Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Do Other Energy-Saving Measures Change the Waste Heat Available to a WHRS?

Other energy-saving measures can reduce the waste heat available to a waste heat recovery system (WHRS), change the share available from each heat source or free up more of the existing waste heat for further use. Measures that reduce the required propulsion power or electrical demand affect the load and operation of the existing engines. The temperature, quantity and availability of heat in the exhaust gases and cooling water may also change.

Thermal energy savings may have a different effect. If existing heat consumers need less engine heat, a larger share of that heat may become available for a WHRS. The engine does not produce more waste heat; instead, the existing heat is distributed differently.

The extent of these changes cannot be inferred directly from the percentage reduction in fuel consumption. Engine efficiency and heat distribution depend in part on the operating point, engine configuration and control. The number of operating hours also determines how much thermal energy becomes available over a voyage or a whole year. Selecting or reassessing a WHRS therefore depends chiefly on how much usable heat remains after the relevant energy-saving measures have been implemented.

Why Do Energy Savings Also Change Heat Rejection from Marine Engines?

An internal combustion engine converts some of the fuel energy supplied into useful mechanical power. The remaining energy is rejected as heat through the exhaust gases, the cooling-water system and other routes. A WHRS can recover some of this heat, provided the temperatures, flow rates and technical operating limits allow it. Under otherwise comparable conditions, the engine can operate at a lower load when a ship requires less mechanical power. Fuel consumption changes as a result, and the total amount of heat released during engine operation usually also decreases. The size of this reduction depends on the engine and its new operating point.

The heat released does not necessarily decrease in proportion to fuel consumption. Engine efficiency may change with load, as may the distribution of energy between mechanical power, exhaust gases and cooling water. At lower engine loads, for example, the exhaust gas mass flow rate may decrease while the exhaust gas temperature follows a different trend. Depending on the engine type and control, this temperature may remain relatively high under certain part-load conditions or vary in a way that would not be predicted from the reduction in power alone. Turbocharger configuration, rotational speed and the fuel used may also influence the exhaust gas temperature.

The response of cooling-water heat rejection to changes in engine load also varies between engines. The temperature-control system keeps relevant cooling-water temperatures within specified limits. When the engine produces less heat, this may be particularly noticeable in the amount of heat rejected through the existing coolers and in the operation of thermostatic valves or bypass arrangements. For a WHRS, changes in engine load may therefore have different consequences for the individual heat sources. For exhaust gas heat, mass flow rate, temperature and the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature are particularly important. For engine cooling water, the specified engine temperatures, water circulation and existing temperature control must also be maintained.

Knowing only how much less fuel the engine consumes is therefore insufficient to determine the remaining heat supply. The assessment needs exhaust gas and cooling-water data at the new engine load. A distinction must also be made between the available thermal power and the amount of thermal energy that can be used over an operating period. Following an energy-saving measure, an engine may release less heat per hour, while its operating hours or load distribution may also change. The consequences for the WHRS are therefore determined by the actual engine conditions and operating duration after the measure, not solely by the expected fuel savings.

How Do Hull and Propulsion Improvements Affect the Available Waste Heat?

Measures that reduce ship resistance or improve propulsion efficiency can lower the required propulsion power. If the ship maintains the same speed under comparable conditions, the propulsion engine may therefore need to deliver less power. Examples are keeping the hull clean, suitable antifouling coatings, propeller optimization and Energy Saving Devices (ESDs) that improve flow around the propeller or rudder. Under suitable conditions, air lubrication can also reduce hull frictional resistance.

These improvements affect waste heat primarily by changing engine operating conditions. When less shaft power is needed for the same ship speed, the engine can operate at a lower load. Both fuel consumption and heat release through the exhaust gases and cooling water may consequently change. For a WHRS using exhaust gas heat, exhaust gas temperature and mass flow rate after the propulsion improvement are particularly important. A lower gas flow rate may limit the amount of available heat, but the exhaust gas temperature does not necessarily fall by the same proportion. The heat available after the improvement cannot therefore be calculated simply by reducing the thermal power originally available in the exhaust gas by the same percentage as the expected saving in propulsion power.

