Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Do You Match Electricity Generation From Waste Heat to a Ship's Electrical System?

To use electricity generated from waste heat in the shipboard electrical system, the WHRS generator must be properly integrated with the existing electrical installation and power management system, taking account of the available power reserve. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can produce electricity from heat that would otherwise largely be lost. However, how much power is available depends on the heat source and operating conditions. The shipboard electrical system must be able to accept this electricity without compromising the required voltage, frequency or reliability of the electrical supply.

The generator connection, protection arrangements and power control must therefore be coordinated with the existing generating sets and any other energy sources. The control system must be able to respond when the heat supply decreases, electrical demand changes or the WHRS fails unexpectedly. The operating strategy also depends on whether the load on a running generating set is reduced or can be shut down altogether. The available waste heat may also change if the WHRS draws heat from generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity it generates. The WHRS electrical power rating is therefore insufficient to establish its contribution to the shipboard electrical system. What matters is how much electricity the installation can deliver under actual operating conditions and how much of that output can replace electricity generated by the existing generating sets. At the same time, the electrical supply must remain reliable when this heat-dependent generation changes or ceases.

When Can Electricity from Waste Heat Be Used in the Shipboard Electrical System?

The shipboard electrical system supplies energy to the ship's electrical loads. Depending on the installation, diesel generating sets, shaft generators, battery storage or other energy sources may be available for this purpose. Together, these sources must deliver sufficient power to meet electrical demand under the relevant operating conditions. A WHRS can replace part of the electricity currently generated by other sources. In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), heat is supplied to a closed thermodynamic cycle. The organic working fluid evaporates and then expands in an expander that drives a generator. The electricity generated can be supplied to the shipboard electrical system through a suitable electrical connection.

The thermal power supplied to the ORC is not the same as the generator's electrical output. Only some of the heat absorbed is converted into mechanical power. The remaining heat is largely rejected through the condenser. The installation also uses electricity for pumps, controls and, where necessary, additional cooling. Assessing its contribution to the shipboard electrical system therefore requires figures for the WHRS's electrical output, conversion losses and additional auxiliary power demand. Gross generator output must be distinguished from the net power available to the ship's electrical supply. Existing auxiliary consumption counts as an additional load only to the extent that it changes because of the WHRS.

The electricity generated must also meet a demand on board. When the WHRS supplies power to the shipboard electrical system while other generating sets are operating, it can displace some of the electricity they generate. The existing generating sets then need to supply less electrical power overall. At low electrical demand, this opportunity may be limited. A generating set that has to keep running for operational reliability may have a minimum permitted load. The WHRS therefore cannot increase its share of electricity generation without limit, even when sufficient heat is available. Depending on the shipboard electrical system and the existing energy supply, WHRS output must be reduced or another permitted use for the electricity must be available.

The ability to use the generated electricity is therefore a separate constraint alongside the available heat and WHRS performance. For a realistic estimate of energy output, the heat supply, net electricity generation and electrical demand must relate to the same operating periods. High generator output does not automatically translate into corresponding fuel savings if there is insufficient demand for the electricity at that time.

How Is a WHRS Generator Connected to the Existing Shipboard Electrical System?

The electrical connection of a WHRS depends on the generator type, drive and arrangement of the existing shipboard electrical system. Many ships have an alternating-current system, but some use direct-current distribution or a combination of both. The generator and any power electronics must be compatible with the existing electrical architecture.

For a synchronous generator connected directly to an alternating-current system, the required system frequency and the number of generator poles determine the necessary shaft speed. When the generator is connected in parallel with an already energized shipboard electrical system, the electrical conditions must match closely enough at the moment of connection. The relevant parameters include voltage, frequency, phase sequence and phase angle. Incorrect synchronization can cause high electrical and mechanical loads. Suitable synchronization equipment, switching devices and protection arrangements are therefore required. The expander control must also be capable of increasing and reducing generator load under the required conditions.

Once the generator is connected in parallel, active and reactive power are not necessarily governed by the same control system. In a conventional synchronous generator, active power output depends on the mechanical power supplied by the drive. Excitation and voltage control, by contrast, affect the exchange of reactive power. Both functions must be compatible with the existing generator controls and the ship's power sharing arrangements.

