How Do Back Pressure and Exhaust Gas Temperature Limit Exhaust Gas Heat Recovery?
Author: Jeroen Berger • Publication date:
Exhaust gas heat recovery is limited by the marine engine's maximum permissible exhaust back pressure and by how far the exhaust gases can be cooled without exceeding the applicable technical limits. A heat exchanger extracts heat from the exhaust gas stream but also creates additional flow resistance. This may increase the pressure at the turbocharger turbine outlet, with possible effects on engine performance and fuel consumption. Further cooling may make more heat available, but may also cause condensation or corrosion, or leave the gases too cool for existing exhaust gas aftertreatment equipment.
Both limits must be assessed for the complete exhaust gas system, including existing pipes, silencers, heat exchangers and any aftertreatment equipment. Exhaust gas conditions and pressure losses also change with engine load and the condition of the installation. A heat exchanger that recovers sufficient heat at rated load therefore does not necessarily offer the same recovery potential in every operating mode.
The aim of exhaust gas heat recovery is therefore not to extract as much heat as possible from the exhaust gases, but to establish how much heat can actually be used while respecting the engine's operating limits and permissible exhaust gas temperatures. The effects on engine operation and the recovery system's own energy consumption must also be taken into account. Only then can the net energy saving for the ship be established.
Why Does Exhaust Back Pressure Limit Exhaust Gas Heat Recovery?
In many marine engines, the exhaust gases leave the turbocharger and then flow through pipes and other equipment towards the funnel. Pressure losses along the exhaust path arise from friction, bends, changes in cross-section and the resistance of individual components. An additional heat exchanger in the exhaust gas path increases the system's flow resistance. In an exhaust gas heat exchanger, the gas flows past heat transfer surfaces. These may consist of tubes and, depending on the design, additional surfaces that increase heat transfer. Their arrangement and geometry determine how much flow area remains for the gas and how it is routed through the heat exchanger. The inlet and outlet connections also cause pressure losses.
In a turbocharged engine, the pressure at the turbine outlet is particularly important. If this pressure rises under otherwise comparable conditions, the available pressure difference across the turbine may decrease. This may affect turbine power and the turbocharger's operating point. Depending on the engine design and control, this may affect the air supply, operating temperatures and fuel consumption. The extent of the engine's response cannot be deduced directly from the additional pressure drop across the heat exchanger. An engine with one turbocharger configuration may respond differently from an engine with another arrangement. The intake resistance of the air supply system may also play a role in this assessment. The engine manufacturer's specifications therefore define the pressure limits within which the engine may operate.
Nor does a higher pressure loss mean that fuel consumption increases in the same proportion. The relationship depends on engine load and the response of the engine and turbocharger to the changed pressure conditions. Additional back pressure can, however, adversely affect energy performance even while the engine remains within its permitted operating limits. This is important for a waste heat recovery system (WHRS). The heat exchanger may make thermal power available for heating or electricity production, while the additional flow resistance offsets part of the energy savings. The net contribution of the WHRS therefore does not depend solely on the amount of heat extracted from the exhaust gases.
Extracting more heat does not necessarily cause a greater pressure drop. This depends on how the additional heat transfer is achieved. If more heat transfer surface is fitted within the same flow area, resistance may increase. A different heat exchanger geometry or a larger available flow area may instead allow more heat to be transferred without a comparable increase in pressure loss. There is therefore no fixed relationship between heat output and pressure loss that applies to every heat exchanger. For each proposed design, the resulting flow resistance must be established and the complete exhaust gas system checked against the engine's permitted operating limits.
How Much Additional Pressure Loss May an Exhaust Gas Heat Exchanger Cause?
An engine's maximum permissible exhaust back pressure is not the same as the pressure loss that a new heat exchanger may cause. The existing exhaust gas system already presents resistance to the gas flow. Only the remaining margin below the applicable engine limit may be available for additional components. On an existing ship, exhaust gas pipes, bends, expansion joints, silencers, exhaust gas boilers and aftertreatment equipment may all contribute to back pressure. A new heat exchanger must therefore be assessed as part of the full exhaust gas path for that engine.
