When Does the Existing Cooling Water System Need to Be Modified for a WHRS Condenser?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
A ship's existing cooling-water system needs to be modified for a WHRS condenser when the system cannot reject the condenser heat under the required operating conditions because cooling capacity or flow is insufficient or the cooling water is too warm. A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can produce sufficient electricity only when usable waste heat is available and the necessary heat rejection on the cold side is assured.
In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), some of the heat supplied is converted into mechanical and then electrical power. Most of the remaining heat is rejected through the condenser. The additional cooling load this creates for the ship depends on the original heat rejection and the heat sources used. Heat from engine cooling water may already have been rejected through the same central cooling system. With recovery from exhaust gases, by contrast, heat that previously left the ship through the funnel may be added to the cooling system.
The total condenser heat load therefore does not in itself establish whether the existing cooling-water system needs to be expanded. The point at which heat is transferred to the cooling water, the available water circulation and the effects on other consumers are also decisive. If the existing cooling has insufficient capacity under certain conditions, the assessment can also consider whether WHRS output can be reduced safely. Expansion is necessary only when the required operation cannot be ensured with the existing arrangements and an appropriate operating strategy.
What Heat Must a WHRS Condenser Actually Reject?
In an ORC-based waste heat recovery system, an organic working fluid absorbs heat to drive a thermodynamic cycle. After expansion in a turbine or other expander, the working fluid must be cooled enough to condense back into a liquid. The condenser transfers the heat released in this process to a cooling medium. The amount of heat the condenser must reject depends on the mass flow rate of the organic working fluid and its state at the condenser inlet and outlet. For the complete cycle, the heat supplied is distributed between the work produced, the heat rejected and any other energy exchanges. The energy that the working fluid pump adds to the cycle is also part of this balance.
The condenser heat load therefore cannot simply be calculated by subtracting the generator's net electrical power output from the thermal power supplied. Generator losses, pump energy and any heat losses to the surroundings must be accounted for at the correct point in the energy balance. Sizing the cooling system requires the actual condenser heat load at the relevant ORC operating conditions.
However, this heat load is not necessarily equal to the additional cooling load on the ship. When an ORC uses heat from an engine's high-temperature cooling circuit, some of this heat may already have been transferred to the low-temperature circuit through an existing engine cooling-water heat exchanger. The heat was then rejected to the surrounding water through the central cooler. After installation of the ORC, the same engine heat may follow a different route. Some of this heat enters the organic cycle, which converts part of it into useful power. The remaining heat is then rejected through the ORC condenser. If this condenser is connected to the same central cooling system, heat rejection through the original engine cooling-water heat exchanger may decrease. The full amount of condenser heat therefore does not automatically constitute a new load on the central cooler.
The combined cooling load consequently need not remain the same as before. The electrical energy actually produced, auxiliary consumption and where any losses are released as heat affect the overall energy balance. After installation, the heat may also be rejected through different pipe branches and heat exchangers. Even when the total heat load changes only slightly, individual parts of the cooling system may therefore be more heavily loaded.
The situation is different for the recovery of exhaust gas heat. If, without a WHRS, exhaust gas heat was rejected to the surroundings through the funnel, it was not part of the existing central cooling load. After conversion in the ORC, the remaining process heat may instead need to be rejected through the ship's cooling system. An ORC recovering exhaust gas heat may therefore create a substantial additional cooling load, even when the original engine cooling-water heat remains virtually unchanged.
When exhaust gas and cooling-water heat are combined, the individual heat flows must therefore be traced back to their original heat sources. The assessment compares the ship's heat rejection with and without a WHRS under the same relevant operating conditions. The assessment must establish both the total heat that the cooling system has to reject and the load on each cooler and pipe branch.
When Does the Existing Cooling-Water System Have Sufficient Capacity?
Many ships have a central cooling system in which closed freshwater circuits remove heat from engines and other machinery. This heat is then transferred to seawater or river water through one or more central heat exchangers. Depending on the engine and ship configuration, high-temperature and low-temperature circuits may be separate or connected at certain points. The low-temperature circuit may receive heat from, among other equipment, charge-air coolers, lubricating-oil coolers and auxiliary engine cooling. Heat from the high-temperature circuit may also be transferred to the central cooling system through a separate heat exchanger. The existing consumers and their connections determine how much heat the central cooling system already has to handle.