In other WHRS configurations, power electronics are used between the generator and the shipboard electrical system. This may be useful, for example, when the expander operates at a rotational speed that is not directly compatible with the system frequency. A suitable converter configuration then matches the generator's electrical output to the characteristics of the shipboard electrical system. This electrical decoupling allows greater flexibility in choosing the expander speed, but also introduces its own technical requirements. The converter must be suitable for the required power, existing system conditions and operation alongside other generators. Depending on the arrangement, harmonic distortion, reactive power and behaviour during voltage and frequency deviations must also be assessed.

However, a converter does not automatically allow the WHRS to supply the shipboard electrical system independently. A grid-following converter supplies power to a system in which other suitable sources maintain the voltage and frequency. Independent grid-forming operation requires a suitably designed control configuration, sufficient available energy and appropriate protection.

For a direct-current system, different connection requirements apply. For example, the generator may be connected to the direct-current bus through a rectifier or other power conversion equipment. The control must then be compatible with the required direct-current voltage, power sharing and protection of the DC installation. The synchronization requirements for a directly connected AC generator do not automatically apply to this connection.

The main switchboard and electrical distribution must also be suitable for the new energy source. Cables, circuit breakers, connection panels and any transformers must be able to handle the expected operating and fault currents. Adding a generator may change short-circuit conditions, requiring reassessment of the existing switching and protection equipment. A directly connected generator may, for example, contribute to the short-circuit current. With a connection through power electronics, the fault-current contribution depends in part on the selected converter and its control. Under certain conditions, the existing protection arrangements may therefore respond differently once the WHRS is connected.

The protection assessment must establish how overloads, short circuits, deviations in voltage or frequency, and unwanted power flows are handled. Where applicable, reverse-power protection, protection selectivity and safe disconnection of a faulty WHRS connection are also important. A technically suitable connection therefore requires more than an appropriate rated voltage and sufficient generator power. Parallel operation, power quality, fault-current contribution and protection coordination must also be compatible with the complete electrical installation and the applicable requirements of the classification society and flag State.

How Does the Power Management System Coordinate the WHRS and Generating Sets?

The power management system (PMS) manages which electrical energy sources operate and how they are loaded on board. Depending on its design, it can start and stop generating sets, allocate load between sources and monitor whether enough power remains available. When a WHRS supplies electricity to the shipboard electrical system, the PMS must include this additional generation in its power sharing. The other generating sets may then need to deliver less power. How much existing generation the WHRS can displace depends on electrical demand, the available WHRS output and the chosen operating strategy.

However, a WHRS has different control capabilities from a conventional diesel generating set. In a diesel generating set, the engine can deliver more mechanical power within the permitted limits when the engine control increases the fuel supply. For a WHRS, output depends on the available heat and the conditions under which the thermodynamic process can operate. The rated WHRS generator power therefore does not indicate how much power is available at any given time. The current heat supply, cooling conditions, expander operating range and the installation's control capabilities also determine the possible output.

The PMS and the local WHRS control must take this into account. The PMS may, for example, send a power setpoint or a maximum permitted contribution to the shipboard electrical system. The WHRS control then determines whether that power can actually be delivered within the thermal, mechanical and electrical operating limits. If insufficient heat is available, the system must not be forced to deliver the requested power at the expense of the required process conditions. The WHRS must then be able to report a lower output limit or reduce electricity generation in a controlled way. Conversely, the PMS may request a reduction in output when electrical demand decreases or an existing generating set would otherwise be too lightly loaded.

Active and reactive power sharing must also be clearly controlled. During parallel operation, the WHRS generator and the other energy sources must not interfere with one another's load sharing or voltage regulation. The system design determines which functions are controlled directly by the PMS and which are managed by the generator's or converter's local controls.

For stable power sharing, generating sets in service must retain enough margin to adjust their output. If a generating set is already operating close to its maximum permitted load, it may be unable to meet a sudden increase in electrical demand in full. At the other end of the range, the minimum permitted load on a generating set may limit how much WHRS output the system can accept. The PMS must therefore know not only how much power the different sources are delivering at that moment, but also how much additional power is actually available. For a WHRS, the PMS must also account for heat-dependent output and how quickly it can change within the permitted operating range.

