity the WHRS actually delivers, under what conditions it is generated and how much counts as an additional contribution to the ship's electricity supply. The resulting fuel savings must then be assessed separately.

What Is the Difference Between Gross and Net Electricity Generation?

A waste heat recovery system can use heat from exhaust gases and engine cooling water, for example, to generate electricity. In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), an organic working fluid is heated for this purpose and passed through an expander. This drives a generator that produces electrical power. A steam-based WHRS can also use a turbine-generator, but operates with a different thermodynamic process. Gross electricity generation is the electricity produced by the generator before the required auxiliary consumption is deducted. This output can be measured at a suitable point on the generator output circuit. If the generator is connected to the shipboard electrical system through power electronics, less electrical power may be available further downstream in the installation because of conversion losses.

Net generation also accounts for the energy the WHRS needs to operate. In an ORC, this includes the working fluid pump, any pumps in intermediate circuits, additional cooling equipment and control equipment. Exactly which loads are included depends on the selected installation and the system boundary within which net production is determined. A distinction must be made between the net power of an individual ORC module and the net electrical exchange between the complete WHRS and the shipboard electrical system. A module may already include certain auxiliary loads in its stated net value, while other equipment is connected elsewhere in the engine room. The two values are then not necessarily equal.

If all relevant electrical energy flows pass through one common connection point, a suitable bidirectional energy meter can record the net exchange directly. During electricity production, energy flows from the WHRS to the shipboard electrical system. During start-up or when the system is stopped, the direction may reverse if the installation draws electricity from the shipboard electrical system. Such a measurement gives the correct net value for the selected system boundary only if the connection carries only the intended energy flows. If certain auxiliaries are supplied through other connections, their electricity consumption is not automatically included in the measured net exchange. This consumption must be established separately if it falls within the selected system boundary.

The effect on existing shipboard systems may also matter when determining the full additional contribution to the ship's electricity supply. If an existing cooling-water pump starts to consume more electricity because of the WHRS, that increase is one of the effects of the new installation. However, the additional consumption may not appear in measurements at the WHRS electrical connection. The net exchange of electricity measured directly at a particular connection point must therefore be distinguished from the additional electrical contribution of the complete installation to the ship. These values may be equal, but need not be if the WHRS changes the load on shared systems.

Power and energy also have different meanings. Active electrical power is expressed in kilowatts (kW) and describes production or consumption at a particular instant. Active electrical energy is expressed in kilowatt-hours (kWh) and indicates how much electricity has been produced or consumed over a particular period. An instantaneous power value is therefore insufficient to establish total net electricity generation. Active electrical energy must be recorded directly or active power integrated over the measurement period.

Net electricity generation is determined from the relevant amounts of electricity generated and consumed within a predefined system boundary. This boundary determines which values can be measured directly and which additional data are needed to establish the complete contribution to the ship.

Where Must the Electrical Measurement Points Be Located?

The location of the electrical measurement points determines which energy flows are recorded. A meter at the generator output can measure gross electricity generation, but does not automatically show how much electricity all the necessary auxiliary systems consume in total. A reliable measurement arrangement therefore starts with the ship's current electrical single-line diagram. The diagram must show where the WHRS generator is connected, any power electronics and the feeds supplying the auxiliaries. It must also show where the installation is connected to the shipboard electrical system.

If all relevant flows of generated and consumed electricity pass through one common connection point, a bidirectional energy meter can record the net electrical exchange. The meter must accurately record the active electrical energy and its direction of flow. Depending on the meter, energy drawn and delivered is recorded in separate registers or a net energy value is recorded. The sign convention used must be clear in advance. If the WHRS delivers more electricity than it draws during a measurement period, the record must show a net transfer of energy to the shipboard electrical system.

If auxiliaries are fed from other distribution boards, metering at the WHRS connection alone is insufficient. An intermediate circuit pump may, for example, be supplied from an existing engine-room distribution system while the ORC generator is connected to the main switchboard. The electricity consumption of that pump is then not automatically recorded by the meter at the generator connection. Separate energy meters may be needed for such components. Existing measurement data may also be usable, provided that the measurement points, accuracy and recorded energy flows are suitable for the intended assessment.

The electrical quantity being measured must also be selected correctly. In an alternating-current installation, measuring only current or voltage is insufficient to determine the active power actually produced. For this, the measurement must account correctly for both voltage and current and for the relationship between them. In a three-phase connection, the measurement must account correctly for each relevant phase. Total active power follows from the contributions of the individual phases. Any imbalance between phases must be handled correctly by the measuring equipment.