The pressure measurement location must be clearly defined. The pressure loss across a heat exchanger is the pressure difference between that component's inlet and outlet. Total exhaust back pressure, by contrast, is assessed at the measurement or reference point specified for the engine configuration, for example in a suitable straight section of pipe after the turbocharger. The location also matters when taking measurements. If static pressure is measured too close to a bend, a change in cross-section or another component that disturbs the flow, the result may not be sufficiently representative. The measurement points must therefore comply with the engine manufacturer's requirements and suit the actual pipework layout.
A heat exchanger with a low pressure drop across the unit may still be unsuitable if the existing exhaust gas system already uses most of the available back-pressure margin. For an initial assessment, the pressure losses of individual components can be combined. However, the final calculation must take account of the gas conditions and changes in flow throughout the complete exhaust gas path. The operating conditions for which pressure losses are specified also make a difference. Pressure loss depends in part on the exhaust gas mass flow rate, gas density, temperature and flow geometry. A pressure drop established at low engine load therefore cannot be used for a higher load without further calculation.
Supplier data must also make clear which components are included in the stated pressure drop. A value for the heat transfer section alone is not necessarily equal to the pressure loss of the complete heat exchanger unit. Connections, valves and other internal restrictions may add to the pressure drop. In a newbuild, the exhaust gas system can be designed to suit the intended heat recovery from the outset. Pipe diameters, components and available space can then be assessed together. In a retrofit, much of the exhaust gas configuration is already fixed. Both the available installation space and the remaining permissible back-pressure margin may therefore limit the options for an additional heat exchanger.
Sometimes pressure loss can be reduced by changing the pipe route, increasing the flow area or selecting a different heat exchanger geometry. The effects of such modifications must be recalculated for the complete installation. A change to an individual component may also affect the flow conditions at other components.
The condition of the system in service must also be considered alongside its original design. Soot, ash and other deposits may reduce a heat exchanger's unobstructed flow area. Pressure loss may therefore increase during use. A heat exchanger that leaves sufficient back-pressure margin only when clean may cause the system to exceed the limit once fouled. Expected fouling and the maintenance strategy must therefore be included in the assessment from the outset. The design must make clear when cleaning is necessary and how an unacceptable rise in exhaust back pressure is prevented.
There is no general percentage of the permissible exhaust back pressure that can be reserved for an additional heat exchanger on every marine engine. The available margin depends on the applicable manufacturer's limit, the existing installation and the pressure losses under the relevant operating conditions. If that margin is insufficient, the exhaust gas path may need to be modified or the intended heat recovery must be limited.
Why Does Exhaust Gas Temperature Limit the Amount of Recoverable Heat?
Together with the mass flow rate and thermal properties of the gas, the exhaust gas temperature determines how much heat can be transferred. Under otherwise comparable conditions, more heat can be recovered if the exhaust gases are cooled further. However, there are technical limits to how far the temperature may fall. A high heat exchanger inlet temperature does not mean that the gases can be cooled to ambient temperature and all the resulting heat recovered. After heat transfer, the exhaust gases must still meet the requirements that apply to the materials used, the downstream exhaust gas path and any other systems.
Heat transfer also requires a temperature difference. When exhaust gas heat is transferred to a water or thermal oil circuit, there must be a sufficient difference between the gas temperature and the temperature of the receiving medium. As the exhaust gases cool further, that temperature difference may decrease. More heat transfer area may then be needed to transfer the same thermal power. The additional heat theoretically made available by further cooling therefore cannot automatically be absorbed in full by an existing or proposed heat exchanger. How much heat can actually be transferred depends on the temperatures of both media, the flow direction and the properties of the heat exchanger.
This distinction is particularly relevant when the recovered heat is supplied to an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) or a steam-based system. A thermodynamic cycle requires suitable operating temperatures. Heat made available by further exhaust gas cooling is not necessarily at a high enough temperature to make the same contribution to electricity production. Significant temperature differences may also arise within the heat exchanger itself. The exhaust gases cool as they flow through it, while the receiving medium is heated. The local temperatures depend on the heat exchanger arrangement and the distribution of heat transfer.
The temperature of the metal heat transfer surfaces requires particular attention. These surfaces may be considerably colder than the exhaust gases flowing past them. Condensation can therefore occur on parts of the surface even while the average gas temperature remains relatively high. The minimum acceptable exhaust gas temperature therefore cannot be deduced solely from a temperature measurement at the heat exchanger outlet. The actual temperature distribution, the temperature of the receiving medium and the properties of the exhaust gas must also be assessed.
