Company logo of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable maritime innovation and solutions.
Small logo version of Berger Maritiem featuring a green leaf, symbolizing global sustainable innovation and solutions in the maritime sector.
Illustration of a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) with a control panel and pipework in a ship's engine room.

How Does the Use of Multiple Engines Affect the Waste Heat Available to a WHRS?

The amount of waste heat that a waste heat recovery system (WHRS) can use on board depends heavily on which engines are in service and how they are loaded. What matters is not only the installed engine power, but above all which engines actually run, how heavily they are loaded and how long these conditions last. This affects both the amount of heat available and the temperatures of the individual heat streams.

The same electrical power demand can, for example, be met by two generating sets at part load or by one more heavily loaded set. Although the electrical power supplied is the same, the exhaust gas temperatures, gas flow rates and heat carried by the cooling water may differ. Moreover, electricity production by the WHRS may reduce the load on the very generating sets that supply the recovered heat. The heat available to sustain WHRS electricity production may therefore also change.

A reliable assessment therefore requires the load and heat rejected by each engine to be matched to the combinations of engines running simultaneously and their corresponding operating hours. The options for recovering heat jointly from several engines and the technical limits of the systems involved also play a role. This provides a basis for establishing how much waste heat remains available during actual operation and what proportion the WHRS can use.

Why Does the Available Waste Heat Change with a Different Combination of Engines?

An internal combustion engine converts only part of the fuel energy supplied into mechanical power. Some of the remaining energy is rejected as heat through several routes, including the exhaust gases, engine cooling water and other cooling streams. How much heat is released through each stream depends on the engine design and the conditions under which the engine operates.

On a ship with several engines, the same power demand can be met in different ways. Two generating sets may, for example, share a particular electrical load, while under a different operating strategy one generating set supplies that same power. The total electrical power supplied then remains the same, but the load on the individual engines changes. An engine's efficiency and heat rejection depend on its operating point. At a different load, the fuel energy input, exhaust gas conditions and heat transfer to the cooling circuits change. The balance between mechanical output and heat rejected through the exhaust gases and cooling water may therefore also change. When engine loads are determined from electrical power demand, generator efficiency also plays a role.

The characteristics of the individual engines also make a difference. Different engine types or designs may have different heat losses at the same power output. Even engines with similar rated power do not necessarily have the same heat rejection characteristics at part load. The available waste heat must therefore be established for each engine and relevant operating point. Running more engines does not automatically mean that the WHRS receives more usable heat. When the same power demand is distributed across more engines, the load per engine usually decreases. This may affect both the amount of heat and the available temperature. Under certain conditions, fewer, more heavily loaded engines may provide more favourable conditions for heat recovery, but the outcome may differ with another engine configuration.

A combination of engines that produces more waste heat is not necessarily more favourable for the ship's total energy consumption. If more fuel is needed for the same useful power output, more recoverable heat may indeed be produced, but that extra heat is not automatically an advantage. Any additional WHRS output must therefore be weighed against the higher fuel consumption of the engine installation. The choice of which engines to run cannot be based solely on heat availability. A generating set may, for example, remain in service because of the required power reserve, while another engine is temporarily taken out of service. The required operational reliability, permitted engine load and capabilities of the power management system determine which combinations of engines can actually be used.

How Does Load Distribution Affect Heat Recovery from Exhaust Gases and Cooling Water?

Redistributing engine load changes not only the total amount of waste heat, but also the characteristics of the individual heat streams. Exhaust gases and engine cooling water must be considered separately, because their temperatures and responses to load changes differ. For exhaust gas heat, gas temperature and mass flow rate are particularly important. Together with the permitted exhaust gas temperature drop and the gas's thermal properties, they determine how much heat can be extracted. A high exhaust gas temperature does not automatically mean that substantial thermal power is available. If the gas flow rate is low, the usable heat flow may remain limited.

When the engine load changes, both the exhaust gas temperature and mass flow rate may change, but not necessarily in the same proportion. For a given engine, a higher load may increase exhaust gas flow while the temperature follows a different pattern. The design of the air and combustion system, turbocharger control and the fuel used may affect this. To calculate the recoverable heat reliably, the temperature and flow rate must therefore relate to the same engine operating point.

When several engines run simultaneously, their exhaust gas streams may together provide sufficient thermal power, while gas temperatures differ between engines. This is particularly important when each engine has its own heat exchanger transferring heat to a common circuit. Adding together the thermal power outputs of the individual engines does not yet show the temperature at which the heat ultimately becomes available to the WHRS. Heat release through engine cooling water follows a different pattern. The amount of heat rejected is related to heat transfer from the engine and the operation of temperature control. Together, the cooling-water flow rate and the temperature change of the cooling water across the relevant heat transfer step indicate the thermal power rejected. The available amount of heat may therefore change even when temperature control maintains a relatively constant cooling-water temperature.