The voltage and current waveforms may also be important. If power electronics cause distorted waveforms, the meter must still measure actual active power reliably. Apparent power in kilovolt-amperes and reactive power in kilovars must be distinguished from active power. Net generation in kilowatt-hours is based on active electrical energy.

The measurement arrangement must also record changes in the direction of energy flow correctly. A WHRS may draw electricity from the shipboard electrical system during start-up, then deliver electricity and use energy again during shutdown. These different energy flows must be distinguished and processed according to the chosen convention for direction of flow. Other equipment must also not be included unintentionally within the measurement boundary. A meter on a shared supply cable may, for example, record both the WHRS and other shipboard loads. The net exchange at that common connection is then not automatically equal to the net electricity generation of the WHRS alone.

The measurement plan must therefore identify the points for recording gross generator output, metering individual auxiliaries and measuring the net exchange with the shipboard electrical system. This arrangement must match the actual electrical connections so that no relevant energy flows are omitted or counted twice.

Which Auxiliary Consumption Must Be Included in the Net Measurement?

A WHRS's own electricity consumption consists of the energy needed to run the heat recovery system and its auxiliaries. Which loads are relevant depends on the selected installation and the way it is connected to existing shipboard systems. In an ORC, the working fluid pump is a necessary part of the thermodynamic process. It raises the pressure of the liquid working fluid again after condensation. If heat is supplied through a separate water or thermal-oil circuit, the circulation pumps of that intermediate circuit may also consume electricity.

Control equipment, fans, electrical drives and other auxiliary components may also be present. Depending on the connection and the cooling available on board, the condenser may also require additional cooling-water circulation. Not all the equipment has to be housed within the same module. An ORC may, for example, be supplied with an integrated working fluid pump, while the intermediate circuit pump and required cooling-water equipment are installed separately in the engine room. For the net electricity generation of the complete installation, it must be clear which of these loads fall within the selected system boundary.

If all the energy flows concerned pass through the same electrical connection, they are included in the net exchange at that point. The consumption of separately supplied auxiliaries must be measured separately or estimated by a sufficiently well-supported calculation if they belong within the selected system boundary. For shared shipboard systems, an additional assessment is needed. An existing cooling-water pump may also operate without a WHRS to cool engines and other machinery. If this pump draws more power after the WHRS is connected, the difference between the original and new consumption is particularly relevant to the additional electrical contribution.

The pump's entire consumption must then not automatically be treated as new WHRS consumption. Conversely, the increase must not be disregarded because the pump was already present before installation. To establish this difference reliably, the original and new operating conditions must be sufficiently comparable. Pump power can also change because of different engine loads, cooling-water flow rates or temperature controls. If these conditions differ, a direct comparison may require additional corrections.

For a separately added WHRS pump, the additional electricity consumption can often be measured directly. For an existing shared pump, a comparison with a representative baseline or a technical calculation may be needed. In that case, the additional electrical contribution is not based entirely on direct measurements of new loads. The same auxiliary consumption must be deducted only once. If a net measurement at the common WHRS connection already includes the working fluid pump's electricity consumption, the pump's consumption must not be included again as a separate correction.

The same applies to suppliers' net power specifications. If internal auxiliary consumption is already included in a stated net module power, the assessment only needs to identify required equipment excluded from that figure. The system's own consumption may also change with operating conditions. At a lower heat input, the generator may produce less electricity while certain pumps and controls still draw power. Other pumps may instead run at reduced output and draw less power.

For net electricity generation over a longer period, it must therefore be established when the various auxiliaries operate and how much electricity they use under those conditions. Energy consumption may also occur during start-up, shutdown and standby. The WHRS may draw electricity during start-up, before the generator begins supplying power. After shutdown, certain pumps or protective equipment may remain active for some time.

If the measurement period includes these operating phases, the associated consumption must be included in the electrical energy balance. Net generation at a steady operating point may therefore differ from the net contribution over a complete voyage or a longer period of operation.

How Is Measured Electrical Power Converted into Net Energy?

To determine net electricity generation, all relevant amounts of electrical energy produced and consumed must relate to the same measurement period and a consistent system boundary. A suitable energy meter records the active electrical energy flowing through the connection point over a particular period. For a meter with cumulative energy registers, the energy produced or drawn can be established from the difference between the initial and final readings.