Communication between the PMS and WHRS must also be considered. If a control signal is lost, incorrect power information is received or a communication fault occurs, the installation must be able to respond safely in a predefined way. The reliability of the shipboard electrical system must not depend on assuming that the last WHRS power setpoint received remains valid indefinitely.

Effective coordination between the two control systems makes it possible to use WHRS output when sufficient heat is available and there is enough electrical demand. Meanwhile, the existing generating sets must continue to operate within their permitted load range and retain sufficient scope to adjust their output and supply the shipboard electrical system reliably.

When Can a Generating Set Be Loaded Less Heavily or Be Shut Down Completely?

Electricity from waste heat can reduce the load on a running generating set. When the WHRS meets part of the electrical demand, the generating set needs to supply less electrical power under otherwise comparable conditions. Fuel consumption may consequently decrease, but these savings are not necessarily proportional to the reduction in electrical power. This is because a generating set's fuel consumption and efficiency vary with engine load. The WHRS's own energy consumption and any effects on other generators must also be taken into account.

During prolonged operation at low load, engine-specific limits may also apply. Depending on the engine design and the manufacturer's requirements, it may be necessary to avoid certain load levels or limit the operating time at those loads. A WHRS that supplies a large share of the electrical demand must therefore not cause the remaining generating set to operate outside its permitted range.

Another option is to shut down a generating set completely. This may be attractive because the auxiliary engine stops consuming fuel once shut down. However, having enough WHRS output to replace the generating set's current contribution is not sufficient on its own. After shutdown, the remaining energy sources must be able to supply normal electrical demand. Sufficient power must also remain available to cover relevant load changes and the loss of an energy source. The reserve required depends on the requirements for the ship and the operating mode concerned.

A running generating set can, within its available control range, immediately deliver additional mechanical and electrical power. A standby generator that is stopped, by contrast, must first start, reach the required operating conditions and, where necessary, synchronize before power can be supplied to the shipboard electrical system. This difference becomes particularly important if the WHRS fails unexpectedly. It may therefore be necessary to keep a generating set running even when the WHRS produces enough electricity in normal operation to cover most of the current demand. Whether a set can be shut down depends in part on the power reserve required, the speed at which other energy sources can respond and the continuity of supply required by shipboard functions.

Under other conditions, shutting down a generating set may be beneficial. The remaining engines may then be more heavily loaded and may consequently operate in a more favourable range. At the same time, the available reserve changes and the engine installation's heat output may also change. The choice must therefore be based on total fuel consumption, the electrical power reserve required and the heat sources remaining after the change in generating-set operation. The combination of engines that gives the highest WHRS output need not be the one with the lowest total fuel consumption.

What Happens When Lower Generator Load Also Reduces the Available Waste Heat?

When a WHRS uses heat from the same auxiliary engines that supply electricity to the shipboard electrical system, the electricity generated and the available heat supply may affect each other. The WHRS then replaces some of the electricity generated by those sets, using heat supplied by those same auxiliary engines. During electricity generation, an auxiliary engine releases heat through the exhaust gases, cooling water and other heat flows. The WHRS uses some of it for additional electricity production. Once this additional generation reduces the generating set's load, the auxiliary engine's operating point changes.

The exhaust gas flow rate, exhaust gas temperature and heat transferred to the cooling water may also change as a result. If less usable heat becomes available, the WHRS may then produce less electricity. The generating set may then have to meet more of the electrical demand again. An output estimate based solely on generator load before the WHRS was switched on may therefore be too high. The available waste heat and electricity generation must be established at the engine load that results once waste heat recovery is operating.

When a generating set is shut down completely, this interaction becomes even clearer. If the engine that has been shut down supplied heat to the WHRS, that continuous heat supply disappears. The WHRS cannot then continue producing from the same original heat source as though the engine were still running. Electricity generation can continue under the changed conditions only if other available heat sources supply sufficient energy.