The new operating point must also be taken into account when assessing engine cooling water. The engine may release less heat, while the existing temperature control continues to determine how much of it can be transferred to an additional installation within acceptable technical limits. The way the propulsion improvement is achieved also matters. A modified propeller may change not only the required shaft power but also the rotational speed and load at which the engine operates. With a controllable-pitch propeller, rotational speed, pitch and load can be combined in ways that differ from those used with a fixed-pitch propeller. To calculate heat availability, both the power change and the corresponding rotational speed and engine configuration are therefore relevant.

Air lubrication introduces an additional consideration. Lower hull resistance may reduce propulsion engine load, while the air lubrication system itself may require electricity for compressors or other air supply equipment. If auxiliary engines supply this electricity, their load and waste heat production may change in turn. The overall effect on the heat supply available to the WHRS then depends on both the changed propulsion load and the additional electricity demand. The reduction in shaft power alone does not provide a complete picture in that case.

How the improved propulsion performance is used is also decisive. If the shipowner maintains the same speed with less engine power, the available heat supply may decrease. If the improvement is used to increase the ship's speed, engine load need not fall to the same extent. A propulsion improvement can therefore increase the ship's energy efficiency while less heat remains for a WHRS. The primary measure reduces the required propulsion power, while the WHRS can use only part of the engine heat that remains.

Why Can Wind-Assisted Propulsion Make the WHRS Heat Supply More Variable?

Wind-assisted propulsion can provide some of the required propulsive force. Under suitable wind and operating conditions, the main engine may consequently need to deliver less mechanical power to the propeller. However, the amount of wind assistance available varies during a voyage. Wind direction and speed, the vessel's course and speed, and control of the wind-assistance system together determine its contribution to propulsion. Engine load may therefore change even when the desired ship speed remains the same.

Changes in engine load may also affect the exhaust gas mass flow rate, exhaust gas temperature and heat rejected through the cooling water. Under favourable wind conditions, less engine power may be needed and the available heat supply may decrease. If wind assistance subsequently diminishes, the main engine may need to deliver more power again, with a corresponding change in heat flows. A WHRS using main-engine heat must therefore be suited to the engine loads that occur with and without wind assistance. An installation that receives sufficient heat at the usual load may receive less thermal power, or heat at a different temperature, during periods of strong wind assistance.

Electricity generation may be limited or interrupted, particularly if the heat supply temporarily falls below the WHRS's minimum operating requirements. For an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), this depends in part on the required source temperature, permitted cycle operating range and control capabilities of the installation. However, electricity generation does not necessarily respond immediately or to the same extent as engine load. Heat exchangers and fluid circuits contain thermal energy, so the WHRS may respond to changes in heat supply after a delay. This thermal mass can partly buffer short-term fluctuations, but does not provide a continuing heat supply when the engine releases less heat for a prolonged period.

The wind-assistance system's own energy consumption also plays a role. Certain solutions, such as rotor sails and suction sails, use electrical drives or fans. This equipment may increase electrical demand on board and thus affect auxiliary engine load. The consequences for the WHRS therefore do not depend solely on the lower main-engine load. The operation and heat release of auxiliary engines may also change if wind assistance requires additional electricity.

Nevertheless, combining wind assistance with waste heat recovery may remain beneficial for the ship's total energy consumption. Lower WHRS output under certain wind conditions does not mean that the combined fuel savings decrease. The propulsion energy saved directly may exceed the reduction in electricity generated from waste heat. A reliable assessment therefore requires more than an average reduction in power attributable to wind assistance. The distribution of engine load across different wind and operating conditions determines how much heat remains available and during which periods the WHRS can actually use it.

How Do Ship Speed, Route Planning and Engine Optimization Change the Heat Supply?

Not every energy-saving measure changes the heat supply in the same way. Improving propulsion efficiency at a constant ship speed, for example, has a different operational effect from deliberately reducing ship speed. When a ship travels at a lower speed under comparable conditions, the required propulsion power usually decreases. The engine can then operate at a lower load, resulting in different exhaust gas and cooling-water conditions.