If the meter records import and export separately, the net exchange is determined according to the predefined convention for import and export. For a WHRS supplying electricity to the shipboard electrical system, this may mean, for example, that the electricity drawn is subtracted from the electricity delivered. The result then describes the net electrical exchange at that connection point. Consumption by auxiliaries on other feeds must be accounted for separately if it falls within the selected system boundary.

If only power measurements are available, electrical energy can be calculated by integrating active power over the measurement period. In digital recording, this is done using successive power values and the periods to which they relate. It must be clear what the recorded values represent. A system may store instantaneous power measurements, record average power over a particular interval or integrate power directly to obtain electrical energy. An average power value in kilowatts must not be treated as energy in kilowatt-hours without the corresponding duration.

The quality and frequency of recording are also important. If generator power changes rapidly, recording at intervals that are too long may fail to capture important variations adequately. An energy meter that integrates active energy directly may then be more suitable for determining total energy than a calculation based on a limited number of stored instantaneous power values.

With several meters in use, all records must relate to the same start and end times. Time recording must also be accurate enough to associate changes in generator output and auxiliary consumption with the same operating conditions. If measurement data come from different onboard monitoring systems, it may be necessary to align the clocks and timestamps to a common time base. This is particularly relevant if equipment uses different clock settings or the ship crosses time zones during a voyage.

At an operating point that remains steady for a long period, small time differences may have a limited effect on total energy. During start-up, shutdown and rapid load changes, however, the same discrepancies may lead to an incorrect association between production and consumption. The measurement data must therefore be aligned in time with sufficient accuracy.

Periods with no generator output must also be accounted for consistently. If the WHRS delivers no electricity but certain auxiliary systems still draw energy, the net electrical contribution during that period may be negative. For assessment of a steady operating point, a separate measurement window may be selected in which the generator actually produces electricity. If the aim is to establish net electricity over a complete voyage or period of operation, the relevant consumption during start-up, shutdown and downtime must also be included.

The selected measurement period therefore also helps determine what the result describes. A net energy total measured at a steady operating point cannot simply be compared with net energy over a complete voyage. When the records are aligned, net electrical energy is determined from measured production and relevant consumption over the same period. Any calculated corrections for shared systems must remain separately identifiable so that it is clear which part of the result was measured directly.

Why Must the Heat Source and Cooling Be Measured at the Same Time?

An electrical energy meter shows how much electricity the WHRS produces, but does not automatically explain why production changes during measurement. Explaining those changes also requires data on the available waste heat and the conditions under which the installation converts it. During recovery from exhaust gases, gas temperature and mass flow rate change with engine load. The thermal power available at the heat exchanger may consequently vary while under way. An ORC producing less electricity at lower engine load is therefore not necessarily performing worse than during an earlier measurement with a greater heat supply.

The heat available from engine cooling water also depends on engine load, cooling-water circulation and temperature control. To interpret electricity generation correctly, the relevant engine loads, water temperatures and flow rates must therefore be known. If the WHRS uses a separate intermediate circuit, the temperatures of the hot medium at the ORC module may be important in establishing its actual operating point. The original exhaust gas temperature then does not by itself describe how much heat the ORC actually receives. The thermal measurement points must therefore correspond to the heat transfer that governs the selected installation.

The cold side also affects electrical power. If the cooling water becomes warmer, the condensing temperature may rise and the expander may deliver less power. Generator output may consequently decrease while the available thermal power on the hot side remains virtually unchanged. For the performance assessment, the relevant cooling-water temperatures and, where necessary, flow rates or other data on the available cooling capacity must therefore also be recorded.

The heat source and cooling data must relate to the same period as the electrical measurement. If a generator power value at high engine load is combined with cooling-water data from another operating mode, the combined data may misrepresent the conditions under which the electricity was generated. On a ship with several engines, it must also be known which engines are supplying heat during measurement. Bringing individual engines into service, unloading them or shutting them down may change the available heat flows, even if total installed engine power remains the same.

Thermal measurements therefore help explain and assess electrical performance. They do not replace electrical energy measurement. A heat-input calculation indicates how much energy may be available, but does not prove how much net electricity the generator actually delivered. The distinction between measurement and explanation must therefore remain clear. The electrical measurements determine the electricity produced and consumed. The heat source, cooling and engine-load data describe the operating conditions and allow comparison with the performance that could have been expected under sufficiently comparable conditions.

How Do the Shipboard Electrical System and Changing Operating Modes Affect Measurement?

