Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Does a Waste Heat Recovery System Recover Heat From Cooling Water Without Disrupting Engine Cooling?

A waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can use heat from engine cooling water, provided that the specified engine temperatures, necessary cooling-water flow and available cooling capacity are maintained. During engine operation, the cooling water removes heat to keep cylinder walls and other components subject to thermal loads within their permitted temperature range. An additional heat exchanger can transfer some of this heat to a heating system or an electricity-generating system.

The new heat exchanger must not disrupt the existing temperature control, cause unacceptable pressure losses or restrict the necessary circulation through the engine. Sufficient cooling must also remain available when the WHRS absorbs less heat, is taken out of service or fails unexpectedly. The way the heat exchanger is connected and controlled must therefore be compatible with the existing coolers, pumps, thermostatic valves and any bypass arrangements.

Under suitable operating conditions, the WHRS can take over part of the original cooling load without making the engine dependent on the recovery system for its necessary cooling or temperature control. Whether cooling-water heat can be used safely therefore depends on more than the amount of heat available. The way heat extraction is integrated into the existing cooling system is particularly important.

Where Can Heat Be Recovered from Engine Cooling Water?

A marine engine's cooling-water system removes heat generated during combustion and the operation of mechanical components. Cooling-water circulation keeps the temperatures of the components it cools within the specified range. Depending on the engine design, different cooling-water circuits may be present, each with its own function and temperature control. In many marine engines, a high-temperature cooling circuit cools the cylinder walls, cylinder covers and other connected components. This is often called the HT circuit or jacket-water circuit. As the cooling water flows through the engine, it absorbs heat. Under suitable conditions, some of this heat can be recovered before the water is returned to the engine.

Where this heat can be extracted depends on the existing pipework layout. In some installations, a heat exchanger can be connected to a suitable branch of the HT circuit. Other arrangements have dedicated heat recovery connections or already supply equipment that uses recovered heat. In every case, the new connection must be compatible with the specified flow direction, temperature control and hydraulic characteristics of the engine installation.

An additional heat exchanger can transfer heat from engine cooling water to a separate water or thermal oil circuit. The engine cooling water remains separate from the medium transporting the heat to the consumer. In an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), the heat is ultimately transferred to an organic working fluid circulating in its own closed loop. Depending on the arrangement, this takes place through an intermediate circuit or directly through a heat exchanger designed for that purpose.

Low-temperature (LT) cooling circuits may also contain usable waste heat. Their temperature is usually lower than that of the HT circuit, which may limit the opportunities for heat transfer and electricity production. A low-temperature circuit may also absorb heat from various components, including charge-air and lubricating-oil coolers. To determine the available amount of heat correctly, it must be clear how these heat flows are already distributed across the existing cooling system.

A high cooling-water flow rate does not automatically mean that a large amount of heat can be safely extracted. The thermal power also depends on the temperature drop possible across the heat exchanger. If only a limited temperature reduction is permitted, the recoverable heat may be considerably less than would be expected from the total circulating water flow rate. Existing heat consumers must also be taken into account. A freshwater generator may, for example, already absorb heat from the HT circuit, while another connection supplies heating on board. Only the heat remaining after these existing demands have been met is available to the WHRS. The same energy flow must not be counted more than once as available heat.

The best connection point is therefore not automatically where the cooling water has its highest temperature. What matters is where sufficient heat can be transferred without disrupting the specified circulation through the engine, temperature control and existing heat supply.

How Does Heat Extraction Affect Engine Temperature Control?

The temperature of engine cooling water is determined by the heat released by the engine, water circulation and heat rejection through the coolers. In many installations, a thermostatic valve controls what proportion of the cooling water flows through a cooler and what proportion is routed through a bypass. This allows the engine to continue operating within the specified temperature range as its load changes. The temperature-control arrangement differs between engines. Some systems use the cooling-water temperature at the engine outlet for control, while others monitor the inlet temperature. The position of the thermostatic valve and the cooler connection may also differ. The same additional heat exchanger may therefore affect temperature control differently in two engine installations.