How Do Condensation and Corrosion Limit Permissible Exhaust Gas Cooling?
Exhaust gases contain water vapour and various other constituents, depending on the fuel used and the combustion process. If the temperature falls sufficiently, certain substances may condense on the surfaces of heat exchangers and exhaust gas pipes. If these condensates are corrosive, further heat extraction may adversely affect the installation's service life. With sulphur-containing fuels, the possible formation and condensation of sulphuric acid are particularly relevant. During combustion, sulphur in the fuel forms mainly sulphur dioxide (SO2). Some of it may be converted to sulphur trioxide (SO₃), which can react with water vapour to form sulphuric acid (H2SO4). Under suitable temperature and concentration conditions, this sulphuric acid may then condense on colder surfaces.
The relevant acid dew point depends in part on the exhaust gas composition, the concentrations of sulphuric acid and water vapour, and the pressure conditions. There is therefore no universal minimum gas temperature that provides the same protection against corrosion for every fuel and engine installation. The local surface temperature is a key factor in whether condensation occurs. The exhaust gases may leave the heat exchanger at an average temperature that appears acceptable in itself, while certain metal surfaces have already cooled sufficiently to allow acid condensation.
This may happen, for example, where the relatively cold fluid enters the heat exchanger. The temperature of the water or thermal oil influences the temperature of the metal between the two streams at that location. The temperature distribution within the heat exchanger depends in part on the flow direction, geometry and local heat transfer. A design based solely on a minimum exhaust gas temperature at the outlet therefore does not automatically provide sufficient protection against condensation on the heat transfer surfaces. The assessment must also consider further cooling downstream in pipes, silencers or other components.
The materials used play an important role. Not every material is suitable for prolonged exposure to acidic condensates or other corrosive exhaust gas constituents. Depending on the application, material selection, surface protection, drainage and condensate management may determine technical feasibility. With fuels containing less sulphur, the risk of sulphuric acid condensation may decrease. However, this does not eliminate all potential condensation problems. Water vapour and other constituents remain present. The corrosion risks that actually arise depend on the composition of the exhaust gases and the temperatures of the surfaces involved.
Condensation does not, however, have to be avoided under all conditions. Some heat exchangers are specifically designed to recover heat under condensing conditions. Such arrangements require suitable materials, appropriate condensate drainage and treatment, and sufficient protection for downstream components. A conventional non-condensing exhaust gas heat exchanger cannot simply operate under the same conditions. If the existing installation was not designed for wet or corrosive operating conditions, further cooling may require substantial technical modifications.
How far the exhaust gases may be cooled ultimately depends on the actual condensation and corrosion risks throughout the complete installation. This requires an assessment of the properties of the fuel and exhaust gases, the expected metal temperatures and the suitability of the materials used.
How Do Exhaust Gas Aftertreatment and Fuel Choice Affect Temperature Limits?
Alongside condensation and corrosion, existing exhaust gas aftertreatment systems may determine how far the exhaust gases may be cooled. These systems have their own temperature and flow requirements. The available heat therefore cannot be assessed independently of the rest of the exhaust gas path. For selective catalytic reduction (SCR), the exhaust gas temperature at the catalyst is important. The catalytic reduction of nitrogen oxides (NOx) takes place within a suitable temperature range. If a heat exchanger upstream of an SCR system cools the exhaust gases too far, aftertreatment performance may deteriorate.
Depending on the design, requirements also apply to reductant dosing, nitrogen oxide conversion and the prevention of unwanted deposits. Deposits in the aftertreatment system may be a concern, particularly with certain combinations of sulphur-containing exhaust gases, ammonia and lower temperatures. The heat exchanger location therefore helps determine how much heat can be recovered. In certain low-pressure SCR configurations, it may be preferable or necessary to recover exhaust gas heat only after the catalyst. The heat exchanger then receives exhaust gases whose temperature and flow conditions are partly determined by the preceding equipment.