At the same time, the voyage may take longer when the same distance is covered at a lower speed. The engine may then release heat at a lower rate, but it remains in operation for longer. Whether more or less heat becomes available over the complete voyage therefore cannot be established from the lower engine load alone. The amount of usable thermal energy depends on the thermal power at the new load and the number of hours during which that heat can be used. During prolonged low-load operation, the temperature or flow rate may also become insufficient for the selected recovery system.

The effect of a lower engine load on WHRS output cannot therefore be assessed simply by multiplying the original WHRS output per hour by the longer voyage duration. Both engine heat release and WHRS performance must be established for the new operating conditions. Route planning and weather-dependent speed adjustments may also change the load pattern. If a ship operates less often in adverse weather, the required propulsion power may decrease. However, a different route or revised arrival schedule may also create periods of higher or lower engine load.

For a WHRS, the resulting load profile is therefore particularly important. Figures for average ship speed or total fuel savings cannot show the exhaust gas and cooling-water conditions in each period of the voyage. Alongside changes to the operational profile, measures applied to the engine itself may influence heat distribution. Engine optimization, changes to engine control or replacement with a different engine may alter the balance between useful mechanical power and rejected heat.

Even when the shaft power required remains unchanged, exhaust gas and cooling-water conditions need not remain the same. A more efficient engine may require less fuel, while the remaining heat is distributed differently between the exhaust gases, cooling and other losses. With substantial changes to the engine installation, the heat sources must therefore be characterised again. The previous engine load and fuel consumption then no longer provide a reliable basis for estimating future WHRS output.

How Do Electrical Energy Savings Affect Waste Heat from Auxiliary Engines?

A lower electrical energy requirement may change the load and operation of auxiliary engines. The amount of waste heat these engines can supply to a WHRS may consequently also decrease, or the heat supply may be distributed differently across the installation. Measures such as more efficient lighting, variable-speed pumps, modified ventilation and optimization of electrical auxiliary systems can reduce electricity demand on board. If diesel generating sets produce this electricity, the auxiliary engines in operation may therefore need to deliver less power. Their fuel consumption and available exhaust gas and cooling-water heat may then change.

With a sufficiently large reduction in electrical demand, a different engine combination may also become possible. When an auxiliary engine is shut down, it stops supplying a sustained flow of waste heat. The remaining engines may simultaneously be more heavily loaded, so their heat release changes. For a WHRS receiving heat from several auxiliary engines, this may substantially change the combined heat supply. One engine still in service may supply a larger share of the available heat, while other heat sources cease to supply heat altogether.

Whether this is favourable or unfavourable for heat recovery depends on the new engine loads, temperatures and the way in which the individual heat sources are connected to the WHRS. Fewer running engines do not automatically mean that total usable heat decreases in the same proportion. Battery storage and hybrid energy management may also affect auxiliary engine operation. A battery can temporarily deliver or absorb electrical power. Generating sets may consequently be loaded differently or remain out of service during certain periods.

However, battery storage does not automatically reduce total energy consumption. The effects on available engine heat depend on how the battery is charged and discharged and on the selected operating strategy. If the ship uses shore power and the auxiliary engines are consequently shut down, they cease producing heat for that period. A WHRS using waste heat exclusively from these engines cannot then continue operating in the same way.

For a WHRS receiving most of its heat from the propulsion engine, the effect of electrical energy savings may be different. If the propulsion engine is loaded independently of the auxiliary engines, lower electrical demand need not directly change its heat release. Electrical energy savings may also affect how much of the WHRS output the ship can still use. If electricity consumption falls substantially, the WHRS may be able to displace less of the output from the existing generating sets. The available thermal power may then remain unchanged, even though less WHRS-generated electricity can be used effectively.

The assessment must therefore distinguish between two effects. First, it must establish how lower electrical demand changes engine load and heat release. It must then determine how much electricity generated from the remaining heat can still be used effectively under the new conditions.

Can Thermal Energy Savings Actually Make More Waste Heat Available?

Energy savings need not always lead to less available heat for a WHRS. If some engine heat is already used for heating or other thermal applications, lower heat demand may instead make more heat available for additional recovery. On board, waste heat may, for example, be used for hot-water supply, fuel treatment or other applications that require heat. The applications used depend on the ship's equipment and operating arrangements.