A suitable low-temperature circuit may provide a connection point for an ORC condenser. However, this does not automatically mean that sufficient capacity is available. A central cooler is designed for particular water flow rates, temperatures and heat loads. Its stated cooling capacity applies to the conditions on which the relevant performance calculation is based. The available heat transfer may change with the intake-water or freshwater temperature, even at the same water flow rate.
Comparing the rated cooling capacity with the new condenser heat load is therefore insufficient. First, the amount of heat rejected by the existing installation during the relevant operating modes must be established. The change in this heat load when the WHRS is operating is then determined. The heat loads must relate to conditions that actually occur simultaneously. High engine load may, for example, coincide with high ORC electricity output and thus a substantial condenser heat load. Other cooling-water consumers may also release a large amount of heat under those conditions. The combined load must therefore be assessed for the operating modes in which these heat flows actually coincide.
The existing temperature control also affects the available cooling capacity. If some of the central cooling water is directed around the cooler through a bypass during normal operation, this may indicate that the full cooling capacity is not needed. This does not, however, establish how much additional heat the system can reject under less favourable conditions. With warmer intake water, for example, the control system may direct more water through the central cooler to maintain the required freshwater temperature. Once the control system has reached the end of its operating range, the central cooling-water temperature may still rise. A cooling system therefore has sufficient thermal capacity when the combined heat load remains within its available heat transfer capacity and all the consumers concerned retain their required water temperatures.
The condition and availability of individual coolers must also be taken into account. In an installation with several heat exchangers, it must be clear how much cooling capacity must remain available under the design requirements when a cooler is isolated or out of service. Adding a WHRS must not make the necessary cooling of essential ship systems dependent on all coolers being available. This does not mean that the ORC must be able to continue operating at full power during every fault condition. If the WHRS can safely reduce output or stop, the required cooling capacity for the other consumers can be maintained without the full condenser heat load also having to be rejected during a fault.
Why Are Cooling-Water Temperature and Condensing Temperature Decisive?
Cooling-water temperature directly affects the temperature at which the organic working fluid in an ORC can condense. For heat transfer, the working fluid must be sufficiently warmer than the cooling water. The temperature difference required depends on the condenser design, available heat transfer area, flow rate and required heat transfer. At a lower cooling-water temperature, the condenser can operate at a lower condensing temperature under otherwise comparable conditions. This may benefit the ORC because the usable expansion range may then increase.
As the cooling water becomes warmer, the organic working fluid usually has to condense at a higher temperature to reject sufficient heat. The corresponding condensing pressure may therefore rise. Depending on the cycle and its control, this may reduce turbine or expander power and, in turn, net electrical power output. The effect may be substantial, particularly at a relatively low source temperature. The usable temperature difference between the hot and cold sides is then already limited. A further increase in condensing temperature may therefore noticeably reduce the scope for electricity production.
The temperature at which cooling water enters the condenser is not the only consideration. The water warms up during heat transfer. This temperature rise depends on the condenser heat load, water mass flow rate and thermal properties of the cooling medium. A higher water flow rate can limit the cooling-water temperature rise at the same heat load. However, pumping more water is not the best solution under all conditions. A higher flow rate may require additional electrical pumping power and increase pressure losses in the pipework. Any potential improvement in condensing conditions must therefore be assessed alongside these effects.
Local temperature differences within the condenser also play a role. The organic working fluid must be able to release sufficient heat to condense under the required operating conditions and reach the specified state at the condenser outlet. A favourable average cooling-water temperature alone does not provide sufficient assurance of this.
For an existing cooling-water system, the actual water temperature at the condenser connection must therefore be established. The temperature immediately after the central cooler need not be the same as at the selected branch connection. If the cooling water first serves other equipment, it may already be warmer when it reaches the condenser. The return point for the warmed condenser cooling water also matters. If this water raises the supply temperature to other cooling-water consumers, the cooling available to those consumers may decrease. An unfavourable connection may therefore affect both ORC performance and the cooling of other equipment, even while the central cooling system can still reject sufficient heat overall.