This is not, however, a universal rule for positioning the heat exchanger. Different SCR configurations exist, including arrangements in which the catalyst is installed on the high-pressure side of the turbocharger. The correct sequence of components must therefore be determined from the actual engine and aftertreatment configuration. Temperature requirements may also apply to a diesel particulate filter. Particle filtration and any filter regeneration impose requirements on operating conditions. If a heat exchanger adversely affects the exhaust gas temperature, this may affect regeneration or the conditions under which the filter functions reliably.
An exhaust gas scrubber has different characteristics. A wet scrubber may cool the exhaust gases considerably and increase their moisture content. Conditions downstream may therefore differ substantially from those in the original hot exhaust gas stream. For an additional heat exchanger, it must then be assessed whether the remaining temperature, gas moisture content and the possible presence of liquid droplets are compatible with the selected design.
An SCR catalyst, a particulate filter and a scrubber perform different functions and each imposes different requirements on the exhaust gas. These systems therefore cannot be assessed using the same general temperature correction. The flow resistance of all the components involved also must also be included when checking against the exhaust back pressure limit.
Fuel choice may change the conditions further. A different fuel may affect the sulphur content, amount of water vapour, the composition of the combustion products and formation of deposits. The exhaust gas flow rate and temperature may also change at the same engine load. If the ship is to use a different fuel in future, the assessment must check whether the existing heat recovery system will remain suitable. This may affect the heat exchanger, control system, materials used and expected energy output.
The amount of heat that may ultimately be extracted from the exhaust gases therefore depends in part on the temperature requirements of the complete exhaust gas system. The heat exchanger must continue to function properly, and the other components must also continue to perform their required functions under all relevant operating conditions.
Why Do Pressure and Temperature Limits Change with Varying Engine Load?
The exhaust gas flow rate and temperature change with engine load. This changes both the available heat supply and the flow resistance of the exhaust gas system. A heat exchanger that operates within the permitted limits at a particular operating point does not necessarily offer the same opportunities for heat recovery at all other loads. At higher engine load, the exhaust gas mass flow rate usually increases. The pressure drop across the heat exchanger, pipes and other components may therefore also increase. The remaining margin below the exhaust back pressure limit may then become an important constraint.
At lower engine load, the available temperature may instead become decisive. If the exhaust gases reach the heat exchanger at a lower temperature, the amount of heat that can be extracted without cooling the exhaust gases beyond the permitted limit may decrease. This pattern is not the same for every engine. Exhaust gas temperature depends in part on the engine design, turbocharger configuration, the control system and operating conditions. In some engines, exhaust gas temperature does not change uniformly across the load range. The actual temperature and flow data for the engine concerned must therefore be used.
The governing technical limit may therefore change with engine load. At a high exhaust gas flow rate, flow resistance may limit further heat extraction, while under certain part-load conditions further cooling is not technically acceptable. The applicable constraint must be established for each relevant operating point. Moreover, the highest exhaust gas temperature, greatest mass flow rate and largest pressure drop do not necessarily occur at the same engine operating point. Combining separate extremes from different operating modes may therefore provide an incorrect basis for the heat exchanger design.
Additional considerations arise during engine start-up and shutdown. The temperature of the exhaust gases may change faster than that of the heat exchanger and the connected fluid circuits. Heat transfer may therefore temporarily differ from that during steady engine operation. The WHRS control system must be able to respond to such changes. If the exhaust gas temperature is too low or the receiving system stops drawing heat, heat extraction may need to be limited or stopped. Rapid changes must also be prevented from causing unacceptable temperatures or pressures on the receiving side.
With several engines, the assessment must reflect how the engines are actually used. Engines running at different loads may have different exhaust gas conditions. If shared exhaust gas equipment is used, how the flow and back pressure vary across the exhaust paths of the individual engines must also be established. Usable heat output therefore depends not only on engine conditions, but also on the operating hours during which the heat exchanger can function within the required limits. High thermal power at rated load has limited value if the ship mainly operates under other conditions. The suitability of exhaust gas heat recovery must therefore be assessed across the relevant operating range, using the pressure and temperature conditions occurring during actual operation.
How Do Heat Exchanger Design, Fouling and Bypass Provisions Affect Both Limits?