When a WHRS absorbs heat from the cooling water, the engine temperature does not necessarily fall. If the existing thermostatic control can compensate, the main effect of the additional heat extraction may be that less heat needs to be rejected through the original cooler. The control system then reduces cooling through that route while maintaining the required engine temperature. This situation changes if the WHRS extracts more heat than the existing control can compensate for. If the original cooler is already largely bypassed and the new heat exchanger continues to absorb heat, the cooling-water temperature may fall too low. The thermostatic control can then no longer adequately counteract the temperature drop by further reducing cooling through the original cooler.

An excessively low engine temperature cannot be assumed to be acceptable. The engine is designed to operate within a specified temperature range. Unwanted cooling may affect the thermal condition of engine components, lubrication and combustion conditions. The applicable temperature limits must therefore be derived from the engine manufacturer's data.

The location at which the WHRS extracts heat also affects the control response. A connection on the cooler side of a thermostatic control arrangement may receive less heat once the control system restricts flow through that cooler. At another connection, heat extraction may instead continue while the original control is already using very little cooling capacity. The effect on engine cooling therefore cannot be determined solely from the water temperature at one measurement point. The assessment must consider the relevant engine inlet and outlet temperatures together with the position and operation of the control valves. It must be clear how the original control responds when heat recovery is switched on, increased or reduced.

The WHRS control system must not counteract the engine's existing temperature control. If both control systems continually respond to the same temperature change, unwanted valve movements and temperature fluctuations may occur. Their control setpoints and response times must therefore be coordinated, to maintain the specified engine temperatures.

How Is a Heat Exchanger Connected Without Restricting Cooling-Water Circulation?

Alongside temperature control, the hydraulic operation of the cooling-water system must also be maintained. Under the relevant operating conditions, the cooling-water pumps must be able to circulate sufficient water through the engine and the other connected components. An additional heat exchanger must keep the flow and pressure needed for circulation within acceptable limits. Every heat exchanger creates flow resistance. The pressure loss depends on the internal flow area, flow rate, heat exchanger geometry and the resistance of the connected pipes and fittings. How the heat exchanger is incorporated into the existing circuit partly determines the consequences for circulation through the engine.

In a series connection, the cooling water flows through the existing components and the new heat exchanger in sequence. The additional pressure drop increases the circuit's resistance. The cooling-water pump's operating point may therefore shift, potentially reducing the flow it delivers. Whether this is acceptable depends on the available pump capacity and the minimum cooling-water circulation required by the engine.

With a parallel connection, some of the cooling water is routed through a separate branch. This may allow heat extraction to be controlled more independently, but the flow must then be distributed correctly among the branches. An unfavourable pressure difference may cause too much water to flow through the recovery system, while other components receive insufficient flow. The positions of isolation and control valves also affect this distribution. A valve used to reduce heat extraction may also change the hydraulic resistance of a branch. The consequences must be assessed together with the existing pumps, thermostatic arrangements and flow resistances. The assessment must cover valve positions during normal control and during faults.

A separate intermediate circuit can hydraulically isolate the equipment using the recovered heat from the engine cooling-water circuit. The receiving circuit then has its own circulation pump and controls, while heat is transferred through a heat exchanger. This allows heat extraction to be controlled without directly linking the receiving circuit's flow to engine cooling-water circulation. However, this separation does not automatically leave engine circulation unchanged. The heat exchanger still causes a pressure loss on the engine side. The chosen connection points and water flow through the original cooling-water circuit must also be suitable. An intermediate circuit therefore does not remove the need for a hydraulic assessment.

As well as adequate pump discharge pressure, the pressure at the pump inlet, venting and the operation of the expansion system are also important. New pipe routes may introduce high points or local pressure losses. Air accumulation or insufficient suction pressure may then disrupt circulation even when the calculated rated pump capacity appears sufficient. Particularly in a retrofit, existing pipe diameters, connection points and available space may limit the options. Even a thermally suitable heat exchanger may not be safely integrated if the additional flow resistance is too high or the original cooling-water distribution cannot be maintained reliably.

The hydraulic assessment must therefore go beyond the rated flow rate of the new heat exchanger. The engine's full cooling-water circulation must be maintained during normal heat extraction, partial recovery and WHRS shutdown.

What Role Do Thermostatic Valves and Bypass Provisions Play?