If an existing consumer needs less heat while the engine continues to operate under otherwise comparable conditions, some of the waste heat previously used may become available for another application. This may happen, for example, when heat losses from pipes or heated spaces are reduced. The required heat supply then decreases, while the engine may still release the same amount of heat. This may make more heat available to a WHRS for electricity generation or another application. The engine does not necessarily produce more waste heat as a result. The difference lies in the distribution of the existing heat between the various consumers.

However, not every thermal saving has this effect. If a heating system is supplied exclusively by a separate fuel-fired boiler, lower heat demand initially reduces the required boiler output and associated fuel consumption. As a result, more waste heat from a marine engine does not automatically become available. It therefore matters whether the reduced heat demand was originally met by engine waste heat or another energy source. Only if engine heat was used previously can the reduction directly free up more of the engine's existing heat supply.

Where in the system the heat becomes available, and at what temperature, must also be assessed. When an existing consumer extracts heat from a circuit, the heat-transfer medium may be cooler downstream. Reducing the heat extracted may change the downstream temperature, but does not automatically make that heat suitable for electricity generation. For an ORC, sufficient heat must be available at an appropriate temperature. At the same time, the original functions of other equipment that uses heat must be maintained.

Heat demand also changes during operation. A heating system may require little heat during certain periods, while under other conditions almost the full original heat demand remains. The additional heat available must therefore be determined for the periods in which engine heat and the changed heat demand actually coincide.

Broader energy optimization may also result in the engine itself being less heavily loaded. In that case, the total amount of engine heat produced may decrease, while the existing thermal consumers also need less heat. How much ultimately remains for the WHRS depends on both changes. Lower heat demand may therefore free up more existing waste heat, while lower engine load may reduce the total heat supply. The actual outcome must be determined from a heat balance that accounts for both effects.

Heat already in use must not be counted again in full as an additional saving. If the WHRS takes heat away from an existing consumer, it must be clear how the original heat demand will subsequently be met. Thermal energy savings can make waste heat recovery more attractive, particularly when sufficient heat remains at a suitable temperature after existing heat demands have been met and the WHRS can use it during the relevant operating periods.

Why Can Several Energy-Saving Measures Affect Each Other?

When different energy-saving measures are combined on the same ship, their effects on the heat supply available to the WHRS cannot simply be added together. This is because the measures may affect the same engine load, energy demand or heat distribution. A propulsion improvement may, for example, reduce the required engine power. If ship speed is also reduced, the engine operating point changes again. The WHRS then receives heat from an engine operating under different conditions from those that prevailed before either measure.

The savings from each measure must therefore not be calculated against the original engine operating conditions as though the measures were independent. The first change alters the operating conditions under which the next measure takes effect. This also applies to combinations of propulsion improvements. If an Energy Saving Device reduces the required propeller load, a further improvement may take effect at a different engine operating point. The combined effects on engine heat must therefore be assessed for the final configuration rather than by simply adding up the individual reductions in power.

Electrical energy savings may also change the effect of other measures. Lower electrical demand may affect auxiliary engine operation, while a simultaneous propulsion improvement reduces main-engine load. Both the total amount of waste heat and its distribution between main and auxiliary engines may consequently change.

The energy consumed by the measures themselves must also be taken into account. An air lubrication system may reduce ship resistance but at the same time require electrical power for compressors. A wind-assistance system may supply some of the power needed for propulsion and, depending on its design, use electricity for its own operation. The main engine may consequently produce less heat, while the load and heat release of certain auxiliary engines change. These effects must be established for each heat source to assess the combined heat supply correctly.

Another interaction arises when the WHRS generates electricity from waste heat supplied by generating sets whose load falls as a result. Lower generator load may change the heat release of these engines. This, in turn, may alter the WHRS's electricity generation. The final electrical and thermal operating conditions must therefore be mutually consistent. A heat calculation must not continue to assume an engine load that no longer occurs after the combined energy-saving measures.