A separate intermediate heat exchanger can improve hydraulic separation. However, the additional heat transfer requires a further temperature difference. The temperature on the cold side of the ORC may therefore be higher than with a direct connection to a suitable cooling circuit. In the condenser assessment, a distinction must therefore be made between sufficient total cooling capacity and a sufficiently low available cooling-water temperature. Both conditions must be met to allow the intended electricity production.
When Do Pumps, Pipes and Connection Points Limit the Condenser?
A cooling-water system may have sufficient thermal capacity yet still be unsuitable for a direct WHRS condenser connection. The existing water circulation, pump characteristics and pressure distribution may impose separate limits. The condenser needs a certain cooling-water flow rate to achieve the required heat rejection and temperature conditions. The existing or modified pipework and pumps must be able to deliver this flow to the selected connection. Pressure losses occur in the condenser, connecting pipes, bends, isolation valves and control arrangements.
In a series connection, the condenser is installed in a section of pipework that also supplies cooling water to existing equipment. This increases the flow resistance of the route. Equipment supplied downstream of the condenser may also receive warmer cooling water. A series connection may therefore affect both the available water flow and the temperature conditions for other consumers.
In a parallel connection, the condenser has a separate supply and return route. The flow must then be distributed correctly between the new branch and the existing equipment. If the new branch has relatively little flow resistance, an unfavourable arrangement may allow more water to flow through the condenser than intended. Excessive resistance may instead cause insufficient flow. Both situations may affect the cooling of other equipment. The required condenser flow rate must therefore be calculated, and it must also be established how much water the other consumers will still receive after connection.
The existing pumps partly determine how cooling water can be distributed. The flow rate delivered by a pump depends on the resistance of the connected system. Its actual operating point depends on the pump curve and the resistance of the complete connected system. Sufficient total pump flow rate therefore does not automatically mean that every individual pipe branch receives the required amount of cooling water. In a central system with several pumps or controlled water flows, the distribution may also change when another pump is brought into service or a valve changes position. The hydraulic assessment must therefore also account for the different operating modes encountered in service.
A dedicated condenser pump may be needed to deliver the required flow rate. However, an additional pump does not remedy insufficient heat transfer capacity in the central cooler. The new pump may also change the pressure distribution in common pipes. The effects on other consumers must therefore be taken into account.
A separate intermediate circuit can hydraulically isolate the condenser from the existing cooling system. The heat is then transferred to the ship's cooling system through an additional heat exchanger. This may be suitable when the ORC requires flow rates, pressures or water quality that differ from those available in the central cooling circuit. However, this additional heat transfer requires a sufficient temperature difference and causes additional pressure losses. Any intermediate circuit pump also consumes electricity. The heat rejected by the ORC must ultimately still be transferred to the surroundings through a suitable heat-rejection system.
The feasibility of the connection therefore depends on the cooling-water flow rate, available temperature, pump pressure and effects on other consumers, considered together. If the existing installation cannot meet these conditions, a hydraulic modification may be necessary even when the total thermal cooling capacity is sufficient.
What Modifications to the Existing Cooling-Water System May Be Needed?
If the existing cooling system cannot adequately serve the proposed WHRS condenser, the limiting factor must first be identified. Insufficient heat transfer capacity requires a different modification from inadequate water circulation or excessive cooling-water temperature at the selected connection point. If sufficient cooling capacity is available but a suitable connection is lacking, additional supply and return pipes may be needed. Isolation valves, control valves and connection points may also be modified to provide the condenser with the required amount of cooling water.
If flow distribution is unfavourable, hydraulic rebalancing or a change to the pipework configuration may be sufficient. The condenser must then receive the required flow rate without leaving the existing cooling-water consumers with insufficient flow. If the existing pumps cannot provide sufficient differential pressure, a different pump configuration or additional pumping capacity can be considered. The effects on the complete cooling-water system must be taken into account. A larger pump can increase pressure losses in common pipes and change the operation of other control arrangements.
The additional energy consumption also matters. If extra pumping power is needed to improve condensing conditions, that additional power demand must be accounted for when determining the WHRS's net electrical output. Better heat rejection does not automatically deliver an equally large improvement in the net electrical power available.