The engine's thermostatic control partly determines how much heat is available for recovery under different operating conditions. When the engine produces less heat, the existing control may limit heat rejection through the cooler. This may also reduce the scope for additional heat extraction. The WHRS must be able to respond to this change and reduce heat extraction when necessary. Engine temperature control remains the governing consideration. A higher energy output must not be achieved by changing the specified engine temperatures or the necessary cooling-water flow.

A controlled bypass can help limit the amount of heat flowing to the new heat exchanger. Depending on the connection, some of the cooling water may be routed around the heat exchanger when less heat extraction is needed. The bypass and associated valves must be arranged so that the necessary circulation through the engine is maintained. In other configurations, heat extraction can be controlled on the intermediate circuit side. The pump or control valve in this circuit then changes heat transfer without requiring the same change in engine cooling-water circulation. The appropriate approach depends on the heat exchanger, existing temperature control and hydraulic characteristics of the cooling system.

The position of the thermostatic valves remains important. If the WHRS control and the original engine control respond to similar temperature changes, the two may work against each other. Coordinating their control setpoints and response times can prevent repeated valve adjustments that fail to stabilize the temperature. During a rapid reduction in engine load, heat production may decrease while the heat exchanger continues to extract heat. The system must then be capable of reducing the additional heat extraction sufficiently. While a cold engine is warming up, it may instead be necessary to prevent recovery temporarily so that the engine can first reach its specified operating temperature.

At higher engine load, the need for heat rejection may increase. The original cooling arrangements must then be able to provide sufficient capacity to keep the engine temperature within the permitted limits. The WHRS can absorb some of this heat, but must not hinder the operation of the thermostatic control or the necessary heat rejection.

A bypass may therefore serve purposes beyond controlling WHRS output. Depending on the design, a bypass may also be necessary to maintain the correct flow path when recovery is unavailable. The valve positions and responses to faults needed for this must be established for each installation. There is no universal valve position that is automatically safe for every engine configuration. Ultimately, the control systems must work together to maintain the specified engine temperatures and water flows. The heat absorbed by the WHRS is adjusted to the available heat and the operation of the original engine cooling system.

How Does Engine Cooling Continue to Function if Heat Recovery Fails?

An important condition for waste heat recovery from engine cooling water is that the engine still receives sufficient cooling if the WHRS stops unexpectedly. Necessary heat rejection must not become dependent on an additional system intended for energy recovery. An exception is possible only where the complete cooling architecture has been specifically designed and approved for that purpose, with appropriate safety and backup arrangements.

During normal operation, the WHRS can take over some of the heat that would otherwise be rejected through the existing coolers. Those coolers may consequently need to absorb less heat, and the temperature control adapts to the changed distribution of cooling load. If heat recovery is lost, the engine continues to produce heat for as long as it runs. The heat no longer rejected through the WHRS must then be removed by the available cooling system. The original cooling or the alternative cooling designated for this purpose must therefore retain sufficient capacity to cool the engine at the relevant loads without the WHRS.

This capacity must also be sufficient under unfavourable cooling conditions. High seawater temperatures, a high load on the central cooling system or limited available cooling capacity may make heat rejection more difficult. The design must therefore establish whether the engine receives sufficient cooling under the specified design conditions when recovery is out of service.

Hydraulic operation requires the same attention. If a WHRS circulation pump, power supply or control device fails, the necessary water circulation through the engine must remain available without an uncontrolled interruption. The design must make clear which flow path remains available and how the valves concerned behave during a fault. A fault may also have consequences beyond the loss of heat transfer alone. A valve that closes off a necessary cooling-water path may directly restrict circulation. A leaking heat exchanger may also impair the original cooling function through loss of cooling water. The protection systems must therefore be matched to the possible faults in the actual installation.

Both the transition and the subsequent operation without the WHRS must be considered. If the additional heat extraction suddenly stops, the engine may continue producing heat while the original cooling arrangements have to reject more heat again. The cooler and temperature control must be able to respond quickly enough to keep the engine temperature within the permitted limits.

Engine cooling must also be maintained during maintenance. When a heat exchanger is isolated for inspection or cleaning, it must be clear how the necessary cooling-water circulation and heat rejection will continue to function. Isolation valves, bypass pipes and any drains must be positioned to maintain those functions. The design and backup provisions required depend on the engine configuration and the applicable requirements of the classification society and flag State. The same valve position or number of standby pumps therefore cannot be specified for every installation.