The fact that different measures affect each other does not mean that a WHRS is unsuitable for use alongside them. However, the additional WHRS contribution may change when the ship needs less engine power or produces and uses the required energy differently. Lower WHRS output is not necessarily an unfavourable outcome. If the primary measures reduce fuel consumption directly, the ship's total energy savings may increase while less waste heat remains available.

A reliable comparison therefore requires a clearly defined baseline. First, the effects of the primary measures on energy demand, engine operation and heat release must be established. The additional useful energy the WHRS can still deliver under those new conditions can then be calculated. This prevents WHRS output from being calculated on the basis of heat that is no longer available because of other measures. It also prevents the same quantity of heat or fuel savings from being attributed to more than one measure.

How Do You Determine the Usable Waste Heat After Energy-Saving Measures?

A technical assessment starts with the engine and energy-system configuration expected after the planned measures have been implemented. The original operating data provide an important starting point for this, but do not automatically describe the future heat supply. The first step is to identify which engines currently operate, the loads at which they run and the heat sources a WHRS could use. This establishes the baseline against which the changes can be assessed.

It is then established how the energy-saving measures affect operation. For propulsion improvements, relevant factors include the expected shaft power, rotational speed and engine operating point. For electrical savings, the changes in electrical demand and auxiliary engine operation are important. For thermal savings, the assessment must identify which existing heat demand is reduced and how this changes the distribution of engine heat.

For the new engine operating points, suitable data are needed on exhaust gas temperature, exhaust gas mass flow rate and heat rejection through the relevant cooling-water circuits. These values must relate to the same engine load, fuel and operating conditions. For measures that have not yet been implemented, the future heat-source conditions may not be directly measurable. Manufacturer data and technical calculations may then provide a starting point. It must nevertheless remain clear which values are based on measurements and which are derived from assumptions or calculations.

The expected performance improvement may also be uncertain. During actual ship operation, propeller optimization, hull cleaning or a wind-assistance system may not deliver exactly the reduction in power originally assumed. During WHRS selection, it must therefore be assessed how sensitive the available heat supply is to departures from the expected engine load. An installation that performs well only at a single operating point based on favourable assumptions may receive considerably less usable heat during actual operation.

Once sufficient data on the new heat sources are available, the proportion that can be used within acceptable technical limits can be determined. In this assessment, the original engine functions and permitted operating limits remain decisive. For exhaust gas heat, the permitted exhaust back pressure, the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature and any temperature requirements of aftertreatment equipment must be taken into account. For engine cooling water, the specified engine temperatures, necessary water circulation and existing temperature control must be maintained.

The heat that other consumers already absorb must also be included in the energy balance. This shows what proportion of engine heat is already being used and how much remains available for additional recovery after the measures have been implemented. For electricity generation, thermal power alone is insufficient. Source temperatures, the scope for heat transfer, available cooling and the permitted WHRS operating range determine how much of the heat can actually be converted into useful electrical power.

The calculated heat flows must then be related to the expected voyage and operating profile. The assessment must identify which energy-saving measures are active in each operating period and which engine loads, temperatures and flow rates actually occur together. For wind-assisted propulsion, for example, periods with substantial, limited and no usable wind assistance may need to be assessed separately. For electrical energy savings, the difference between running a single generating set and running several may be important. If ship speed is reduced, account must also be taken of the changed voyage duration.

An analysis based solely on rated engine load therefore provides too little information if the measures are specifically intended to allow the ship to operate at lower power for long periods. The thermal energy available annually is then determined from the usable heat flows and the operating hours during which they actually occur. When reassessing an existing WHRS, its minimum heat input, control range and ability to operate at lower or varying loads must also be taken into account.

For a complete net energy assessment, it must then be established how much useful heat or electricity the WHRS can deliver under the new operating conditions. The WHRS's own energy consumption and the demand for the electricity or heat it supplies must also be considered. The final comparison must distinguish between the savings that arise directly from the primary measures and the additional savings that the WHRS can still achieve afterwards. Both contributions must be assessed within the same ship and operating boundaries so that the combined energy savings are not overestimated.

When Must an Existing or Planned WHRS Be Reassessed?