The amount of electricity a WHRS generates depends partly on the available heat supply. Electrical demand on board and interaction with other energy sources may also determine how much power the installation actually produces. If the shipboard electrical system can accept enough electricity, the WHRS can replace part of the output from existing generating sets. At lower electrical demand, however, the power management system may limit WHRS production.

Measured electricity production may then be lower than would be technically possible under the same heat and cooling conditions. This difference must remain identifiable in the operating record so that lower production is not incorrectly attributed to insufficient heat supply or reduced technical performance of the WHRS. Operating status must also be recorded. During start-up, normal operation, output reduction and shutdown, the relationship between gross generator output and auxiliary consumption may change. The measured net energy can therefore be interpreted correctly only if it is clear which operating phases are included in the record.

On ships with several generating sets, WHRS electricity may also affect engine load. If the installation uses heat from the same engines whose load is reduced by the electricity the WHRS generates, the available waste heat may also change. Generator output and engine load must then be recorded together. Heat-source conditions before the load is reduced may differ from those under which the WHRS ultimately generates electricity.

With battery storage, shore power or other electrical energy sources, additional power flows may arise. These do not change the meaning of the directly measured WHRS production, but may affect how much electricity the shipboard electrical system can absorb at that time. Generation from each source must be accounted for separately. A meter on a common switchboard may record the combined exchange of several generators, loads and storage systems. A change in that combined reading does not by itself show how much electricity the WHRS generated.

For this, sufficient separate measurements or a well-supported power balance are needed. If WHRS production is measured directly at its own electrical connection, it can be distinguished more clearly from other energy sources. Additional data from the shipboard electrical system are still needed to explain why production is limited at particular times.

Lower net electricity generation therefore need not indicate a technical problem with the WHRS. The cause may be less available waste heat, warmer cooling water, higher auxiliary consumption or limited electrical demand. Only when these conditions are assessed together with the measured energy flows can the result be interpreted correctly.

How Do You Check the Accuracy and Reliability of the Measurement Data?

A well-chosen measurement point is necessary for reliable WHRS measurement, but does not guarantee that the recorded values are correct. The measuring equipment, any instrument transformers, electrical connections and data processing must also be suitable for the intended assessment. At higher-capacity electrical connections, current and voltage transformers are often used to supply current and voltage signals to the measuring equipment. The configured transformer ratios must match the transformers actually installed. An incorrect ratio may directly affect the recorded power and energy values.

The accuracy and any phase errors of these transformers may also affect the result. The assessment must therefore cover the entire measurement chain, including the energy meter specification. For three-phase measurements, it must also be checked that the current and voltage signals are correctly paired by phase. If these signals do not correspond, the meter may record incorrect active power even when the individual current and voltage values appear plausible.

Polarity and measurement direction must also be set correctly. An incorrectly connected current transformer may cause an energy flow to be recorded as electricity delivered while the system is actually drawing electricity, or vice versa. At a bidirectional connection, however, a change in energy-flow direction is not automatically a measurement error. The WHRS may draw electricity during start-up and deliver it during normal operation. The measurement direction must therefore be checked with the system in a known operating state and according to a predefined sign convention.

The electrical waveform may also be important. If the generator is connected through power electronics, harmonics and other deviations from purely sinusoidal voltages and currents may occur. The measuring equipment must be suitable for reliably determining active power under the electrical conditions present. Measuring active energy may require different instrument capabilities from a detailed power quality assessment. An energy meter does not necessarily need all the functions of a separate power quality analyser. The choice depends on the measurement objective and required accuracy.

During installation and verification of the instrument transformers, meters and electrical connections, the applicable electrical safety regulations and the instructions for the equipment concerned must be followed. This work is the responsibility of appropriately authorized specialists. The required measurement accuracy depends on the purpose for which the data are used. For day-to-day WHRS monitoring, a different level of accuracy may suffice compared with contractual performance acceptance or a comparison between two installations with only small differences in net output.

The complete measurement chain must be assessed. The meter's accuracy class alone does not automatically describe the uncertainty of the final result. Transformers, connections, timekeeping and any calculated contributions may also affect the result. Particularly when net power is relatively small compared with separate measurements of gross generator output and auxiliary loads, the relative uncertainty of the difference may be substantial. The same applies when two installations show only a small difference in measured net electricity generation.

A difference between measurements is therefore convincing only if it remains credible once measurement uncertainty and any differences in operating conditions are taken into account. The quality of data recording also deserves attention. Missing measurements, interrupted communications and timestamp errors may affect the calculated net energy.