A distinction must also be made between the different cooling circuits. Heat from a high-temperature circuit may be more suitable for certain applications than heat from a low-temperature circuit. For electricity production, the usable temperature difference between the heat source and the cold side of the thermodynamic process is particularly important. At a lower temperature, the same thermal power therefore does not offer the same opportunities for generating electricity.

When several engines are in service, exhaust gas and cooling-water flows at different temperatures may become available simultaneously. These heat flows cannot be compared solely on the basis of their thermal power. For recovery using an Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC), for example, the temperatures of the streams entering the individual heat exchangers and the amount of heat that can be transferred to the working fluid at those temperatures are also important.

In common circuits, the same energy must not be included more than once in the heat balance. If engine cooling water transfers heat to a common intermediate circuit, that intermediate circuit is not a separate primary heat source. It carries heat previously released by the connected engines. A correct calculation therefore requires clarity about where the heat comes from and how much of it is actually available after transfer.

When Can Waste Heat from Several Engines Be Recovered Together?

Whether heat from several engines can be used together depends in part on how the heat sources are connected. Engines may have separate exhaust gas paths and cooling circuits, while the recovered heat is routed to the WHRS through a common water or thermal oil circuit. Each engine may, for example, have its own exhaust gas heat exchanger transferring heat to the same intermediate circuit. How much heat each engine supplies then depends on its load and operating status. As soon as an engine is shut down, the sustained heat supply through that connection ceases. Meanwhile, the other running engines can continue supplying heat to the intermediate circuit.

For this form of combined heat recovery, the exhaust gases from individual engines do not need to be combined directly. The existing exhaust gas paths and permissible back pressure remain decisive for the design. Directly combining exhaust gas streams requires a separate assessment, partly because unwanted backflow to an engine that is not running must be prevented. The necessary separation, isolation and protection must suit the engine configuration and the applicable classification requirements.

A common intermediate circuit can simplify the transport of recovered heat to the WHRS. However, the temperature and flow rate depend on the connected heat exchangers, engine loads and how the system is controlled. When an engine is brought into or taken out of service, the combined heat supply changes. Unwanted circulation through a connection that is out of service must also be prevented from disrupting the temperature or flow in the other circuits. Combining sources at different temperatures may also yield heat at a lower temperature than the hottest source provides. This may make an important difference for electricity production. When a warmer and a cooler stream are mixed directly, the combined quantity of heat is not automatically as usable as it would be if both streams were supplied separately at their original temperatures.

It may therefore make technical sense to keep heat sources separate or transfer their heat to the WHRS at different points. A hotter source may then, for example, supply a part of the process that needs a higher temperature, while heat at a lower temperature serves a different function. Which arrangement is most suitable depends on the available sources and the recovery system selected. The choice between a central ORC system and several separate modules can only be assessed once the heat source conditions and operating hours are sufficiently clear.

The WHRS must also be able to continue functioning when not all heat sources are available. Valves, backflow protection where necessary, bypass arrangements and intermediate circuit control must prevent the loss of one engine from adversely affecting the other connections. The original exhaust gas and cooling functions must also be maintained when the WHRS is shut down or experiences a fault. Under certain conditions, an engine that is not running may also need heat for preheating. The engine is then not an active heat source; instead, the necessary preheating represents a potential heat demand. With a common heat transfer circuit, it must therefore be clear what proportion of the heat goes to the WHRS and how much remains necessary for other engine connections.

When recovering heat from engine cooling water, the required engine temperatures and the original cooling function remain the governing considerations. If several engines are connected to a common cooling circuit, water distribution, temperature control and available pump capacity must match the needs of each engine. An additional heat exchanger must not restrict the necessary cooling-water circulation. Existing heat consumers also determine how much of the combined heat supply remains. Heat already needed for heating, hot-water production or other necessary functions cannot simply be allocated to the WHRS again. The available heat must therefore be established within the constraints of the ship's overall heat supply.

What Happens to the Heat Supply When Engines Are Started or Shut Down?

The temperature of an engine system does not change immediately when an engine is started or shut down. During start-up, the engine components, exhaust gas paths and fluid circuits involved gradually reach their new operating temperatures. The temperatures and heat flows may therefore temporarily differ from the values associated with a steady operating point. When an additional engine is brought into service, the full heat output associated with its eventual operating point may not be available immediately. The engine load may still change during start-up, while the exhaust gases and cooling water continue to warm up. The heat exchangers and any intermediate circuit also need time to respond to the changed heat supply.

The combined heat supply may therefore increase without the WHRS being able to use all the additional heat immediately. Particularly if the temperature is temporarily too low or the heat flow changes considerably, heat extraction may need to be limited until suitable operating conditions have been reached. When an engine is shut down, continuous heat production from combustion ceases. However, heat remains temporarily stored in the engine components, heat exchangers and fluid circuits. This heat can still be removed for a limited period, but the stored energy is gradually depleted. An engine that is not running therefore cannot be regarded as a continuing heat source comparable to a running engine.