A waste heat recovery system is selected for particular heat sources and operating conditions. If energy-saving measures change these assumptions, the assessment must check whether the original WHRS configuration still suits the available heat supply. For a planned installation, the order in which the measures are implemented is particularly important. If a WHRS is first selected on the basis of the existing engine load and a substantial propulsion improvement follows, less waste heat may remain available than was assumed in the original selection.

At lower engine loads, a system designed for a greater heat supply may not deliver the same electrical output. However, this does not automatically mean that a larger WHRS becomes technically unsuitable. The effects depend on the permitted control range, minimum heat input required and ability to operate at lower temperatures and flow rates. If the heat source falls outside the usable operating range for long periods, the system may need to run at reduced output or shut down more often.

Changes in heat distribution between several engines may also be a reason for reassessment. If certain generating sets run less often or another engine takes over propulsion, the connected heat exchangers and shared heat transfer circuits may receive fluid at temperatures and flow rates that differ from those originally expected. For an existing WHRS, the current or expected heat-source data must therefore be compared again with the installation's permitted operating range. The issue is not simply whether the rated generator power can still be achieved. Above all, performance during typical operating hours determines how much useful energy remains.

Sometimes the existing WHRS can be retained and a control adjustment is sufficient. In other cases, changes to heat exchangers, intermediate circuits or the module configuration may be needed. Which solution is technically sound depends on the original design conditions and the scale of the changes. Reassessment may also be necessary if thermal energy savings actually make more usable engine heat available. The existing WHRS may then receive a larger heat supply, but only if the available temperatures, heat exchangers and the permitted capacity of the installation allow the system to use that additional heat.

Electrical demand may also constitute a new limitation. If other measures substantially reduce the ship's electricity consumption, the ship may be able to use less of the electricity generated by the WHRS. A technically suitable heat source then does not guarantee the same annual energy savings. For measures yet to be implemented, it is therefore preferable to assess the future heat and energy balance before the WHRS is finally selected. For an already installed WHRS, reassessment may be needed if engine load, heat consumption or electrical demand differs substantially from the original design assumptions.

The modification ultimately required depends on the new operating conditions and the actual capabilities of the existing or planned installation. It must not be assumed that every energy-saving measure automatically reduces WHRS output.

How Do Other Energy-Saving Measures Change the Waste Heat Available to a WHRS?

Other energy-saving measures change the waste heat available to a WHRS because engine load, engine operation or existing heat demand on board changes. Depending on the measure, less heat may therefore be produced, the heat supply may be distributed differently between engines or a larger share of the existing waste heat may become available.

Hull and propulsion improvements, wind assistance and lower ship speed can reduce the required engine power. Exhaust gas mass flow rate, exhaust gas temperature and heat rejection through cooling water may consequently change. The amount of usable heat does not necessarily decrease in the same proportion as fuel consumption.

Electrical energy savings may reduce the load on auxiliary engines or allow them to be shut down for certain periods. This may change both the available heat sources and how much WHRS-generated electricity can be usefully supplied to the shipboard electrical system. Thermal energy savings may instead make more existing waste heat available when consumers need less engine heat. The engine does not automatically produce more heat as a result, but a larger share of the original heat supply may remain available for additional recovery.

When several measures are used together, their overall effect on engine operation and heat distribution must be assessed. Their individual effects must not simply be added together, because each measure may change the operating conditions under which the other measures function. Lower WHRS output does not necessarily mean that the ship's overall energy performance deteriorates. A primary measure may reduce fuel consumption directly, leaving less waste heat available for recovery.

For a technically suitable WHRS, the decisive factor is therefore the heat that actually remains available and usable after the relevant energy-saving measures have been implemented. Matching heat recovery to these future operating conditions prevents an installation from being selected on the basis of heat that is no longer available in the same quantity, at the same temperature or for the same number of operating hours.

This Article in the Series

When other energy-saving measures change engine operation, a WHRS may receive less usable waste heat while the ship as a whole operates more efficiently. At the same time, lower electrical demand may affect how WHRS electricity generation is matched to the shipboard electrical system. The heat available after these measures therefore provides an important basis for sizing a WHRS using the vessel's operating and load profile, as part of WHRS system selection and integration.