If the main limitation is the available heat transfer capacity, the central cooler may need to be expanded or replaced. It must also be established whether sufficient flow and a suitable temperature are available on the intake-water side. A larger central heat exchanger does not automatically provide more cooling if the intake-water pump cannot deliver sufficient flow. The necessary modification may therefore also involve intake-water pipes, pumps, filters and control arrangements. The entire heat rejection route must be suitable for the intended load.
A separate cooling arrangement for the ORC condenser may be another option. This allows the condenser to operate under its own hydraulic and thermal conditions, provided that sufficient heat can be rejected to the surroundings. If such a separate circuit is ultimately connected to the same central cooler, the total available cooling capacity remains decisive. An additional heat exchanger or intermediate circuit does not create a new route for rejecting heat to seawater or river water.
The available cooling-water temperature may also provide a reason to change the connection. If a suitable central cooling circuit is present but the selected branch receives water that is too warm, a different connection point may be more favourable than increasing cooling capacity. However, it must be checked that the lower temperature does not come at the expense of cooling for other consumers. The changed water flows must remain compatible with the original temperature control.
Not every limitation has to be resolved with additional equipment. If the existing cooling has insufficient capacity for the desired ORC output only under certain conditions, a controlled reduction in heat input or electricity production may be a technically sound alternative. The condenser must remain able to reject sufficient heat at this lower ORC load. The control system must also be suitable for reducing output or stopping the process safely when condensing conditions are likely to fall outside the permitted operating range. Such an operating strategy may reduce annual electricity production.
In the choice between additional cooling capacity and a temporary output restriction, the number of hours during which the restriction occurs, the energy output lost and the technical consequences of the modifications required must therefore be considered. Particularly in a retrofit, physical installation may also play an important role. A larger central cooler or additional pump may be technically suitable, but must also be possible to fit in the existing engine room. The available space, pipe routes and maintenance access may therefore help determine which solution is feasible.
The necessary modification ultimately follows from the identified limitation. The assessment must first establish whether the limitation concerns thermal capacity, hydraulics or control. The change needed to enable the desired operation while preserving the original cooling-water functions can then be determined.
How Is Cooling Maintained for Engines and Other Consumers?
A central cooling system often performs several necessary functions on board. Adding a WHRS condenser must therefore be assessed in terms of more than the desired electricity production. The specified cooling of engines and other connected equipment must be maintained. If the condenser releases heat to a circuit that also serves engines, lubricating-oil coolers, charge-air coolers or other equipment, higher water temperatures may affect these existing consumers.
The point at which the heated cooling water is returned is particularly important. If the condenser return water raises the supply temperature to other consumers, their available cooling may decrease. A change in how cooling water is distributed may also cause insufficient flow locally, even while the central cooler still has sufficient overall capacity. The specified temperature and flow requirements of essential ship systems therefore remain the governing conditions. The WHRS must adapt to the available cooling capacity without compromising the cooling required by other equipment.
If the cooling-water temperature rises or the available flow rate decreases, the ORC must be able to limit heat rejection through the condenser. Depending on the installation, this may involve reducing heat input, curtailing electricity generation or shutting down the ORC safely. The safety of the ORC cycle must also be maintained. If the condenser rejects insufficient heat, the condensing pressure may rise and the working fluid may fail to reach the required state at the condenser outlet. The control and protection arrangements must therefore prevent the expander, working fluid pump or other components from operating outside their permitted limits.
The available cooling capacity may also change when the load on other shipboard systems increases. If, for example, an additional engine is started, the combined heat load on the central cooling system may rise. Less capacity may then remain for the ORC condenser. The same applies if a cooling-water pump fails or a central cooler is temporarily unavailable.
The backup cooling and redundancy required depend on the function of the connected equipment and the applicable requirements of the classification society and flag State. The WHRS does not necessarily have to continue producing electricity during every fault. However, the ORC must be able to reduce output or stop safely so that the necessary cooling of engines and other essential systems is maintained.
The original cooling-water circulation must also continue to function during maintenance. When the condenser is isolated for inspection or cleaning, isolation valves and modified pipe routes must not unacceptably restrict cooling for other equipment. The necessary bypasses and maintenance provisions must therefore form part of the connection design. Reliable integration thus requires both sufficient cooling capacity during normal operation and a safe response when that capacity decreases. The ORC must not draw on the cooling capacity reserved for essential equipment to such an extent that a necessary cooling-water function is lost during a relevant fault.