On ships where the combination of engines in service changes frequently, these transition periods may account for a significant part of the heat profile. An engine may be started or stopped several times during a voyage, changing the heat supply to the WHRS each time. Using steady-load heat data for all these periods may overestimate the heat supply that can actually be used. Rapid load changes may also cause temporary differences between the heat released by the engine and the temperature reached by a heat exchanger or intermediate circuit. The existing thermal mass may partly smooth these changes, but also causes a delay before a new temperature is reached.

The WHRS control system must be able to respond to these conditions. Depending on the arrangement, the system may temporarily absorb less heat, use a bypass or adjust the heat supply. An ORC system may, for example, produce less electricity or temporarily go out of service when the available heat flow is insufficient. The original engine and cooling-water functions must be maintained. A realistic calculation therefore requires a distinction between steady engine loads and transition periods. The amount of heat that can be used during start-up, shutdown and changes in engine load depends on the frequency and duration of these changes, the thermal properties of the connected circuits and the control response of the WHRS.

How Can Electricity Production by a WHRS Change Its Own Heat Supply?

If a WHRS uses heat from generating sets whose load is reduced by the electricity generated, electricity production and the available heat supply affect each other. The WHRS can reduce the load on the generating sets concerned, which also changes the amount of heat these engines supply to the system. A generating set that needs to supply less electrical power because of WHRS output runs at a different operating point. Its exhaust gas flow rate, exhaust gas temperature and heat rejected through the cooling system may therefore change. The WHRS then receives heat from an engine whose load has changed since heat recovery was introduced.

A calculation based solely on the original generator load may therefore overestimate the future heat supply. The available heat supply at a particular engine operating point determines how much electricity the WHRS can generate. That electricity production then affects the generator load and, in turn, the engine's heat release. For a correct assessment, the generator load, available heat and WHRS electricity production must therefore relate to the same operating condition. The recovery system's auxiliary electrical consumption must also be taken into account. If the calculated WHRS production leads to a different generator load, it must be checked again whether the assumed heat supply still matches the heat data at that new load.

A larger change may occur if the recovered electricity makes it possible to shut down an entire generating set. That engine then stops supplying a sustained flow of waste heat. At the same time, the remaining engines may be more heavily loaded, changing their heat release. The combined heat supply must therefore be recalculated for the combination of engines remaining after shutdown. This requires particular attention if the WHRS depends on heat from the generating set to be shut down. As soon as that engine stops, its continuous heat supply is also lost. The previously calculated WHRS output cannot simply be assumed to remain available. Electricity production can continue under the new operating conditions only if other operating heat sources supply sufficient heat.

Shutting down a generating set must therefore be assessed on the basis of the heat sources that actually remain available afterwards. It must also remain possible to maintain the electrical power balance if WHRS production falls or fails. The required power reserve, operational reliability, permitted load changes and capabilities of the power management system determine which combinations of engines can be used without compromising these requirements.

This interaction does not occur in the same way if the WHRS uses heat from an engine whose load remains independent of the electricity generated. An engine providing mechanical propulsion may, for example, continue to supply heat while WHRS electricity reduces the load on separate auxiliary engines. As long as the propulsion engine's operating point remains the same, its heat release is not directly changed by the lower generator load. The change in engine operation does, however, remain important for the ship's total energy consumption. A lower generator load may save fuel, but a change in the number of running engines also affects specific fuel consumption and the available waste heat. The combination of engines with the greatest gross WHRS production is therefore not necessarily the one with the lowest total fuel consumption.

The assessment must establish which engines supply heat, which engines' loads are reduced by electricity generated by the WHRS and what power reserve must be maintained. Ultimately, the relevant heat supply is that of the combination of engines that can actually continue to operate after the WHRS is commissioned.

How Does Day-to-Day Engine Operation Determine Waste Heat Availability?

The need for propulsion, electricity and operational power reserve changes during a voyage or work period. Which main and auxiliary engines are in service therefore depends on the operating conditions. Each combination of engines may provide a different heat supply. During extended periods under way, a particular combination of engines may operate relatively steadily. The associated exhaust gas and cooling-water flows may then remain available for longer periods. During manoeuvring or changes in propulsion load, the engines in service may change, which also changes the heat supply to the WHRS.

For seagoing and coastal ships with several generating sets, the difference between operation under way and in port may be particularly important. Certain propulsion and auxiliary systems may run for long periods while the ship is under way, whereas demand for electricity and heat may differ while alongside. If engines are shut down or shore power is used, a heat source that was available during the voyage may be wholly or partly lost. On ships carrying out specialised work, engine operation may also differ considerably between operating periods. For some tasks, the electrical or mechanical load may be higher than during transit. Additional engines may then be brought into service or existing engines operated at different loads. Both the temperature and amount of available waste heat may consequently change.