The complete cooling-water system must continue to support the specified engine functions under the relevant fault and maintenance conditions. A WHRS that recovers sufficient heat during normal operation is only properly integrated if the loss of that heat extraction can also be managed safely.

How Does the Available Cooling-Water Heat Change with Varying Engine Load?

The amount of heat rejected through engine cooling water changes with engine load and the operation of the cooling system. The thermal power available for recovery is therefore not constant throughout operation either. At higher engine load, the amount of heat that must be rejected through the cooling water usually increases. Under suitable conditions, the WHRS can absorb some of it. The specified engine temperatures and cooling-water circulation must be maintained, even if the original coolers need to reject less heat.

At part load, less heat may instead be available. The thermostatic control may already have partly reduced the original cooling. If the WHRS continues to absorb a large amount of heat under those conditions, the scope for further cooling may be limited. Cooling-water temperature does not necessarily change in the same proportion as the engine's heat release. In an engine whose control maintains a relatively constant cooling-water outlet temperature, the amount of heat rejected through cooling may change without a comparable change in water temperature. Engine load, water flow rate and actual heat extraction must therefore be assessed together.

Conditions differ again while the engine is warming up. The engine must first reach the required operating temperature. Additional heat extraction may prolong warm-up and must therefore be compatible with the specified warm-up procedure. In certain operating modes, the WHRS may need to stay off temporarily.

In an installation with several engines, the heat supply also changes with the engines in service. An engine that is shut down provides no continuous heat from combustion, while a more heavily loaded engine may release more heat. If several engines are connected to a common cooling circuit, heat distribution and temperature control must remain suitable for each engine concerned as engines are brought into or taken out of service. Existing heat consumers may also affect how much waste heat is available. Some of the cooling-water heat may already be used for heating, hot-water supply or freshwater production. The amount remaining for an additional WHRS then depends in part on the heat already used by these applications.

Annual recovery therefore depends on more than the maximum available thermal power. The actual energy output also depends on the number of hours during which the engine supplies sufficient heat and the WHRS can safely absorb it. A system that recovers a large amount of heat at high engine load may receive considerably less usable heat during prolonged part-load operation. A reliable assessment must therefore be based on heat release and cooling-water conditions at the engine loads encountered in service. This keeps the expected output tied to the conditions under which engine cooling must actually function.

Why Must Heat Extraction from Engine Cooling Water Be Distinguished from Condenser Cooling?

In an ORC-based waste heat recovery system, engine cooling water can be used as a heat source. The heat is then supplied to the hot side of the thermodynamic process. Some of it is converted into mechanical power and then electricity. After expansion, the remaining heat must be rejected through the condenser. This requires a sufficiently cool heat sink, such as a suitable low-temperature cooling circuit or a separate connection to the seawater cooling system.

These two functions occur at different points in the ORC process. Heat extraction from engine cooling water concerns the heat supplied by the engine to the ORC. The condenser, by contrast, rejects the heat remaining in the ORC process after electricity production. This distinction is particularly important when both sides of the ORC are connected to the ship's existing cooling-water systems. Heat extraction from a high-temperature cooling circuit may reduce the load on the original engine cooler. At the same time, the ORC condenser may release heat to a low-temperature cooling circuit.

The change in total heat load depends on the original heat rejection and the chosen connections. If some engine heat was previously rejected through an existing cooler and, after ORC installation, passes through the condenser to the same central cooling system, the full condenser heat load does not automatically count as additional load for the ship. However, this does not mean that every individual pipe branch or cooler has sufficient capacity for the changed heat flows. The point at which the condenser rejects heat to the cooling system, the available water flow and the cooling-water temperature also remain decisive for feasibility.

The cold side must also provide a low enough temperature for effective ORC operation. A high-temperature circuit supplying heat to the ORC cannot simultaneously be regarded as a suitable cold side for the same cycle without further assessment. The available temperature difference partly determines how much electricity can be produced. The assessment therefore starts with the amount of heat that can be safely extracted from engine cooling water. The suitability of the cooling arrangements for the ORC condenser must then be assessed separately, including the effects on the other cooling-water consumers.

What Data Demonstrate That the Original Engine Cooling Is Maintained?