Why Do Cooling Capacity and ORC Performance Change with the Operating Area?
The temperature of the sea or river water affects how much heat a central cooling system can reject. On many ships, heat from closed freshwater circuits is transferred to sea or river water through central coolers. As the intake water becomes warmer, the temperature difference available for heat transfer decreases under otherwise comparable conditions. Rejecting the same amount of heat may then require a higher freshwater temperature, more heat transfer area or different water circulation.
The existing temperature control can respond to this change within certain limits. A bypass may, for example, close further, directing more water through the central cooler. Pump capacity can also be adjusted in suitable installations. However, the options remain limited by the available heat exchanger area, pump characteristics and permitted water flows. If the intake-water temperature rises further, the central cooling-water temperature may also increase. For the ORC condenser, this means that the organic working fluid may have to condense at a higher temperature. Depending on the cycle, electricity production may consequently decrease.
This effect may be important, particularly at a relatively low heat source temperature. The usable temperature difference between the hot and cold sides is then already limited. An increase in condensing temperature may remove a substantial part of that difference. A condenser with sufficient capacity when the intake water is cold therefore need not allow the same electricity production during operation in warmer waters. A reliable output calculation requires cooling conditions that match the operating area and the periods in which the WHRS is actually used.
Engine load and heat rejection from other ship systems also change throughout the ship's operating profile. When several engines run at high load, the central cooling system may already use a large proportion of its available capacity. The capacity remaining for the condenser then depends on the simultaneous heat load and available cooling-water temperature. The least favourable situation for the condenser therefore does not necessarily occur at the highest individual engine load or the highest intake-water temperature. What matters is which heat loads, cooling-water temperatures and operating modes actually occur at the same time.
In the design assessment, a distinction must therefore be made between conditions for which the cooling must remain suitable and periods during which ORC output may be reduced. The ship's necessary cooling functions must remain available within their specified design conditions. A more limited operating range may be technically acceptable for the WHRS.
The condition of the cooling system, as well as the intake-water temperature, affects the available cooling capacity. Fouling of heat transfer surfaces reduces heat transfer. On the intake-water side, biofouling, deposits and fouled filters may also restrict water circulation. On the freshwater side too, deposits or unsuitable water quality may affect heat transfer and flow resistance. The extent of these effects depends on the arrangement, water treatment and maintenance of the installation.
A central cooler with sufficient capacity when clean may therefore offer less reserve during service. In the WHRS condenser assessment, a design and maintenance margin appropriate to the cooling system must be taken into account. This does not mean that every WHRS must be designed for the highest conceivable cooling load. If unfavourable cooling conditions occur only for limited periods, producing less electricity during those periods may be more technically and economically attractive than expanding the entire cooling installation.
The cooling capacity required therefore depends on the selected ORC operating range and the conditions under which the other shipboard systems must continue to function reliably.
How Do You Determine Which Modifications Are Actually Necessary?
A sound assessment starts with the existing cooling-water configuration. This requires current piping and instrumentation diagrams, pump characteristics, heat exchanger data, temperature-control arrangements and data on the connected equipment. On an existing ship, the documentation must be checked against the equipment actually installed. Previous modifications to pumps, pipes or coolers may have changed the original heat balance and water distribution. The current installation therefore provides the basis for the assessment.
The amount of heat that the existing cooling-water circuits must reject during the relevant operating modes is then established. Engine loads, existing consumers and the corresponding cooling-water temperatures are considered together. For the WHRS, data are needed on the actual condenser heat load, required cooling-water inlet temperature, water flow rate, permissible temperature rise and pressure drop across the condenser. These values must relate to the operating modes in which the ORC must function. The rated generator power alone provides insufficient information for this.
It must also be clear how much heat the condenser releases to the selected cooling-water circuit. To determine the additional load on the central cooling system, the original heat rejection is compared with heat rejection after WHRS installation under the same operating conditions. For recovery from engine cooling water, it must be established how much heat was previously rejected through the existing engine cooler and how this heat flow changes after installation of the ORC. For recovery from exhaust gases, the main consideration is how much condenser heat will now pass to the ship's cooling system, even though that heat was not previously rejected through this system.