For annual heat availability, what matters most is how long each combination of engines is actually used. An operating mode in which all engines run simultaneously at high load may provide high thermal power. If this occurs only briefly, however, that power is not a representative basis for the ship's overall operating profile. A smaller heat flow that remains available for long periods may therefore be more important for the feasibility of a WHRS than a brief peak in thermal power. The temperature and the limits of heat transfer also remain important. Heat available for a long period at too low a temperature need not be more useful than higher-temperature heat available for a shorter period.

The operating hours must also be linked to the conditions that occur simultaneously. If different engines supply heat during the same period, it must be clear which sources are available together. For an ORC-based WHRS, cooling conditions and electrical demand are also important. These do not directly determine how much heat the engines originally release, but they do affect how much of it can actually be used at the time. The ship's future use also deserves attention. A change in the operating profile, different electrical loads or a change in how the generating sets are used may alter the distribution of engine loads. Historical operating data therefore provide a suitable basis only if they are sufficiently representative of the engine operation expected during the future operating period.

What Data Are Needed to Establish the Heat Supply from Several Engines Reliably?

A reliable assessment starts with the individual engines and the conditions under which they are used. The loads at which each engine operates in the relevant operating modes must be known. It must also be clear which engines run simultaneously and how long each combination is used. The rated engine power is only a starting point. The heat calculation requires data on heat rejected at different loads. For exhaust gas heat, these include temperature and mass flow rate. For engine cooling water, the available temperatures, flow rates and relevant cooling-circuit characteristics are important. These data must match the engine design and configuration actually installed.

The location within the system to which the data relate must also be known. The exhaust gas temperature immediately after the turbocharger may, for example, differ from that at the proposed heat exchanger. If equipment between these points already extracts heat or imposes certain temperature requirements, the full original heat flow cannot be allocated to the WHRS. For cooling circuits, a distinction must be made between the heat released by the engine and the proportion that can additionally be recovered. The required engine cooling must be maintained, and existing thermal consumers must be included in the heat balance. If several engines supply heat to a common circuit, it must be clear which engines and any other heat sources contribute to it.

Each engine's load, operating status and heat flows must all relate to the same operating period. Only then can the temperatures and quantities of heat actually available simultaneously be established. Adding the maximum thermal power outputs of engines that do not run simultaneously under those conditions does not give a representative combined heat supply. Start-up and shutdown periods must also remain identifiable in the data. Heat conditions during these transitions may differ from the values at steady load. If the engines in service change frequently, these periods may need to be assessed separately instead of allocating the entire time to a steady operating point.

These data can be used to draw up a heat balance for each relevant combination of engines. First, the amount of heat released by the running engines at their actual loads is determined. The proportion that can be recovered within the permitted temperature, flow and operating limits is then investigated. Existing heat consumers, the options for connecting different sources together and the available cooling capacity are also taken into account. If the WHRS affects the load on the engines supplying the heat, the operating configuration after commissioning must also be calculated. The potential WHRS electricity production and remaining generator load must be consistent with each other. Any change in the number of running generating sets must also be included. This keeps the heat forecast consistent with which engines are in service in the new operating mode.

A complete energy assessment also requires a comparison of the fuel consumption of the different combinations of engines. More recoverable heat does not automatically mean better energy performance if the engines have to be operated less efficiently to produce it. The comparison must therefore be based on combinations of engines that meet the operational requirements and for which the expected total fuel consumption, including the effect of the WHRS, can be established.

The result is a heat profile showing, for each relevant operating mode, which engines supply heat, how much heat is available, the temperature levels at which it can be used and how long those conditions last. The distinction remains clear between the original heat supply, the heat that can be recovered within acceptable technical limits and the proportion that the WHRS can actually absorb.

The use of several engines therefore affects the waste heat available to a WHRS through the combination of engine load, heat release, simultaneous availability and operating duration. Higher installed engine power does not automatically mean that more heat can be recovered. Nor does running more engines simultaneously guarantee more favourable heat conditions. What matters is how much heat the combinations of engines actually used can supply within their technical limits, and during which operating periods that heat remains available. If WHRS electricity production changes the engine load or the engines in service, the new operating condition must also be taken into account. This allows the waste heat actually available for recovery to be established without losing sight of the energy performance or operational reliability of the ship's systems as a whole.

This Article in the Series

Heat from several engines can be used together, but adding their thermal power outputs does not show how much is usable by a WHRS. This also depends on the suitability of the individual heat sources and, for exhaust gas heat, on the limits imposed by back pressure and exhaust gas temperature. How engine operation and these technical constraints are coordinated is discussed in the system selection and integration of a WHRS.