This interaction is different when the WHRS mainly uses heat from a propulsion engine whose load remains independent of the reduction in auxiliary engine load. As long as the propulsion engine's operating point remains unchanged, the available engine heat does not change directly as a result of the lower load on the separate generating sets. For the final power distribution, electrical demand, generator load and heat-dependent WHRS output must therefore relate to the same operating configuration. The control system must also remain stable when the engine operating point changes slightly. The effect of this feedback must be included in the assessment of actual generating-set operation, not just in the calculation of rated WHRS output.

How Does the Shipboard Electrical System Respond to Varying WHRS Output and Electrical Demand?

Electrical demand on board can change rapidly. Starting a large electric motor, bringing a bow thruster into service or changing the load on electrically driven equipment may require additional generator power. When electrical loads are switched off, electrical load may instead fall suddenly.

The heat supply to a WHRS does not necessarily change at the same rate. Exhaust gas and cooling-water flows respond to changes in engine load, but heat exchangers, fluid circuits and other WHRS components have their own thermal mass. The amount of usable heat may therefore lag behind changes in engine load. The expander and generator control also have a permitted operating range. A WHRS therefore cannot necessarily respond to power changes as quickly as a diesel generating set or battery system designed to do so. How quickly power can be adjusted depends on the thermodynamic cycle, expander and electrical connection.

When electrical demand rises suddenly, the other energy sources must be able to deliver sufficient additional power. In a conventional alternating-current system, the available generator reserve and response of the engine governors are particularly important in accommodating the change. Voltage control must also be suitable for the new electrical load. In the event of a sudden fall in electrical demand, a surplus of generated power may instead arise. If the WHRS and the other generators do not reduce their output in time, undesirable frequency deviations or changes in power sharing may occur. The control system must therefore be able to adjust generator loading to match the new demand.

Reducing electrical output must also be feasible on the thermal side. When the shipboard electrical system requests less WHRS power, the heat source may still supply the same amount of heat. The recovery system must then be able to reduce the output of the thermodynamic process within the permitted limits or restrict heat absorption in another suitable way. Depending on the design, arrangements may be needed to divert heat around the recovery system or adjust the operation of the expander and heat exchangers in a controlled way. The requested electrical power therefore cannot be determined independently of the thermal control.

Start-up must also account for the fact that waste heat may be available before the WHRS is ready to generate electricity. The installation must first reach the required process conditions. The generator can then be connected to the shipboard electrical system once the applicable electrical conditions have been met. During shutdown, the generator's electrical load can be reduced and the generator disconnected while the heat exchangers and fluid circuits still contain thermal energy. The WHRS must be able to handle this remaining heat safely. Disconnecting the generator therefore does not mean that all thermal processes stop immediately.

For effective coordination, the PMS and the WHRS control system must therefore work together during normal load changes, start-up and shutdown of heat recovery. The rapid adjustments in power required must still be provided by energy sources capable of responding to those changes.

How Does the Shipboard Electrical System Remain Reliable if the WHRS Fails?

If a WHRS fails unexpectedly, the electrical contribution it was delivering at that moment is lost. The other energy sources must cover this power loss. If the remaining sources cannot supply enough power, electrical load must be reduced using the available load reduction measures. The severity of the consequences depends on WHRS output at the moment of failure and the available reserve in the rest of the electrical installation. A running generating set may be able to deliver additional power by increasing its load. However, that power remains limited by the rated capacity, current load and the speed at which the engine and generator can respond.

In the event of a large sudden power loss, the frequency of an independently operating alternating-current system may fall. Depending on the electrical configuration and control response, voltage deviations may also occur. If the remaining sources cannot deliver enough power or do not respond quickly enough, part of the shipboard electrical system may fail. It must therefore be known in advance which energy sources can deliver additional power immediately. An automatically starting standby generator may help restore or supplement the energy supply, but cannot supply electrical power to the shipboard electrical system until it has started and been connected.

The initial power change may require reserve power from generators already in service. If the ship has suitable battery storage, it may also supply power under the required conditions. If the available generation remains insufficient, automatic load shedding of designated non-essential loads may be necessary. These arrangements do not all serve the same function. A distinction must be made between measures that prevent an interruption, arrangements that limit the consequences of a fault and means by which the electrical supply is restored after an interruption. Which combination is needed depends on the electrical system and the requirements for operational reliability.