An exhaust gas heat exchanger must transfer sufficient heat without exceeding the permitted flow resistance or cooling the exhaust gases beyond the permitted limit. Its geometry partly determines the relationship between these characteristics. The heat transfer area, gas velocity, unobstructed flow area and arrangement of the flow passages affect both heat transfer and pressure drop. A design with a large heat transfer area may perform well thermally but also cause greater flow resistance if its gas passages are poorly arranged.
A larger flow area can help limit pressure loss. At the same time, it changes gas velocity, which affects heat transfer and susceptibility to fouling. The most suitable geometry therefore follows from a combined assessment of heat transfer, pressure loss and maintainability. The temperature distribution within the heat exchanger also requires attention. The flow directions of the exhaust gas and receiving medium influence where the smallest temperature differences occur and which surfaces cool the most. An arrangement with an acceptable average exhaust gas temperature may therefore still leave some metal surfaces at unfavourable temperatures. The design must adequately control both total heat transfer and local thermal conditions.
During operation, deposits may change the performance of the heat exchanger. Soot, ash and other fouling on the gas side may reduce heat transfer while restricting the available flow passages. The pressure drop may therefore increase while less heat is transferred to the receiving medium. This may produce an unfavourable combination: the engine may experience greater exhaust back pressure while the recovery system receives less thermal power. Heat transfer and pressure drop must therefore be assessed for the expected conditions in service as well as for the clean unit.
In certain exhaust gas boilers, soot accumulation also poses a safety risk. If sufficient combustible deposits are present and the temperature and oxygen supply favour ignition, a soot fire may occur. The combination of deposits, high local temperatures and the design of the heat transfer surfaces requires particular attention. The necessary cleaning equipment and protection systems must suit the heat exchanger type concerned. How quickly fouling develops depends in part on the fuel, combustion conditions, heat exchanger geometry and operating duration. The maintenance strategy must therefore match the expected deposits and the options for inspecting and cleaning the gas side.
Measurements during operation can help identify deterioration early. An increasing pressure drop under comparable exhaust gas conditions may be a reason to investigate fouling. If heat transfer decreases at the same time, this may provide further evidence of fouling. Such changes must, however, be assessed at comparable engine loads, gas flow rates and temperatures. A bypass can be used to route all or part of the exhaust gas stream around the heat exchanger. Heat extraction can then be reduced or interrupted if heat demand ceases, the recovery system has to be taken out of service or other conditions require it.
The bypass itself must also be compatible with the engine and the permissible exhaust back pressure. Pipes, valves and connections also create flow resistance. A large difference between the pressure losses of the normal route and the bypass may also affect the turbocharger's operating point. A lower pressure drop during bypass operation is therefore not necessarily beneficial and requires further assessment. For the different valve positions, it must be clear how the exhaust gas flow is distributed, what pressure losses arise and how the engine responds. The design must also prevent valve positions that would restrict exhaust gas discharge beyond permissible limits.
The control system must also respond to changes on the receiving side of the heat exchanger. If a circulation pump stops or the receiving system suddenly stops taking up heat, the heat transfer surfaces and fluids in the system may continue to absorb heat. Depending on the heat exchanger type and connected fluid circuits, this may cause temperature or pressure problems. The protection systems must therefore be suitable for the relevant operating and fault conditions. Ultimately, a heat exchanger must be assessed as part of the complete exhaust gas system. What matters is not only its thermal performance when clean, but also its behaviour when fouled, during changes in engine load, at reduced output, in bypass operation and at shutdown.
How Do You Establish How Much Exhaust Gas Heat Can Be Recovered Within Acceptable Technical Limits?
A sound assessment starts with the exhaust gas data and permitted operating limits of the engine concerned. The exhaust gas mass flow rate and temperature must be known at the loads for which heat recovery is being investigated. The fuel used, turbocharger design and engine control are also important. The specified exhaust back pressure limit and corresponding measurement or reference point must also be known. Without these data, the additional flow resistance that the exhaust gas system may accommodate cannot be established reliably.
On an existing ship, the actual exhaust gas arrangement must then be established. The existing pipes, silencers, heat exchangers, aftertreatment equipment and any previous modifications determine which pressure losses and temperature requirements already apply. Measurements of the existing exhaust back pressure can help assess the remaining margin within the engine limit. It must be clear at which engine load the measurements were taken, where the measurement point is located and whether the system's condition is representative of its state in normal service.