When several heat sources are combined, all the energy flows involved must be included in the same heat balance. Heat transferred from one circuit to another must not be counted again as separately produced heat. This makes clear how much additional heat the cooling system actually has to handle.
Once the heat balance has been established, the available cooling-water temperatures are assessed. The performance data for the central coolers must be compared with the relevant heat loads, intake-water conditions and required supply temperatures for the connected consumers. The hydraulic assessment follows. It is then established whether the existing pumps and pipes can deliver sufficient water against the pressure losses of the new configuration. Water flows and temperatures at the other connected equipment must also be taken into account.
The installation must then be assessed under the relevant operating conditions. These include normal operation, higher combined cooling loads, unfavourable intake-water conditions and situations in which part of the cooling system is unavailable. If the existing cooling installation can maintain the necessary cooling-water functions under these conditions and the condenser can reject sufficient heat within the intended ORC operating range, a connection with suitable pipes and control arrangements may be sufficient.
If the thermal cooling capacity is sufficient but the available water flow rate or pressure distribution is inadequate, a hydraulic modification may be necessary. A larger central cooler does not automatically provide a solution in that situation. If the heat transfer capacity is insufficient instead, expansion of the central cooling system or a different heat rejection configuration must be investigated. The capacity required must be established on both the freshwater and intake-water sides.
It may also become clear that the existing cooling installation remains suitable if the ORC produces less electricity under certain cooling conditions. In that case, it must be clear at which water temperatures or available flow rates the WHRS reduces output and when the installation must stop safely. The effects of these limits on annual electricity production must then be calculated. A solution requiring fewer modifications may be technically attractive, but the reduced availability of ORC output must be included in the energy and investment assessment.
During commissioning, the relevant temperatures, pressures, water flow rates and control responses can be checked. It must also be verified that the existing cooling-water consumers continue to receive sufficient cooling when ORC output is reduced or the ORC is switched off. The nature and extent of these tests are matched to the engine, the installation and the applicable approval conditions.
Not all the governing operating conditions necessarily occur during commissioning. If, for example, the highest intake-water temperatures or another operating mode that determines the design requirements are absent, suitability for those conditions cannot be established solely from the measurements taken. Additional calculations and adequately substantiated manufacturer data then remain necessary. Only once thermal capacity, hydraulic operation, controllability and the necessary operational reliability have been assessed together can the modifications actually required be established.
When Is Modification of the Cooling-Water System Necessary for a WHRS Condenser?
The existing cooling-water system must be modified if the WHRS condenser cannot reject sufficient heat at the available cooling-water temperatures and flow rates, or if the new connection would disrupt the necessary cooling of other shipboard systems. The assessment starts by distinguishing between the condenser heat load and the actual additional load on the ship's cooling system. For recovery from engine cooling water, some of the original heat rejection may follow a different route. With recovery of exhaust gas heat, by contrast, additional heat may be brought into the central cooling system.
It must then be established whether the existing coolers can reject sufficient heat under the relevant operating and intake-water conditions. Even when the total cooling capacity is adequate, the available pumps, pipes, connection points or cooling-water temperatures may impose a limit. The modification required depends on the cause. Sometimes additional pipes, modified control arrangements or better water flow distribution are sufficient. In other situations, additional pump capacity, additional cooling capacity or separate heat rejection is necessary.
Expansion is not always the only technically sound solution, however. If the cooling capacity is insufficient for the desired electricity production only under certain conditions, a controlled reduction in ORC output may be an appropriate alternative. The installation must then be able to operate safely within the available cooling capacity, and the ship's necessary cooling-water functions must be maintained.
A suitable condenser connection therefore takes account of the original heat rejection, available cooling capacity, hydraulic distribution and operational reliability of all the equipment served. The necessary modification is ultimately the smallest technically adequate change that allows the WHRS to function within the selected operating range without impairing the ship's cooling.
This Article in the Series
The condenser heat load does not automatically indicate how much additional cooling capacity a ship needs. During recovery of engine cooling-water heat without disrupting engine cooling, some of the existing heat rejection may shift to the condenser. Once sufficient cooling is available, matching WHRS electricity to the shipboard electrical system also determines how much of the energy generated can actually be used. This interaction between the heat source, cooling and electricity use forms part of WHRS system selection and integration.