It must therefore be clear how invalid or missing data are identified and handled. Any estimated or reconstructed readings must be clearly identified. A calculated value used to fill a gap must not be presented as directly measured electricity without explanation. A reliable measurement report therefore shows which energy flows were measured directly, which corrections were calculated and which uncertainties affect the net result. This also shows how far the available data support the technical conclusions.

Which Measurement Period Is Suitable for Reliable WHRS Performance Verification?

The appropriate measurement period depends on what the measurement is intended to establish. Different conditions are needed to check a specific design operating point than to establish net electricity generation over a complete voyage or period of operation. If a stated net power must be checked at particular reference conditions, the heat source, cooling and electrical load must be sufficiently stable during measurement. The operating conditions are recorded so that measured power can be compared with the stated performance.

A measurement period in which engine load changes continuously may be less suitable for assessing one rated operating point. The average then reflects generation under several heat and cooling conditions rather than a single clearly defined reference state. For an assessment of operational energy output, such changes are part of the conditions being measured. If the aim is to establish how much net electricity the WHRS produces during a voyage, the operating modes that actually occur must therefore be included.

These include periods in which WHRS output is reduced or the system is temporarily out of service. Relevant auxiliary consumption during start-up, shutdown and standby continues to count if the complete voyage or period of operation falls within the selected system boundary. For performance acceptance, by contrast, it may be justified to use only a stable measurement window agreed in advance. The results are then assessed according to the agreed reference conditions, including any permitted corrections for deviations from those conditions.

A short acceptance test can demonstrate that the installation delivers the agreed power under a particular condition. It leaves open how much net electricity the system generates over a complete voyage or a whole year. For an annual forecast, performance must be linked to the operating and load profiles, available heat sources, cooling conditions and periods in which the WHRS can operate. If not all these operating conditions have actually been measured, annual output remains an estimate based on calculation.

Over a longer period of in-service measurement, the net electricity actually delivered over the recording period can be established more directly. The measurement data must be sufficiently complete for this, and the relevant auxiliary consumption must be accounted for over the same period. If existing shared shipboard systems use more electricity because of the WHRS, a comparison with the original operation may still be needed for the additional system contribution. A longer measurement period does not automatically make that difference directly measurable.

The measurement period and purpose of the assessment must therefore always be stated with the results. A short performance acceptance test, a complete voyage measurement and an annual record may all be technically correct, but do not describe the same electrical performance.

What Does Measured Net Electricity Generation Actually Demonstrate?

A reliable measurement of net electricity generation shows how much active electrical energy the WHRS delivered during the period examined, after accounting for the system's relevant electricity consumption within the selected system boundary. If all relevant flows of generated and consumed electricity pass through a suitable common connection, the net electrical exchange can be measured directly. With separate connections, the relevant energy flows must be combined in the calculation. Electricity consumption already included in a net measured value must not be deducted again.

If the WHRS changes the load on existing shared shipboard systems, an additional calculation may be needed to determine the extra electrical contribution to the ship. This correction must be based on sufficiently comparable operating conditions or a well-supported baseline. The measurement report must therefore distinguish between directly measured electricity and calculated changes in the consumption of shared systems. Only then is it clear which part of the net result is based entirely on electrical measurements.

The corresponding heat-source, cooling and engine-load data show the conditions under which the electricity was produced. On that basis, it can be assessed whether the measurement is representative of a particular operating point and whether technical factors explain differences in output. Measured net electricity generation is not, however, automatically equal to the ship's fuel savings. For this, it must be established separately which existing electricity production was replaced by the WHRS and how the fuel consumption of the engines concerned changes as a result. Any effects of heat recovery on other shipboard systems may also affect the result.

Nor does one measurement prove that the same net electricity generation remains available at other engine loads or cooling conditions. The result must therefore remain linked to the operating conditions and the period in which it was established. A technically verifiable WHRS measurement requires a clear system boundary, correctly located electrical measurement points, consistent treatment of auxiliary consumption and reliable records over the same period.

This establishes the actual net electrical contribution of the waste heat recovery system while distinguishing gross generator output, net exchange with the shipboard electrical system, additional system contribution and fuel savings.

This Article in the Series

Reliable measurement starts with the same power definitions and system boundaries needed for comparing stated WHRS power values. Recording generator output and the relevant auxiliary consumption over the same period makes the net contribution to the ship's electrical supply verifiable. How that contribution changes when the heat supply varies is discussed in WHRS electricity production under varying engine load. This relationship between stated, measured and operationally available power is central to WHRS sizing and performance assessment.