A WHRS contributing to the normal energy supply must therefore not automatically be regarded as fully available generating reserve. Its output depends on sufficient heat, suitable cooling conditions and a functioning recovery system. The contribution, if any, that may count as power reserve must be established for the actual installation and applicable operating conditions.

The electrical protection of the WHRS must also be coordinated with the existing distribution system. In the event of a fault in the generator, converter or electrical connection, it may be necessary to disconnect the WHRS from the switchboard. Protection must be coordinated so that the fault is cleared safely without unnecessarily disconnecting unaffected energy sources.

The control system must also be able to respond to faults on the thermal side. If the condenser cannot reject enough heat or the heat source is lost, the available electrical output may fall rapidly. Even if the generator itself remains undamaged, a sudden electrical power shortfall may therefore arise. These situations must be included in the power balance. In the event of an electrical shutdown, the WHRS must remain safe for as long as heat is still present. The heat source may continue supplying heat even when the generator is no longer delivering electricity to the shipboard electrical system. The controls and protection must then prevent the expander, working fluid or other components from exceeding their permitted operating limits.

The consequences of WHRS failure must therefore be assessed for the different electrical operating modes. The power reserve, protection and any load shedding required depend on the actual power distribution and the continuity of supply required by shipboard functions.

What Role Do Battery Storage, Hybrid Operation and Shore Power Play?

Battery storage or a hybrid electrical installation may offer ships additional ways to accommodate changes in WHRS output and electrical demand. A battery can, under suitable conditions, temporarily supply power when WHRS output decreases or an electrical load suddenly increases. The battery can also absorb electricity when more WHRS power is temporarily available than the other loads on board can use directly.

The extent of this support depends on the available charging and discharging power, energy capacity, state of charge and battery control system. A battery capable of delivering additional power quickly does not necessarily store enough energy to replace lost WHRS output for an extended period. In a hybrid installation, the PMS must therefore consider not only the battery power immediately available but also the period for which that power can be supplied. Battery storage can support the electrical power balance, but does not change the amount of waste heat that the WHRS receives.

The energy source responsible for maintaining the voltage and frequency of the shipboard electrical system must also be identified. If a battery is connected through power electronics, this function depends on the selected converter control. Not every battery or WHRS converter can establish and maintain the shipboard voltage and frequency independently.

Shore power introduces a different operating configuration. When the ship's electrical loads are supplied from shore, it must be established whether the WHRS may simultaneously supply electricity to the shipboard electrical system. This depends on the shore connection, protection arrangements, permitted power flows and chosen operating strategy. A WHRS producing electricity during shore-power operation must not export power to the public grid or the port's electricity network without meeting the necessary conditions. For this purpose, the connection and protection must be suitable, and the applicable connection requirements must be met. If simultaneous operation is impossible or not permitted, WHRS output may be limited or stopped.

During port operation, the necessary heat source may also be absent. If the main engine is shut down and the auxiliary engines are used less or not at all because of shore power, the available heat supply may decrease substantially. The ability to use or store electricity therefore does not mean that the WHRS can actually generate power in this operating mode.

What Data Are Needed to Match a WHRS to the Shipboard Electrical System?

A technical assessment starts with the ship's existing electrical configuration. It must be clear from the current single-line diagram which generators, switchboard sections, bus-tie breakers and other energy sources are present. It must also be known how the shipboard electrical system is used while under way, during manoeuvring, in port and during any special operations. The electrical characteristics of the installation are then established. These include the rated voltage and frequency (or DC voltage, where applicable), available connection options and existing generator and distribution protection. The existing earthing configuration and relevant fault-current conditions must also be taken into account.

For the WHRS, data are needed on the generator, any power electronics and the associated controls. Rated power is only a starting point. The available active and reactive power, permitted operating limits and behaviour during voltage and frequency deviations are also important, where relevant to the selected connection. For a directly connected alternating-current generator, it must be clear how synchronization, excitation and load control are implemented. For a converter-connected generator, relevant factors include output control, power quality, fault-current contribution and the options for parallel or independent operation.

The next step is to determine how much net electrical power the WHRS can deliver under the relevant heat and cooling conditions. The data must distinguish between gross generator output, electrical conversion losses and additional auxiliary consumption. The minimum and maximum outputs and the rate at which power can change must also be adequately established.