The pressure loss of the new heat exchanger is then determined under the relevant exhaust gas conditions. The stated data must make clear which components are included and how pressure loss changes at other flow rates and with fouling. The additional flow resistance can thus be assessed together with the existing exhaust gas system. On the thermal side, how far the exhaust gases can be cooled without exceeding the applicable technical limits must be established. The fuel, exhaust gas composition, heat exchanger materials and any exhaust gas aftertreatment requirements are taken into account. The temperatures arising within the heat exchanger must also be investigated.
The average exhaust gas temperature at the outlet provides only part of the information needed. To assess condensation and corrosion risks, the local metal temperatures and the temperature of the receiving medium must also be known with sufficient accuracy. Once the permissible pressure losses and temperature limits have been established, the amount of heat that can be extracted from the exhaust gas under the relevant operating conditions can be calculated. This requires the gas mass flow rate and thermal properties, as well as the heat transfer actually possible with the selected heat exchanger and receiving medium. The calculation must be based on exhaust gas conditions occurring at the same engine load.
The result may differ at each operating point. At high load, sufficient heat may be available while pressure drop limits further increases in recovery. In other operating modes, the allowable drop in exhaust gas temperature may instead determine how much heat can still be extracted. It must then be clear how much of the recovered heat can actually be used. An exhaust gas heat exchanger supplies thermal power, but this is not equal to the electrical power that a steam turbine or ORC system may be able to generate.
For electricity production, the net contribution depends in part on thermodynamic conversion, the available cooling and the system's own auxiliary consumption. For direct heat use, what matters most is how much existing heat production is actually displaced. In both cases, the effect of the additional exhaust back pressure on engine operation must also be taken into account. If heat recovery adversely affects fuel consumption, that effect must be included in the calculation of net energy savings.
A heat exchanger that recovers more thermal power may therefore produce a less favourable overall result than a design with lower flow resistance or more limited exhaust gas cooling. Maximum heat extraction therefore does not necessarily mean that the best design has been chosen in technical or energy terms. For the final assessment, the heat output and effects on engine operation must relate to the same operating conditions. Operating hours, the expected condition of the equipment in service and the periods during which sufficient heat can be consumed must also be taken into account.
The result must make clear how much heat can be extracted without exceeding the applicable technical limits at the relevant engine loads, which technical limits the heat exchanger must observe and how much useful energy actually remains under those conditions.
Where Is the Technical Limit for Exhaust Gas Heat Recovery?
Back pressure and exhaust gas temperature limit exhaust gas heat recovery in different ways. Exhaust back pressure determines how much additional flow resistance a heat exchanger may cause without the complete exhaust gas system exceeding the permitted engine limits. Exhaust gas temperature determines how far the gases can be cooled without exceeding the applicable technical limits, taking account of condensation, corrosion and the temperature requirements of any aftertreatment equipment. Both limits must be assessed for the engine, fuel and exhaust gas configuration concerned. A single allowable pressure drop or minimum exhaust gas temperature therefore cannot simply be applied to different marine engines.
Which constraint is decisive depends in part on engine load and the technical condition of the heat exchanger. At a high exhaust gas flow rate, the remaining margin within the permissible back pressure may be limited. Under certain part-load conditions, the available gas temperature may instead be too low for further heat extraction. Recovering the maximum technically feasible amount of heat does not necessarily produce the greatest net energy savings. Additional exhaust back pressure, auxiliary consumption and limits on the connected heat or electricity production may reduce the benefit.
The technical limit is therefore the amount of heat that can be extracted under the relevant operating conditions without exceeding the permitted pressure and temperature limits. Within those limits, the selected WHRS must deliver as much useful energy as possible without adversely affecting engine performance, exhaust gas aftertreatment or the ship's operational reliability.
This Article in the Series
For exhaust gas heat, back pressure and how far the gases may be cooled determine how much heat can be recovered within acceptable technical limits. These limits must be assessed at the relevant engine loads, and the effect of multiple engines on the available heat supply is also important. Different requirements apply to the use of cooling-water heat without disrupting engine cooling, particularly concerning temperature control and circulation. Both heat sources require their own assessment within the system selection and integration of a WHRS.