A sound technical assessment starts with the existing cooling-water configuration and the engine manufacturer's requirements. The available drawings must show which HT and LT circuits are present, how the pumps and coolers are connected and which temperature control applies to the engine concerned. The specified cooling-water temperatures, minimum or rated flow rates and relevant pressure conditions are particularly important. The assessment must also establish how the thermostatic valves, bypass arrangements and other connected equipment operate. It must also be clear whether engine control is based on cooling-water temperature at the inlet or outlet.

The connection point for the new heat exchanger is then established. For a series connection or parallel branch, the change to the complete hydraulic configuration must be assessed. Pump characteristics and pressure losses are at least as important for this as the heat exchanger's rated flow rate. On an existing ship, the drawings must also match the equipment actually installed. Previous modifications to pumps, pipes, thermostatic valves or coolers may have changed the original design assumptions. The assessment must therefore be based on the current cooling-system arrangement.

The heat balance requires temperatures and flow rates on both sides of the new heat exchanger. These allow the thermal power actually transferred to be calculated. The temperatures and water flows used must relate to the same operating conditions. Heat extraction is then compared with the original operation of the cooling system. Relevant factors include the temperatures at the engine, the setting of the thermostatic control and the amount of heat still rejected through the existing coolers.

For example, the WHRS may absorb a substantial amount of heat while the engine temperature remains virtually unchanged. If the original control system consequently reduces heat rejection through the cooler, this may be consistent with normal interaction between the two systems. At lower engine load, however, the same heat extraction may become excessive. The engine then produces less heat, while the original cooling may already have been reduced considerably. Further heat extraction may lead to unwanted cooling under those conditions. The assessment must therefore cover different relevant engine loads and must not be based solely on rated load.

The cooling capacity without the WHRS must also be known. In the event of failure, the original or alternative cooling arrangements must be able to reject sufficient heat under the specified design conditions. Relevant factors include seawater temperature, the load from other cooling-water consumers and available pump capacity. It must also be established how the system responds if heat extraction, circulation or control fails. The necessary cooling-water flow must not then be blocked. The protection functions and valve positions required depend on the installation design selected.

If the existing installation data are insufficiently reliable, targeted measurements may be necessary. Temperatures, flow rates and pressures must then be established at suitable measurement points and under sufficiently representative operating conditions. The actual cooling-water installation can thus be compared with the available design data. During commissioning, engine and cooling-water temperatures, pressure differences, water flows and the control response can be checked. The checks must also establish whether the cooling system continues to function as designed when heat recovery is reduced or switched off. The nature and extent of these tests are matched to the engine, the installation and the applicable approval conditions.

A favourable heat transfer measurement does not in itself prove that the original engine cooling is sufficiently protected. Hydraulic operation, temperature control, available backup cooling and the necessary responses to faults must also be shown to meet the requirements.

How Can a Waste Heat Recovery System Use Cooling-Water Heat Safely?

A waste heat recovery system can use cooling-water heat without disrupting engine cooling by controlling heat extraction so that the engine stays within its specified temperature range, the required water circulation continues and the original cooling system remains effective. The heat exchanger must be connected at a point where sufficient heat is available without unacceptably changing the hydraulic distribution or temperature control. The control system must be able to reduce heat extraction if the engine produces less heat, the water temperature falls too far or operating conditions change.

Sufficient cooling must also remain available when the WHRS is switched off or fails unexpectedly. The existing or designated alternative cooling equipment, together with the pumps and control or bypass arrangements, must continue to support the necessary engine functions under those conditions. The recovery system can thus take over some of the original heat rejection, but must not cause an uncontrolled change in engine temperature or cooling-water flow. The technical assessment must therefore establish not only the thermal power recovered, but also how the complete cooling-water installation functions at normal load, at part load, during warm-up and if recovery fails.

When these conditions are met, available cooling-water heat can be used for heating or electricity production without disrupting the original engine cooling. Engine function remains the priority, and only the proportion of heat that can be safely recovered during actual ship operation is used.

This Article in the Series

Whereas back pressure and exhaust gas temperature limit recovery from exhaust gases, the use of engine cooling water centres on preserving circulation through the engine and temperature control. A separate design question is when the existing cooling system needs to be modified for a WHRS condenser. This condenser rejects process heat, whereas the connection discussed here extracts heat from the engine circuit. Both functions come together in the system selection and integration of a WHRS.