PMS integration also requires clarity about the information the WHRS provides and the commands it can receive. Examples include the power actually delivered, the maximum output available at that moment, operating status and any limits or faults. The control system must distinguish between a power setpoint and the power that is actually available within the technical limits.

The ship's electrical load is then established for each relevant operating mode. This assessment must look beyond maximum demand. Typical loads, major load changes and periods of low electrical demand also matter. Particularly at lower demand, the minimum permitted load of generating sets in service may limit how much WHRS power is usefully accepted.

The generator reserve required is then determined in accordance with the applicable requirements and operating strategy. This assessment must distinguish between additional power available immediately and power available only after another energy source has been started or connected. The effects of losing the largest relevant power contribution must also be assessed, to the extent that the electrical configuration and applicable requirements call for this.

If the WHRS uses heat from generating sets whose load falls when the WHRS supplies electricity, this changed engine load must also be included in the heat balance. WHRS output and the remaining generator load must ultimately relate to the same operating configuration. If the number of running generating sets changes, it must also be established again which heat sources remain available. To calculate net fuel savings, the comparison considers how the generating sets are operated before and after the change. The comparison must account for the engines' fuel consumption at their changed loads, the WHRS electricity that can actually be used and the recovery installation's additional energy consumption. A reduction in electrical generator output does not necessarily lead to a proportional reduction in fuel consumption.

The electrical protection must also be reassessed. Depending on the connection, calculations may be needed for short-circuit currents, protection selectivity and behaviour during overload or generator failure. For a converter-connected WHRS, the specific characteristics of the power electronics used must be taken into account.

Further engineering requires coordination between the PMS and the local WHRS control system. The division of responsibilities must specify which controller determines the power demand, which technical limits always take priority and how both systems respond when communication is lost, insufficient heat is available or electrical load differs from the expected level.

During commissioning, the electrical connection, power sharing and control responses can then be checked under suitable operating conditions. Start-up, controlled reduction of output and shutdown of the WHRS, as well as its operation alongside existing generating sets, must also be assessed. Where safe and permitted, the relevant fault responses must be tested. These include the loss of WHRS output and the PMS response. If certain operating conditions cannot be reproduced during testing, calculations, simulations or other adequately substantiated verification methods must support the aspects that remain untested.

A technically suitable connection therefore involves more than simply fitting a generator capable of supplying electricity to the switchboard. The assessment must make clear how the heat-dependent output is used during normal operation and how the electrical energy supply remains reliable when operating conditions change or faults occur.

How Do You Reliably Match Electricity Production from Waste Heat to the Shipboard Electrical System?

Electricity generation from waste heat can be reliably integrated into the shipboard electrical system when the WHRS generator is correctly connected, the power management system accurately accounts for the available output and the other energy sources retain sufficient scope to adjust their output as well as the required power reserve. The generator connection must be compatible with the electrical distribution, protection and required system conditions. The PMS must then account for the power that the WHRS can actually deliver and the amount of electricity that the existing generating sets no longer need to produce within their permitted operating range. Shutting down a generating set altogether requires a different assessment of the remaining power reserve than simply reducing its load.

If the WHRS uses heat from engines whose load falls when the WHRS supplies electricity, the changed heat supply must also be taken into account. The calculated WHRS output must correspond to the engine load and generating-set operation that actually result once the WHRS is in operation.

The shipboard electrical system must also remain reliable when WHRS output changes or is unexpectedly lost. The other energy sources, power control and protection must be suitable for this. At the same time, the WHRS itself must continue to operate within its permitted thermal and electrical limits.

The WHRS's actual contribution therefore depends on how much net electricity it can safely supply to the shipboard electrical system during the relevant operating periods and how much existing electricity generation it can thereby displace. A well-integrated WHRS delivers this contribution without unacceptably compromising the electrical system's stability, protection or required power reserve.

This Article in the Series

Whether the shipboard electrical system can accept the available WHRS electricity is only one aspect of integration. The cooling capacity for the WHRS condenser also determines how much electrical power the installation can deliver, while other energy-saving measures may change engine load and thus the heat supply. These interdependencies require a combined assessment of the heat source, cooling and electrical operation as part of WHRS system selection and integration.